Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely HATE New York

993 replies

GreetingsFromVenus · 10/01/2022 01:01

Dreamed of going there for many years. Thought it would be amazing. Everyone seems to think it is.

Here now and I hate it. Extortionate prices, rude ignorant locals, so many aggressive beggars. mentally ill people shouting in the street. loads of homeless people. The subway stations are disgusting and feel very menacing compared to London.

I find it really depressing actually and feel that the way Hollywood has portrayed New York is all smoke and mirrors. It is nothing special at all IMO. In fact it has a LOT of social issues and it made me feel quite sick to be spending $100 just for a mid range meal for 2 (no dessert) while there were people asking for food outside.

Central Park - pffttt!

Cannot wait to get home next week and will never complain about London prices again!

Anyone else felt the same?

OP posts:
mustlovegin · 12/01/2022 15:22

NY has beautiful architecture. I agree with PPs that you need to visit in spring or summer for the experience to be more pleasurable.

A lot of places in the US appear to be massively overpriced ATM though (I assume it's worse in tourist locations), as in 6 USD for a latte at a market stall Hmm. I have no idea why.

UglyModernWindows · 12/01/2022 14:40

@allfurcoatnoknickers Thank you so much! We'll be perusing the hotel and flight offerings tonight Grin!

As a family we've also been to Orlando, San Diego, Santa Monica and Las Vegas. Don't remember ever having anyone being rude. Indifferent maybe but not rude. So many been very friendly though. The retired navy personnel at USS Midway in San Diego were so so charming. We also had a very helpful check out assistant in one of the drugstores, insisting on flicking through the coupon leaflet trying to find out the best saving for us Grin.

Parisians on the other hand... apart from some exceptions, they are scary! I reckon they just smelled my fear and couldn't help themselves Grin.

allfurcoatnoknickers · 12/01/2022 13:59

@UglyModernWindows You'll probably miss the real trick or treating but there will be loads of Halloween themed stuff happening that week! Definitely Halloween decorations in the shops etc. Chelsea Market always does a great display and the Business Improvement Districts (ie Bryant Park and Meatpacking) always go all out.

It'll be chilly, but not uncomfortably cold. DS was running around with just his costume over his clothes and was fine. Autumn is, IMHO, the best time to visit. You'll have so much fun!

UglyModernWindows · 12/01/2022 13:53

@allfurcoatnoknickers October half term is the last week of October. We'd be flying back Oct 29th.

Sounds amazing, I'm defo loving the free wine concept Grin. My DC love Halloween so they'd love all the buzz around it! Not to mention free candy!

allfurcoatnoknickers · 12/01/2022 13:47

@UglyModernWindows October is an amazing time to visit! I'm not sure when half term is? All of the proper Halloween stuff happens the week before the 31st, but there will be Halloween decorations etc. up before that in many places.

Honestly, Hallloween in NY is the best, you can go trick or treating in the shops and they give you loads of swag. DS got candy from a witch in DvF Grin and the wine shop we're hanging out free glasses to the beleaguered parents Grin. Very different to the UK as it's a proper cultural moment here.

Quirrelsotherface · 12/01/2022 13:44

YABU - I hate cities but I absolutely loved NY.

MadMadaMim · 12/01/2022 13:42

Whilst at uni 30 years ago, my then boyfriend did lots of travelling all over the US as most of his family live there. He did Camp America for a few summers to see different places and NY was top of his list. He arrived and managed to stay 2 nights. Said it was the most awful, dirty, aggressive, scary, smelly place he'd ever been. The day he was leaving (he'd cut his planned long weekend there short) he was mugged in plain view middle of the day with witnesses galore at the greyhound station/stop. And it wasn't a quick grab and run - there was a long struggle, he put up a good fight, everyone literally stood and watched.

To this day he says it was the biggest disappointment of visiting a place ever.

UglyModernWindows · 12/01/2022 13:39

On another note, I'd love to go again this year and take our DC with us (11 and 14). I have a milestone birthday and we'd be going in October half term. Those in the know, would it be a good time to go? Would there be lots of Halloween stuff going on?

UglyModernWindows · 12/01/2022 13:36

I've been to NY twice in mid-noughties, first time it was September (still quite hot and humid) and the second time was in January. I am from Scandinavia though so it didn't faze me at all.

My then fiance, now DH used to live there before we met so knew his way around. On both occasions we stayed in Soho which I loved. I've never been to Times Square apart from driving through it in a cab. Never visited any other "must do" sights either unless you count the Grand Central station and the flagship Macy's Grin. We just loved mooching there and meeting DH's old colleagues for dinner etc.

