Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have your parents become funny about childcare since covid?

308 replies

Longcovid21 · 10/01/2022 19:32

I was speaking with a colleague today who mentioned her parents are now reluctant to help with childcare since covid. I'm in the same boat. Mine in their 70s now refuse to do any child care and instead pop by to spend time with me outdoors. They will not sit in a house with the children and I as if we have become biohazards.

I am going away for a week with work and they refuse to help, citing covid risk, which leaves me truly buggered as exdp is working and cannot help (we also live 70 miles apart). Is this a common thing? I know they are in the vulnerable category etc., but given how much help they had off their parents when I was growing up this seems really unfair. Aibu?

OP posts:
helenjerome · 11/01/2022 09:18

I’m in my early 70’s and I look after my granddaughter quite often. I love doing it!

freckles20 · 11/01/2022 09:14

My mum and Stro dad spent loads of time with my son pre Covid. He's 14, and they have been a huge part of his life. They all enjoy time together, and now he's older this includes cooking, board games and sharing record collections.

But they are terrified of catching Covid (mid 70s, step dad in remission from cancer). They have reduced social contact and are heartbroken to have the face the fact that contact with my son statistically presents their biggest risk of catching Covid.

He is in school, in close contact with hundreds of young people each week. He's only been able to have one vaccine so far.

OP from my POV every person needs to make their own judgement call on how they choose to modify their life to manage their own perceived risk of Covid. Contact with children and young people is generally relatively risky.

Shmithecat2 · 11/01/2022 09:11

@Spanielsarepainless

Your elderly parents presumably brought you up. Your job is to bring up your own children.
OP isn't asking them to bring up her children though. Confused
BlondeDogLady · 11/01/2022 09:08

I wouldn't expect anyone to want to babysit when they are in their 70's, and that's without the added anxiety that a global pandemic brings.

My parents were 50 & 54 when I had my first, and I had my second baby the following year. They could only babysit at the weekend, as they both worked FT, and I didn't ask often because we didn't live close, but as they were in their 50's they could handle it when I did ask.

My parents were in their 70's when my sibling had children. They did babysit a bit, but found it so exhausting in a way that they didn't in their 50's.

I think you need to find alternative childcare. Even without covid, they were only going to be physically able for another year or two anyway.

I'm quite surprised that you would even want them to take this risk!

GrendelsGrandma · 11/01/2022 09:08

OP is getting a really hard time on here! If GP previously happily provided childcare then stop because of Covid, that's hard to deal with. Especially if the GP are basically shutting down socially, it's up to them but reduced activity is not good for the health either.

I don't like people saying GP are not there for childcare - I think you do what gives you pleasure and there's an element of paying forward help that you received as a parent. My kids have two sets of GP, both in their 70s, one set have never provided childcare and are physically less able, one set provide lots (a day a week and the odd weekend) and are still active and fit.

It's up to them but the set that provide childcare definitely get a lot out of it and have a close relationship with GC. We're always open to things changing if it gets too much for them but I would have been upset if Covid alone was a reason for stopping.

HardbackWriter · 11/01/2022 09:05

@HoppingPavlova

At some point, they will become frail and need help from their grownup children; what goes around, comes around.

So their hard work over 20 odd years in raising their kids to be responsible, productive, independent adults means jack all and is not appreciated if they don’t babysit after they have essentially already done their job as a parent. Righto.

But raising your own children isn't a favour you do them - it's literally the bare minimum when you decide to have children. It's a crime to not attend to your children's needs! I don't think adult children owe their parents just for being their parents. If they have a loving, mutually supportive relationship then I'd expect both sides to help each other, in a 'from their means, according to their needs' way. I think both providing childcare and providing elder care are basically supererogatory - neither side owes it to the other. So no, a grandparent doesn't have to offer to help their adult child with their DC in any way, but nor does an adult have to help care for their elderly parent.

Personally I'd much rather have the relationship where we help each other as and when we need it, but if people want to establish the other kind - 'I've done my job raising you and so now all obligations we have to each other are finished and I certainly won't be helping voluntarily!' - then that's fine and up to them, of course.

maddy68 · 11/01/2022 09:04

I think it's totally understandable. I wouldn't ask my elderly parents for that very reason

pinkyredrose · 11/01/2022 09:04

The children's father has 3 months to rearrange his work so that he can look after his children.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/01/2022 09:02

IMO age can make a big difference. I was 67 when the first Gdc arrived, 6 years on there are now 3. I did some regular childcare for the first, but not since, though I willingly do quite a few one-offs. Unless they were all at school, I don’t mind admitting that I’d find a whole week of younger children utterly exhausting.

After a week of emergency help with just one toddler a few years ago, when a younger one was in hospital, I was wiped out, immediately succumbed to a stinking cold, followed straightaway by shingles. I still put that down to sheer exhaustion.

An elder sister who gave a lot of childcare help in her 50s, said she’d never have been able to do the same 15- 20 years down the line.

wishingitwasspring · 11/01/2022 09:01

Maybe covid has made them realise they have limited time and opportunity to live their lives as they want to.

diddl · 11/01/2022 08:58

At least you know now Op so have time to organise something.

twominutesmore · 11/01/2022 08:56

Also - the enforced isolation of the pandemic may have seen some gp lose confidence in their childcare abilities. It's use it or lose it. They may look back at how hard it was and wonder how they ever did it and not be enthusiastic about starting up again.

And expecting gp to give up paid work to provide childcare for free is cf imo.

