Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Money issue. WWYD?

132 replies

IHateThis5hit · 10/01/2022 14:32

DH and I have been married for 18 years or so. Never had a joint bank account for lots of different reasons. When we were DINKIES this was fine, and we just settled up at the end of a month, splitting costs in proportion to our salaries (so if I earned £30k and him £50k, 37.5/62.5 and so on).

Had DC 10 years ago. I was made redundant and used some of my payout to pay a chunk of a house extension and the rest to live off (DH away a lot with work and so finding a job that fit around DD was not easy). Having DC caused me PTSD and brought some childhood trauma to the surface and I had to spend a fair bit on counselling. I was probably a bit too focussed on DC and wanted “the best” for them, so bought expensive high chairs, complete sets of toys, bed etc for them. Not an issue as I had my nest egg. Once that was gone, however, I started building up debt, eventually admitting to my husband that I had around £10k on a 0% card. Not great, I know, and almost cost me the marriage, but DH forgave and we carried on. With me paying off the debt. (He made me get all the bank statements so that he could work out what should have been split but that never happened.)

I’ve been back at work full time since DC was 3 and paying the debt off slowly.

DH and I recently decided it would be easier to just get a joint account for bills and we would both pay in. I said we should review the split as I’ve just had a promotion but he said it should just be 50/50. (I think it should be more like 45/55.). On top of that it appears he has over £20k stashed (plus a load in crypto) whilst I have no savings at all. I said it was unfair that I was paying back all of the debt myself when a significant portion would have been for us as a family or for DC, whilst he sits on a ton of money. He thinks it’s fair.

He spends barely anything day to day. He works from home in t-shirts that are falling apart because nobody ever sees him. Washes with cheap soap, shaves his own head, buys a new pair of shoes maybe every 3 years.

I on the other hand have had to buy office kit to work on a hybrid since 2020. I’m on zoom calls 90% of the time, have to look presentable. There are a fair number of out of hours events and socials. I use good shampoo and conditioner and have my hair cut and coloured every 3 months. I wear make up pretty much daily and need smart clothes (have lost weight so having to buy new ones, mainly from eBay/Vinted). Use face wash and moisturiser - not the cheapest but not designer, always bought on offer. I commute to work 3 days a week so use fuel that he doesn’t have to use. I do 90% of the life admin and am feeling that this whole thing is very unfair and geared towards making him richer and me poorer. I’m feeling taken advantage of. I know I did wrong in building the debt but I was quite unwell after having DC, needed a year of therapy at £60 a week and I wasn’t buying things for myself. I was at home all week with DC enabling him to work and earn a high salary and yet I’m going to be punished for years while he sits pretty.

So, should we be paying into the joint account in proportion to our incomes? Should any allowance be made for the fact that I need to spend more for work etc than him?

(My pension pot is many many times the size of his, so I could leave this alone until then and see the tables turn, I guess.)

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 10/01/2022 17:40

@WallaceinAnderland

£40k we had saved between us for the work. It overran and we upgraded some things which was another £10k. I paid that from my redundancy settlement.

Why?

Well why not?

In a normally functioning relationship, this makes sense. I agree in this relationship OP is being taken advantage of.

I also note from OP's posts that she chose to be very financially separate from DH. I'm not excusing his behaviour, at all, but it seems like the marriage never started on an even footing, of trust & honesty.

WallaceinAnderland · 10/01/2022 17:36

£40k we had saved between us for the work. It overran and we upgraded some things which was another £10k. I paid that from my redundancy settlement.

Why?

LannieDuck · 10/01/2022 17:36

Fine to have separate money and pay all bills 50:50... but then the housework and childcare have to be split down the middle too.

DH persuaded me to have DC. I wouldn’t be without them now, but my god it took its toll on me. And then doing it on my own most of the time the resentment started.

This is where the problem is. He can't expect you to pay half the bills and then dump his share of the childcare on you also. If he expected you to continue paying half the bills during mat leave, he should have done half the childcare during that time.

For that reason, I think he should pay off the debt in full (in lieu of you having done all his childcare during that time).

And sort out the division of labour going fwd - if he insists on 50:50 bill split, you'll be expecting him divide up all the household chores equally (incl mental load), and do half the childcare.

IHateThis5hit · 10/01/2022 17:35

@WallaceinAnderland

This is crazy.

Go back over all the big expenses and work out what you have each spent. He should have paid for most of the extension as you weren't earning. You should not have used your savings on that. He should also pay towards holidays for his child.

