Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was I in the wrong here or partner re walk

134 replies

Ieattoomuchsugar · 10/01/2022 06:56

We went out for a walk, was quite a high ascent but made it to the top which was great.

We started our descent and then it began getting dark around 4:30pm. The choice was either a road which would take a bit longer or a dirt path. I said we should go on the road as it's safer in the dark and my partner was adamant that the other path was shorter.

We took it and it was essentially a steep downhill mudslide in the dark for large parts of it. I admit I was pretty scared as we had a torch but didn't know the path and we kept slipping over despite having walking boots on. I just felt it was unsafe and we could have injured ourselves. It was a bit terrifying at the time.
We made it out but I was saying to my partner that we should have taken the road as it's safer, at least we made it.
Maybe I was overreacting but I have a bit of a phobia of falling whereas my partner is less afraid and doesn't worry.
If this situation arises again should I just take the safer road on my own ? Or just get over it ?

OP posts:
Butchyrestingface · 10/01/2022 09:58

Have you posted about your walking experiences with your partner before, OP?

This all sounds very familiar.

Themadcatparade · 10/01/2022 09:56

Also get yourselves some decent head torches these dark nights can creep up on you. We prefer to have a later start and night hikes/night camp but we make sure we are kitted out for it (apart from the rope we didn't have of course!)

Themadcatparade · 10/01/2022 09:53

Sounds like your partner wanted the quickest route. It happens and wasn't the best choice but neither of you was to know which one was the best choice? You could have taken a road and been ages and been kicking yourself not taken that road? But may it be a lesson to both of you especially him. Safety first always. And never walk on your own that would have left him struggling and both of you exposed to the risk of getting lost.

Maybe be more assertive next time? Put your foot down if your intuition is calling you.

Me and my partner are regular mountain walkers and a few months back we was doing one in not too great conditions, rain and fog. We got a little disorientated via OS maps and my partner looked at the satellite and thought he found a route which was quicker and more direct. I wasn't sure and wanted to follow the planned route but he was adamant. So I went against my better mind.

He led us in to a grade 2 gully which we only realised what we had done when it was too dangerous to turn back. We had no climbing aid and we had to cling on to grass at one point to keep from slipping. The most frightening experience of my life and it took us a good hour and a half scrambling up this gulley with no view of whether we would be stuck and have to call mountain rescue at the top. Luckily the ledge was doable to get over and we got over. I cried and cling to him and we made a vow to stick to the main route always! We were very very lucky that day. Don't be us, and use your wits. But don't punish him for it either he wasn't to know.

Leftbutcameback · 10/01/2022 09:51

Walking poles are a great idea - I did a flat walk recently which was incredibly slippery. Wish I’d had them.

Leftbutcameback · 10/01/2022 09:49

@fairylightsandwaxmelts - that’s a scary experience. Hope your dad recovers well.

Barbarantia · 10/01/2022 09:43

It's done now. As a previous poster said, don't fall out over it. Next time be prepared.
You need to know daylight hours and extreme temperatures for the day as well as wind speed and terrain and a rough guide on how long the trek might be.
Depends how much of a leisure it is. Romantic walk? Take a simple round route. Exercise and exploring needs more prep.
Advanced exoloring would need additional equipment and nutrition planning.
We all make these mistakes at least once. You are not alone.

helpfulperson · 10/01/2022 09:41

Taxi companies in hill areas are very used to picking people up at roadsides when things don't go according to plan.

bongsuhan · 10/01/2022 09:41

If you had persuaded him to take the road and susequently nearly been run over by cars that couldn't see you, he'd be asking who was unreasonable and everybody would be agreeing that the path would have been much safer...

RedToothBrush · 10/01/2022 09:39

DH does organised walks of this nature.

You go with the option that reflects the ability of the weakest member of your group, otherwise you put everyone (particularly the least experienced) more at risk.

You were not well prepared, so again that favours the safer route by the road.

When in doubt take the safer option.

Him putting you outside your comfort zone and then berating you for it is a sure fire way to cause problems. Everyone in a group should be respected and feel able to state they don't have the confidence / ability to do something - for the safety of everyone.

Your husband is a dick who really doesn't have the relevant experience to be leading in this way.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 10/01/2022 09:37

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

Feeling safer on the road isn't the same as actually being safer. I would also argue that the person with the most experience should decide what's safer, not the anxious newbie.

To be fair, most walkers with experience would have turned back without reaching the summit and taken the safest path based on the abilities of the group members.

The anxious newbie gets given the utmost courtesy and consideration, because everyone else in the goroup has been that person and nows how it feel. Nobody with experience would do anything to scare them off.

It's not that the newbie makes the decision. Their presence dictates what decisions should be made - by someone who knows what they are doing.

Absolutely- they shouldn't have been out anyway.

But thinking it's even remotely safe to walk along a dark, unlit country road when you're not wearing the right equipment is worrying to me. All it takes is for you to be hidden by a tree, verge or corner and you're in real trouble.

I drive narrow country lanes daily and the amount of people who walk down them wearing dark trousers and dark coats is scary - and that's in daylight. At night it's almost impossible to see them until you're practically on top of them.

The road may seem safer as it's tarmac but that doesn't mean it is safe to be on at night.

KitKat1985 · 10/01/2022 09:34

YANBU but the real issue here is that both of you should have timed your walk better so you weren't walking back in the dark.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/01/2022 09:30

Feeling safer on the road isn't the same as actually being safer. I would also argue that the person with the most experience should decide what's safer, not the anxious newbie.

