Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Really weird kids’ books from the past

361 replies

aweebitlost · 11/01/2022 21:30

I was reading the DC The Elephant & the Bad Baby tonight and it struck me how very odd it is.

An elephant takes a baby for a joyride to nick a load of food and then everyone is cross with the baby for not saying please?!

Then there’s the Long Slide with the 3 stuffed animals that climb a giant slide, vomit, meet some witches etc and don’t seem to get any pleasure out of the experience.

AIBU or were some kids’ books from the past plain bizarre?! Any other good ones people can think of?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
SantaClawsServiette · 15/01/2022 02:51

Another one that is less weird but which I always ponderd as a child was The Story about Ping. It's about a duck living in China. It's late to go home, and doesn't want to be spanked so runs away, Then it sees weird fishing birds, and is caught and almost eaten by a family. In the end it goes back to it's home, where the boatmaster spanks it, and is happy to be back with his family. I always wondered, was Ping better off free, without the threat of being spanked, in the scary world? Or safe with his parents but under the boat-master? And was the boat master right to spank the ducks to keep them from wandering off at night? It was a bit unsettling but I liked it.

I work in a library, and I can say that the vast majority of the picture books now are dead boring.

SantaClawsServiette · 15/01/2022 02:44

Caleb and Kate is one I loved. It's about a man and his wife, they love each other but are quite feisty. One day they have an argument, he goes into the woods to cool off, and a witch turns him into a dog. He goes home to Kate, desperate that she will think he's left her, which she does. They live like that for several years, he tries always to show her how much he loves her, she is sad but loves the dog and tries to live with it. In the end robbers try to break in, he stops them and they accidentally break the spell.

My very favorite as a child was called Higglety PIglety Pop, or There Must Be More to Life. It is about a dog who has everything but runs away to find out if there is more to life. It's a bit creepy, there is a creepy baby who won't eat and whose parents have moved away, and if the dog can't get her to eat, she (the dog) will be sent to the lion in the basement. The dog is constantly eating everything - a plant she is talking to, all the contents of the milk-man's van, and then the baby's lunch. In the end she becomes an actress.

FurryAntiWaxer · 14/01/2022 23:42

@Grendalsmum

DS1 loved Squirrel Nutkin which is pretty out there - Non-neurotypical riddle obsessed squirrel gets his tail bitten off by an owl ...
Funnily, Tolkien and CS Lewis both listed squirrel Nutkin as a childhood favourite.
FurryAntiWaxer · 14/01/2022 23:38

I haven't read the full thread, but there is a really popular vintage Australian illustrator and writer called May Gibbs. Her illustrations are iconic and on everything nowadays. But the stories...Shock
So many characters are eaten alive, torn from their parents, caught in steel traps, abducted by various villains.

And my favourite line...'good root, said the old shag'. Cracks me up every time.

winewolfhowls · 14/01/2022 23:06

I love the art work in the giant jam sandwich and the end bit where the birds have a feast for a hundred weeks or whatever is really satisfying the way it rolls off your tongue

There was a Dutch, maybe translated book about a cow in Holland that was so greedy it went on a barge into the city and it was so rectangular it used to really disturb me.

Tabbypawpaw · 14/01/2022 22:59

Great thread. Mine live elephant and the bad baby but I agree it is strange, and the elephant complains twice about the baby not saying pls. Marianne Dreams is a v dark book, I could only read it when I was older because of the terrifying stones that follow the children.
So many kids books are reallly odd. We have one called Alfie’s Anger or something like that, 1980s book about a boy whose tantrum is so bad he breaks the world and ends up on his own on a bit of rock in space.

DelurkingAJ · 14/01/2022 22:34

@TheSpiral - I love I’m a Prisoner in a Toothpaste Factory…with the message coming out in toothpaste!

Weird one for me was called Chocolate Fever about a boy who eats so much chocolate that he develops chocolate measles.

whatth · 14/01/2022 22:18

My grown up DC is still disgusted with me for inflicting a children's book about neglect and emotional abuse on her. Not Now Bernard of course!

