Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want my son to do rugby because of the culture?

263 replies

sausagedogsforever · 11/01/2022 11:38

I probably am being unreasonable but, my DS aged 5 really wants to do rugby. He once had a taster session, loved it and has asked to go since (for a good year). So shows no signs of getting over the urge.

I am thinking maybe I should take him again to another taster (maybe he won't like it) but also what if he loves it?

I used to like watching rugby and I find the games much more family friendly to watch than football matches. However, I've heard terrible things about rugby players and rugby playing culture? Like gross drinking games, sexism, just all round bad behaviour and treatment of women, initiation games to fit in etc.
is this really what it's like? Does anyone have any experience?
The other issue is injury, it's likely in a sport like that, so do I really want to encourage this?
Any advice welcome. Has anyone got a rugby playing son/husband?
Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Hbh17 · 11/01/2022 12:48

When my godsons played, they were taught principles of fair play, discipline & respect. Strict rules of behaviour in the club house etc. Supposed to be a game for gentlemen.

PotatoPie888 · 11/01/2022 12:45

I loath the rugby culture as do my Ds who despite being good players, preferred other sports. I’ve never been around so many twats in my life. I think it was Orwell who said if you want to get rid of fascism in England bomb Twickenham. Having spent an afternoon there, I think he had a point.
The way the game is played these days is also too dangerous. Macho attitudes are endangering children’s health.

Freshprincess · 11/01/2022 12:42

You’re massively overthinking this.

In his teens, if he sticks with it, you’ll be delighted that he’s got such an active hobby. Kids hanging around with nothing to do are way worse than whatever you think happens in rugby.

It’s a really family friendly game.

ShinyHappyPoster · 11/01/2022 12:41

@StrychnineInTheSandwiches

And in my experience the old adage of “football is a gentlemen’s game played by thugs, while rugby is a thugs’ game played by gentlemen,” is largely true.

People always trot this one out and I'm not sure I agree with it. I've seen plenty of boorish behaviour from rugby players.

But if a 5 year old is enthusiastic about a sport I'd certainly be encouraging them to try it out.

Yy I think the old adage is just classism tbh. They mean 'gentlemen' by class and money - not by behaviour. I've seen much more boorish behaviour from rugby players (amateur teams) than football. Thinking rugby is for 'gentlemen' is elitist and classist, and can translate into certain rugby teams and clubs being cliquey.
Billandben444 · 11/01/2022 12:41

My 13yr old grandson plays for his local club and has done since he was 8. It's a great masculine environment for him (no dad around) and the emphasis is on respect, playing as a team and channelling their competitiveness. He's made another group of friends apart from school, which is always a bonus, and they often meet up at the club to help set up for the seniors or act as ball boys as well as play their own matches. Please don't dismiss it out of hand - we'd sooner have him hanging out there at a weekend than on a street corner somewhere. As to drinking, well, I'm sure the blokes have a good time but no worse than with any other sport.

Simonjt · 11/01/2022 12:39

I play rugby, I was a full time professional player, i’m now part time semi-professional.

Rugby is a great sport, team spirirt is very strong, rivlary is very friendly, fans sit together at games, they don’t need to be apart, racism really isn’t tolerated at all, neither is sexism, homophobia etc. Players don’t verbally abuse fans, refs etc. Poor behaviour just isn’t tolerated, that includes team mates, if someone is acting like a twat they’ll be told to stop it.

Teamwork, kindness, respect etc are really really drilled into rugby players, thats why you’re unlikely to see fans or players fighting, you’re unlikely to see us trashing anywhere because we lost and we certainly don’t sing racist chants.

Most university sports teams have initiations, at my university the most well known, so the worst was the tennis club.

I’ve never had to do any initiation, we still sometimes do stupid things, like soapy up a shower floor and sliding around on it, or putting more shampoo on someones head everytime they have rinsed. But nothing outrageous or dangerous.

HollaHolla · 11/01/2022 12:37

Also, get him a mouthguard and headguard if you're worried about loose teeth and split heads. Mind you, it's all got a bit 'enthusiastic' if 5 year olds are getting those types of knocks. Let him enjoy it, and you can re-assess as time goes on.

HollaHolla · 11/01/2022 12:35

I played for years, my brother played for years, my dad played for years.... none of us have ever been in trouble with the law, behave deliberately offensively, or developed a drinking problem. What we do have are great groups of friends, and amazing memories of team-based activities. We kept fit (wish I was half as fit now!), got into the outdoors, and got the opportunity to play representatively, and travel.

