Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex won't tell me what he's in court for

260 replies

bravermanclan · 10/01/2022 13:02

Me and my ex share 9 year old son. He is in court for the second time in 4 years today. I only found out due to a friend sending me the court roll. He is refusing to tell me what he is in court for (it is a criminal court). He says it's none of my business and he hasn't told his family and doesn't trust me not to.

When he was in court the last time it was because he crashed his car on the motorway high on drugs, I only found out when it appeared in the paper. He had seemed to clean himself up the past 3 years but now in court again for god knows what.

He has our son EOW. AIBU to think as we share a child I have the right to know why he is in court? What if he goes to prison? This impacts on our son!

OP posts:
Potterybarniclemum · 10/01/2022 20:47

I’d just like to say also that there is the possibility he will be found not guilty and not be prosecuted in which case I’m not sure if that information would be publicly available although I could be mistaken

timeisnotaline · 10/01/2022 20:45

@Potterybarniclemum

The man has a fundamental right to privacy, it obviously has nothing to do with you, you sound like your just being nosey and unfortunately the courts don’t have time to waste on crazy exes
Rubbish. His prior offence makes it very clear his offence could affect their child together. Driving while high and crashing the car is not the kind of parent behaviour you want to let your child go and stay with.
Potterybarniclemum · 10/01/2022 20:45

I will happily admit I was wrong and I do apologise, sincerely, after reading OPs responses I can understand her concern and I hope that he does tell op the reason

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/01/2022 20:42

I've just looked at my local court via the link provided upthread.

It DOES show charges. There's everything on there, assaults, drink driving, knife crimes etc..

youvegottenminuteslynn · 10/01/2022 20:39

@Potterybarniclemum

I do understand what you are saying, you might be better speaking to someone that knows him someone like a mutual friend or something, it is suspicious that he won’t say, it could be something serious or he’s doing it to annoy you, have you said to him you are concerned about your child op? You could just say that if he doesn’t tell you you might not be able to let him have contact for your child’s safety? Which given your concern and his past I think would be reasonable
Thank god youve changed your tune from "you sound like your just being nosey and unfortunately the courts don’t have time to waste on crazy exes"

Refreshing for someone to (almost) admit they were wrong to name call an OP for wanting to safeguard their child.

Potterybarniclemum · 10/01/2022 20:35

I do understand what you are saying, you might be better speaking to someone that knows him someone like a mutual friend or something, it is suspicious that he won’t say, it could be something serious or he’s doing it to annoy you, have you said to him you are concerned about your child op? You could just say that if he doesn’t tell you you might not be able to let him have contact for your child’s safety? Which given your concern and his past I think would be reasonable

youvegottenminuteslynn · 10/01/2022 20:31

@Potterybarniclemum

If it was to do with a child social would have already been in contact the truth is the reason is unknown, why do people on here always assume the worst when it comes to men, and the criminal courts aren’t as open as you think, they hold closed door trials all the time and there’s been no inclination a child was involved in the offence so why assume so
If he has been for example caught drink driving or drug driving again, you genuinely don't think it's in his child's best interest for the mum to know about it so she can put in as many safeguarding measures as possible to try to stop her child being driven by him for example? Because he has form for it so a repeat offence within the same category would be (for responsible parents) cause for concern about him driving children, even if a child wasn't present in the car for his drug / drink driving offences. Your attitude seems to be either blissfully ignorant of necessary safeguarding or flippant about children's safety.
bravermanclan · 10/01/2022 20:27

[quote Ohpulltheotherone]@limitedperiodonly has given you a step by step process of how to find out the information you need by applying to the court for it.

You could keep asking your ex and he can keep saying no, or you can take the advice given to you by someone who clearly does this as part of their daily employment! Thus somewhat of an expert Confused[/quote]
As stated, I have phoned the court today and was told they cannot and will not give out any information in relation to an offence to a random person.

OP posts:
bravermanclan · 10/01/2022 20:26

@Potterybarniclemum

If it was to do with a child social would have already been in contact the truth is the reason is unknown, why do people on here always assume the worst when it comes to men, and the criminal courts aren’t as open as you think, they hold closed door trials all the time and there’s been no inclination a child was involved in the offence so why assume so
I don't think a child was involved in the offence, not at all. But say for instance he has been caught driving under the influence AGAIN or selling drugs...I need to know that to make the right decision for our son. When he was using drugs around the same time he crashed his car on the motorway going 80 mph (he is extremely lucky to be alive), he was in not fit state to have our son so wasn't allowed him unsupervised. If he has been caught drug dealing (I only mention this because it's something I know he has done in the past) then once again I need to know as my son can't be around that.

He won't confirm or deny anything either, he won't confirm whether it's a traffic crime, drug crime, sex crime, violent crime or something as simple as not paying his TV licence or a fine.

