Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want my son to do rugby because of the culture?

263 replies

sausagedogsforever · 11/01/2022 11:38

I probably am being unreasonable but, my DS aged 5 really wants to do rugby. He once had a taster session, loved it and has asked to go since (for a good year). So shows no signs of getting over the urge.

I am thinking maybe I should take him again to another taster (maybe he won't like it) but also what if he loves it?

I used to like watching rugby and I find the games much more family friendly to watch than football matches. However, I've heard terrible things about rugby players and rugby playing culture? Like gross drinking games, sexism, just all round bad behaviour and treatment of women, initiation games to fit in etc.
is this really what it's like? Does anyone have any experience?
The other issue is injury, it's likely in a sport like that, so do I really want to encourage this?
Any advice welcome. Has anyone got a rugby playing son/husband?
Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 11/01/2022 13:53

The likelihood of your ds continuing rugby for another 10 years even if he enjoys it now isn’t actually that high. At his age he is just learning about life, exploring everything and having as much fun as possible.

My dd was part of a great and family oriented club. She loved the social side of things more than the playing tbh. Wholesome fun. But had to stop going when girls and boys were split by sex at 11 as there was no girl’s team and she didn’t want to go another club.

Let your ds do this fgs. At 5 my dd was wearing pretty dresses and sparkly crowns. These days it’s all about sports branded goods. Children change beyond all recognition.

PotatoPie888 · 11/01/2022 13:48

@KO81 but it’s funny that everyone’s experiences are exactly the same, and when you challenge the middle-class equals good, working-class equals bad, you are met with a Hmm

CuriousaboutSamphire · 11/01/2022 13:47

Stereotype alert - but I taught lots of rugby and football students at A level for over 20 years and I can tell you one thing that stands out a country mile: the rugby 'lads' are very 'laddish' when it comes to drinking etc but so very polite and considerate in every day activities.

Footballers - not so much, They are somehow 'tighter' individuals. more self centred and prone to small outbursts similar to "It's not fair".

Something about the different team cultures rubs off and, if I had had kids, I would by far prefer then to take up rugby to football - and I come from a footballing family!!

Not that there's anything wrong or inherently nasty about the footballers. Just that rugby, as a cohort, seems, more comfortable in its physicality, they have less to prove, socially, and are 'softer' in their behaviour.

Doubtless someone else will have an entirely different take on it, but that's my two penn'orth Smile

vodkaredbullgirl · 11/01/2022 13:44
Hmm
KO81 · 11/01/2022 13:44

@PotatoPie888

Ok *@KO81* Mine have both played football and we’ve never seen that and we live in a rough part of the country. But yeah, all rugby players and their parents are solid decent middle-class respectable people and all footballers and their parents are thugs. This is mumsnet after all.
S’not what I said. Why is it when people talk about their own personal experiences on here, making it clear it’s their own personal experiences, people come along to tell them they’re wrong? That’s Mumsnet, it seems.
edwinbear · 11/01/2022 13:41

DS (12) has been playing since he was 2, DD (10) took it up last year after years of trailing round, watching her brother play. Nothing but a positive experience from us. DS had a fully 50/50 mixed team before they split into single sex teams and the boys were in awe of the girls - they were superb. If anything, it's taught him that women are very much his equal. We see the same ethos in DD's current minis team.

The culture is very much one of inclusion, respect and teamwork. Regardless of ability, everyone on the squad gets to play at least half a match at fixtures, whereas in football it's not unusual for a child to sit on the benches for a full game. Backchat, to referees, coaches, or the opposition is simply not tolerated and the children will actively pull each other up about it - this trait has carried over into DS's other sports as well as his attitude to his school teachers.

At 5, I'd suggest letting him have a go. We lost numerous players once they moved from tag to contact as many stopped enjoying it and the training commitment stepped up a gear, which they couldn't, or didn't want to, commit to. You really don't need to worry about a misogynistic, drinking culture from a bunch of 5yr olds.

