Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

AIBU to think that Boris should resign now?

994 replies

Seemslikeagoodidea · 11/01/2022 17:45

Today it has been revealed that in May 2020 invitations were emailed to (allegedly) 100 Downing Street staff, for a garden party. This party happened during the first lockdown, when many people could not visit their elderly relatives, even on their death beds, due to the lockdown rules. The email was sent by one of the PM's top people, and stated that people should "bring their own booze and enjoy the sunshine". Today Boris has been conspicuous by his absence.

I think this is the final straw and shows a lack of judgement and absence of moral fibre. Enough is enough - he should resign and if he doesn't do it then his own party should force him to go.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
WindyState · 12/01/2022 14:29

"I can't get my knickers in a knot over work colleagues being in an outdoor area of their workplace. He's apologised, it was an error of judgement."

But that's not the truth of the matter, is it? It's not just that he attended a party - which was illegal at the time. It's the fact that the person writing the laws, if he/she is going to have any moral authority to see them enforced needs to be seen to follow them.

It's really, really simple to understand.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 12/01/2022 14:29

@Clavinova

What is it you dont understand?

People drink at work, whilst working. I've done that. But I'm doing actual work. Which is what Starmer was doing whilst visiting that constituency office. They were also hosting an online labour event and it was over dinner so they were working, eating and drinking. That was never against the rules.

The party held at downing street, the other parties held in other government building areas held at the end of the work day and involved no work. They were social gatherings in their entirety.

I'm just repeating the exact same think i replied to you in my last post, so how many times are you going to ask the same thing and need the same answer before you understand?

Notonthestairs · 12/01/2022 14:28
  1. There were no parties.
  1. If there were parties all guidelines were followed.
  1. I didn't breach the guidelines and attend a party. I am as furious as you are.
  1. I might have had cheese and wine with my wife and assorted advisors but it was strictly work.
  1. Oh you mean the 40 people in my garden who brought their own booze ...
BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 12/01/2022 14:28

@justasking111, aside from the toxic masculinity BS argument you’ve presented, the number of service people with PTSD from active service is a tragedy. A lack of counselling, stiff-upper lip attitudes and dismissal of a need for mental health support as ‘namby-pamby’ is not helpful at all.

SafeMove · 12/01/2022 14:28

@Itsalmostanaccessory

Do you not see an issue with that sort of behaviour from a prime minister?

No the poster doesn't. He/she has repeatedly said he/she doesn't see it as a problem and is 'meh' about it. He/she sees more value in the economic recovery and the vaccine rollout. Their lens is on this. Not on lies or deaths or failings. I guess it gives us a broader view. Even if it is pretty chilling to read.

justasking111 · 12/01/2022 14:28

@ancientgran

Isn't it a bit odd that people are still trying to justify this on here when Johnson has apologised (several times, did anyone count?) and admitted it was wrong and he wishes it hadn't happened.

Do all his fans think he's wrong now or wrong then?

Yes it was wrong but folks were partying through the pandemic from the start some got sick, some really sick, some died. Some still think it's a government conspiracy, some think it's Chinese warfare. The reasons for breaking the rules are legion
Moppiehen · 12/01/2022 14:28

Keir Starmer didn’t make the rules. Boris did and he broke them. Does this really need pointing out. Is this the only line of defence now for Boris fans?

BashStreetKid · 12/01/2022 14:27

@JaniieJones

'If 40 plus people turned up to the party then 40 plus people are also tossers who didn't obey the restrictions'

But they were surely people who minutes before were inside the building working together so what actually is the problem?

If we find out people on their days off were turning up with their kids in tow fine, but work colleagues going outside and the PM spending 25mins with them does not outrage me.

Some of you must stopped being so whipped into a frenzy by the media.

The problem, as you well know, is that it was being emphasised that this sort of gathering was out of the question, irrespective of the background circumstances. There was no exception saying "but it's fine if you were working with them during the day". Nor was there any exception saying "It's fine if you keep socially distanced". And Johnson and his friends knew that perfectly well.
SueSaid · 12/01/2022 14:27

'That was actually at work, whilst doing work. You can drink during work if it is allowed in that business.'

Exactly! work colleagues in an outdoor communal work area, drinking which is no doubt 'allowed in that business'. Not say, if they were a bunch of neurosurgeons on a break.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 12/01/2022 14:27

It was an error or judgement not crime of the century, he's apologised but it was a work place. They were colleagues. So what.

The "so what" is the stark contrast between overprivileged. gits poncing about in Downing Street and the austere and stern pronouncements and instructions being issued forth to us proles by those exact same cunts - or which Johnson is leader.

nanbread · 12/01/2022 14:27

There was a statue of limitation but some people dismantled it and threw it into the harbour.

Grin
VikingOnTheFridge · 12/01/2022 14:25

@Soffit

it is obvious that Rishi does not want the job, right now in 2022 at a stage of the pandemic when we still cannot predict the end. This leaves precisely nobody with more charisma. It leaves may honest potential leaders but as Kier proves, it is not enough
I dunno, I think all the obvious contenders now aren't really big enough hitters to be able to wait for their moment. They're all the sort who get presented with an opportunity by circumstance rather than clear leaders in waiting.
Clavinova · 12/01/2022 14:25

Itsalmostanaccessory
That was actually at work, whilst doing work. You can drink during work if it is allowed in that business

So you can have an alcoholic drink whilst working after all? Was Keir Starmer asked to bring his own beer?

ancientgran · 12/01/2022 14:23

Isn't it a bit odd that people are still trying to justify this on here when Johnson has apologised (several times, did anyone count?) and admitted it was wrong and he wishes it hadn't happened.

Do all his fans think he's wrong now or wrong then?

