Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is MN middle class? Feeling inadequate and that my life is boring.

332 replies

sleaf · 11/01/2022 21:50

Is MN mainly full of middle to upper class posters?

Having read through some of the threads, especially tonight's holiday thread where everyone appears to be having multiple holidays this year, I'm feeling very low and inadequate, and that there's something wrong in my life Sad

Oh well, comparison is the thief of joy and all that.

OP posts:
onlychildhamster · 12/01/2022 10:49

If it makes you feel better OP, I have been slammed on Mumsnet for having an 'unrelatable life' as I bought a london flat at 27, go abroad multiple times a year, eat out every week, go on regular day trips to towns and other attractions and shop at Boden/Joules (only sales items!), but I have an ongoing thread now on the property thread about whether £1400 is too much to spend on a sofa bench and PP are telling me that this is very cheap honestly and a poster spent £5k on a chair she doesn't use.

I am sorry, i can't relate at all. When I first bought our flat in London 2 years ago, we were worried about having enough money to even furnish our flat, we were fully prepared to buy everything in Ikea. We bought from Ikea, Muji and Made; could not have imagined spending anything like £5k. we have the money now but I still balk a little at spending so much when we have lived quite well till now with cheaper furniture. For some posters, it seems 5k on a a chair is something really normal. so you see, most people probably end up feeling inadequate on Mumsnet in some area. Some people spend more on some areas, other less. However unless you keep a record of which posters have nice stuff in excel and split them into categories, it may seem like everyone is spending £££ on every area in their life and that is just not true. I don't have a car or a tv and as it turns out (lots of furniture that people consider essential) and I don't really want those things, but most people do want those things and consider them essentials, so if people are envying my life, they shouldn't...

AlDanvers · 12/01/2022 10:45

[quote Minfilia]@AlDanvers

Most of MN seems to base class on a BBC survey, which is confusing at best. Apparently, you can't move class or it takes 3 generations to change class. There's no set rules.

I had to Google this. I got told I was “elite” Grin

I’m not. I’m 100% working class and 3 generations previously, my family were travellers!

It’s an old survey though and income, house values etc have changed significantly since then. If the survey was repeated today with comparative incomes I would get a very different result!![/quote]
I came across it on another 'mn is so middle class' thread, a couple of months ago.

I think I came out elite, but then some mners insist you are the class you born as, you can't change. No idea if that's true, but that would make me working class.

I find it all too confusing, tbh and genuine have no idea how it actually works Grin

loveliesbleeding1 · 12/01/2022 10:40

You are talking income,not class.

Manc2 · 12/01/2022 10:40

@chessycurls I totally agree with this. I recently asked about how much people would feel comfortable paying for a mortgage on here and the responses were so much lower than people I know irl. It must be people who bought a house 20/30 years ago or who don’t live in cities

AllThePogs · 12/01/2022 10:32

@99victoria nobody is saying a holiday is only available to the rich, it does depend on what type of holiday you have.
But if by average paying jobs you mean you were both earning £30k a year, then a combined income of £60k until recently, plus now final salary pension, does mean you are better off than most.

Subulter · 12/01/2022 10:31

I think the default predominant world view on Mn is lower-middle-class -- it's visible in the aspirations to a 'detached house and a nice car and foreign holidays', the anxiety about schooling/ 'good schools' etc. and a widespread tendency to compare yourself anxiously with other people to see how you're 'getting on'.

It's not everyone, obviously, and LMC can of course cover a wide range of income levels, and isn't necessarily limited by your upbringing, job etc.

99victoria · 12/01/2022 10:30

We're early retired at 60 and 61. We have both worked at average paid jobs (me in the public sector) all our lives. I posted in that holiday thread because we have started travelling now we are not working. I had my children young (3, in my 20s) and we were always hard-up- we holidayed in the west country in a caravan for years and didn't take our children abroad until a trip to Lanzarote when my oldest was 14.

What I'm saying is, it's not necessarily about being wealthy - my children are now all grown and working, our mortgage is paid off so we can afford holidays. We still don't have an extravagant lifestyle- no expensive hobbies, second hand car etc. We don't eat out unless we're on holiday. I research and book all our holidays myself as it saves a lot of money but travelling is our favourite thing to do :)

AllThePogs · 12/01/2022 10:30

@DeepaBeesKit

*I work as a GP - but probably earn comparatively little as work only “part time “ - although my part time is actually 35 to 40 hrs per week - and not a practice owner. On paper I am definately MC but my income and spending are definately not!*

Ha at this. I know several GPs working part term and they are on £50 or £60k despite only working 3 days a week. So its only really comparatively little if you are comparing to very highly paid jobs in law, finance & the like.

That is interesting. So yes a high salary.
5128gap · 12/01/2022 10:29

[quote Kanaloa]@5128gap

Hmm, a staffy on a GREY soulless probably from b&ms rug? Might as well let him load up on I’m a celeb because Ken or Mabel that is not an appropriately middle class dog.

