Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is MN middle class? Feeling inadequate and that my life is boring.

332 replies

sleaf · 11/01/2022 21:50

Is MN mainly full of middle to upper class posters?

Having read through some of the threads, especially tonight's holiday thread where everyone appears to be having multiple holidays this year, I'm feeling very low and inadequate, and that there's something wrong in my life Sad

Oh well, comparison is the thief of joy and all that.

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 12/01/2022 16:21

For context, 10% of people in the UK have no savings at all, nothing. (And that doubles to 20% of people in their twenties.) Another third of the population have less than £600. So if you have over £1,500 in your savings, you’re immediately doing much better than half the population (and even more so if you can afford to raid those savings for an extravagance like upgrading furniture.) Over 70% of people overall don’t have enough in savings to pay the bills for three months if they lost their income. Having £15,000 “easily” saved for a new kitchen and being able to talk about it as a fairly trifling amount that you wouldn’t need to save for, is not the reality for the vast majority of the UK.

user5656555 · 12/01/2022 16:10

@onlychildhamster do you think interest free credit and credit in general would be so widely popular if it was "unusual" to not have 4 figures in the bank to hand? You're incredibly sheltered if you think that's the case and validating what the OP is raising!

5128gap · 12/01/2022 16:05

[quote onlychildhamster]@ComtesseDeSpair but 15k would be something even a young professional would easily have in their savings...Let alone £1k. Its not something you have to save towards. I would agree with stuff like loft conversions- taking out finance against the value of your house is a good idea as loft conversion would increase value.[/quote]
You must know this isn't true? You must have some idea of how expensive houses can be and how much of even professional salaries mortgage repayments eat up, leaving little available for savings. Even more so if you are young and haven't been on that salary for long, and may have not had a gifted deposit from your parents, so had to save for that too? You cannot be so sheltered from reality (even MC reality) that you think a £15k kitchen is not something to save up for.

onlychildhamster · 12/01/2022 16:01

@user5656555 I would generally be able to pay £1500 from our savings. I guess thats why its not as appealing to me! i don't think its that unusual though. my MIL had a tooth extracted and she is on a low income but she is paying £4k for an implant using cash from savings. It was a sudden event that she didn't foresee...

ComtesseDeSpair · 12/01/2022 15:59

Don't see why anyone would bother lying either!

I dunno either - but it’s amazing when you see it “live”, so to speak. Am suddenly recalling the poster who years ago posted a Rightmove link for “their” (big, expensive) house asking for advice on making the house even better for more viewings and offers - only for somebody else to pop up to point out “err, that can’t be your house because that’s very much my cousin’s house and your posting history shows you clearly aren’t them.”

Funnily enough, the OP never came back and the thread was pulled by MN “for privacy reasons.”

ColourMeExhausted · 12/01/2022 15:52

I've been thinking this. Always thought of myself as middle class and reasonably well off...but then you read some of the threads on here and it feels like the enclave of wealthy London, DC privately educated and six figure earners! Was reading a thread on the HE topic (no idea why, my DC are barely primary aged) dissing 'low ranking' Universities like Glasgow and Edinburgh. One of which i graduated from. The mentality of some on here is seriously privileged.

Don't see why anyone would bother lying either!

onlychildhamster · 12/01/2022 15:51

@ComtesseDeSpair *low interest rates

onlychildhamster · 12/01/2022 15:51

@ComtesseDeSpair well cos you said that someone of your income bracket would do well borrrowing 15k on the best interest rates. I assume you have a good income and therefore ability to build up good savings. If someone doesn't have the ability to build up good savings, then choosing an upmarket product probably isn't the most prudent. I think the problem isn't actually taking out the credit due to low inflation rates, but because credit makes lifestyle inflation much easier! Of course, some people think £1k for a sofa or some other item is better than them suffering for years on something that isn't optimal so for that reason, the no interest finance could be a very good idea for them. But thats why I don't really see the appeal of furniture finance for someone who does have the money to pay for it but just chooses to spread it out! Thats just my opinion though.