I have no idea and I think - even more so due to his past - I have an absolute right to know. He doesn't need to go into details but I should know.

OP posts:
Ohpulltheotherone · 10/01/2022 20:25

@limitedperiodonly has given you a step by step process of how to find out the information you need by applying to the court for it.

You could keep asking your ex and he can keep saying no, or you can take the advice given to you by someone who clearly does this as part of their daily employment! Thus somewhat of an expert Confused

Santaisstilleatingmincepies · 10/01/2022 20:25

Google his name tomorrow.. Any charges may show up.

Potterybarniclemum · 10/01/2022 20:21

The courts obviously feel a right to privacy if they won’t give any information

Potterybarniclemum · 10/01/2022 20:20

If it was to do with a child social would have already been in contact the truth is the reason is unknown, why do people on here always assume the worst when it comes to men, and the criminal courts aren’t as open as you think, they hold closed door trials all the time and there’s been no inclination a child was involved in the offence so why assume so

Hapoydayz · 10/01/2022 20:19

The only crazy ex here is him and whatever he has done illegally. I guess potterbariclemum would just let her child go with whoever regardless of unknown pending charges.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 10/01/2022 20:17

@Potterybarniclemum

The man has a fundamental right to privacy, it obviously has nothing to do with you, you sound like your just being nosey and unfortunately the courts don’t have time to waste on crazy exes
He has previous for drug driving resulting in a motorway crash.

They share a child.

OP wanting to know what he has been charged with isn't her being nosey, it's her being a responsible parent.

GrandmasCat · 10/01/2022 20:15

@Potterybarniclemum

The man has a fundamental right to privacy, it obviously has nothing to do with you, you sound like your just being nosey and unfortunately the courts don’t have time to waste on crazy exes
Nah… criminal courts are public for a reason, child safety trumps privacy.
bravermanclan · 10/01/2022 20:14

@Potterybarniclemum

The man has a fundamental right to privacy, it obviously has nothing to do with you, you sound like your just being nosey and unfortunately the courts don’t have time to waste on crazy exes
Not really when it could have a detrimental impact on my child.
OP posts:
Potterybarniclemum · 10/01/2022 20:10

The man has a fundamental right to privacy, it obviously has nothing to do with you, you sound like your just being nosey and unfortunately the courts don’t have time to waste on crazy exes

CuriousaboutSamphire · 10/01/2022 19:50

Then do exactly as you please.

He can't complain if it then turns out he was there for doing 80 in a 50 limit and got a 28 day ban. hHe could have just told you! As any decent human being would do if there was a child involved.

bravermanclan · 10/01/2022 19:46

He is just off the phone and said he has told his mum but is still refusing to tell me what it is! I almost think it's like a power move on his part, like he knows it's frustrating me and he's almost getting a kick out of not telling me. When I said I will have to speak to my lawyer about this incase it will impact visitation with our son and he just said 'as you please' 🤯

OP posts:
mumshouse · 10/01/2022 17:38

He doesn't have to tell you. It isn't any of your business.

Because after all, a drive in a car with a parent off their head on drugs is such a jolly adventure for a child!

She parents her way, he parents high his way.

Florabelle · 10/01/2022 17:32

I’ve just been in jury duty in Scotland. It’s remote with jurors socially distanced in a cinema in my case and no public gallery so it’s not like normal non-Covid times. No reporters or members of public can attend so no point getting time off work. The lawyers and accused etc were in court but no one else (we weren’t as jurors)

limitedperiodonly · 10/01/2022 17:27

[quote TheWickedStepmum88]@limitedperiodonly I think you may have misunderstood. No one is arguing the sentencing isn't public record. It's the charge OP is unaware of. How can you give the court the charge if you don't know it? That's the issue.[/quote]
As I said you don't have to give a charge because you might not know or it might change. It would be helpful for guidance but not essential.

It's the correct name that is most important along with other details that would help with identification. It's not hard for court staff to look up and anyone who says that in the face of appropriate additional information is lying. This is my job.

I once asked for James Lastname of Acacia Street, Townsville, who appeared in court in March and the woman I got from the court said she had no record and couldn't help.

I asked her to look again for J Lastname of Acacia Whatever and search from February to April. She found it. It just needed a bit of application and imagination. I shouldn't have had to tell her how to do her job but sometimes you have to and not take no as the first answer.

LSLLM · 10/01/2022 17:12

OP if it’s Edinburgh sheriff court, it can be done simply by emailing the request giving the court roll info and a DOB.

I’ve done it before.

TheWickedStepmum88 · 10/01/2022 17:10

@limitedperiodonly I think you may have misunderstood. No one is arguing the sentencing isn't public record. It's the charge OP is unaware of. How can you give the court the charge if you don't know it? That's the issue.