To be fair, most walkers with experience would have turned back without reaching the summit and taken the safest path based on the abilities of the group members.

The anxious newbie gets given the utmost courtesy and consideration, because everyone else in the goroup has been that person and nows how it feel. Nobody with experience would do anything to scare them off.

It's not that the newbie makes the decision. Their presence dictates what decisions should be made - by someone who knows what they are doing.

RedskyThisNight · 10/01/2022 09:28

@BarbaraofSeville

I suggest the safe alternative might well have been to call a taxi at the point where you met the road as neither route home in the dark was risk free

Indeed, they could have just got an Uber. Grin Because taxis are queuing up to drive out into the countryside to pick up stranded walkers to drive them a few miles back to their car. Perhaps they should have also got Domino's delivered while they were waiting?

They could have at least considered it as an option rather than just deciding to walk back via a dangerous route in the dark.

Or they could have rung a friend. As we have no idea where they actually were, your level of sarcasm is unnecessary. As clearly people who are not habitual walkers, I suggest it's more likely that they were in a popular walking spot, where actually it's often quite possible to get taxis.

fellrunner85 · 10/01/2022 09:26

Yes, the person with more experience should decide what's safe, taking into account the capabilities of those, with them, and always going at the pace/capability level of the most unfit/novice walker.

There's a very simple alert you can put on your watch or phone to remind you when sunset is coming, too. I use it when I'm out running, so it gives me a half hour warning. I've always checked sunset times in advance and planned properly, but that extra little alert that it's time to go home is useful.

Nothavingfunrightnow · 10/01/2022 09:24

My ex would have gone down the steep path. My boyfriend now would walk on the road with me.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 10/01/2022 09:20

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

This. This is ALWAYS the rule. The slowest, least able, least confident walker ALWAYS dictates the pace and path!

Yes, absolutely this. You should not try and force someone into a situation which is beyond their comfort zone. Your OH was no wrong to suggest that the dirt track was quicker and that was his preference. To continue being adamant when you'd said that you were very concerned about it in the dark is a bit of an arsey thing to do.

But the road could have been even more dangerous as neither of them were in high vis or equipped with head torches etc.

Feeling safer on the road isn't the same as actually being safer. I would also argue that the person with the most experience should decide what's safer, not the anxious newbie.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 10/01/2022 09:16

This. This is ALWAYS the rule. The slowest, least able, least confident walker ALWAYS dictates the pace and path!

Yes, absolutely this. You should not try and force someone into a situation which is beyond their comfort zone. Your OH was no wrong to suggest that the dirt track was quicker and that was his preference. To continue being adamant when you'd said that you were very concerned about it in the dark is a bit of an arsey thing to do.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/01/2022 09:12

I should have added that too. I voted YABU because you didn't think for yourself and do what was best, safest for you.

Have a read of some of the more friendly sites that explain the safety considerations. And never, ever think that a hill/mountain walk is just anything!

martinthehills.co.uk/mountain-safety/mountain-safety/

rookiemere · 10/01/2022 09:10

YABU for seemingly being surprised that it turned dark at 4.30pm. DH is a keen hill walker and just about the first thing he does when considering a walk is to work out what time he needs to be down before it gets dark.

Once dark, neither option was great. There's merit in getting down as quickly as possible but equally it's good to do that on a stable terrain.

Your lesson for next occasion is to work out your timings and route in advance not in the dark late afternoon.

MrsWinters · 10/01/2022 09:03

I voted YABU because you shouldn’t ever put yourself in this situation again. Next time you should turn around before you reach the summit if you are running out of time to make it down safely. It’s not just you that you are putting at risk, but also the poor sods who have to go out looking for you.
In this situation you should’ve taken the road though

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/01/2022 09:01

@MamaGaia

I voted YABU because you’re acting like he did it deliberately. How was he supposed to know the path would be like that?
And this is how people get stuck, lost, hurt.

Even people who know what they are doing can have a minor incident that turns into a major accident.

I know 3 or 4 of the volunteers involved it his... and they would have a LOT to say to OPs partner

www.walesonline.co.uk/news/wales-news/cave-rescue-man-injured-powys-22097687

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/01/2022 08:58

@KiloWhat

You should go with the least confident/able climbers preference I'd have thought
This. This is ALWAYS the rule. The slowest, least able, least confident walker ALWAYS dictates the pace and path!
Sirzy · 10/01/2022 08:54

I would have actually turned back and gone the way I had come. At least you know that route a little bit!

NinaProudman2022 · 10/01/2022 08:52

You both went out unprepared and could have potentially put both yourselves and any volunteer rescuing either of you at risk.

Your DH sounds like a selfish, thoughtless knob head.

In future plan ahead, set off in good time (or scale down/shorten your walk if running late or time is too tight), look at how long the route will take you (based on both of your abilities), think about the weather a few days beforehand and how quickly conditions can change if you are climbing any height, stick to a route within both of your capabilities and make sure you tell someone exactly where you are going, exactly what routes you will be taking (including a plan B route for all eventualities) and what time you will be back etc.

I am saying all this as during lockdown a volunteer in the Lake District got seriously injured rescuing someone.

Crinkle77 · 10/01/2022 08:49

Sorry OP but you and your partner are idiots who are inexperienced, fail to plan ahead and then expect mountain rescue to come and save them.