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 11/01/2022 08:54

I wouldn't expect routine childcare from my parents at that age but I don't see why they couldn't have dc on the odd occasion.
More than a couple days would be too much I think though depending on their fitness levels.

My 60s in laws regularly look after our 19 month old ds and haven't caught covid, he also goes to an nhs nursery and has been for the past year. Your risk is just the same as going to a shop to be honest and I bet they still go shopping.

NorthSouthcatlady · 11/01/2022 08:54

No, my mum has never ever wanted to do any childcare. Which is fine BUT her mother -my grandmother would do a world of free childcare for her. Care for me and my siblings during school holidays, before / after school, evenings, weekends etc. It’s not that my grandma didn’t work either, she did in her younger days and more than my mum. So to me it’s the height of hypocrisy. Needless to say l have sky high boundaries with my mum when she wants me to do things

twominutesmore · 11/01/2022 08:52

It's horrible to read some of the opinions here, about gp who don't feel able to look after their gc for extended periods.

Surely it is obvious that different people have different ailments, energy levels, illnesses and mental capacity.

Whilst some are active and healthy and thrive on children's noise and chaos, many will worry about the responsibility, their ability to handle an emergency and so on, and may be physically drained afterwards.

If they were shit parents, fair enough, criticise away. But if they were good parents who simply don't feel up to providing childcare as they get older then that's to be respected imo.

Lalliella · 11/01/2022 08:52

How old are your kids? If they’re in school then there is a big covid risk to your parents who are vulnerable. Yes maybe they’re being a bit over-cautious but you need to respect their choices. You never know, come April they may feel differently.

Howareyouflower · 11/01/2022 08:45

I worked all my life with children and loved it. However, I'm 72 now and wouldn't have the energy to look after my grandchildren for longer than about an hour, so I wouldn't be surprised if that has some bearing on your parent's refusal as well.

Emerald5hamrock · 11/01/2022 08:37

but during term time i have a hefty childcare bill, me and my sister ask my mum when she will slow down with work dropping a day to look after grandchildren, she says she would love to but cannot afford to.*
You both asked her to slow down in work dropping a day to look after grandchildren unpaid, that is very cheeky.

Peaseblossum22 · 11/01/2022 08:36

@Spanielsarepainless

Your elderly parents presumably brought you up. Your job is to bring up your own children.
Surely that’s the point the OP is making that her grandparents had a big role in bringing her up. For many families this is completely the norm and I spent huge amounts of time with both sets of my grandparents as I was growing up. There simply wasn’t childcare available for normal working families in the 1970s .

I have been very lucky my children now grown up have spent lots of time with grandparents who have readily provided childcare, for which I am very grateful. Now they are vulnerable my children cannot do enough for them . Even those who no longer live at home or are at university call them regularly to check up on them and chat . We are not just a family we are a team, a supportive unit where give and take us important.

namechanger2222 · 11/01/2022 08:36

@Candyss

I mean, in real life, those who have a relationship with their parents do get help with their kids. I feel it is only on here that there is feigned outrage at the idea of a grandparent ever looking after their grandchildren even if it is only on a rare occasion. almost a how dare you have children and then ask for help.

however, if they are genuinely that scared of COVID, then the media did their job a gooden didnt they.

This. It's just mind boggling. I feel really sorry for people who have families like this. It sounds so cold and unloving to me.
namechanger2222 · 11/01/2022 08:32

Your parents owe you nothing OP ! They didn't even owe you to look after you when you were a child - let alone supporting you now with your own children.

I can't believe you think you're actually entitled to anything from your parents.

I am obviously being sarcastic. One generation helps out the next. When they're old and frail, you'll help them too.

As to your current problem, wait for things to die down a bit. At the moment there's a lot of covid around. So I do understand they're worried about their health as they're older. A few months and things might be a bit less scary for them. I have older relatives- my parents and they have not stopped doing anything they want to do. They won't let covid stop them and they simply refuse to live like that. I have other relatives - actually younger ones, who are on voluntary quarantine for two years now, as they're so scared to catch it. It really depends on the person.

phishy · 11/01/2022 08:31

@wtaf37

You know nothing about my life. I’m a carer to my elderly mum whilst working full time and with my own family.

Doesn’t mean I can’t see that OP is struggling and needs help for just 1 week out of a whole year.

And I’m glad I don’t know you let alone related to you.

muddyford · 11/01/2022 08:25

Your elderly parents presumably brought you up. Your job is to bring up your own children.

RosesAndHellebores · 11/01/2022 08:24

For all those talking about age, I am a fit 61 year old. I intend to retire in a couple of years. If i am able I will help in emergencies and for babysitting. I have no wish to spend my retirement looking after small children however much I may love them. By the time I finish work I'll have worked for 36 years and the 7 years I had as a SAHM were the most physically demanding of all. I am looking forward to pottering, lunches, book club, gardening and more time in France.

My views are possibly tempered by the fact my mother and MIL did very little to help.

wtaf37 · 11/01/2022 08:18

@phishy

YANBU, OP. It doesn’t around like they’re vulnerable.

If they can’t help with childcare for one week in a whole fucking year then I wouldn’t help them either.

I bet you do do things for them?

What a selfish attitude! They don't necessarily need to be vulnerable to feel vulnverable.

Any why do people with children automatically assume their parents have an obligation to provide childcare ffs? That's very selfish too; if you choose to have kids, make the decision based on your ability to care for them, not relying on your parents to do so.

I would hate to be your child @phishy - life must be a series of quid pro quo for them if they only get favours if they do you a favour...