Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely HATE New York

993 replies

GreetingsFromVenus · 10/01/2022 01:01

Dreamed of going there for many years. Thought it would be amazing. Everyone seems to think it is.

Here now and I hate it. Extortionate prices, rude ignorant locals, so many aggressive beggars. mentally ill people shouting in the street. loads of homeless people. The subway stations are disgusting and feel very menacing compared to London.

I find it really depressing actually and feel that the way Hollywood has portrayed New York is all smoke and mirrors. It is nothing special at all IMO. In fact it has a LOT of social issues and it made me feel quite sick to be spending $100 just for a mid range meal for 2 (no dessert) while there were people asking for food outside.

Central Park - pffttt!

Cannot wait to get home next week and will never complain about London prices again!

Anyone else felt the same?

OP posts:
Ineke · 12/01/2022 08:00

My DD went there for Christmas this year but stayed with her friends parents who live there. She loved it, they went to a show, and that famous Godfather Restaurant, and did some sights. I think it must help to be with someone who knows the place. She had no trouble at the airport and a taxi took her to where she needed at a fair price. I was relieved that she was with someone who knew the city though. It does not appeal to me at all.

Dadto4munchkins · 12/01/2022 07:55

Was there last week and its great. It isnt usually normal to punish a homeless person for being homeless. Yes NY has lots buts thats because the US is a money obsessed cruel merciless society that destroys people who fail or choose the wrong path an grinds them into dust with no chance of redemption. Zero tolerance society. Its not because of New York. SanFrancisco and Honolulu are much worse they really are the pits of hell for homeless addicts. Make New York look like a holiday camp.

EmmaPaella · 12/01/2022 07:46

I found New York one of the friendliest places I have been.

YourenutsmiLord · 12/01/2022 07:28

Saying all Americans are rude is like saying all Europeans are rude.
Just ridiculous.

Billandben444 · 12/01/2022 07:16

Years since we've been to NY so can't really comment but disagree with posters who lump all Americans as rude. We've had some brilliant road trips in the Western States and met nothing but kindness. We had a puncture in the middle of nowhere and, while my son was doing the necessary, 3 different people stopped to check we were OK - one on a large Harley had a gun in his belt which we'd never seen before. Waiting for elevators in Vegas, the Americans politely stood back 'after you', a breath of fresh air after England.

Kanaloa · 12/01/2022 06:52

@PrincessNutella

Yes it’s quite ground breaking. Was thinking of writing a book on my special techniques of communicating with the savages (Americans). It’s an unusual form of communication which basically involves me not being an arsehole. So far they have responded well to it so I’m thinking many could learn from it.

Kanaloa · 12/01/2022 06:50

@PlantingTulips

Oh dear. No sweetie, it's 2022. Wakey wakey!
Grin

Americans are rude. Fuck’s sake, even for a troll you’re a total melt.

B1ngB9ng · 12/01/2022 06:20

“People from NY are known all over the world for being rude and abrupt. I mean, they're Americans so that's a given! At least people from NY usually have a sense of humour to go with it unlike many Americans. But to say Americans have a rude way of speaking and lack manners is hardly news, it's well known? They just have a very rude culture and speak to each other in a way that would never be considered acceptable in most of Europe, so obviously is a culture shock for European visitors. Even more so for people from countries like Japan where politeness is even more central to the culture. This is just a fact of differences in cultural norms surely.”

I find that really offensive and the complete opposite to what we experience. If anything it’s the reverse. Part of the reason I love the US is the people. The positivity, kindness , sense of humour, openness, zest for life….The minute you touch down in Blighty you’re dragged back down to Earth with the grumpiness.Travelled all over and my Dh has American family.

