Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To work even though I could afford to stay home?

164 replies

Alfixn · 10/01/2022 14:30

I have a good career in a professional job which I find mentally stimulating, although it is extremely demanding, and the hours are long.

I have just had my first baby and my mat leave is ending soon. I have slightly reduced my hours to fit in better with childcare, although I will still be working longer hours than most full time jobs.

I've never considered not going back.... but financially, we can afford for me to be a SAHM.

A comment on another thread got me wondering if it's an unusual choice to make, to go back to work when I don't "have to". I love my daughter and don't want to be away from her, but never envisioned having a family meaning the end of my own career.

I'm curious now about what most women would choose if they were in my position.

OP posts:
Needsomehope · 11/01/2022 07:54

Your in the exact same position as me, personally I find it helps drive my work performance knowing I that if the sh!t hit the fan, we are in the fortunate position that we wouldn’t be in any danger of loosing our home/lifestyle. It also means I can save more now with an eye on retiring early and perhaps being around more for grandkids, or potentially taking a career break when dc are at school. Covid has meant we’re now 100% Homebased which il admit makes thinks much much easier with regards to childcare and drop offs etc.

SpinsForGin · 11/01/2022 07:48

You don’t get this time back with them

This phrase gets trotted out on every single thread on this topic and tbh I find it an odd justification for not working.

What did I miss out on exactly? I still saw DS as a baby - I still witnessed all of his milestones and while it might not have always been the first time he did something it was always the first time for me. I spent mornings, evenings and weekends with him. I didn't feel like I had to spend 24/7 with him to enjoy his baby/toddler years.

I also got to see him thrive at nursery which was wonderful to see.

Ragwort · 11/01/2022 07:47

I was a SAHM for 12 years ... (by choice), we were very financially comfortable so it wasn't a matter of being bored and hard up .. I had plenty of interesting volunteering commitments to challenge me etc and I had enough money to do what I wanted ... my DH did equal housework, childcare at weekends .. it was a very pleasant, easy 12 years (one child by choice).

BUT ... circumstances change, my DH became self employed, our household income was smaller, I returned to work but it was very hard to earn anything like the salary I used to earn. I now work part time in a job I love but earn barely more than minimum wage ... I look back and can't believe I was the same person with a good salary, company car etc ...

And I don't think it made the slightest difference to my DS ... he's 20 now and there is no way you can tell between him and his friends who had a SAHM or not .... so, in hindsight, I would not make the same choice again.

Lucifersleeps · 11/01/2022 07:46

I would, and did, go back full time.
Never, ever be financially dependent on someone else. You have no idea what the future holds.

When my ex started to drink and later turned violent I could leave straight away and knew I could support myself and my child.

Lanique · 11/01/2022 07:42

I took five years out to be a SAHM and I don't regret it for a second, however I was VERY lucky in that I managed to find a managerial, part time job after that time, on a much higher (pro rata) salary than I'd been on previously. I'm still there, but I wish I had more hours now, so am thinking of finding something else. Looking back, I wouldn't change anything, but I appreciate that I took a massive risk in leaving my job for the dc and I would advise anyone in your position op to try to negotiate a part time contract. Sorry I haven't read the whole thread, so I'm not sure if that's possible for you?

SpinsForGin · 11/01/2022 07:37

[quote user5656555]@JanuaryBluehoo and yet you've made it quite black and white. A "few years" might not sound like much, but when is it in reality actually just a "few years" the impact is felt for much longer and depending on the career some never fully recover, or it's a real struggle. The stats demonstrate it clearly enough. Many women talk about part time being the compromise, but that will still have a huge impact on pension and a degree of vulnerability for the parent if they become single (salary dependent).[/quote]
This. It's often underestimated how much of an impact taking a few years out of your career can have in certain sectors.

Tooshytoshine · 11/01/2022 07:35

You've had a baby not a personality transplant. You are still the person you were before but with added expectations, responsibilities and possible compassion to other mothers.

I love my kids but I love the independence, stimulation and drive working provides. We could afford for me to stay at home and I tried it and felt completely depressed.

user5656555 · 11/01/2022 07:33

@JanuaryBluehoo and yet you've made it quite black and white. A "few years" might not sound like much, but when is it in reality actually just a "few years" the impact is felt for much longer and depending on the career some never fully recover, or it's a real struggle. The stats demonstrate it clearly enough. Many women talk about part time being the compromise, but that will still have a huge impact on pension and a degree of vulnerability for the parent if they become single (salary dependent).

JanuaryBluehoo · 10/01/2022 23:30

I don't see it in such a black and white way..

You start work at... Teen? Saturday job? Continue working until 68? Longer if you can and want.
About 48 years of work minimum.
Taking one, or two or three years minimum out to be with a vulnerable non verbal child for most of the week doesn't actually sound like much in their decades you'll be working?

Rubyupbeat · 10/01/2022 23:23

I was a sahm, and would never change a thing. I couldn't bear another person experiencing my childs milestones.
As for intellectual input, I managed a 2nd degree and a doctorate whilst I was at home with my boys.
I was never bored and was out everyday with them. We also spent time in different countries for long periods, which was great.

Idontknowlondon · 10/01/2022 22:43

I always intended to be a SAHM. DH had a good enough income for us to live very comfortably. I had a good professional job but felt being a SAHM was important for the early years based on extensive research I'd done.