On our second trip we also bought our wedding bands from the iconic 5th Avenue's Tiffany & Co. It was such a lovely experience, the sales lady couldn't have been nicer and more patient. We were bedraggled from the January wind and snow so weren't looking particularly posh. The whole experience was so charming, it's a lovely memory now.

LakeShoreD · 12/01/2022 13:25

Fantastic, it’s going on my list should I ever visit LA!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/01/2022 13:11

Trust me, LakeShoreD, if I'm in the area I most certainly will Grin

It strikes me that we could do with a few nice links to truly ghastly "attractions" in the US, since for a nation who do this kind of thing so well it's cheering to find that even they can mess it up
I can't really improve on the horror of Forest Lawn's chapel presentation, but there is this ... preciousmomentschapel.org/

LakeShoreD · 12/01/2022 12:57

@Puzzledandpissedoff I’m clearly uncultured because I thought the Nashville Parthenon was way better than the Elgin Marbles. You MUST go!

retirementsucks · 12/01/2022 12:34

I love New York. I find it feels safer than London, although it has been 3 years since we were last there so maybe it has changed since Covid. Central Park is lovely in the spring and Autumn. I have been when its very cold and rainy then its not so good but then neither is a park in England when its raining. Its exciting and vibrant. You dont get ripped off on taxi from airport as there is a standard price that is well advertised as taxi rank.

Mercyovermerit · 12/01/2022 11:53

Exactly how I felt about it when I was there … in winter though so that may hade contributed to the ills. Rude store attendants, not very nice locals either. I couldn’t stop comparing the services here in England to theirs.
Will I return? Yes cos my 8yr old daughter wants to.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/01/2022 11:51

Or the Parthenon in Nashville

Oh dear Grin
Tennessee is one of the few states I've never visited, but now I'm desperate to go - especially as it seems that, not to be outdone, Memphis have a pyramid!!

LakeShoreD · 12/01/2022 11:43

For pity's sake don't ever go to Forest Lawn in LA and see the fake Michelangelo statues and the excruciating "LastSupper" presentation - you'll probably self-combust!!
Or the Parthenon in Nashville 😬

limitedperiodonly · 12/01/2022 11:35

Apart from US Immigration who are a special breed of arsehole I didn't find New Yorkers particularly rude and many people were kind and took pride in their city and helping a stranger.

People in Los Angeles tend to be relentlessly positive and dish out compliments but unsettling though it is to a so-called negative English person, it's not fake, it's just their way.

And I have also been astounded by the courtesy and friendliness of most people in other parts of the US. They're known for many things but rudeness is not one of them.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/01/2022 11:32

People are mostly mirrors. You don’t see them as they are but as you are. I’ll accept the occasional person is just a dick but if it’s everyone, then it’s you

Spot on, and surely the only explanation for why some of us have such a great time and others damn an entire nation as rude
With the one exception of Scotland I've travelled most of the world and found nothing but friendliness and good manners wherever I've been

Appropriated objects from elsewhere are hardly interested because by being moved to the middle of NY they've lost all historical context and significance

For pity's sake don't ever go to Forest Lawn in LA and see the fake Michelangelo statues and the excruciating "LastSupper" presentation - you'll probably self-combust!! Grin

EchosMum2007 · 12/01/2022 11:16

Can't agree more with you! Over the years I have had to make several trips to NY with my work, always staying in decent hotels and eating in expensive restaurants all paid by my company. Yet I never looked forward to traveling there, and always felt overjoyed when I was in a taxi on my way to the airport for my flight back to London. It's just not my vibe, I suppose, very brash, self-obsessed, crazily expensive (even compared to London) and actually quite fake, if you know what I mean. I think it would be different if you actually lived there for a number of years and were able to find your own "soul" places and people that you feel comfortable with /in. Having said that, I actually hate LA far far more having had to make multiple work trips there over the last 15 years. I'd say as much as I am not a fan of NY, I'd pick it any time over LA. And yes, I agree, each trip to NY or LA makes one appreciate one's life in London more and more.