Maybe it’s attitude.We have come across nothing but kindness or professionalism in NYC on a budget. Never rudeness. 2 stories. We got married in NYC at City Hall. Forgot we needed witnesses. Freaking out and a lovely young couple gave up their entire morning and lunch hour to queue with us snd be our witnesses. So much help from various sources getting the paperwork done from pillar to post( it’s a ball ache). Another time got lost on the subway and a lovely bloke stopped his journey to personally get us on track and walk us to a better and quicker route and train…

Ellowyn · 12/01/2022 05:33

People from NY are known all over the world for being rude and abrupt. I mean, they're Americans so that's a given! At least people from NY usually have a sense of humour to go with it unlike many Americans. But to say Americans have a rude way of speaking and lack manners is hardly news, it's well known? They just have a very rude culture and speak to each other in a way that would never be considered acceptable in most of Europe, so obviously is a culture shock for European visitors. Even more so for people from countries like Japan where politeness is even more central to the culture. This is just a fact of differences in cultural norms surely

Americans are different all over the US and shouldn't be painted with a broad brush.

I live in a western state in the US and people here will always wave to each other when they're out driving. People will even stop their cars in the middle of the road to chat to someone. If there's a car stopped on the side of our many miles of open country, everyone passing will stop and make sure they are ok. Mind you, here you can drive 50 miles before you see another car on the road. We don't lock our doors or our vehicles.

My family/visitors from England were always amazed that the people here were so nice to each other.

mathanxiety · 12/01/2022 05:15

Outside of New York, 15-20% is expected. New Yorkers are greedy and rude. There is nothing there there.

@Ericaequites, you should get out more. See more of the country.

mathanxiety · 12/01/2022 05:11

It looks as if someone has forgotten that NYC is full of people from all over the world, and their descendants. I think NYC is fundamentally a Dutch city, with lots of Irish, lots of Jews, lots of Sicilians and Puerto Ricans, all adding their own special sass.

On my first, flying, trip to NYC many years ago, I was bowled over by the cheery helpfulness of the security guard in Penn Station who took a suitcase of ours and walked us out to the street on the right side for where we were going, then hailed us a taxi, the uncomplicated curiosity of complete strangers on the train form Long Island about the reason DD and I were schlepping two huge suitcases and two bulging backpacks, and above all, the offers of delicious food. DD is something of a fresh airian, but all I had eaten since leaving home that morning was a bagel in Baltimore airport and I must have looked starving. The taxi driver who returned me alone to Penn Station after dropping DD off offered me a bite of his sandwich, and it smelled so delicious I almost took him up on it. I settled for some of his fries. I dived into the bowels of Penn Station along with hundreds of commuters when my train to Long Island came up on the old noticeboard, and then took a taxi with two other passengers from the station to Islip airport - surprise surprise - winding our way via back lanes to a strip club out in the boonies where one of my fellow passengers left our taxi and asked the driver to wait while she picked up some money she was owed. We waited and waited and waited and waited. The passenger beside me in the back seat asked me if I was also trying to get back to Chicago on the last flight that night. More than half an hour later the woman came out and hopped back into the car, and we booted it to the airport. On the way, my backseat companion and I checked the meter and got our cash ready. As soon as the taxi stopped, fellow passenger slapped our money (plus tip) into the driver's hand and we legged it through the airport, which was almost empty. Fell into my own bed many hours later, dreamt of lox and bagels.

PrincessNutella · 12/01/2022 04:36

Thank you, anotherone! Let me reach across my blood-drenched subway platform for a friendly handshake!

anotheronenow · 12/01/2022 04:21

Honestly, I don't know what to say to OP. She's reported blood on the floor, (that she thinks is from stabbings), being accosted by pan-handlers every five minutes, paying more than $100 for a bad meal for two without desert, narrowly avoiding being ripped off $27 for a carton of take away fruit and ... she hates all the coffee in NY.

Far be it for me to wonder how hairy her palms might be, or why she can't use google to, at a minimum, find a great coffee place near her hotel, but I'll just say before the pandemic I was in NY every few months for five years for work. None of these things have ever happened to me. I've stayed in the usual chain hotels, Hyatts, hiltons, Marriotts. Only an occasional homeless person asking for money. It's winter and bitterly cold and OP seems to be a bit short on compassion.

And I used those take away deli style places for food every time. Even in WholeFoods (affectionately known as WholePaycheck over here) a carton on fruit is not $27. I wonder where she went.... I just don't get it... I recommended a few things, as did many people, but she seems comfortable in how much she hates it.