As soon as I had DC1 I knew I made a HUGE mistake and couldn't wait to get back to work. Due to birth injury and a few other issues I couldn't return until DC was 1 but I still hated it so returned to work full time. It gave me "me" back and I've never looked back. I got 2 promotions in quick succession and I'm really good at it and enjoy it much more than parenting. I went part time around 12 months ago (4 days a week) and enjoy the balance.

Once I established myself back at work and enjoyed it we made financial decisions based on my income and for a while we couldn't have afforded for me to stop, but once again we're in a position where I don't need to, but I want to.

monotonousmum · 10/01/2022 22:26

I really didn't want to go back after my first, but had to for the money- and glad I did.

With the benefit of hindsight, I'd say go back and see what you think. Give it a few months, if you hate it you can leave. But it'll be much harder to get back in if you leave and regret it.

SockFluffInTheBath · 10/01/2022 22:25

I was a sahm. I wanted to be, and I felt I should be. I wasn’t fulfilled by it and did feel hemmed in. I ran back to work as soon as DC2 was in school but my career was crocked by then and I had to work my way back in and up. With hindsight I should have gone back PT but I thought that would make me a bad mother. I think you’re very eyes-open OP, sounds like you know what you’d like and what you need.

TheCatShatInTheHat · 10/01/2022 22:24

I chose to go back 3 days a week when DC was 6 months old. Did that until they went to school and then worked 9-3pm 5 days a week.

I've always been very luck in that I could choose my hours at work.

I was also able to save a lot of money, which came in handy when DP ran off with someone else.

KO81 · 10/01/2022 22:23

@Bluebluemoon

See now, I’d rather my kid have quality time with a parent who felt fulfilled and happy, than with one who felt hemmed in and trapped as a SAHM

I think it's the "see now" at the beginning that makes it seem rather aggressive and in response to some of the SAHM comments rather than coming from a positive place.
It's definitely a bit arsey.

No it isn’t. How do I know this? Because I wrote it. What’s aggressive about ‘see now’? It’s dialect. I often start sentences with it verbally and it reaches my written vernacular.

You’re projecting bad feeling onto what I wrote for some reason, because I said I’d trapped and unfulfilled as a SAHM. Which is true. I would and I did so I went back to work and that makes me happy and enjoy my time with my child more.

Why are you so determined I’m being arsey? Why would I be arsey about women who choose to stay at home? What would I have to gain? Confused People should do what makes them happy. I did.

I can only assume you’re projecting something that you’re feeling onto my post, because I said I was happy working…

whatkatydid2013 · 10/01/2022 22:20

you may find one or two days at home is fun not fine 🤦🏼‍♀️

whatkatydid2013 · 10/01/2022 22:17

I think in general you get one life and you should live it in a way that makes you happy and fulfilled. If what will you want is to go back full time or close to then you should do that. It may also be worth considering reducing to 60/80% for a while as it might make for an easier transition back and you may find one or two days at home is fine. Regardless you can prioritise spending time with the kids outside work and you may well have the option to take some blocks of time off in the future (I’m having a couple of summer holidays off using unpaid parental leave over next few years). Equally if someone wants to take a career break and be a SAHP then I’d say go for it and enjoy the time with the kids but if option exists to do a bit of work in a block occasionally to keep your skills up to date or you can get great part time hours consider those too. There isn’t a right or a wrong answer anymore than it’s right or wrong to live in a terrace vs detached house or be religious vs atheist etc. What feels perfect for one person might be someone else’s worst nightmare.

user5656555 · 10/01/2022 22:14

@FTEngineerM indeed. And yet it's fine to say "but WHY have kids to put them in childcare" Hmm not disparaging at all apparently 🤷‍♀️

follygirl · 10/01/2022 22:11

I'm a SAHM and have been since I had my dd 17 years ago. I love it. I feel privileged that I've had the choice and we've been lucky in that we can afford it.

Now my children are older I'm more involved with volunteering etc so I'm never bored. I'm actually really grateful that I got to spend the time with them before they both leave to go to University.

My dd is applying to study vet med so it's not as if I've set feminism back to the 50s. Wink

FTEngineerM · 10/01/2022 22:06

I always find it funny how working mums get all arsey like this and make comments about being "unfulfilled" as a sahm - when the sahm on here haven't said anything of the sort and also don't make disparaging comments about working mums

Is it bad that I find it monotonous?
I don’t think it’s bad that you/sahp don’t find it
monotonous.

Just like some humans like Stilton, I ducking hate it. Neither is invalid.

TitoMojito · 10/01/2022 22:03

It's up to you. Not everybody wants to be a SAHM and that's totally fine. It's your decision. Doesn't matter what you can afford, it's about what will make you happiest.

realhousewifeofmodor · 10/01/2022 21:57

Sorry for all the typos 🤦‍♀️

Onionpatch · 10/01/2022 21:56

Something i have found as time goes on is that being able to work in well paid fullfilling work is a real privilege. At any point our own health might make working impossible, or we might need to become a carer for a spouse or child who has needs. Then you cant work anymore and it is financially hard. I think making hay while the sunshines is very wise.

realhousewifeofmodor · 10/01/2022 21:55

Due to the cost of a very lovey nursery, I will be actually effectively paying £500 a month to go to work after mat leave no. 2 (fees are £2000, I earn £1500). But I love my job and wouldn't risk giving it up, I want to keep on paying into my pension and I love the sense of achievement it brings outside of raising my children. So no- you're definitely rely not being unreasonable!

ZenNudist · 10/01/2022 21:49

Plus mumsnet is full of tales of women whose "high earning" husband left them and then they are stuck. Even worse the people whose partner is ill or died. Or lost their job.