CaterpillaNavilla · 14/01/2022 21:38

Doctor Dog - aimed at 3/4/5 year olds (picture book). A dog doctor treats a family for various ailments - the oldest boy gets smokers cough from too many fags behind the bike sheds at school and the youngest gets told, ‘never pick your bum then suck your thumb’ as prevention against future worm infestations.

Needless to say my children were delighted to find a copy at my mums house and think it’s hilarious!

itsnotmeitsu · 14/01/2022 21:02

Der Struwwelpeter > Haunted me all my life, after I was introduced to it in primary school Shock.

5foot5 · 14/01/2022 20:33

@RainbowCrayons

My contribution would be 'fatty-puffs and thinifers'. I was a non-NT girl and loved reading and it seems one of my teachers tried to put me off reading to make me less weird. She took away all the books that were 'too hard' including 'around the world in 80 days' while I was half way through reading it. We ended up in a standoff when I got half way with fatty puffs and thinifers and wanted to change it but she wouldn't let me read anything else until I finished it. I ended up in a bitter standoff staring at the same page in reading time for the rest of the school year and reading what I liked at home.

I probably remember my personal war with that teacher far better than the book itself but it was about fat people having fun and eating and thin people being strict and boring, going to war with eachother. Apparently it was about French vs Germans in ww2 so some casual racism thrown in with the body shaming.

@RainbowCrayons I remember reading "Fattipuffs and Thinifers" and it was one of the first weird books I thought of when I saw this thread.

However having read your post I am now more gripped by your stand off with that horrible teacher. What happened? Did your parents ever find out?

phlebasconsidered · 14/01/2022 20:19

The machine gunners is brilliant! Honestly one of the best books for engaging 11ish year old boys. He wrote excellent teen horror too which is a real find if you can get it in second hand book shops.

The elephant and the bad baby is wonderful- repetition is important for phonologicsl understanding and the fact the baby is naughty enchants the babies reading. My own 2 kids used to love Burningams "Courtney" which is absolutely odd. A family adopt an old dog, it is extremely talented, saves them all from a fire then vanishes. Then one day years later the kids are on a boat that goes adrift and something rescues them as the boat is pulled in. As an adult I never got it but every kid, including my own, i've ever read it to has recognised it as a death metaphor. An old year 2 class I had was obsessed with it. Burningham was very talented imo- tapped right into kids minds.

I loved Z for Zachariah as mentioned here. H.M Hoover also did some great teen dystopias. "This time of Darkness" is excellent. And of course, Swindells "Brother in the Land".

Twopenny · 14/01/2022 20:16

The Moomin books - not for the quirky and charming characters and their attitude to life (which I love), but for the gradual and upsetting tonal shift of the books which I did not see coming as a child. The first few have such a lovely carefree 'anything can happen' feel to them (particularly Moominsummer Madness), but the latter few are very lonely and sad, I think. As a younger child I was quite baffled by Moominvalley in November which is about a disconsolate collection of waifs waiting bored and unhappy in the empty Moominhouse for the Moomins to return.

ArbleMarchTFruitbat · 14/01/2022 19:59

@Redannie118

The machine gunners by Robert Westall was pretty grim. Group of children find a crashed German plane complete with rotting German pilots corpse. The steal the machine gun from the plane for their den. Set during WW2 in North Shields in North East England( a very bombed place due to the coal mines and nearby Vickers munitions plant) its really dark, but was a big deal at the time. It was part of the ciriculum in the 80s and the BBC even turned it into a TV series
Yes - there's an equally dark sequel, Fathom Five, which is well worth a read if you enjoyed the original. Chas & co are sixth form age and the book is more adult in tone - much of the action revolves around a brothel of all things.
Redannie118 · 14/01/2022 19:55

The machine gunners by Robert Westall was pretty grim. Group of children find a crashed German plane complete with rotting German pilots corpse. The steal the machine gun from the plane for their den. Set during WW2 in North Shields in North East England( a very bombed place due to the coal mines and nearby Vickers munitions plant) its really dark, but was a big deal at the time. It was part of the ciriculum in the 80s and the BBC even turned it into a TV series

ArbleMarchTFruitbat · 14/01/2022 19:36

[quote EmmaPaella]@YesILikeItToo I would also be intereated in the podcast Smile

I'd forgotten about Mary Plain. I loved those books.