On the other hand, her thread has garnished a w-h-o-l-e lot of interest and I for one have enjoyed comments from regular posters like Misconduct and Princess Nutella, while being amazed, as I often am, by the overt prejudice some people think it's fine to direct at Americans.

Brit here by the way.

SquirrelG · 12/01/2022 04:19

People from NY are known all over the world for being rude and abrupt. I mean, they're Americans so that's a given! At least people from NY usually have a sense of humour to go with it unlike many Americans. But to say Americans have a rude way of speaking and lack manners is hardly news, it's well known? They just have a very rude culture and speak to each other in a way that would never be considered acceptable in most of Europe, so obviously is a culture shock for European visitors. Even more so for people from countries like Japan where politeness is even more central to the culture. This is just a fact of differences in cultural norms surely.

That might be YOUR opinion. I find the majority of Americans I've ever met to be extremely polite and pleasant - and certainly nothing like the whining Brits I have encountered!!!

unname · 12/01/2022 03:59

Oops, I misread that but nevertheless, a gift.

unname · 12/01/2022 03:57

The castle was built in place. Worth reading about.

The Obelisk was a gift from the Egyptian government.

From www.centralparknyc.org/locations/obelisk

In the 1870s, the Egyptian government gave one obelisk to England, and the second obelisk was gifted to the United States by the Khedive Ismail Pasha in commemoration of the opening of the Suez Canal. The removal of the Obelisk and its transportation to New York took over a year, and was a significant feat of logistics, diplomacy, and engineering. It was installed in Central Park in January 1881.

Pallisers · 12/01/2022 03:50

Appropriated objects from elsewhere are hardly interested because by being moved to the middle of NY they've lost all historical context and significance.

There go most of the museums in London.

BasiliskStare · 12/01/2022 03:21

Have been to Florida - once - did not like except for DCs liked Disney & much more the Space Museum

A friend and I stayed a weekend in New York prior to going on elsewhere for work & I have to say one of the nicest afternoons I have spent was in Little Italy. ( We had gone round the major sights and also took a boat around Manhattan which was really interesting to see everything from the rivers ) but we ended up in a little restaurant in Little Italy where they had a football match on & it was an Italian team versus someone else - can't even remember (neither of us terribly interested in football ) & the man said - who are you supporting "Italy" we said - well it was European so we went for that - he showed us to a lovely table and gave us free glasses of wine & we had a plate of pasta each which as I recall was not dreadfully expensive - & it was just such a lovely evening - everyone was kind and cheerful - my friend said to me I would ever have thought I could have sat in a restaurant and watched a football match. Nor could I

One anecdote only - but I will remember that fondly .

BayesianBlues · 12/01/2022 03:20

@PlantingTulips

I agree. It's rude and blunt, but I prefer it to a "try to read my mind/ between the lines" approach to communication. Objectively - by most European standards - it is rude. Personally I find it much easier because I am autistic so I like it when people say what they mean!
Have you been to the Netherlands? Grin
Contactmap · 12/01/2022 02:39

@CornishGem1975

You want to be ripped off for food, go to Disneyworld 🤣 I thought New York was comparable to dining out here to be honest.
Except the food is better in NY.
lboogy · 12/01/2022 02:38

YANBU- I went in 2008, 2010, and 2015. It's very expensive. Times Square is horrible. Too many homeless people. Outside of that the surrounding boroughs are quite nice

Contactmap · 12/01/2022 02:21

@GreenLunchBox

Not been but it looks grotty, dirty and a couple of decades behind. I imagine it has lots of rats and people are rude. Not a place I want to visit.
You've never been there but you imagine all that? You are missing a lot, but I suspect you generally do.
PlantingTulips · 12/01/2022 02:15

Think people may have got a little muddled up here. 😂😂

PlantingTulips · 12/01/2022 02:12

@knitnerd90

"How is it on a much larger scale than London? 🤣 NY actually has a slightly smaller population than London."

London is 2x the land area. New York is more densely built. Also, New York has a much larger metro area.

As for all the historical detail: the USA is a former colony, and given British history, there's a rather large glass house we hit with our complaints about it.

Lol! Are you assuming I am British?
Swipe left for the next trending thread