I was earning when the extension was being built. It overran and cost more than expected, which I ended up paying.
OP posts:
IHateThis5hit · 10/01/2022 17:34

@BluebellsGreenbells

Hang on!

You paid £50K deposit and £50K on the extension and mostly half of all the bills even when you weren’t working AND you have dept the pay off?

Where’s his half of the £100K? Get that back pay off your debt and keep the rest

No.

£50k deposit, yes.

Extension cost £50k total. £40k we had saved between us for the work. It overran and we upgraded some things which was another £10k. I paid that from my redundancy settlement.

OP posts:
givethatbabyaname · 10/01/2022 17:33

I’m so sorry OP. Sounds like you’re in a real mess, and going 40/60 or 45/55 is the least of it.

It doesn’t sound like it’s about money at all, to me. You’re both comfortable, separately and jointly.

This is about trust.

For whatever reasons, you fundamentally don’t trust him and he knows it. No criticism or judgement, just an observation.

And after nearly 20 years together, he’s living his life separately from you, and you’re living your life separately from him. Where you overlap is the child, and that’s where you’re coming unstuck (isn’t always DC…).

Park, for now, whether it should be 40/60 or 45/55. Address your issues head on. Resolve them and move together as a family - the money thing will fall into place. Right now, you’re not a family. You’re a collection of cohabiting individuals.

So sorry you feel this way.

WallaceinAnderland · 10/01/2022 17:31

This is crazy.

Go back over all the big expenses and work out what you have each spent. He should have paid for most of the extension as you weren't earning. You should not have used your savings on that. He should also pay towards holidays for his child.

BluebellsGreenbells · 10/01/2022 17:31

Hang on!

You paid £50K deposit and £50K on the extension and mostly half of all the bills even when you weren’t working AND you have dept the pay off?

Where’s his half of the £100K? Get that back pay off your debt and keep the rest

IHateThis5hit · 10/01/2022 17:27

@FlowerFlour

He’s not afraid of divorce. I’m sure everything is locked away where I can’t get it.

Half of what he has is yours. If you divorce he will have to legally disclose everything he owns and it will be split fairly.

While you still have access, get copies of his bank accounts, savings, crypto holdings etc. And store them in a secure place offsite/ on the cloud. This will be very useful when / if he lies about his financial position during the divorce.

Hyper independence is a trauma response. Your husband has exploited that to feather his nest while leaving you to do the majority of the financial heavy lifting for the family. He is a shitbag.

I don’t have any access to his accounts, nor he to mine.
OP posts:
Huntswomanonthemove · 10/01/2022 17:24

This is definitely not fair on you @IHateThis5hit. If you don't get it sorted fairly, your marriage is doomed.

Quartz2208 · 10/01/2022 17:24

Do you even like him OP? It sounds as if your marriage is over

FlowerFlour · 10/01/2022 17:20

He’s not afraid of divorce. I’m sure everything is locked away where I can’t get it.

Half of what he has is yours. If you divorce he will have to legally disclose everything he owns and it will be split fairly.

While you still have access, get copies of his bank accounts, savings, crypto holdings etc. And store them in a secure place offsite/ on the cloud. This will be very useful when / if he lies about his financial position during the divorce.

Hyper independence is a trauma response. Your husband has exploited that to feather his nest while leaving you to do the majority of the financial heavy lifting for the family. He is a shitbag.

ChiefStockingStuffer · 10/01/2022 17:16

Two words: forensic accountant.

Get legal advice and tell them you're sure he's hiding money.

ifeelabitsad · 10/01/2022 17:13

He's got it good and he knows it. You've been made a mug of. I'd say 50/50 on everything now or bye bye!

IHateThis5hit · 10/01/2022 17:13

I’ll try and answer several posters’ questions here rather than separately:

A lot of this is linked to my childhood trauma, which has left me needing absolute independence. I find it hard to commit/trust others as I fear abandonment. Unfortunately my therapy was only partly successful, because when I tried to address this with those involved (who are still in my life) they shut me down and refused to speak about it. I’m still working through it on my own but it’s hard and is taking a long time.

I did love (or whatever it is that I’m able to allow myself to feel for another person) DH. I think I was playing a role, to an extent - marriage is what everyone did so I did it too. It was never emotionally important to me. That may sound cold but it’s part of my protective mechanisms derived from childhood.

The cycling thing is pretty new but we have always had very separate interests.

