Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Exchange at full value?

65 replies

Exchange101 · 10/01/2022 21:56

I’m not sure if my thinking on this is correct - AIBU?

I purchased an item of jewellery from an independent online business with their discount last year. It was quite delicate so I asked about quality before purchase. They replied to say there was a year’s guarantee (replacement) and they could offer a repair outside that time.

A year in, it breaks, I ask about a replacement but it is no longer stocked and a repair is not possible. A credit note has been kindly offered but for the price paid rather than the value of the item (15% difference)

Should the full price value of the item be credited as this is what is being ‘replaced’ in lieu of the actual item? If I was to be given a refund I would expect the value I actually paid

I am looking to purchase an item which is of higher value of the original full priced item. The 15% makes quite a difference

What do you think?

Thanks

OP posts:
DogInATent · 10/01/2022 23:59

I don't think you understand value. If you bought something that was (full price) retailed at £220 it's value is probably somewhere between £70-£120. Unless it was from whatever the modern version of Ratner's is, in which case it's probably worth £20 if you smile.

You don't get back as a refund more than you paid. That's not how life works.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 10/01/2022 23:54

I actually do see your point Op!

If it was cash, I might say the £187 was fair enough, as you were put back in your original position. But with it being credit, you have to use it in their store. Therefore you want something that’s as good as / the same value as the item you had, not something cheaper.

Clymene · 10/01/2022 23:50

@Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov

I think if the op was getting a cash refund she'd obviously accept what she paid it's the fact they're offering her credit that she's unimpressed that it's for what she paid rather than the value of the item.
It's an independent jeweller though. There no such thing as RRP - they set their own prices.
AnnaSW1 · 10/01/2022 23:45

You get back what you paid Smile

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 10/01/2022 23:44

I think if the op was getting a cash refund she'd obviously accept what she paid it's the fact they're offering her credit that she's unimpressed that it's for what she paid rather than the value of the item.

FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 10/01/2022 23:31

You are owed what you paid. You can then take your money elsewhere or reinvest it back to that business

PurplePansy05 · 10/01/2022 23:28

No, there is no logic. You are being reimbursed for what you paid. You were lucky the first time round tobsave yourself 15% off the full price. You've already made that saving. Thrir reimbursement now gives you the top up to the full price of the item.

You seem to think that you can save twice, once through the 15% discount, and second time through them reimbursing you the non-discounted price of the same item. It's obvious it would make the shop worse off and you'd be unjustly enriched.

🙄 Not enough eyerolls for this one!

TheGoldenWolfFleece · 10/01/2022 23:22

You're outside the 1 year period in their terms and conditions so they could just say nope. They're being pretty reasonable to offer you the price you paid back as a credit note.

pollygartertidywife · 10/01/2022 23:18

@Slowboiledfrog

Law of Contract 101. The contract is in breach if the seller cannot fulfil the terms of the contract (warranty) agreed at the time of the sale with the buyer.

But the contract might say, if unrepairable after 3 months, credit will be issued.?

That is not the information provided in the OP.

'They replied to say there was a year’s guarantee (replacement) and they could offer a repair outside that time.'

Slowboiledfrog · 10/01/2022 22:53

Law of Contract 101. The contract is in breach if the seller cannot fulfil the terms of the contract (warranty) agreed at the time of the sale with the buyer.

But the contract might say, if unrepairable after 3 months, credit will be issued.?

pollygartertidywife · 10/01/2022 22:49

If you do decide to settle in the lower price . .. it needs to be cash /bank transfer so you are then at liberty to buy from a retailer with worthwhile warranties and good quality products.

pollygartertidywife · 10/01/2022 22:46

Yep. Very cheeky to offer a credit note. They are the ones unable to fulfil their warranty contract.

Law of Contract 101. The contract is in breach if the seller cannot fulfil the terms of the contract (warranty) agreed at the time of the sale with the buyer.

mediumbrownmug · 10/01/2022 22:45

I think I understand what you’re saying, OP. It sounds like you had a coupon for the initial purchase, and it broke, so you’d like to transfer the coupon to its replacement so you don’t lose the discount you would have had if their jewelry had held up the way it should. That way, the discount doesn’t get wasted and you don’t feel like you’re losing out just because their item broke and they no longer carry it.

That doesn’t seem too unreasonable to me. In your situation, I would probably ask if it’s possible to transfer the coupon, and if they decline I would request a cash refund and wait for another sale to come along to purchase the next item. Good luck!

haribofiend · 10/01/2022 22:41

No I get what you mean OP, and you’re not being unreasonable for asking.

If you were asking for a refund, you get what you pay.

However, you made this purchase and they said they would offer you a like for like replacement. What you had was an item worth £220, so you’re not unreasonable to ask for a credit note to that value, seeing as they can’t offer the actual item as promised.

However, I think in this circumstance it would be more sensible for them to give you a refund of the money paid, than a credit note.

pollygartertidywife · 10/01/2022 22:41

I completely understand you OP. If it were simply that you got something on a discount and were asking for the full price back - then I would agree with the other posters that the return price should be what you actually paid .. however . You and this is the difference. You bought it with a warranty. That warranty was for the item ... which they promise to repaid or replace. They are not able to fulfil that part of the contract of warranty . Therefore they need to find you an item of the same value as the one they are not able to replace.

It's the warranty that makes the difference. If it didn't then no one would buy a warranty. It is meant to guarantee the quality of your product . The price you paid is irrelevant.

FluffyBooBoo · 10/01/2022 22:35

I dunno. I think I would rather have the new polo than a year old golf, which is what usually happens with cars, you would get equivalent to what you had - which isn't a new golf.

Exchange101 · 10/01/2022 22:34

@frenchfancy55 - it was bought with a 1 year warranty to replace or repair so they would be honouring that rather than doing me a favour

They can’t honour it so are offering a credit

OP posts:
Exchange101 · 10/01/2022 22:33

@Clymene - one of the small stones fell out of a ring

OP posts:
frenchfancy55 · 10/01/2022 22:32

This is actually insane. You had the use of the item for a year, they are being more than generous.

Lougle · 10/01/2022 22:31

I can see your logic. My DF got a dishwasher with a £15 discount. It broke under warranty and couldn't be repaired. When the manufacturer gave an uplift number, he was allowed to put the price of the old dishwasher against a new one. However, they also applied the £15 discount he originally got, even though that discount is not in force now, so he didn't lose out on getting the discount.

I think in law, though, it's your retail price that is under contract. They're not likely to give you a good will 15%. You might convince them to give you 10% for inconvenience, etc., though.

Clymene · 10/01/2022 22:30

But they aren't giving you a Polo. They're saying the golf isn't available at the price you paid. So here's some money which you can either use to buy a polo or put towards a golf.

I'm intrigued about what it is that you managed to break it beyond repair within a year

JackieCollinshasnoauthority · 10/01/2022 22:30

For comparison, I had a similar issue with a sofa and was offered an additional 10% off anything over the original price. This was to recognise that their prices had increased since the original purchase.

Personally I'd ask for a cash refund as a £220 item of jewellery shouldn't break after a year.

Exchange101 · 10/01/2022 22:28

Ok thanks for your opinions, I won’t pursue it

For people asking me why I am asking - I suppose an example would be:

Buy a VW golf with a discount
Warranty can’t be honoured (replace or repair)
They replace with a VW Polo as that’s the value of the price paid
Surely you would want the Golf?

OP posts:
Calendulaaaaa · 10/01/2022 22:25

Is this a reverse

Bringonsummer19 · 10/01/2022 22:22

I know what you mean OP but the contract price is £187.

Swipe left for the next trending thread