Refrosty · 12/01/2022 15:49

@LadyPropane

Everyone on MN falls into 2 categories:

So poor that they haven't eaten in 3 weeks and are selling their toenail clippings on Etsy to save up for a pack of bog roll, or so rich that they have their Butler check MN for them and post fancy musings on their behalf.

You forgot rich/decent disposable income, but like to competitively underspend. That's what I see the most here.
hangrylady · 12/01/2022 15:47

Yes MN is very middle class it stands out a mile! Using the word cunt doesn't fool anybody.Grin

user5656555 · 12/01/2022 15:44

If you save up £1500 for a sofa, by the time you've saved for it, it could have gone up in price. If you pay with interest free credit you buy it at the potentially cheapest price (particularly with inflation increasing) without any interest charges. Just an example of how it can work out though I appreciate the comment about temptation to spend more.

It's too simplistic and old school to say credit purchases are always a bad thing, especially when interest free.

ComtesseDeSpair · 12/01/2022 15:43

[quote onlychildhamster]@ComtesseDeSpair but 15k would be something even a young professional would easily have in their savings...Let alone £1k. Its not something you have to save towards. I would agree with stuff like loft conversions- taking out finance against the value of your house is a good idea as loft conversion would increase value.[/quote]
I think this is exactly what the OP of this thread she started several pages ago is talking about. No, the average going professional does not necessarily have £15k easily sitting about in their savings; and seeing people state that as a fact is what the thread was originally about.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 12/01/2022 15:43

Ok so you’re only permitted to start threads if you’re struggling or about struggling otherwise you’re lying or making others feel bad. Got it.

alienalan · 12/01/2022 15:42

MN is like any social media app. Everything appears to be better than the reality

onlychildhamster · 12/01/2022 15:39

@ComtesseDeSpair but 15k would be something even a young professional would easily have in their savings...Let alone £1k. Its not something you have to save towards. I would agree with stuff like loft conversions- taking out finance against the value of your house is a good idea as loft conversion would increase value.

onlychildhamster · 12/01/2022 15:33

@5128gap

I mean here are the pitfalls;

www.fool.co.uk/personal-finance/your-money/learn/is-furniture-finance-a-good-idea/

You may be tempted to overspend. If you are not paying the full amount for a sofa or bed or table up front, it may be tempting to go above your budget.
You will be taking on more debt. Having multiple loans and credit accounts can affect your credit score.
You are making a monthly financial commitment, which in turn will impact your disposable income.
If you miss any repayments, you could negatively impact your credit score.

When I pay in cash, I just pay what I can afford and if my financial situation changes, I am not worried about the furniture i bought a few months ago. Horses for courses though. I can see why its attractive for people without the savings though!

ComtesseDeSpair · 12/01/2022 15:32

” You're far better off using interest free credit for large purchases. That way the lump sum stays in your account earning you more money, rather than in the company's. Perhaps they're not 'poor people' who shop there, just people with good financial literacy.”

Agreed, and I think attitudes towards credit is one of those things which can be a class distinguisher. My parents (upper working class) always taught me never to use credit, would never use it themselves – because that made sense several decades ago for people of their class and income bracket and when interest rates were high, so borrowing money was a really expensive way of having something. Plus - and perhaps just as meaningfully - for people of their background, credit carried a certain stigma: you only bought things “on tick” if you were either really poor or a bit feckless with your money and unable to budget properly. Where I came from, respectable working class people lived within their means, and that was very much an important social value for us.