Yes, we have all had a few injuries, and I'm sure we all got carried away with daft games, and drank a few too many. But, the support I have personally found from rugby friends, is as fierce as the competition in the games.

Also - he's 5; it's non-contact, a run around with mates, and maybe an orange squash after - not a drug fueled bender to South Africa.
I would say the benefits massively outweigh the negatives.

bg21 · 11/01/2022 12:33

I'm a woman , I play rugby , my kids play rugby i think you may be confused with football lol

Itsalmostanaccessory · 11/01/2022 12:33

Just let him give it a go. I'm in Scotland so not sure if it is different in England but up here, the primary 1 to primary 3 training is touch only. Not tackling. They do grab a little bit and get a but excited but it is touch rugby. Primary 4 is when it becomes full contact and requires gumsheilds. That's when they start learning to full on tackle. That's also the age where a lot of kids drop out, once they get a taste for tackling and decide whether or not they actually like that.

So let him try it and then when it's time for real tackling, he will have had a couple years experience and be ready for the next stage. And he might not even want to continue after it starts getting a bit dangerous!

CarrotVan · 11/01/2022 12:27

Much nicer than football culture. And if he really wants to do it then why not let him try. The local clubs have really good programmes from age 4+ with the teens learning to coach the little ones alongside their own training. I'd look at a programme run from a proper club over Rugby Tots type programmes as you can continue with the same provision as long as you want. It's tag rugby and drills/skills at that age

Sparklingbrook · 11/01/2022 12:26

@HalloHello

Football is way worse and I've never heard anyone complain about a 5 year old wanting to get involved in that. Football fans, the aggression, the drinking, the division between clubs is all terrible. You never ever see rugby fans ransacking the city like football fans do. Obviously a lot of generalisation there, not all fans etc but I've never seen rugby fans reported on the news for running riot.
I think at 5 years old none of that is a concern TBH. In either football or Rugby. They might show a flicker of interest in either at 5 and be doing neither in a couple of years let alone supporting a team and being a hooligan.
Pluvia · 11/01/2022 12:25

Can you think of any sport where he won't be exposed, when he's an adult, to sexism, drinking opportunities and so on? He doesn't have to join in and you have a decade in which to influence him to stand up to this kind of expectation. There have been rugby and cricket and soccer players (Graham le Saux is the one who comes immediately to mind) who haven't gone along with laddish behaviour. Wouldn't it be great if there were more thoughtful, civilised, woman-friendly sportsmen around? Your son could be one of them.

Many of us would be thrilled to have a child who wanted to get involved in any kind of sport. It's great: he'll be fit and strong and have mates for life if he continues in rugby. It'll go down well on his CV and if he's good it could help get him into a university of his choice or even be a career.

Ilovewillow · 11/01/2022 12:24

My son doesn't play but my 13 yr old daughter does and has done for a number of years now. I can't speak for all clubs but her rugby club caters for very small children right up to adults. Without fail she has been supported, as have the entire girls/women's teams. They have been included in all activities. The coaches have been fantastic even through the various lockdowns. I have seen them turnaround troubled children and support children from poorer backgrounds. The male players have never been disrespectful although I'm sure that the changing room banter, at times, can be lively as it is with the U15 girls. I would not hesitate to send my child to our rugby club. With regards to injuries, of course there is a chance of injury but the children are very well looked after. My daughter plays full contact rugby and they always wear a gum shield. She always wears a headguard and the club are diligent in their care for safety. The worse injury she has had, despite also being a rock climber is a knee dislocation and crutches for three months after dancing in the kitchen.

HalloHello · 11/01/2022 12:23

Football is way worse and I've never heard anyone complain about a 5 year old wanting to get involved in that. Football fans, the aggression, the drinking, the division between clubs is all terrible. You never ever see rugby fans ransacking the city like football fans do. Obviously a lot of generalisation there, not all fans etc but I've never seen rugby fans reported on the news for running riot.

Crowdfundingforcake · 11/01/2022 12:23

Close friend pulled her 14 yo son out of rugby - underage drinking encouraged by coaches, awful drunken behaviour after matches. It's a great sport, but some of the historic behaviours round it are toxic.

