Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To work even though I could afford to stay home?

164 replies

Alfixn · 10/01/2022 14:30

I have a good career in a professional job which I find mentally stimulating, although it is extremely demanding, and the hours are long.

I have just had my first baby and my mat leave is ending soon. I have slightly reduced my hours to fit in better with childcare, although I will still be working longer hours than most full time jobs.

I've never considered not going back.... but financially, we can afford for me to be a SAHM.

A comment on another thread got me wondering if it's an unusual choice to make, to go back to work when I don't "have to". I love my daughter and don't want to be away from her, but never envisioned having a family meaning the end of my own career.

I'm curious now about what most women would choose if they were in my position.

OP posts:
ZenNudist · 10/01/2022 21:47

It's not unusual at all. I work in a well paid profession. Most people have 2 incomes with both partners earning well. Most people still choose to work even if they could easily cope on one income. For a start off the extra security is so important. Most people like to keep their options open for the future and losing your career seems like a short term view. You could have 10 years off and come back to it but why make life hard? Most of my friends don't "need" both salaries but equally the lifestyle is nicer with 2 people working: better house better holidays, more money to make nice life for DC, money for retirement.

Staying at home is not for everyone, or Most.

Personally with my mortgage paid off years ago I don't need to work but I like it.

Mum2jenny · 10/01/2022 21:42

Please ensure you can always earn enough money to be self supporting in the event you separate. I feel that if you are in that situation, the man in your life cannot exert sufficient control to ensure you do what he wants, rather than you do what YOU want.

BigYellowHat · 10/01/2022 21:42

I’d go part time if I was you. I didn’t work full time until my son was 9 and it was the right choice for me. Three of those years were at uni though. It meant I could spend lots of time with DS enjoying being his mum but still keep my professional identity.

MuchTooTired · 10/01/2022 21:41

I am a SAHM. I absolutely would have gone back to work if I were in your position. I love my children dearly, but I am not cut out for being a SAHP, and I think my DTs would’ve had more fun being in nursery.

bettertocryinamercedes · 10/01/2022 21:41

We could easily afford for me to be a sahm but even after two weeks hols I am needing to get back into the real world and my routine! I find I get depressed and snappy.

We live very rurally tho and you can easily go a couple of days without seeing anyone, so I suppose that doesn't help.

Zombiemum1946 · 10/01/2022 21:38

Do what works for you, with the comfort of knowing, that should you want to, you can cut your hours further or stop working completely. Just keep an eye to further down the line when kids are off to school and almost independent of you.

Siuan · 10/01/2022 21:35

My children are grown up now but I was in your position. Could easily afford not to work but chose to. I felt it was expected that I work, all my friends and colleagues went straight back to work. So I did.

In hindsight I regret it hugely. I could have taken a 5 year career break and instead I went back after 6 months, twice.

If I was doing it again I would spend the time at home while they were little. A few years out of a lifetime of working.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 10/01/2022 21:34

@gamerchick

It's tempting but I wouldn't give up financial security to rely on a partner financially long term.
This. With bells on. Mat leave spent perusing Relationships threads in the silent watches of the breastfeeding night made me realise just how vulnerable I could become

Plus role model, choice for both parents, greater choice through more family financial security etc etc.

Everyone's circs are different. A child with additional needs for example. Incomes are often wildly disparate though staying at home doesn't help that long term - maternity leave will create a blip for a bit. Corporate attitudes to men doing their share have been historically crap particularly in some industries.
I didn't contemplate giving up work but I knew I'd be a better mother away from the daily grind it can often be.

Bluebluemoon · 10/01/2022 21:27

See now, I’d rather my kid have quality time with a parent who felt fulfilled and happy, than with one who felt hemmed in and trapped as a SAHM

I think it's the "see now" at the beginning that makes it seem rather aggressive and in response to some of the SAHM comments rather than coming from a positive place.
It's definitely a bit arsey.

guardiansofthegalaxychocs · 10/01/2022 21:27

@Fallagain

I’m a sahp but I think everyone should do what is right for their own families. A happy Mum is pretty essential to a happy family.
I agree. I was a sahm for a good while because my child has disabilities. I now work part time. I love my life.

The only thing I’d disagree with from this thread is that sahms can’t get back into work. I truly believed that (partly because mumsnet told me so!) and was a nervous wreck looking for jobs. In the end it was easy and when I told my boss this in passing he said I was worrying for no reason as I clearly had skills and experience so they got me cheaply!

Do what’s best for you. If you stop liking it, change it. Don’t feel stuck. You’re in control of your destiny!

KO81 · 10/01/2022 21:26

@G5000

I always find it funny how working mums get all arsey like this and make comments about being "unfulfilled" as a sahm - when the sahm on here haven't said anything of the sort and also don't make disparaging comments about working mums.

I read it as one poster saying she would have felt trapped as a SAHM, not that all SAHMs must feel this way. Plenty of women who are happy and fulfilled being SAHMs but this is not for everybody.

Thank you. That is how I intended it. I’m not sure why the poster was so bothered by what I wrote about my own experience.
allofthecheese · 10/01/2022 21:17

I was in this position and decided to go back but reduced how many days a week I work. Felt like best of both worlds.

G5000 · 10/01/2022 21:15

I always find it funny how working mums get all arsey like this and make comments about being "unfulfilled" as a sahm - when the sahm on here haven't said anything of the sort and also don't make disparaging comments about working mums.

