Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

AIBU to think that Boris should resign now?

994 replies

Seemslikeagoodidea · 11/01/2022 17:45

Today it has been revealed that in May 2020 invitations were emailed to (allegedly) 100 Downing Street staff, for a garden party. This party happened during the first lockdown, when many people could not visit their elderly relatives, even on their death beds, due to the lockdown rules. The email was sent by one of the PM's top people, and stated that people should "bring their own booze and enjoy the sunshine". Today Boris has been conspicuous by his absence.

I think this is the final straw and shows a lack of judgement and absence of moral fibre. Enough is enough - he should resign and if he doesn't do it then his own party should force him to go.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
LondonJax · 12/01/2022 17:44

@Toblerone20

Having watched todays pm questions I think Boris should stay, as do most people I’ve spoken with in person today at work etc.

We have more important things to worry about as a country than whether people broke lockdown. Plus an element of this behaviour from politicians doesn’t surprise me.

I also think it’s quite distasteful to bring up all the stories about people who have died while MPs were partying. The restrictions were in place to keep people safe and for our benefit however hand on heart how many people can say they stuck to them 100 percent? Not everyone on here I bet.

The opposition would be best focussing on how to actually offer a credible alternative for voters rather than playing the sympathy card and how outrageous Boris is. We all know that….what we haven’t a clue about is what else they have to offer other than criticism.

The government aren’t to blame for the pandemic and I believe they have done the best they can and I’m sure they’ve all worked extremely hard. I don’t believe labour would have done any better.

I’m not some sort of die hard Tory or Boris fan, I just don’t see the sense in wasting so much time raking this stuff up now it’s just a massive distraction from many more pressing concerns and the reason behind it gaining so much traction is the cynical agenda behind those responsible for the leaks. Nothing to do with morality and all to do with power struggles.

Idiots that we are @Toblerone20, my family and I did obey the rules in April 2020. When we held the funeral for my mum. Who didn't die of Covid but got caught up in the 'rules' that apparently I could have ignored.

We had just six people to her funeral. We had to sit in our 'family bubble' type groups which meant I sat alone. My DH had to stay with our DS as there was no-one to look after him (we weren't 'allowed' to mix - maybe I should have broken that rule?)

We couldn't hug each other, had to leave 2 metres between our groups and had to leave separately.

Mum had no wake, nothing was open. She had silk flowers from EBay as florists weren't open and my friend, who was a florist, couldn't get flowers anywhere.

But, hey, there you go. We should have broken the rules. Our fault. What idiots eh?

Huntswomanonthemove · 12/01/2022 17:44

@Roussette

Angela Rayner lets herself down and Starmer is weak

Good job this thread isn't about them then, isn't it?

It's a discussion on an internet forum. Discussions on internet forums tend to be discussions. Are you the internet discussion police?
Clavinova · 12/01/2022 17:42

LondonJax
Yes...and?

I've made my point already - I recognise a number of posters on this thread who seem to be rather hypocritical. I didn't bring up 'Europe'.

Hotchox · 12/01/2022 17:42

Priti Patel (person in charge of law and order) actually said she'd call the police on neighbours found to be having a party. Now it turns out Boris did actually have one, she's decided what we need to do is put it to one side and get behind him again....

... what it must be like to be a Tory eh? Sheesh!

22itsallnew · 12/01/2022 17:38

Boris Johnson isn't sorry about Covid lockdown breach. He's sorry he got caught – Ian Murray MP

Exactly this

user1363157897422457887532356 · 12/01/2022 17:38

You can not create legislation, enforce it against the public but then reserve the right to flout it - and repeatedly lie to Parliament and the public about it.

Exactly.

This man is responsible for people being forced to die alone. For people being forced to receive terminal diagnoses alone. For people being denied their only chance to say goodbye to loved ones.

He set the rules that put people in those positions. And meanwhile he was attending parties.

That matters.

BashStreetKid · 12/01/2022 17:35

@Galdos

And if he resigns or the Tory party boot him out, who will become PM? Absent a general election none of us will have a say in who replaces him. He’s behaving exactly as he always has, and at least that’s a known quantity, even if some of us seem surprised.
Hardly a valid reason for keeping a lying, incompetent, corrupt PM, is it?
LondonJax · 12/01/2022 17:35

@Clavinova

We are constantly picking empty fights with Europe for no good reason

That reminds me - a number of posters on this thread were defending Ursula von der Leyen last year - not only did she hold some unnecessary in-person meetings which sparked several outbreaks of Covid amongst EU Commissioners and staff, but she also drove 5/6 hours to Germany when everyone thought she was self-isolating in her flat in Belgium. That was all hushed-up.

Yes...and?

Cummings drove to Barnard Castle (and finally went)
Scottish MP Margaret Ferrier went on a train whilst positive for Covid (Nicola Sturgeon called on her to resign, suspended her in October 2020 and she was arrested on 4th January 2021 and stands trial this year)
Catherine Calderwood, Scotland's chief medical officer, resigned or was sacked (can't remember which) for travelling to her holiday home during lockdown
Kay Burley was suspended for six months for having a meal with more friends than was allowed.