LondonJax · 12/01/2022 14:23

"But it happened throughout, my family awash with NHS workers from consultant's down partied hard, Christmas, birthdays, nightclubbing, it's up on their Instagram pages no big secret. They're still standing after 22 months of covid from 50 plus year olds right down to 3rd year med students."

@justasking111 - well they certainly weren't doing it when Boris was enjoying his little booze up/small glass of wine (whichever you believe). Pubs and restaurants didn't open until June? July? We went for a weekend break in August and they were doing the 'eat out to help out' to get people using the restaurants again. I couldn't get my hair cut until then as my hairdresser was inundated for appointments when she opened in July.

And nightclubs were closed for well over 12 months - I remember everything finally opening just before the schools broke up last year. My sister has a daughter with an auto-immune problem and she was worried about covid levels soaring when nightclubs opened.

They may have partied, I don't doubt that, people play hard when life is hard. But they didn't do it in May 2020 because nowhere was open for them to do it and they'd be arrested if they tried it in a park!

Itsalmostanaccessory · 12/01/2022 14:22

@Clavinova

That was actually at work, whilst doing work. You can drink during work if it is allowed in that business.

What happened at downing street and other government buildings was not work. They were purely social gatherings. Not work.

BashStreetKid · 12/01/2022 14:21

@JaniieJones

Why are the media trawling out all the stories people who lost people. Yes very sad but not comparable situations.

If we find out Johnson attended a funeral with 100 people present fine but he didn't. A brief garden visit with colleagues, he has apologised it was an error of judgement.

They have got a lot right in the pandemic.

You know perfectly well why that is highly relevant. Please don't pretend to be obtuse.

And 150,000 deaths doesn't look like "getting a lot right".

CPL593H · 12/01/2022 14:21

My neighbor retired now saw NI Falkland Islands, Eastern Europe, he says it's normal to party in awful times. He's not impressed with the pearl clutching, mask wearing, self righteous namby pambies who have never had to dig up mass graves in Bosnia, no counselling out there he said

@justasking111 with respect, your neighbours military service and views on Covid measures are utterly irrelevant.

ancientgran · 12/01/2022 14:21

@BashStreetKid

Simon Hoare MP now saying this was a party to welcome Johnson back from hospital and say thank you to Raab for holding the fort. twitter.com/search?q=Raab&src=trend_click&vertical=trends

So definitely a party, then, and it does look rather like Raab has some questions to answer, too.

Raab was furiously whispering to Boris Johnson at one point in PMQs and by the screwed up brow he wasn't whispering sweet nothings.
SueSaid · 12/01/2022 14:21

@IGotHam

JanieJones how do you explain so many errors of judgement? Boris seems to have a error of judgement every other day.
Errors of judgement over a 25min visit to a alleged 'party' and wallpaper. I agree he should've gone to B&Q like the rest of us.

Fortunately he gets much of the important stuff right. Fastest growth in the G7, fastest vaccine rollout, best handling of omicron in the UK (sniggers at Nicola and Drakeford), Freedom day in July etc etc.

I can't get my knickers in a knot over work colleagues being in an outdoor area of their workplace. He's apologised, it was an error of judgement.

Cornettoninja · 12/01/2022 14:21

It occurs to me that Boris wasn’t long out of hospital himself at the time of this party. The PM dying would have caused some serious problems at a time the country was in the midst of a crisis. Following this line they were prepared to risk 100 members of staff - who would have had to be classified as essential - at a time any outbreak in number 10 would have affected the running of the country.

Those of us who worked during the first lockdown know there was no such thing as a bubble of 100 people. People had smaller departmental bubbles for work purposes and there were even video calls between departments on the same site to keep contacts at a minimum.

Anyone defending this needs to think long and hard about which side of the debate they think they belong on. If you weren’t sent an invite for 20/05 not one person in charge of the country thinks you’re their equal - they think they’re a class distinct from you and only you should have been subject to scrutiny/potential legal repercussions for similar behaviour at the same time. It’s one thing to have the piss taken out of you, quite another to defend them with their boot on your head.

mumshouse · 12/01/2022 14:20

We'll see him again once he's over this latest sulk and wants more pictures in the press.

BashStreetKid · 12/01/2022 14:20

@JaniieJones

I just find it odd that all these reported 'parties' have been anything but.

3 people doing a zoom Christmas quiz, Downing Street staff sitting outside. Wine may have been drunk but we've yet to see 2am photos of people actually 'partying' aren't we.

When you have a get-together in the garden at 6 pm which is expressly for drinks on a BYOB basis, it's a soiree/celebration/party. In May 2020, all of those were unlawful.
placemats · 12/01/2022 14:20

@justasking111

If she does, I will personally hold her to this come the next general election.

Jellllybeeen · 12/01/2022 14:20

Absolutely he should go. My wonderful grandma passed away in May 2020 due to complications following a fall in April. She was one of the kindest people I've ever known. The last time I saw her well was in March not long before lockdown but when Covid was spreading and I didn't hug her because we were conscious of being careful. She fell a few weeks later and broke her leg and didn't recover. I managed to visit her once in the nursing home as she was deemed end of life so the eg allowed one visit per day for an hour. When she got very lightly better we were no longer allowed to visit her and she passed all of a sudden without any of us by her side. We couldn't have a proper funeral for her and she so deserved to have a wonderful send off with all the family there. It still doesn't feel real that she passed and I miss her so much. I wish now that I had hugged her before she got ill. We followed all the rules as we were told it was the right thing to do to stop the spread and protect people. I am disgusted to think that around this time, Boris Johnson and the others making the rules, those who are supposed to set an example were meeting up and enjoying drinks together. He needs to go and whoever replaces him needs to do better!

Swipe left for the next trending thread