Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To work even though I could afford to stay home?

164 replies

Alfixn · 10/01/2022 14:30

I have a good career in a professional job which I find mentally stimulating, although it is extremely demanding, and the hours are long.

I have just had my first baby and my mat leave is ending soon. I have slightly reduced my hours to fit in better with childcare, although I will still be working longer hours than most full time jobs.

I've never considered not going back.... but financially, we can afford for me to be a SAHM.

A comment on another thread got me wondering if it's an unusual choice to make, to go back to work when I don't "have to". I love my daughter and don't want to be away from her, but never envisioned having a family meaning the end of my own career.

I'm curious now about what most women would choose if they were in my position.

OP posts:
cptartapp · 10/01/2022 17:26

I didn't have to but was desperate for a regular break from childcare so went back pt at four and five months respectively.
I effectively worked for nothing for over two years when both were in nursery. DH didn't want to be a SAHP any more than I did.
Work preserved my sanity and my skills.
Now 19 and 16 and never a single regret.
And my pension looks great.

mycatistrans · 10/01/2022 17:20

I'm really proud of my salary, which is equal to my husband's. It means I can give my child a good life and pay for university and activities etc... I feel happy when I spend money because I know half of it's my money which I worked hard to get.

Rainartist · 10/01/2022 17:10

I could have afforded to stay off but never considered doing so. I value my independence and worked hard to get where I am today. I Also didn't want to be financially dependent on DH. I don't think that would have done my mental health any good.

koalacat · 10/01/2022 16:32

It doesn’t matter what anyone else thinks or does OP. Personally, I did not return to work after our children and I’ve never regretted it for a second. But we were never ‘living off his income’ iyswim, because at the time I could have returned to work (once they were all in school) he had sold a company for millions so it was different financial decision context by that point. When, as a family you have money invested in ways that work for you regardless of ‘income,’ then I think you can be a SAHM longer term and explore other interests as the kids get older. I would have not have been a long-term SAHM with a ‘salary man’ without significant other investments snd income streams / property etc - even if he earned hundreds of thousands a year or whatever - because if he left the income would go with him and that’s too risky. But, to be honest, even in that scenario, I still think I still would have risked being a SAHM for a few years because it’s important to me and you only live once. You never get that time back! For me, it would have been a risk worth taking, but I totally understand why others would have a different attitude.

FireworkParrot · 10/01/2022 16:19

I don't think there's any right or wrong and it depends on what you want and what works for your family.

I went back to work 3 days per week after maternity leave and still work 3 days (DDs are 4 and 2.) I've always said that it's the best of both worlds in terms of work life balance as I keep my hand in with work and get the mental stimulation and social side of working but also have time in the week with them, DDs only need three days a week of nursery/after school club.

Granted, my pension will have been impacted and that is definitely a negative but I feel that I've at least kept a foot in the door and I've been promoted during my time working part time (I know there can be an issue with good quality PT work so feel lucky in this respect.) I've also had time with my DDs that I'll never get back when they're little and been home with me twice a week.

That's just my perspective but I'd never be a SAHP, I'd rather work full time than stay at home. Mainly because I think I'd be a frazzled, bored mum and am just not cut out for staying at home but also because I wouldn't give up my financial independence.

Alfixn · 10/01/2022 16:13

@Alfixn

Wow, thank you all so, so much for the replies. I very much thought I would get the opposite type of response so this has all been very heartening to read!

The points re pension and unexpected life events are food for thought, but a lot of you mentioned self fulfilment too, and that's a large part of it for me. My identity is massively tied up in what I do, and I really enjoy the mental challenge it gives me as well as the opportunity to keep expanding my skills.

We are lucky enough to have an excellent nanny lined up and despite the long hours we work, my husband and I have shifted around our time on so that our daughter will only need to be with the nanny 3 days a week. Still it's hard not to have moments of doubt or guilt, but with all the above in mind, you have all erased the small portion of doubt that had crept in for me.

Thank you again!