However, none of those people were Prime Minister of this country, lied about what he knew until he was backed into a corner, nor broke his own rules.

Oh and before you bring it up. Yes, Nicola Sturgeon did remove a mask whilst indoors at a funeral a while ago and apologised a week later. Quote: 'Ms Sturgeon said: "I want to be clear that regardless of the circumstances, I was in the wrong. There are no excuses.

"These rules do apply to me, just as they do to everyone else, and the rules really matter.

"I am kicking myself very hard - possibly harder than my worst critic ever could - but more importantly I'll be making sure I don't drop my guard again." She managed that a little quicker than 18 months and didn't deny, deny, deny before apologising but there you go.

Can you find any more? I'm enjoying this game. Because it is a game. Find some people who either don't live in this country, don't make the rules, are complete idiots or who have paid the price and compare them to Boris. Who is actually the person this thread is about.

Pumperthepumper · 12/01/2022 17:34

Waiting for ‘all politicians lie’

Pumperthepumper · 12/01/2022 17:34

It has quite a lot to do with morality, doesn’t it? We’ve got a prime minister who openly and unashamedly lies. Lies all the time. Lies to everyone, creeps and covers up and deflects. Don’t you think we deserve better than that?

doublemonkey · 12/01/2022 17:34

Is anyone wondering how it could be that people in No.10, who were privvy to all kinds of data, statistics, science etc. that we are not - is anyone wondering why these people thought it SAFE to hold a large party for 100 people??

Because that is the real question. Not whether they lied, or broke the rules.. It's that they knew those rules were bullshit and they felt no compulsion to obey them.

Poetrypatty · 12/01/2022 17:34

Having watched todays pm questions I think Boris should stay, as do most people I’ve spoken with in person today at work etc

Do you work at Tory HQ?

Everyone I know thinks he should have already resigned over this.

user1363157897422457887532356 · 12/01/2022 17:34

hand on heart how many people can say they stuck to them 100 percent?

We are talking about the people responsible for imposing these rules and the terrible harms they caused.

What is distasteful is not people talking about their bereavements, it is that our PM forced people to die alone while he continued attending parties - without any regard for the rules he imposed upon the rest of the population.

The man didn't even have the decency to apologise. His statement was a series of self-serving excuses and he dismissed challenges as "partisan" and "playing politics" - all of this is a game to him.

He has no respect for the British people.

Cornettoninja · 12/01/2022 17:30

And who could forget all the conga lines in May 2020 for VE Day?

All the conga lines? That didn’t happen by me and no one else I know anywhere else in the country reported conga lines either. Now I don’t doubt that they happened but I do doubt the majority of the country were living it up on VE flouting all the restrictions at the time.

You’re rewriting history with a flair for spin that makes me think one of the red tops might approach you for a work opportunity.

Notonthestairs · 12/01/2022 17:27

You can not create legislation, enforce it against the public but then reserve the right to flout it - and repeatedly lie to Parliament and the public about it.

The Prime Minister lied about there ever being parties at Number 10, lied that the parties followed guidelines and then lied about attending them.

Likkleredridinghood · 12/01/2022 17:27

@Toblerone20 agree he should stay. He's a liability. The tories need to own the mess they have created. The effects of brexit are slowly emerging, ordinary w/c and m/c people are going to see their living standards tumble over the next few years, resigning enables him to avoid accountability for the absolute chaos they have created.

ElenaCouch · 12/01/2022 17:27

@Toblerone20

Having watched todays pm questions I think Boris should stay, as do most people I’ve spoken with in person today at work etc.

We have more important things to worry about as a country than whether people broke lockdown. Plus an element of this behaviour from politicians doesn’t surprise me.

I also think it’s quite distasteful to bring up all the stories about people who have died while MPs were partying. The restrictions were in place to keep people safe and for our benefit however hand on heart how many people can say they stuck to them 100 percent? Not everyone on here I bet.

The opposition would be best focussing on how to actually offer a credible alternative for voters rather than playing the sympathy card and how outrageous Boris is. We all know that….what we haven’t a clue about is what else they have to offer other than criticism.

The government aren’t to blame for the pandemic and I believe they have done the best they can and I’m sure they’ve all worked extremely hard. I don’t believe labour would have done any better.

I’m not some sort of die hard Tory or Boris fan, I just don’t see the sense in wasting so much time raking this stuff up now it’s just a massive distraction from many more pressing concerns and the reason behind it gaining so much traction is the cynical agenda behind those responsible for the leaks. Nothing to do with morality and all to do with power struggles.

Are you actually serious?? If people didn't have to stick to the rules 100%, and could break them, let's say, 5%, then don't you think people would of used their 5% to be with their loved ones on the deathbeds. No, because they weren't ALLOWED. FFS get it in your head.
DeliriaSkibbly · 12/01/2022 17:26

@Toblerone20

Having watched todays pm questions I think Boris should stay, as do most people I’ve spoken with in person today at work etc.

