Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I can eat this and lose weight?

170 replies

bendywendygivemeablast · 11/01/2022 20:58

Struggling to lose half a stone🙄

I do a spin class every day for 30 mins, this is what I ate today and kind of typical for me:

Breakfast
1 slice low carb bread with peanut butter
2 black coffees

Snacks:
1 Maryland cookie
2segments of chocolate Orange

Dinner:
Salmon fillet
Jacket potato with cheese
Roasted broccoli and cauliflower with grated parmesan

AIBU to think even with the two naughty slip ups I should still be able to lose weight given that I exercise every single day?!

OP posts:
Ohpulltheotherone · 11/01/2022 21:19

@bendywendygivemeablast

Thank you everyone. I think I'll have to start actually logging the calories and mixing up the exercise. I have been eating like this for a long time, now I'm wondering whether I've destroyed my metabolism?
Destroyed, no.

Buggered up temporarily- likely yes.

See my post above on reverse dieting.

bendywendygivemeablast · 11/01/2022 21:18

@Ohpulltheotherone

You’re not in a calorie deficit.

However - this is important.
I’ve estimated your calories about 1300 for the day. This is really low. Unless you’re 3ft tall or absolutely tiny.

When you find you can’t lose weight when your calories are really low it is because your body has adjusted to a continual calorie deficit. Meaning that you have to continually go lower and lower to keep losing weight.

Which obviously is not good, because we need food as fuel. To live, for our body to work.

So what you need to do is not continually keep restricting, you need to reverse diet.
This means to add in more calories slowly over a period of time, like a few hundred a day for one week, a little bit more the next week etc etc.
until you are at a reasonable maintenance level - which I don’t know your body composition or height etc but is likely to be around 2000/2200 if you are active and have good muscle mass.

Then you will need to sit at a maintenance position for a little while before you drop your calories again to achieve weight loss.

This sounds counter intuitive I know but this is the reality of continual restrictive eating.

Look up reverse dieting and have a read, it’s a massive issue especially for women as we tend to spend so many years restricting calories

Thank you so much, this is really helpful. X
OP posts:
HairyFanjoBanjo · 11/01/2022 21:17

@LordEmsworth

Oh great, we all love a competitive under-eating thread! Yay!
Lawd yes! Someone else gets it..Grin
Ohpulltheotherone · 11/01/2022 21:17

You’re not in a calorie deficit.

However - this is important.
I’ve estimated your calories about 1300 for the day. This is really low. Unless you’re 3ft tall or absolutely tiny.

When you find you can’t lose weight when your calories are really low it is because your body has adjusted to a continual calorie deficit. Meaning that you have to continually go lower and lower to keep losing weight.

Which obviously is not good, because we need food as fuel. To live, for our body to work.

So what you need to do is not continually keep restricting, you need to reverse diet.
This means to add in more calories slowly over a period of time, like a few hundred a day for one week, a little bit more the next week etc etc.
until you are at a reasonable maintenance level - which I don’t know your body composition or height etc but is likely to be around 2000/2200 if you are active and have good muscle mass.

Then you will need to sit at a maintenance position for a little while before you drop your calories again to achieve weight loss.

This sounds counter intuitive I know but this is the reality of continual restrictive eating.

Look up reverse dieting and have a read, it’s a massive issue especially for women as we tend to spend so many years restricting calories

MarleneDietrichsSmile · 11/01/2022 21:17

It is impossible to know Grin

You can't really bargain like that with life/nature

Only you know how tall, big, active you are and only you know how much butter and cheese you add to that baked potato Wink

To me it looks like not much food

FWIW I eat a lot more than you, especially a lot more carbs through bread/oats etc and am a good bmi, but I am 6ft and do 1-2 hrs exercise a day... which makes comparing hard!

bendywendygivemeablast · 11/01/2022 21:16

Thank you everyone. I think I'll have to start actually logging the calories and mixing up the exercise. I have been eating like this for a long time, now I'm wondering whether I've destroyed my metabolism?

OP posts:
BlueBottle46 · 11/01/2022 21:15

I think you also need to build in some rest days. A spin class everyday gives your body no recovery time

I'd shake it up to maybe 2 1hr long spin classes and 2 weight training days, maybe 1 gentle exercise and 2 rest days. You need rest days to allow your body recovery time. You need food to give you energy to get through the day. You don't have any space to cut more calories

gwenneh · 11/01/2022 21:15

My thoughts exactly, so what's the problem?! Perhaps it is just not enough variety in exercise.

It's likely where your weight is starting, what your total daily energy expenditure is, and actually challenging your body with your exercise rather than what you're eating. How long you've been underconsuming food will also play a large role.

PurpleDaisies · 11/01/2022 21:14

Have you tried weighing everything and working out how many calories you’re actually eating a day? Sometimes portions get out of hand over time.