And to add - the thought of being a positive role model for my daughter is also quite gratifying.
OP posts:
IglesiasPiggl · 10/01/2022 16:11

This isn't a permanent decision. Do what you think is right for you now. You can always change it by cutting down in the future if you wish.

Alfixn · 10/01/2022 16:05

Wow, thank you all so, so much for the replies. I very much thought I would get the opposite type of response so this has all been very heartening to read!

The points re pension and unexpected life events are food for thought, but a lot of you mentioned self fulfilment too, and that's a large part of it for me. My identity is massively tied up in what I do, and I really enjoy the mental challenge it gives me as well as the opportunity to keep expanding my skills.

We are lucky enough to have an excellent nanny lined up and despite the long hours we work, my husband and I have shifted around our time on so that our daughter will only need to be with the nanny 3 days a week. Still it's hard not to have moments of doubt or guilt, but with all the above in mind, you have all erased the small portion of doubt that had crept in for me.

Thank you again!

OP posts:
tealandteal · 10/01/2022 16:05

When I went back after having my first, my income barely covered childcare but we both saw it as an investment. I too never really considered not going back. I went back on 4 days and moved to 5 days when he started school.In the 4 years I have been back I have had 3 promotions and and now pregnant with my second. It’s not just about the money when you first go back but your progression and opportunities that you gain by not having a longer break from work.

Pugroll · 10/01/2022 16:04

Financial freedom affords you the greatest thing- choice! If you want to go back do so, I did and I have worked with many women who have.

Tamtam86 · 10/01/2022 16:03

Financially I could be a SAHM, sometimes it does even seem like that would be more sensible at the moment! But I'm not ready to give over my whole identity to being a mum and I fear I'd struggle to get back into work later down the line. I have reduced my hours though, and that works for me at the.moment, then I can always up them again once the children are a bit older.

I don't know many people who have chosen to stay home but the few I do have been more due to their wages barely covering childcare so it not feeling worth it.

megletthesecond · 10/01/2022 15:57

Go back to work. Keep your hand in and your pension contributions up. Even reduced hours is better than not working.

BiddyPop · 10/01/2022 15:55

I could have stayed at home with my only. At the time, a lot of new mums around me were doing that, but I enjoyed work, there was a good creche near work that we used to DD commuted with us, and it worked well for our family. I had told my bosses I was cutting back on travel committments, with at least no travel until DD was a year old (I could only take 14 weeks statutory mat leave back that, I added 4 weeks unpaid to it so she was just about 5 months old when I went back to the office but I was still b'fing so reached that agreement with bosses).

As it happened, I got a place on a taught Masters when DD was 9 months - a year out of work doing a full time taught course and another year writing a thesis alongside desk job (on related matters) and then a different role internally so travel didn't arise again until she was 5 and I had another internal change.

KO81 · 10/01/2022 15:54

For me identity became a huge thing when I found out I was pregnant. I couldn’t not return to work because I didn’t want to not be the person I’d always been. And for me personally, child-rearing didn’t utilise my brain in the way I needed.

So I went back part time when my baby was four months old. It made me very happy as it meant I felt I was adding being a mother to myself, rather than mothering overwriting everything that had gone before.

SpinsForGin · 10/01/2022 15:42

We could afford for me to stay at home but i chose to go back full time as I love my job and it is important for me to financially independent. Seven years down the line I have zero regrets!

AlexaShutUp · 10/01/2022 15:38

@Kshhuxnxk

I'm old school, I've never seen the point of having children, sticking them in nursery and going back to work. However I fully support everyones right to do what is right for them.
Surely the point of having children is to get the satisfaction of raising happy, well balanced individuals who will contribute positively to society? And to experience the unique love that most parents typically have for their children? I'm not sure that the employment status of the mother has much bearing on either of these?
Guardup · 10/01/2022 15:38

I am about 10 year ahead of you.

I had a decent career and was pretty much financially independent from my husband at the time we had my first child. We decided that I would give it up to become a SAHM. I worked long hours (as does my husband) and I just couldn’t see how I would be happy with not seeing her too much in the week.
I then went on to have 2 more children and have been a SAHM all this time. It’s been absolutely wonderful. It took a few years to get used to the money side of things for both of us, but me being at home meant my husbands career has really gone from strength to strength. Now my youngest is due to go to primary school I’ve been very lucky in being able to pick my career back up and am returning to my old work place 10 years later.