MrsJackRackham · 11/01/2022 12:20

We have a local rugby club who come into the pub I work in for nights out, usually a pub crawl, round of same drinks in every pub. They are chaperoned by the retired players and kept in check all night for behaviour and over indulgence. Any bad behaviour is a reflection on the the club as a whole and very harshly dealt with. I've never witnessed any trouble from them in over 20 years of serving them. They are polite, kind, well behaved and tip well Grin I'd rather them any night than a football team/ supporters.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 11/01/2022 12:17

What you have described is the behaviour of every male group. So unless he is never allowed to hang around with groups of men then he will experience a lot of that.

However, all the men in my family play rugby. My kids started young and love it. It is a great game and all the boys are really supportive of each other. It is really great to watch actually, after a tackle or ruck and your kid is on the ground, someone from their team or the other team will give them a hand and they clap each other on the back then run back to the play. It really is a great game for camaraderie. The older teens in the club help out sometimes with the younger ones, and they're great. My oldest son did football as well as rugby and you could see the difference in the culture. He said himself that the older boys in the football were much more intimidating and "laddy".

Also in rugby, they play to the whistle. There isn't arguing and shouting at the ref, or rolling around on the ground looking for a penalty. Even if it is a bad call from the ref, the kids are taught right from a young age that you accept it and get back in the game. No fights or nastiness. And after, all the boys get food and when they're older they have a drink together without any of the nasty rivalry between teams. (Therr are obviosily exceptions but generally, it is really nice and respectful sport).

If he's going to do a male dominated sport then really, rugby is not a bad choice.

ArtichokeAardvark · 11/01/2022 12:17

In terms of culture, you'll find that rugby players (and supporters) are a hell of lot better behaved and mannered than football. Case in point, supporters in stadiums are mixed together and you're allowed to drink in the stands because supporters for rival teams tend not to get blind drunk and attack each other like you see at football matches. (Yes I am aware of a sweeping generalisation here, but this entire thread is about stereotypes!). The behaviour of the players is also generally better, they may look like thugs but they show each other and the referee a lot of respect.

At university, the rugby lads were no worse than those from other sports - they all had hellish initiations and drank themselves stupid.

I massively hope my son gets into rugby rather than football. The only consideration from your original post I'd agree with is that injuries can and do happen, but not until they start playing contact rugby which is a long way off for your son yet.

LittleGwyneth · 11/01/2022 12:17

If he starts drinking and calling women sexist names then you can pull him out. But he's five, so it's unlikely they'll be giving him beers for at least the first few months.

Keeping him away from lad culture isn't the way to protect him. Fair better to teach him how to stand up for himself and disengage from people who are saying sexist shit.

I would be somewhat worried about injuries, but I think you've probably got half a decade before it's time to worry about that in any serious way.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 11/01/2022 12:16

And in my experience the old adage of “football is a gentlemen’s game played by thugs, while rugby is a thugs’ game played by gentlemen,” is largely true.

People always trot this one out and I'm not sure I agree with it. I've seen plenty of boorish behaviour from rugby players.

But if a 5 year old is enthusiastic about a sport I'd certainly be encouraging them to try it out.

Westmeathtip · 11/01/2022 12:15

I’d take rugby a million times over footie and cricket.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 11/01/2022 12:15

My daughters play Minis? (Think that's the term for the U11s bit before Juniors?). The team is great with them despite being the only girls in that section. No sexism whatsoever (only a changing room issue... old clubhouse with one open changing room and set of showers so they can't use it... in the older age groups they don't schedule overlapping girls/woman's games with boys/mens to get round it).

Its very family orientated. I'm such the Mens team behaves differently alone, like any group of men. But its modernising.

DDs got into it through school. (Local Private School shares their sports coaches for free with their Primary School)

Tal45 · 11/01/2022 12:12

I went out with a rugby player in my teens. We both did a lot of drinking (as did everyone I knew) but he was very respectful.

oreosoreosoreos · 11/01/2022 12:12

DSS played throughout his teen years and I’d say on the whole it was very positive. Yes, there were some injuries, and definitely a drinking culture as they got to older teens, but all the boys who played loved it, and they are still a tight knit group even though most don’t play any more.

They were very supportive when he was going through some very hard stuff, and I think they really helped him turn things around.

We all had Covid after Xmas, and a couple of them dropped groceries and take aways round, they really are a lovely bunch of lads!