Whereas nowadays, with interest rates so low, and for somebody of my income bracket who is both eligible for the best inflation-busting rates and can easily afford to service a debt, credit is often actually the cheapest and most sensible option for a large purchase. If I wanted to, say, replace my kitchen I could borrow £15,000 at 1.99% over three years. In total I’d pay back a little over £16,000 so it would cost me about £1,000 to do so. With inflation running at over 5%, and the cost of building materials and trade labour having almost doubled in some parts of the country, if I’d chosen to save up first I’d need to save far more money to buy the same thing a couple of years later. The same value which was sensible and respectable for my parents, would be really quite financially illiterate behaviour for me.

onlychildhamster · 12/01/2022 15:27

@5128gap Oh I use credit for everything, I pay it off in full every month! I wasn't saying everyone who uses credit for a sofa is poor, its just not enough money to be bothered about having to be paid in installments personally. I would just pay in cash so I don't need to bother about it. But credit does make such purchases more accessible so people who don't have the cash can afford the furniture they really want more easily.

5128gap · 12/01/2022 15:06

[quote onlychildhamster]@seekinglondonlife I have an integrated living/dining area so the sofa bench is a key piece of furniture in my reception room. So I am willing to spend what people spend on a sofa. Yes it is very expensive, but it is full leather and there are many sofas in excess of £1k at DFS. I presume that not everyone who shops there is rich, because when we went there, they had so many ads on buying sofas on credit, so I imagine that some poor people must be buying them.

I haven't looked into how much interest they charged, they claim to be 0% but I wouldn't buy something I can't pay off immediately (except for housing)...Appreciate thats a privilege but that means such an item is a big expense bigger than my mortgage.. But such a system of credit means that for big ticket items, this would increase people's disposable income and hence the price considerably...[/quote]
You're far better off using interest free credit for large purchases. That way the lump sum stays in your account earning you more money, rather than in the company's. Perhaps they're not 'poor people' who shop there, just people with good financial literacy.

onlychildhamster · 12/01/2022 14:47

@seekinglondonlife I have an integrated living/dining area so the sofa bench is a key piece of furniture in my reception room. So I am willing to spend what people spend on a sofa. Yes it is very expensive, but it is full leather and there are many sofas in excess of £1k at DFS. I presume that not everyone who shops there is rich, because when we went there, they had so many ads on buying sofas on credit, so I imagine that some poor people must be buying them.

I haven't looked into how much interest they charged, they claim to be 0% but I wouldn't buy something I can't pay off immediately (except for housing)...Appreciate thats a privilege but that means such an item is a big expense bigger than my mortgage.. But such a system of credit means that for big ticket items, this would increase people's disposable income and hence the price considerably...

Kanaloa · 12/01/2022 14:25

@MaryAndHerNet

I think some people would do well to remember that showing a starving man that you have bread won't make him happy for you, it will just make him notice his hunger all the more.
Well yeah but if the starving man’s standing staring into a bakery he’ll probably see some bread.

If I didn’t want to see people chatting about their holidays I would avoid a thread titled ‘where are you going on holiday this year?’

Cici22 · 12/01/2022 14:08

Bet half of them are Tories too 😂

Honestly ex council estate background and working class. I have to laugh at some of these post I see. Never know so many entitled people.

On the flips side, some amazing post and I'm happy knowing I'm not alone in certain thoughts and situations ❤️

seekinglondonlife · 12/01/2022 14:07

@AngelsWithSilverWings it isn't just very wealthy people who get told they are lying, it's anyone that has more than a disgruntled poster. I was on benefits for several years due to dc being very ill and we went on holiday (term time, £9.99 flights, very cheap accommodation off peak) and I was told I was lying about being on benefits, because when you are a benefit recipient you can't afford toilet roll let alone a holiday.

Guacamole001 · 12/01/2022 14:07

Sorry meant to type bete noire earlier. Auto correct in overdrive.

seekinglondonlife · 12/01/2022 14:03

@onlychildhamster sorry I didn't mean you in particular, I was just thinking of very high end items (that are unaffordable for most) that I have seen over the last few days and then posters use them to say they feel inadequate, or that MN isn't relatable to them. I was actually thinking you were mad to consider spending £1400 on your dining bench 😂