Why didn’t you adopt a greyhound called Titus? Sigh.[/quote]
Lol. My neighbours dog is actually called Titus! They call him Tits for short. Grin

Kanaloa · 12/01/2022 10:29

[quote Minfilia]@Kanaloa

I know a Connor through work. He is a lovely, quiet, good looking young lad, was privately educated, and is doing well in his career as a pilot.

He’s about as far from a prison inmate as you could possibly get Grin[/quote]
I’m afraid not Angry

He is a naughty boy and possible even a chav or a criminal. Unless possibly his name is actually Thomas or Wilfred and you’ve misheard it? Or perhaps Connors is his last name. HTH.

AllThePogs · 12/01/2022 10:29

@coogee

l had to Google this. I got told I was “elite”

So did I. Let’s just say the result doesn’t reflect the perception I have of myself.

I have no idea who you are or your background, but lots of well off people don't think they are as well off as they really are.
OneTimeThrowAway · 12/01/2022 10:27

*significant not sufficient

Movinghouseatlast · 12/01/2022 10:27

So should people on high incomes not comment on threads then? I don't understand the problem here, why are a lot of people criticising wealthy people for contributing?

I have always been the poor relation in my friendship group and my family, mainly because of the job I chose. My best friend owns 4 properties outright, lives in a 2 million pound house but she has had some tough things happen, would she not be allowed to post on Mumsnet according to some of the comments on this thread?

OneTimeThrowAway · 12/01/2022 10:27

I think there's a fair mix

I think when reading MN you should remember that as per the rest of the internet very sufficient portions of what people write on here are fully made up and pretending to be super wealthy, pretending to be a woman, pretending to be incredibly proficient in your chosen field, are the bread and butter of internet fantasy

Moonface123 · 12/01/2022 10:26

The thing is Op, holidays dont make people any happier, temporarily maybe, if it goes to plan , but you find like at Xmas, there is a huge expectation, alot of stress beforehand, and inevitably alot of things are out of your control.
Already on here the threads are starting re hassell of even trying to book a holiday, nevermind the competition of where everyone is off too, and how often. Let them get on with it, l csn already visualise the holiday complaints threads being inflicted upon us further down the line.
I dont care if l am boring, give me a book and a lovely glass of wine in my peaceful beautiful garden, surrounded by my pets, l am happy. The secret for me, is to create a life you have no desire to escape from.

Goldi321 · 12/01/2022 10:23

It’s a bizarre place and certainly doesn’t reflect what I see in life around me. We have a good income, childless (for the next 2 months!) and low outgoings but our lives are a million miles away from people on here who have lots of holidays, paid off mortgages in mid 30s etc. All my friends are professionals and it’s certainly not reflective of their lives either.
On top of it all, how do people have so much holiday off a year?!

Emerald5hamrock · 12/01/2022 10:22

@Kanaloa 😇🤣

Minfilia · 12/01/2022 10:22

@Kanaloa

I know a Connor through work. He is a lovely, quiet, good looking young lad, was privately educated, and is doing well in his career as a pilot.

He’s about as far from a prison inmate as you could possibly get Grin

DeepaBeesKit · 12/01/2022 10:20

I work as a GP - but probably earn comparatively little as work only “part time “ - although my part time is actually 35 to 40 hrs per week - and not a practice owner.
On paper I am definately MC but my income and spending are definately not!

Ha at this. I know several GPs working part term and they are on £50 or £60k despite only working 3 days a week. So its only really comparatively little if you are comparing to very highly paid jobs in law, finance & the like.

coogee · 12/01/2022 10:17

l had to Google this. I got told I was “elite”

So did I. Let’s just say the result doesn’t reflect the perception I have of myself.

WoodenReindeer · 12/01/2022 10:14

Yank. Think?

WoodenReindeer · 12/01/2022 10:14

All the pogs. I yank the opposite - only if you rent expensive cottages! We usually pay 500ish 650 this year for one we really like. Cant see how 4 of us can travel abroad for a week on that?

Kanaloa · 12/01/2022 10:14

Dunelm??? No of course that’s not any better!

Your rug should have been handed down from your great grandmother and be an antique. If that’s not possible it should have been bought from an independent rug weaver to support small local businesses. And if it’s grey it honestly doesn’t matter, it’s ‘common.’ Grey is soulless. Mrs Hinch has grey things. It’s WRONG!

AllThePogs · 12/01/2022 10:11

My rug us from Dunelm is that any better?

Kanaloa · 12/01/2022 10:10

@5128gap

Hmm, a staffy on a GREY soulless probably from b&ms rug? Might as well let him load up on I’m a celeb because Ken or Mabel that is not an appropriately middle class dog.

Why didn’t you adopt a greyhound called Titus? Sigh.