We have more important things to worry about as a country than whether people broke lockdown. Plus an element of this behaviour from politicians doesn’t surprise me.

I also think it’s quite distasteful to bring up all the stories about people who have died while MPs were partying. The restrictions were in place to keep people safe and for our benefit however hand on heart how many people can say they stuck to them 100 percent? Not everyone on here I bet.

The opposition would be best focussing on how to actually offer a credible alternative for voters rather than playing the sympathy card and how outrageous Boris is. We all know that….what we haven’t a clue about is what else they have to offer other than criticism.

The government aren’t to blame for the pandemic and I believe they have done the best they can and I’m sure they’ve all worked extremely hard. I don’t believe labour would have done any better.

I’m not some sort of die hard Tory or Boris fan, I just don’t see the sense in wasting so much time raking this stuff up now it’s just a massive distraction from many more pressing concerns and the reason behind it gaining so much traction is the cynical agenda behind those responsible for the leaks. Nothing to do with morality and all to do with power struggles.

Is that you Carrie ?
justasking111 · 12/01/2022 17:25

Rishi was unable to make the commons today he was in Devon. ROFLMAO . He's been invisible for ages now.

Florianus · 12/01/2022 17:25

@BashStreetKid

Maybe he didn't class work colleagues in an outdoor work area, at work, as a 'party'?! I know I wouldn't

It doesn't matter whether he thought it was a party or not. The rules related to gatherings of any sort, not just parties. He's accepted that it wasn't a work event.

The rules related to meeting more than one other person in a public place. The garden of No.10 is not a public place. That, I am afraid, is what Johnson will rely upon.
DeliriaSkibbly · 12/01/2022 17:24

@JaniieJones

'No further restrictions - well, that's not really something to trumpet about, is it ? They're clearly needed in some way still because, despite what Jacob Rees-Mogg would have you believe, Omicron is still a serious problem and there are no guarantees that other, more serious strains aren't just around the corner '

It is something to 'trumpet' if you believe businesses and livelihoods are of importance. Which I do.

Restrictions are not 'clearly needed' whatsoever. What you think we should lockdown in case another variant is lurking?!

I didn't say lockdown, though, did I ? I said restrictions.

I'm sorry you can't see that one doesn't necessarily lead to another.

SueSaid · 12/01/2022 17:22

'No further restrictions - well, that's not really something to trumpet about, is it ? They're clearly needed in some way still because, despite what Jacob Rees-Mogg would have you believe, Omicron is still a serious problem and there are no guarantees that other, more serious strains aren't just around the corner '

It is something to 'trumpet' if you believe businesses and livelihoods are of importance. Which I do.

Restrictions are not 'clearly needed' whatsoever. What you think we should lockdown in case another variant is lurking?!

Toblerone20 · 12/01/2022 17:21

Having watched todays pm questions I think Boris should stay, as do most people I’ve spoken with in person today at work etc.

We have more important things to worry about as a country than whether people broke lockdown. Plus an element of this behaviour from politicians doesn’t surprise me.

I also think it’s quite distasteful to bring up all the stories about people who have died while MPs were partying. The restrictions were in place to keep people safe and for our benefit however hand on heart how many people can say they stuck to them 100 percent? Not everyone on here I bet.

The opposition would be best focussing on how to actually offer a credible alternative for voters rather than playing the sympathy card and how outrageous Boris is. We all know that….what we haven’t a clue about is what else they have to offer other than criticism.

The government aren’t to blame for the pandemic and I believe they have done the best they can and I’m sure they’ve all worked extremely hard. I don’t believe labour would have done any better.

I’m not some sort of die hard Tory or Boris fan, I just don’t see the sense in wasting so much time raking this stuff up now it’s just a massive distraction from many more pressing concerns and the reason behind it gaining so much traction is the cynical agenda behind those responsible for the leaks. Nothing to do with morality and all to do with power struggles.

User135644 · 12/01/2022 17:20

@JaniieJones

Thought he came across well in PMQs. Apologised, admitted it shouldn't have happened then pointed out what they have done well. Fastest economic growth in the G7, least restrictions in Europe, fastest vaccine roll out etc etc.

This was a massive error of judgement. If nothing else it would obviously have got out, but going into a garden for 25mins to thank staff who were drinking wine doesn't seem that outrageous.

You only had to read mumsnet to see many were flouting, fine they weren't running the country but the faux outrage when beaches etc were all rammed that weekend is a bit unconvincing.

And who could forget all the conga lines in May 2020 for VE Day?
WindyState · 12/01/2022 17:20

@JaniieJones

'What is our 'strong position'?'

Fastest growing economy in the G7, fastest vaccine rollout , no further restrictions even with Scotland and Wales flapping, Freedom day in July etc etc etc.

You've erected tents in your carpark to deal with bodies?!! Where tf is this and why aren't the media reporting on it!

Most sensible people realise we are in a fairly reasonable position despite Boris and co's best efforts, certainly not because of them.