Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lodger wants my details for internet provider

83 replies

Greatwhitegats · 11/01/2022 12:26

I’m spending a few days away and the internet started playing up.

He’s told me the other day and I couldn’t call as they weren’t open (I did do as much online as I could). It was all working ok and today it stopped working.

He’s wFH at the moment and sent thus message ‘Hi I'm still having issues, is it possible to share X details so I can talk to X direct’.

I ignored and called them. They did some checks and stated it was the line at fault (didn’t do back end stuff over holiday and recently changed to broadband). Lodger stated “it’s the modem” and obviously doesn’t have faith in me.

What can I do if the internet provider is stating they’ve done the checks?

Also he uses a Mac and he has trouble with that early evening, my dell doesn’t. My friend said it’s because they are swapping frequencies (or something) and he needs to sort out his Mac. Again doesn’t listen.

Aibu for

  1. not giving him my account details
  2. thinking my provider can’t do much more
OP posts:
ittakes2 · 11/01/2022 14:14

See I can’t see why you won’t give the details - I would be delighted if he offered to do the leg work but I am quite lazy.

Dottybackorcid · 11/01/2022 14:14

OP if he is working from home tell him to buy something like this.

Huawei B311 2020, CAT 4, 4G/ LTE 150 Mbps Mobile Wi-Fi Router, Unlocked to All Networks- Genuine UK Warranty STOCK (Non Network Logo) with FREE SMARTY SIM Card- White B311-221 amazon.co.uk/dp/B08B1VFHKB/ref=cm_sw_r_apan_glt_fabc_WZJVE7DKZCKTSC2W68X2?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1]]

Or use his mobile phone as a WiFi hotspot. I use one incase my home WiFi goes down and can keep working.

LampLighter414 · 11/01/2022 14:13

Hi OP

Re: your friends suggestion. It is probably correct. My Macbook (albeit old) played up badly with my new broadband connection and wifi router. The reason being it defaulted to broadcasting over 2.4ghz and 5ghz bands using the same name - previous wifi emitted 2 networks, one which was named the same but with 5GHZ suffix added. Anyways technically a lot of Macs struggle with both frequencies having the same wifi name, I guess there is some confusion when it certain areas of the home it finds the correct network (the wifi name) but is trying to connect via 5GHZ when the 5GHZ signal is weak in that area of the house and doesn't think to try 2.4GHZ.

Solution is often splitting up the network broadcast in the settings (some routers don't allow this) or you can manually fool the mac into only connecting to 2.4GHZ by forgetting the saved wifi on it, changing your wifi to broadcast only 2.4GHZ, connecting the mac and then changing your wifi to broadcast in dual 2.4GHZ/5GHZ again

Some details here:
community.bt.com/t5/Archive-Staging/Wi-fi-constantly-disconnects-from-my-Macbook/td-p/1444261

Hope it helps.

Otherwise more generally communicate what the broadband provider has checked and what they are saying the problem is and when they are going to fix it.

Your lodger can go into the office or use alternative (e.g. tethering) for a few days surely? It would be no different if they had their own property and the internet played up and there was a delay in getting an engineer out.

kirinm · 11/01/2022 14:10

Based on the attitude in your posts here, I'd say crappy wifi is the last of the lodger's problems.

DysmalRadius · 11/01/2022 14:09

I don't expect them to have a magic wand. I expect them to provide the service they advertised, and for which their client is paying.

But the op is paying the ISP for a service that they are currently unable to provide - why is she being held to a higher standard of Internet provision that the Internet service provider themselves?

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/01/2022 14:07

- how you are providing him with internet access (at your expense) in the interim. That, whilst nice, wouldn't be enforceable by any contract. It's wifi, not a roof! OP can offer a small deduction, for the inconvenience not any value of work lost he may try to place in it.

But, along with clear updates, is all she need do. He isn;t in a 5 star hotel, he cannot demand more than a 'reasonable' time and quality of fix than any person who owns the home would expect. The service he can expect is weighed agains 'normal' not 'perfect'.

CheshireChat · 11/01/2022 14:05

I think he's frustrated with your attitude of 'oh well, not my problem, go and tether', I doubt you'd feel the same way if he asked for a reduction in rent because of this.

Since it works worse on a MAC, you should be talking to the BB provider to find out why that is and how they can fix it. Or let him talk to them directly without giving him the details- just pass the phone or tell the chat advisor what's going on.

Wheelz46 · 11/01/2022 14:04

The only solution for a company to speak to a third party is the account holder giving authority for said third party to deal.

OP, could you call the company, give them authorisation to deal with your lodger, giving a password for lodger to provide to them (you should be able to stipulate it is a one off authorisation). Your lodger should then only have to provide your name and address, which they will know anyway, give their own name and password.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/01/2022 14:03

[quote LittleGwyneth]@curiousaboutsamphire I don't expect them to have a magic wand. I expect them to provide the service they advertised, and for which their client is paying.

Having a lodger is a business arrangement. I doubt the OP would like it if the lodger started knocking a few quid off payments every month. It's a business transaction like any other.

Honestly your response worries me with regards to what kind of LL you are/ would be.[/quote]
Not a LL. I do work with lettings and see unreasonable behaviour from tenants and landlords alike. I often have to be the referee between 2 sets of unreasonable people.