Isaw3ships · 12/01/2022 10:27

Op - have you walked across Brooklyn Bridge yet? Or hired a bike and cycled it? Or taken a bait around Manhattan Island? Or walked the High line? Or taken the free Staten Island ferry? Or been in Moma or the NYC public library? Have you been to Battery Park and eaten from a food truck? Or taken the Path or a water taxi over to New Jersey and looked back at the Manhattan skyline? Have you been to the 9/11 museum and memorial - it’s incredibly moving. Have you gone to the top of the Rock and looked out over the skyline at the Empire State Building, or gone up the Empire State Building? Have you walked along Spring Street and home in all the little shops? Been to the enormous Strand Bookshop or McNally Jackson? Explores the West Village? Harlem? Seen a film at the Angelika? Gone to an off Broadway show? Been to the Met, the Guggenheim, the Air & Space Museum? Been to Ellis Island? Eaten in Little Italy or China town? Gone to Grand Central station and had a drink at the bar that overlooks the concourse and watch the whole world go by?

Shodan · 12/01/2022 10:15

And for what it’s worth I had no experience of Americans having a ‘rude culture.’ Quite the opposite in fact, everyone we met spoke to us so nicely. Of course we spoke to them politely too and didn’t give the impression we were looking down on their entire culture so I imagine that helped.

Exactly.

I live in one of the Most Hated Counties in England, and we're apparently Renowned for being rude/insular/snobby/other vacuous insult. Some of us probably are, to be fair- but in my experience, you get what you give.

I think the kind of person who comes onto a popular forum like Mumsnet to bitch about somewhere, be it New York, Middlesbrough or Timbuktu, is going to find 'rude' people wherever they go.

Isaw3ships · 12/01/2022 10:13

New Yorkers aren’t even remotely rude, that’s a total myth. What they are is extremely open and forthright, which I bloody love because you always know where you stand with them and they’re never slow to give a compliment as well as an opinion.

OneTimeThrowAway · 12/01/2022 10:01

People saying that Americans are all rude is pretty funny and certainly not my experience, although I've only actually been to NYC once when I was very young

I own a business in the UK and we have very many US customers, from all over the US but especially from NYC. As far as you can generalise they are great customers, vocally appreciative and genuine and good spenders. These same people though have no hesitation in letting you loudly know that service has slipped and not met their expectations, which is a quality imo

DoubleMumm · 12/01/2022 08:31

I lived in New York for 12 years and I loved it. I have no idea what it is like in the middle of a pandemic. though. there is so much to see and do in NY. The shopping is great and honestly don't find the locals any ruder than they are in London. I feel safer in NY than I do in London. It's possible you had high expectations based on TV and film. At the end of the day it's a large city, full of people getting on with their lives. Get the ferry to Staten Island (free) just to see the views. Take a walk around Battery Park City (views). There are really lovely parts to Central Park. Don't write it off because it didn't live up to your expectations. Take it on it's own terms. Get the train up to the Cloisters art gallery at the very top of Manhattan. It's a great city for walking around.

Fangdango · 12/01/2022 08:14

@mathanxiety

It looks as if someone has forgotten that NYC is full of people from all over the world, and their descendants. I think NYC is fundamentally a Dutch city, with lots of Irish, lots of Jews, lots of Sicilians and Puerto Ricans, all adding their own special sass.

On my first, flying, trip to NYC many years ago, I was bowled over by the cheery helpfulness of the security guard in Penn Station who took a suitcase of ours and walked us out to the street on the right side for where we were going, then hailed us a taxi, the uncomplicated curiosity of complete strangers on the train form Long Island about the reason DD and I were schlepping two huge suitcases and two bulging backpacks, and above all, the offers of delicious food. DD is something of a fresh airian, but all I had eaten since leaving home that morning was a bagel in Baltimore airport and I must have looked starving. The taxi driver who returned me alone to Penn Station after dropping DD off offered me a bite of his sandwich, and it smelled so delicious I almost took him up on it. I settled for some of his fries. I dived into the bowels of Penn Station along with hundreds of commuters when my train to Long Island came up on the old noticeboard, and then took a taxi with two other passengers from the station to Islip airport - surprise surprise - winding our way via back lanes to a strip club out in the boonies where one of my fellow passengers left our taxi and asked the driver to wait while she picked up some money she was owed. We waited and waited and waited and waited. The passenger beside me in the back seat asked me if I was also trying to get back to Chicago on the last flight that night. More than half an hour later the woman came out and hopped back into the car, and we booted it to the airport. On the way, my backseat companion and I checked the meter and got our cash ready. As soon as the taxi stopped, fellow passenger slapped our money (plus tip) into the driver's hand and we legged it through the airport, which was almost empty. Fell into my own bed many hours later, dreamt of lox and bagels.

Brilliant story Smile