Anyone else still a bit freaked out by Tottie, The Story of a Doll's House?[/quote]
Tottie - yes - the ending! I won't post a spoiler but the whole thing is terrifyingly gothic.

Also remember Mary Plain - the Fur Coat Lady and the Owl Man were her human friends but IIRC she was very much the bottom of the pile in her bear family.

The Beatrix Potter where Tom Kitten gets wrapped in pastry to be eaten by the rats terrified me as a small child.

Bookridden · 14/01/2022 19:28

Phoebe Beeberbee and the hot water bottles

MargaretThursday · 14/01/2022 19:24

@EmmaPaella
Yes Tottie is definitely weird as a children's book.

EmmaPaella · 14/01/2022 17:38

@YesILikeItToo I would also be intereated in the podcast Smile

I'd forgotten about Mary Plain. I loved those books.

Anyone else still a bit freaked out by Tottie, The Story of a Doll's House?

EmmaPaella · 14/01/2022 17:27

Totally forgot about Mr Pinkwhistle... Lots of Blyton books are quite odd.

applestamper · 14/01/2022 10:26

@pandaeyes44

Enid Blyton's Mr Pinkwhistle. Creepy perv was invisible and often loitered around in childrens bedrooms. There was also one story where he stole a bullies trousers and made him run home in his pants. A product of its time but quite odd and a little sinister now.
This! The one story I actually stopped reading half way through and refused to finish; DS loves Mr Pinkwhistle and kept asking me to finish it so I think I made up an alternative version in the end.
Footgoose · 14/01/2022 05:59

@AuntieJoyce. I came on to say Little Rabbit Foo Foo. My kids favourite book too. No one else seems to have heard of it. I often wondered if I had the only copy.
He got his comeuppance. Nasty little bunny. Grin

RainbowCrayons · 14/01/2022 02:30

My contribution would be 'fatty-puffs and thinifers'. I was a non-NT girl and loved reading and it seems one of my teachers tried to put me off reading to make me less weird. She took away all the books that were 'too hard' including 'around the world in 80 days' while I was half way through reading it. We ended up in a standoff when I got half way with fatty puffs and thinifers and wanted to change it but she wouldn't let me read anything else until I finished it. I ended up in a bitter standoff staring at the same page in reading time for the rest of the school year and reading what I liked at home.

I probably remember my personal war with that teacher far better than the book itself but it was about fat people having fun and eating and thin people being strict and boring, going to war with eachother. Apparently it was about French vs Germans in ww2 so some casual racism thrown in with the body shaming.

DontFatshameBigBarbara · 13/01/2022 18:26

@CiaoForDiNiaoSaur I have still got There's a hippopotamus on my roof eating cake! Very strange and uncomfortable book, the Mum having salad for tea because she's on a diet! The Dad smacks the girl! Bizarre.
I also had Help I'm a prisoner in a toothpaste factory @TheSpiral!

aweebitlost · 13/01/2022 18:18

@Grendalsmum I completely agree re The Last Battle. I didn’t understand it as a child at all. I remember reading an interview with Philip Pullman where he said something about how he hated the way Susan was banned from Narnia because she had gone through a sexual awakening, and it was very important to him to treat that part of life very differently in the Northern Lights books.

Apologies if it’s already been mentioned but by far the strangest Beatrix Potter is surely Ginger & Pickles about the animals whose shop goes bankrupt because they’re always extending credit to unreliable customers?
Pigling Bland mentioned upthread was one of DD’s absolute favourites when she was young. How we loved it when the pigs got away!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread