Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think ring doorbells are intrusive?

139 replies

museumum · 11/01/2022 19:18

I’ve just discovered that my friends ring football starts recording audio when its motion sensor triggered.
Thank fuck we were only saying “you press it ds, it’s that one on the left” etc and not saying anything more personal or offensive but wtf?
AIBU to find it very intrusive to be recorded like that without knowing!

OP posts:
2022HowDoYouDo · 12/01/2022 10:15

A friend of mine got one last year. Now whenever we meet for coffee she's constantly alerted by the bloody thing: "Oh, it's just Steve leaving to play golf", "Oh it's the postman/Amazon delivery guy/parish magazine being delivered/my friend June" "Hello June, yes its me through the ring doorbell. Ha ha yes it's funny isn't it? Yes I can see you. No I'm not at home but I can see you on my phone hahaha!" Wearing a bit thin tbh.

girlmom21 · 12/01/2022 09:59

@The2Omicronnies

I’m not a fan of them whatsoever, but I think they appeal to a certain type of person and I can see why, but they just don’t fit in with my general beliefs.
We got one when someone smashed DP's car window in an attempt to steal the car. Is 'victim of crime' the type of person you're talking about? Does preventing crime go against your beliefs?
mugoftea456 · 12/01/2022 09:58

i love my ring doorbell. We once caught a neighbour absolutely slagging off my dad because his van was parked (legally and perfectly fine) for too long while doing some building work for me.

It was comical to watch.

HopefulProcrastinator · 12/01/2022 09:56

@museumum dash cams do record audio unless you turn it off.

I had to apologise to the police handing over footage of someone else ploughing into a cyclist because I said "fucking hell" on seeing the poor cyclist fly through the air thankfully only concussion which was picked up perfectly. Although I probably would have been more embarrassed if I'd been singing I suppose!

Sally872 · 12/01/2022 09:56

They are very popular so I would not be shocked to see one. Also I don't say anything controversial on doorstep in case window open or home owner emptying bins/accessing car/popping back from next door.

KO81 · 12/01/2022 09:56

@The2Omicronnies

I’m not a fan of them whatsoever, but I think they appeal to a certain type of person and I can see why, but they just don’t fit in with my general beliefs.
People who have been robbed or harassed, perhaps.
TokyoDreaming · 12/01/2022 09:49

There's so much misinformation in this thread.

The bloke who got told to remove his cameras was quite clearly harassing his neighbour.

We have a Google doorbell as my husband is physically disabled and there was a nasty incident outside last year.

The ICO do not need to be informed, fucking hell.

CriminalOrator · 12/01/2022 09:48

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

Does the ICO know you record audio in public? Anyone can make video and audio recordings in public.
There is some widespread misunderstandings around privacy law on this site. I realised that yesterday in the treehouse thread.

People believe children have more rights than adults to privacy in public. They don’t.

Anyone can be filmed or photographed in public without consent. Within private places, though these are debatable in law, people have greater ‘expectations’ of privacy.

That’s not to say that other laws such as harassment may not be infringed by taking images of someone in public.

It’s different when it comes to the publication of these images, however. Journalists have certain laws and a code of practice they have to adhere to, but the actual taking of said footage is not particularly closely controlled.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 12/01/2022 09:46

@PhoenixReincarnated

I thought cctv/ring doorbells were only allowed to record on your own property. Is this true?
Not really
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 12/01/2022 09:42

Does the ICO know you record audio in public?
Anyone can make video and audio recordings in public.

Ileflottante · 12/01/2022 09:41

Some posters like to present themselves as so ‘hard line’ on here. But would you really disown a friend because they had a Ring doorbell that recorded audio? Or if your husband told you to piss off in the middle of a row, would you really kick him out and change the locks? Or is it affected online moral posturing to improve your own perceived status?

We live in a society of surveillance. It’s not great to dwell on. It’s quite frightening really. But by and large it is protective and useful.

The reality is here, next to no one is going to sit and trawl the footage recorded by their doorbells looking for incriminating audio sound bites of their friends. This appears to be forgotten when people get into a frenzy on these threads.

It’s useful to have the facility of two-way audio for speaking to delivery people when out, or for telling the would-be thief to put the parcel down. Speaking down the doorbell allowed my colleague to surprise an ‘uninvited’ person on the property, who looked up in surprise, allowing the camera a great view. They then spoke back and their voice led to an identification. It was all recorded, obviously.

PhoenixReincarnated · 12/01/2022 09:37

I thought cctv/ring doorbells were only allowed to record on your own property. Is this true?

The2Omicronnies · 12/01/2022 09:34

I’m not a fan of them whatsoever, but I think they appeal to a certain type of person and I can see why, but they just don’t fit in with my general beliefs.

Bigboysmademedoit · 12/01/2022 09:29

I didn’t realise my dashcam recorded audio until I played it back - on the TV in the living room, in front of the kids, following an incident - the air was blue!!!!

mumda · 12/01/2022 09:27

@MaybeHeIsMyCat

I have CCTV which also picks up audio. The people it's targeting like to get cross and make V signs at it but yeah, there's plenty of other CCTV on my road which isn't labelled! I did have a CCTV sign but it's been removed on police advice
Does the ICO know you record audio in public?
Ileflottante · 12/01/2022 09:23

@Ileflottante a conversation doesn't have to be snide for you not want it to be recorded or listened to by those for whom it's not intended.

I know, I know. I was trying to make a bit of fun and lighten things up. Nevermind.

Dottybackorcid · 12/01/2022 09:18

I have CCTV and a video door bell (not all are ring). My cars also have 360 cameras recording motion and audio in parking mode. I have assisted the police on a couple of occasions in my area with footage and audio and they have always been very appreciative of it.

People over hear your conversation on a daily basis, through doors, walls, on transport, inshops, in ques, when you walk past. The recordings are only usually a few seconds any way if recorded by devices, just to assist with identication if needed.

I only check mine if I have a reason, it's part of life, you just need to get used to it. It's just added security and peace of mind for many of us, and helps our neighbors if any thing ever happens.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 12/01/2022 09:15

@HumbugWhale

Why does the ring have to be so loud?? A few of our neighbours have them and I can hear them from several doors away if the window is open. I find that pretty instrusive/annoying!
We've got an amplifier as well as DH is deaf!

I love our Ring, it caught our previous cat sitter out when she was spending less than 5 minutes looking after him and when she didn't bother even going in and sent her boyfriend instead.

saraclara · 12/01/2022 09:14

I don't know why this thread is filled with people talking about Ring doorbells in general, and not what the OP is about. Which is that they record people's (your friends' for instance) private conversations. That's very different from simply alerting you when someone is on your property.
It's only a small step to recording your friends' private conversations when they're IN your house.

@Ileflottante a conversation doesn't have to be snide for you not want it to be recorded or listened to by those for whom it's not intended.

AlternativePerspective · 12/01/2022 09:14

The kinds of people who would check every interaction on their ring doorbell are the kind who would be curtain twitchers and nosy busy bodies before the intervention of ring doorbells.

Anyone who thinks that people watch every time their ring is activated clearly doesn’t realise just how often these things are activated. And anyone who actually does look, and listen every time their ring is activated clearly doesn’t have a job.

I have one because there were some dodgy door-to-door types wandering around the area recently, followed by someone chalking some kind of sign on my door number. I am a single parent and am generally home alone as DS is out at college or at work. I am also blind so could conceivably considered to be vulnerable.

I deactivated the notification for motion pretty early on as it was going off constantly. But recently when my DP had a refusal by a taxi company to carry his guide dog we were able to find the footage, along with the recording of the refusal, and send it to Uber to back up the complaint. My DP had another incident a couple of years ago where an Uber driver not only refused but sped off with the door already open, causing the door to slam as he drove off. It could blatantly have killed both DP and the dog, and if only he’d had a ring doorbell or camera footage it would have been treated as a criminal offence. As it was all that he could do was report to Uber and the council and the bloke’s licence was revoked.

Lilifer · 12/01/2022 09:11

@saraclara

I hate all this. The concept of privacy seems to have been lost forever. Governments all over the world must be loving this blind compliance of the population to being monitored constantly.

To be clear, I have no problem with cctv security in public areas, our outside ones home. But when it comes to people having cameras running inside their homes (when they're in) and ring doorbells recording private conversations (seriously, what extra security from burglars does that achieve?), I'm appalled.

Being monitored anonymously in a shopping centre is one thing. Filming your friends inside your home without their knowledge (the subject of another recent thread) or recording their private conversation outside your door, is beyond intrusive.

If I found that any of my friends were doing this, they'd no longer be my friends.

100% agree
user1471457354 · 12/01/2022 09:03

For anyone thats uses cctv/ring doorbells, I'm not sure if you are aware of this. It means your neighbours may be able to submit a Subject Access Request and you are required to provide with with images you hold of them.

ico.org.uk/your-data-matters/domestic-cctv-systems-guidance-for-people-using-cctv/

Waynemanor · 12/01/2022 09:00

Goodness I never realised they recorded audio either! Must remember that !

Ileflottante · 12/01/2022 08:57

Do you normally make snide remarks about your friends behind their backs and are resentful you nearly got caught out?! Grin

Darbs76 · 12/01/2022 08:55

My friends ring doorbell caught the amazon guy stealing a parcel left by Royal Mail a little earlier