Injury is a bigger concern, in fact DS has just finished a 3 week 'Graduated Return to Play' programme following concussion from a head injury just before Christmas. He's an experienced player, been well trained in how to fall, but yes, injuries still happen (although far fewer aged 5). Rugby has massively stepped up when it comes to injuries, concussion in particular, and I have never seen a group of coaches, first aiders, physios and safe guarders move so fast than when DS sustained his head injury. He went straight to A&E, I had follow up calls from the team physio and his coach for the next 3 weeks and he had to attend two GP appointments before he was allowed to return to play. Rugby takes head injuries incredibly seriously and personally, watching all the procedures kick in, I found it incredibly reassuring.

As an aside, DS is a small, lean, super fast sprinter, so he plays out on the wing - I've positively encouraged this as it keeps him away from the huge front row....worth giving some thought to Grin

Trickleg · 11/01/2022 13:40

No contact Rugby until u9s, definitively. Up until that point just tag rugby and for most clubs even that isn’t actual games until u7s. 5 year olds will basically be playing catch and running round obstacle poles. Rugby clubs are wonderful things - yes the adults often drink too much, but the sense of community, shared culture and being amongst friends doing something fun in the open air is tremendous. Just try it for a bit and see if your son loves it.

WorriedGiraffe · 11/01/2022 13:40

He’s 5, let him play whatever sport he wants and raise him not to be a sexist idiot regardless. YABU to tell him he can’t do a sport on the basis of your own prejudice. Injuries are unlikely to occur at that age because it isn’t played full contact and there’s every chance he would give it up before 12 anyway.

Pyewhacket · 11/01/2022 13:39

That's how I men my husband. At University. He was on the Rugby team. It helped being a student nurse. I was used to the sight of blood. Just make sure he wears a gumshield.

And it may comes as a shock but excessive consumption of alcohol , crude sexism and initation games isn't just the preserve of men. I was on the University Hockey team !!!!. And thank God I wore a gumshield.

PotatoPie888 · 11/01/2022 13:38

Ok @KO81 Mine have both played football and we’ve never seen that and we live in a rough part of the country. But yeah, all rugby players and their parents are solid decent middle-class respectable people and all footballers and their parents are thugs. This is mumsnet after all.

NewYearNewKale · 11/01/2022 13:36

Oh fgs it's not a trope that you won't get away with arguing with the ref in rugby🤷.
The classes playing are all the same where I live anyway.

Rewis · 11/01/2022 13:33

You should see the under 5's hockey team. That's rough. Beer bong during recess etc.

But seriously, what you described could be applied to any men's team sport. It will depend on the team what it will be like. But maybe you still have a few years before that happens.

KO81 · 11/01/2022 13:31

@PotatoPie888

The usual tropes about rugby Union equalling nice middle-class, gentlemanly standards and football being played by unpleasant, cheating kids are in full force today.
It’s not the kids in football that pose problems, it’s often the parents. My nephew refs football and is often roundly abused with parents screaming in his face over his decisions. He’s a teenage boy. That culture is a problem.
mumsiedarlingrevolta · 11/01/2022 13:30

Both my DS's played and so did DD at that age.

Most rugby clubs are very family orientated and friendly.
At that age it will be team work and ball skills in the fresh air and
I look very fondly back on those days.

Let him have a go and enjoy it.
If he carries on playing for the next 15 years then see.

At both of my boys secondary schools it was not optional so he will play at school-might as well know how!

KO81 · 11/01/2022 13:28

@StrychnineInTheSandwiches

And in my experience the old adage of “football is a gentlemen’s game played by thugs, while rugby is a thugs’ game played by gentlemen,” is largely true.

People always trot this one out and I'm not sure I agree with it. I've seen plenty of boorish behaviour from rugby players.

But if a 5 year old is enthusiastic about a sport I'd certainly be encouraging them to try it out.

Hence ‘largely true’.

You get bad apples everywhere but on the whole, the culture of rugby is brilliant and players are held to a high standard of conduct. I have experience of both sports and the conduct of players, coaches and sideline parents is markedly better in rugby than in football. In my own experience.