And in this case, with maybe the exception of clarity of communciations with her lodger, OP has done what she can. The service expected is less than perfect for reasons beyond her control, reasons she has enquired into and found a solution, It will, like most things, take time. Tine she has no control over.

If it were just her living there alone this issue would still exist and woudlld take the same amount of time to put right. And that is ALL that can be expected of a landlord when it comes to such services. - parity of time and quality.

Your expectations seem to require absolute immediacy - which is unreasonable.

OliviaBond · 11/01/2022 14:01

If it's a line issue then it probably has nothing to do with his Mac. When are they fixing the line issue?

mrsm43s · 11/01/2022 13:56

As a minimum, your lodger needs to know

  • what the problem is
  • how it is going to be resolved
  • when it is going to be resolved
  • how you are providing him with internet access (at your expense) in the interim.

You are currently away, he is offering to take over the arrangements in your absence to save you the bother. You don't have to pass this issue over to him to solve and give him your internet details (I wouldn't), but since you are choosing not to do that, then you will have to, as a matter of urgency, interrupt your time away in order to get this resolved for him, including sorting him out with interim arrangements for internet access until the fault is rectified.

What you cannot reasonably do is expect him to just suck up having no internet access, no agreed timescale for when it will be restored, and no interim arrangements in place.

LittleGwyneth · 11/01/2022 13:55

@curiousaboutsamphire I don't expect them to have a magic wand. I expect them to provide the service they advertised, and for which their client is paying.

Having a lodger is a business arrangement. I doubt the OP would like it if the lodger started knocking a few quid off payments every month. It's a business transaction like any other.

Honestly your response worries me with regards to what kind of LL you are/ would be.

2bazookas · 11/01/2022 13:54

His problem not yours.. Maybe he'll need to invest in his own wifi.

UniversalAunt · 11/01/2022 13:53

Do not give him your details.
You are providing residential accommodation with residential internet service, not a business broadband service, so if it takes time to resolve the issue, it takes time.

Have your IP recently upgraded to 5G in your area?

Flowers500 · 11/01/2022 13:48

Stop acting like an overgrown child, he’s paying for this so you need to sort it immediately while keeping him fully informed or give him access to speak to them. Your reasons on here would not assume me you have any idea what’s up or the ability of motivations to sort it. If you resent doing the bare minimum don’t take lodgers.

Jjjayfee · 11/01/2022 13:42

You don't sound like the most accommodating landlord. It is not reasonable for him to tether or go into work if he was told internet is available. Like all of us though he will have to put up with some delay if the internet provider needs to sort something out.

BlingLoving · 11/01/2022 13:36

IF they've said the line is at fault, have they said when it will be fixed and what happens next? because it does feel a bit vague and if I was your lodger that would really irritate me.

if there's an issue with his device, he probably does need to speak to them directly so that they can troubleshoot with him. If you were at home, you could call, go through authentication then hand over the phone. As you're not, I'd call and ask them if you can do the authentication and then bring him into the call or ask them to then call him or something. There must be a way to make this work.

You do seem to have a very relaxed attitude. You clearly think he shouldn't be working from him but that's not really your decision.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/01/2022 13:33

@LittleGwyneth

I couldn't live somewhere where the internet doesn't work - I would find it easier to be somewhere with broken heating. I think you're being extremely unreasonable not to provide it if you said you would when the room was initially advertised. If you said there would be internet, it's your job to make sure there is internet.
And that is why so many landlords have such a bad name. Tenant, lodgers and Uncle Tom Cobbley all expect them to have magic wands.
CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/01/2022 13:32

What is odd? She has contacted the provider, they have identified the problem and have issued a work ticket. OP is aware, lodger is aware. What else is to be done?

The rest is just the confusion over the intermittent nature of the issue.

LittleGwyneth · 11/01/2022 13:32

I couldn't live somewhere where the internet doesn't work - I would find it easier to be somewhere with broken heating. I think you're being extremely unreasonable not to provide it if you said you would when the room was initially advertised. If you said there would be internet, it's your job to make sure there is internet.

3mealsaday · 11/01/2022 13:31

Presumably he needs wifi to wfh. I don't blame him for being frustrated.

Look on the bright side. If this is a frequent issue, he'll probably give notice soon and then you won't have him annoying you. Since he needs to work to earn the money to pay his rent.

MamaGaia · 11/01/2022 13:29

@buckeejit

It sounds like you resent your lodger for some reason.

I would be doing my utmost to get it sorted with specific details from the ISP & apologise to lodger but explain you aren't comfortable sharing account details.

I'd rather have no heating than no internet!

Agreed. Very odd approach from OP. He’s the one who is having his ability to wfh affected and OP’s attitude is not my problem.

Doesn’t matter if he’s just a lodger - he’s paying you to be there, so stop being so difficult and work WITH him to help resolve it.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/01/2022 13:25

@Beautiful3

Perhaps change the modem and see if it improves for the time being.
Why? When the provider has confirmed that they ommitted part of the installation? It won't make any difference.
buckeejit · 11/01/2022 13:24

It sounds like you resent your lodger for some reason.

I would be doing my utmost to get it sorted with specific details from the ISP & apologise to lodger but explain you aren't comfortable sharing account details.

I'd rather have no heating than no internet!

CheshireChat · 11/01/2022 13:14

Can't he contact the Internet provider to report the fault himself? He doesn't usually need your account details then.