His ex-girlfriend warned him that I was only after his money. I was furious and determined to prove that wrong to him, hence being absolutely against any joint accounts for more than 2 decades. I have worked full time since I was 15, bar 3 years out with DC. I had more money than DH when we met. (I bought a house at 20 on my own.). I’ve set myself up to never need another person ever. DIY - I do it. Car maintenance - I do it. I think that may be what DH found attractive to begin with.

DH persuaded me to have DC. I wouldn’t be without them now, but my god it took its toll on me. And then doing it on my own most of the time the resentment started. And that’s how it’s been for me for all that time. But because of my experiences, I want DC to have a fantastic childhood with lots of opportunities for fun. So I focused on that, not me. (Also common theme with childhood trauma.)

DH has accused me of being cold and distant at times, and seems to have run out of patience when I haven’t “fixed” what’s wrong with me. The childhood trauma that has shaped my entire life is nothing but an excuse in his mind. And I’m not doing enough about it. I’m never doing enough about it.

I do think he’s punishing me with the debt. There’s about £7k left to pay off. I should be able to throw more money at it now I’m earning more.

He’s not afraid of divorce. I’m sure everything is locked away where I can’t get it. Sad

OP posts:
daisyjgrey · 10/01/2022 17:07

"Long distance cyclist" - three words guaranteed to make a vagina dryer than the Sahara.

Get a good solicitor and divorce him. You'll be better off in more ways than one. There have so far been no pros to you staying married to this man. Or indeed, for your child.

Nocutenamesleft · 10/01/2022 17:06

I personally think kids. House egc. Should be joint. Anything individual. Like clothes. Hair etc should be paid for by yourselves.

Savings should be the same.

BlingLoving · 10/01/2022 16:59

Oh, and on my list of things he owes you, obviously the kids getting a holiday is important, even if he doesn't attend, so I'd be adding half of the cost of every holiday you've taken without him to that bill you're sending him.

Triffid1 · 10/01/2022 16:58

You paid the majority of the house deposit. You paid a huge chunk off the extension. You took a part time job to care for his children while he was away working. If he wants to be petty about money then it's clear that he owes you tens of thousands of pounds.

This

FlowerFlour · 10/01/2022 16:57

If he wants to be so penny-pinching about money then play him at his own game.

You paid the majority of the house deposit. You paid a huge chunk off the extension. You took a part time job to care for his children while he was away working. If he wants to be petty about money then it's clear that he owes you tens of thousands of pounds.

Unfortunately it looks like he believes his earnings are his alone, and your earnings are for the family. These financially abusive men are all the same.

I'd divorce him and take the majority of his savings in a settlement to support the kids. You'd get more from a divorce than you would for living with him.

TokyoDreaming · 10/01/2022 16:56

He sounds like a right bastard.

VividImaginationAgain · 10/01/2022 16:54

What do you want to happen going forward OP

If you divorce you will get half ‘his’ savings to pay off ‘your’ credit card and you can keep your pension.

You don’t sound very happy with things as they are at the moment.

BlingLoving · 10/01/2022 16:51

V simple - you are 100% responsible for the debt incurred while you were on maternity leave/SAHP. Fine. In which case, retrospectly bill him for half of what 24/7 childcare would have cost during that period. Also, accepting that you overspent on kids stuff, bill him retrospectively for 1/3 of all child-related purchases on the basis that he should have been paying half all along.

It's not clear how food/rent/bills were paid while he was working away and you were a SAHP, but if you were paying for that on credit cards and/or from your redundancy pay, then add 50% of those costs to that bill.

Similarly, for the house - you paid a £50k deposit AND more of the cost of renovations? Obviously, add 50% of all that to your bill.

He can then transfer all that to you and you will have increased your savings.

Job done.

wanker.

JustAnotherUserinParadise · 10/01/2022 16:50

Oh wow...
I can't believe your "D"H! Agree with PP that "his" savings are actually joint legally - maybe you should point this out to him.

We have a joint account which both of our salaries go into, minus some "pocket money" which goes into our private accounts. So we both have the same amount for personal stuff (eg haircuts, clothes, coffee out, fun stuff for ourselves).

We have a baby now and anything for her comes out of the joint account. We have a rough rule that anything over £20ish gets discussed, although I've just bought her some new vests in this and the next size up from asda for £22 lol...

Muthalucka · 10/01/2022 16:49

We combine all our money. All into one pot. I never understand the this is yours this is mine in a marriage. Insist he helps get the debt down faster. He could put £5 off and that would be a huge help to you. Make sure everything is 50/50 going forward if you won’t combine money.