You would only need to do this for a short time until you’ve got a clear idea of whether you’re eating what you think you are.

User48751490 · 11/01/2022 21:14

I would be chewing off my arm on this amount of food😂

bendywendygivemeablast · 11/01/2022 21:12

@PurpleDaisies

Seriously, one cookie is 50 calories. Two segments of chocolate orange is another 100.

150calories in snacks isn’t what’s keeping you from losing weight.

My thoughts exactly, so what's the problem?! Perhaps it is just not enough variety in exercise.
OP posts:
ShirleyPhallus · 11/01/2022 21:12

@PurpleDaisies

They taste like sweets but I'm much better for you and your gut.

Here’s a sentence I never thought I’d write.

Prunes do not taste like sweets.

Grin god love mumsnet
goodwinter · 11/01/2022 21:12

Unless you're having several heaped tablespoons of PB with your toast and half a block of cheese with your jacket potato, there's so few calories in that list. You should absolutely be losing weight, but I'm surprised you have any energy at all. Especially if you're exercising every day, I think you need to be eating more regardless of what the scale is telling you. Have you ever struggled with disordered eating?

CSJobseeker · 11/01/2022 21:12

This isn't much, and it's not very nutritious. Your body needs fuel!

Ledwood85 · 11/01/2022 21:12

I'd be more tempted to up the exercise slightly rather than cut the already sparse food.

Make the spin an hour in duration twice a week? Even better may be to have a couple of rest days and make the remaining classes an hour long, you should achieve much better output and calorie burn.

PurpleDaisies · 11/01/2022 21:11

Seriously, one cookie is 50 calories. Two segments of chocolate orange is another 100.

150calories in snacks isn’t what’s keeping you from losing weight.

bendywendygivemeablast · 11/01/2022 21:11

@gwenneh

Depends on how portion controlled your dinner is and what your starting weight is.

Assuming you're not already at an ideal weight or below, as written and assuming absolutely normal portions (230g salmon, 150g potato with 30g cheese, etc.) yes, that diet would create a calorie deficit. If you're not measuring portions or eating outsized amounts of it all, then you might struggle since there's plenty of cheese in that meal.

That's even before you consider the impact of a 30m spin class (cardio is easy for your body to adapt to and becomes ineffective more quickly than combined or weight training.)

Thank you, this is really helpful.
OP posts:
hulahooper2 · 11/01/2022 21:11

You need to eat a balanced lunch , you’ll be starving if you only eat those snacks all day

gwenneh · 11/01/2022 21:10

Depends on how portion controlled your dinner is and what your starting weight is.

Assuming you're not already at an ideal weight or below, as written and assuming absolutely normal portions (230g salmon, 150g potato with 30g cheese, etc.) yes, that diet would create a calorie deficit. If you're not measuring portions or eating outsized amounts of it all, then you might struggle since there's plenty of cheese in that meal.

That's even before you consider the impact of a 30m spin class (cardio is easy for your body to adapt to and becomes ineffective more quickly than combined or weight training.)

BlueBottle46 · 11/01/2022 21:10

How are they naughty slip ups? You haven't had anything to eat all day!

One slice of toast and a nibble of chocolate is nowhere near enough to get you through an entire day and a spin class! Is this really typical for you?

pregnantncnc · 11/01/2022 21:10

It doesn't sound like you're eating ENOUGH to me.

A better idea would be (keeping it as similar as possible):

Breakfast - low carb bread with peanut butter, a sprinkling of seeds like flax/chia/hemp and some berries

Snack - Greek yoghurt and satsuma, cookie and chocolate orange segments

Lunch - chicken and boiled egg salad with olive oil based dressing. Or a Chicken and lentil broth soup (with veg like celery, carrots, kale in) and some avocado with salt.

Dinner - Salmon fillet, jacket potato with cheese, roasted broccoli and cauliflower with parmesan.

Also, varying your exercise would be more helpful for weight loss than doing the same thing every day - easier said than done, though.

PurpleDaisies · 11/01/2022 21:09

I know I should cut out the bad snacks and have a salad or similar for lunch but time is always the issue.

You’re not not losing weight from one cookie and a couple of bits of chocolate.

Puppalicious · 11/01/2022 21:09

Are you not starving on that? The minimal breakfast and no lunch would leave me feeling sick if combined with sugary snacks (although I seem to be quite sensitive to sugar, can’t have it on an empty stomach).

bendywendygivemeablast · 11/01/2022 21:09

@ILoveAllRainbowsx

If you cut out the snacks then you should definitely lose weight.

Can you try nuts or carrot sticks instead of the snacks?

Or even prunes. They taste like sweets but I'm much better for you and your gut. Tesco do packs of soft prunes which are delicious.

Thank you, this is good and quick!
OP posts:
CurtainTroubles · 11/01/2022 21:09

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request