RaginaPhalange · 11/01/2022 13:27

Yabu! My dh has played rugby from a young age. He would train and go to the gym a lot. He's not had any serious injurys. He has had concussions, dislocated shoulder and knee. They do play gross drinking game. I remember him telling me he had to down some weird pint cocktail with a sausage roll dunked in it. He now plays when he can and trains when he can.

Not sure where you're getting the bad treatment of women from. I've met most of the guys he plays with (and wives/gf's) and they're all decent men who are playing rugby for a bit of fun then having a drink after the game. Yes they act very immature but all they're doing is letting off steam imo.

My ds also 5 goes to rugby. I have no issue with this. He loves it. If he keeps at it. We will be making him aware of risk of injury the more contact they get. He has watched rugby so is already aware of possible Injury. Also the drinking part doesn't bother me either would rather after a rugby match apposed to in a park somewhere doing who knows what.

VoiceOfCommonSense · 11/01/2022 13:24

What a stupid thing to say. Do you think your 5 year old is going to be playing drinking games and being sexist towared women. It's got nothing to do with the game.

DrWhoNowww · 11/01/2022 13:23

I worked behind a bar in a rugby club for three years during my late teens.

Without exception, every player, coach, hanger on etc was decent to deal with, they were respectful, polite and made sure they cleaned up after themselves (I remember the junior coach keeping them all back for half hour to clean the club entrance because one of them had forgot to take their muddy boots off…they made it shine Grin)

I used to love Sunday’s when the minis were playing, they’re so funny at that age - and again incredibly polite as well as the parents!

My nephews have just started under 10’s football and I swear it’s a different world - mainly the parents to be honest, I’ve never heard interaction with the ref from the parents for mini rugby like you see with mini football.

I don’t know what it is - maybe pressure in that good footballers obviously make much more than good rugby players, maybe a general culture, who knows.

I do know that if my 5 year old wanted to play rugby I wouldn’t worry about the culture aspect of it though.

Hankunamatata · 11/01/2022 13:22

He is 5 and may not even continue to like rugby in 2 or 3 years

Sparklingbrook · 11/01/2022 13:20

@PotatoPie888

The usual tropes about rugby Union equalling nice middle-class, gentlemanly standards and football being played by unpleasant, cheating kids are in full force today.
It's always the same on here when you mention Rugby. Grin

One thing's certain though if your DC decide to take up either sport (or both imagine that) and stick with it be prepared for endless driving about into the middle of nowhere all weekend, standing at the sidelines in sheet rain and blizzards and mud, oh god THE MUD. Shock

AnEpisodeOfEastenders · 11/01/2022 13:19

You could take him to football instead! Seriously, you need to get a grip.

PotatoPie888 · 11/01/2022 13:16

The usual tropes about rugby Union equalling nice middle-class, gentlemanly standards and football being played by unpleasant, cheating kids are in full force today.

Campfirewood · 11/01/2022 13:13

On the culture point, specifically, I've been on numerous University and local sports teams and have seen and been involved in various initiations and culture you describe... 1) it's not just men 2) it's REALLY died down in the last 20 years, it's basically not accepted anymore. The Uni I went to has totally banned it. The culture around sports teams in general has changed a lot. It's more about fitness and health now than the booze culture being ubiquitous.

Springlikely · 11/01/2022 13:13

My DS15 has played rugby since he was 5 and also plays football. The culture in Rugby is so much more about team work and respect than it is in football. Ime football attracts or creates over inflated egos. Plus in rugby there's no rolling on the floor with great drama after a little tap, like I see in football every week.

RitaFires · 11/01/2022 13:12

@StrychnineInTheSandwiches

The potential for long term head injuries is the most worrying thing about rugby. Obv this is only going to effect 0.01% of 5 year olds who express an interest in the sport, but ex-players of 40 developing dementia is bloody tragic.
I agree with this, not an issue at 5 but worth considering for the future. A family member had to see a neurologist and having noticed how many other patients were there for rugby related injuries, my mother would never allow any of her kids to play it.