But this is what I would recommend thinking about

  1. Carry on paying into you pension. I realise now I didn’t and I’ve got a lot of catching up to do.
  2. Ensure you have adequate life insurance on you and you husband in the event he can’t work or the worst happens.
  3. Think about retraining or keeping your skills relevant in some way when your child is in nursery/preschool. It will help enormously with getting back into the workplace when you are ready.

I wouldn’t have had it any other way and am
extremely grateful to have had the time with my children with no other distraction. But I’m very lucky in that my husbands business thrived, we didn’t get divorced/separate and I’ve been able to get back to my career quite quickly. There is a lot that can go wrong that leaves you extremely vulnerable as a SAHM which is why so many women on here, rightly, value their financial independence.

Best of luck with whatever you choose xx

padsi1975 · 10/01/2022 15:35

I can't afford to stay at home. Part of me would absolutely love to and I think my kids would be better off (more time to help them with homework, get some of their activities done during week rather than squeezing into weekend, etc). But I'd hate to be so reliant financially on husband. I don't think I could ever accept that risk. It has always felt like a no win situation to me.

olivehater · 10/01/2022 15:31

I think most people would choose part time if it’s possible to get the best of both worlds. I have and am very happy. DH earns a lot more than me and I don’t need to work. but my job is a part of my identity. I could not do it full time though and raise my kids the way I want to.

Kshhuxnxk · 10/01/2022 15:31

I'm old school, I've never seen the point of having children, sticking them in nursery and going back to work. However I fully support everyones right to do what is right for them.

SisterConcepta · 10/01/2022 15:31

I would keep my job if I were you - maybe at reduced hours.
It is so easy to give up your job for a year or two and suddenly the years fly by and you are out of work 6 years and it is so difficult to get back if you want/need to... not least because your children are used to you being around and don't want to go to after school childcare.
Also at this point your husband is used to you doing 100% of the childcare / mental load and again if you go back to work, that mindset is hard to shift so you will end up doing both.
Also do not underestimate how much of your confidence you loose when you are a SAHP....
Speaking from experience here!

MatildaJayne · 10/01/2022 15:30

I had a great job, 10 years after graduating, had moved up the ranks. Then I had my first DS and I became a SAHM. We could just about afford it at the time, then my H's income increased and it became more comfortable. My DS2 has SN so it became difficult to get back to work as childcare was virtually impossible.

I finally found a term time, school hours job. Brilliant.

Then exH left for another woman. It has been pretty shit and I still work in a low paid job to fit around my DS2.

If you can keep up your career, and want to, do that! Don't make my mistake.

GeneGenie123 · 10/01/2022 15:26

I would say if you are happy to be a working mum you should stay in your job. Some women find it very hard to go back to work and pour everything into their children. If you aren't like that... that's okay!

Working part time or reducing hours if you'd like to is a good way to go.

Just 2 observations I've made lately in regards to having more disposable income... 3 friends have confided in me that if they were financially independent they would leave their partners. As it is they have to stay in an unsatisfying home situation. Also, money brings you choices, be that in a relationship, where you wish to live, lifestyle.
Also, as my children have got older if I could earn enough to give them that better lifestyle/private school or a home big enough so they could have their own bedrooms I really wish I could.

I would say financial independence is really important for your happiness and makes a huge impact on the choices you have available to you.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 10/01/2022 15:24

My only advice is don’t assume how you feel now is how you will always feel. I have a toddler and a child in school, I can say my toddler doesn’t really care who plays with her and I don’t feel guilt when I work- my eldest finishes at 3pm, I like the fact she can come straight home, I like knowing the school mums, I like being around to help with homework given the flexibility of my job

AlDanvers · 10/01/2022 15:23

Yanbu. I have worked apart from Mat leave.

Everyone should look at the options and then decided what is best for them and theirs.