I read it as one poster saying she would have felt trapped as a SAHM, not that all SAHMs must feel this way. Plenty of women who are happy and fulfilled being SAHMs but this is not for everybody.

YukoandHiro · 10/01/2022 21:13

Definitely work at least part time. It's not about what you can afford to now but the long term impact on your experience and earning potential. And also your ability to be totally financially independent if you ever needed to be.

KO81 · 10/01/2022 21:11

@Bluebluemoon

See now, I’d rather my kid have quality time with a parent who felt fulfilled and happy, than with one who felt hemmed in and trapped as a SAHM. I treasure our time together and have the finances and the mental wherewithal to be a great parent because I’m fulfilled in all aspects of my life.

I always find it funny how working mums get all arsey like this and make comments about being "unfulfilled" as a sahm - when the sahm on here haven't said anything of the sort and also don't make disparaging comments about working mums.
It sometimes seems like a bit of projecting going on. If you are happy with your choice, you're happy with it - there's no right or wrong!

you don't get years 4-18 back either but most people still 'stick' the kids in school.

I agree, and that's why I'm glad I stayed home in the pre-school years - they grow up so quick. But that's just me. I don't judge friends who put their babies into nurseries or leave them with a childminder - it just wasn't what I wanted to do.

I wasn’t being ‘arsey’ @Bluebluemoon. Not in the least. I was being entirely truthful. That’s how I feel. I personally wouldn’t have felt fulfilled being a SAHM. And I would have felt hemmed in.

Please don’t reduce my feelings about how I felt I needed and wanted to work to being ‘arsey’ because what was right for me doesn’t align with what was right for you.

Bluebluemoon · 10/01/2022 21:07

See now, I’d rather my kid have quality time with a parent who felt fulfilled and happy, than with one who felt hemmed in and trapped as a SAHM. I treasure our time together and have the finances and the mental wherewithal to be a great parent because I’m fulfilled in all aspects of my life.

I always find it funny how working mums get all arsey like this and make comments about being "unfulfilled" as a sahm - when the sahm on here haven't said anything of the sort and also don't make disparaging comments about working mums.
It sometimes seems like a bit of projecting going on. If you are happy with your choice, you're happy with it - there's no right or wrong!

you don't get years 4-18 back either but most people still 'stick' the kids in school.

I agree, and that's why I'm glad I stayed home in the pre-school years - they grow up so quick. But that's just me. I don't judge friends who put their babies into nurseries or leave them with a childminder - it just wasn't what I wanted to do.

rubytubeytubes · 10/01/2022 21:05

I would definitely go back to work. I did four days a week which was perfect for me. I would never give up working for all the reasons mentioned above.
I don’t need to work now my children are at school but I enjoy it and I prefer having more income (plus I couldn’t do years at home, I go to work for a rest 😊)

Why2why · 10/01/2022 21:03

What sort of household income would you need to have for you or your DH to stay home? Well over £150k?

PumpkinPie2016 · 10/01/2022 21:02

When DS was born, we could have managed on my husband's wage. However, I always enjoyed my job, despite it being demanding! I also always had in mind what my Nan used to say 'always make sure you can paddle your own canoe' I.e. make sure you can look after yourself!

So, I went back and have, over time, gained promotions and increased my earnings. I still enjoy my job despite the demands of it and balancing with being a mum.

As it turns out, when our son was 2, my husband had to give up his full time job due to ill health so I am forever grateful I kept my job!

GoodnightGrandma · 10/01/2022 21:01

If you decide to be a SAHM, get your DH to continue to pay into your pension for you. I wish I’d known this.

Simonjt · 10/01/2022 20:59

We could afford for one of us to be a stay at home dad, but that would mean the working parent would be losing family time. Neither of us want to be in a situation where one of us is kept away from the children and only having a few hours at the weekend for quality family time. We both think work is important, we also think its important to work hard to set a positive example.

We both currently work four days a week, he does full days I do short days, so really I work 0.6 where as he does 0.8. He’s dropping down to three full days in February.

Frollop · 10/01/2022 20:56

@user5656555 Grin I needed that laugh and @FTEngineerM Grin

OP I was always taught to be financially independent....you never know what the future holds. I see many people say make sure your married before having kids but I know someone who was left with nothing... husband hid his assets...some abroad...she was left with nothing and after the divorce his assets appeared again!

JurgensCakeBabyJesus · 10/01/2022 20:56

I don't have to work, we could live on DHs salary. I enjoy my job, I'm good at it and I need intellectual stimulation that I just won't get at home. I enjoyed my mat leave but was eager to get back to work. I also like being a two income household, we can have and do things we want rather than just need, we can save well for ourselves and DS, I would feel incredibly uncomfortable ever being financially reliant on anyone else so could never choose to do that

surreygoldfish · 10/01/2022 20:48

Down to personal choice. I haven’t needed to work but always have, albeit PT for many years and then latterly FT again. Youngest now 14 so out the other side, no regrets but it’s had its ups and downs. I knew I didn’t want to be a FT SAHM so an easy decision for me…. hasn’t been without its stresses though and I’m not sure the kids see it as a good role model - they would have preferred me at home FT!

Gunghoing · 10/01/2022 20:45

In modern life both women AND men can stay at home if they wish. It's ground breaking I know. So you don't have to be a stay at home mum. He could be a stay at home dad. OR you could both reduce your hours. Or both work full time. It just doesn't matter.