Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely HATE New York

993 replies

GreetingsFromVenus · 10/01/2022 01:01

Dreamed of going there for many years. Thought it would be amazing. Everyone seems to think it is.

Here now and I hate it. Extortionate prices, rude ignorant locals, so many aggressive beggars. mentally ill people shouting in the street. loads of homeless people. The subway stations are disgusting and feel very menacing compared to London.

I find it really depressing actually and feel that the way Hollywood has portrayed New York is all smoke and mirrors. It is nothing special at all IMO. In fact it has a LOT of social issues and it made me feel quite sick to be spending $100 just for a mid range meal for 2 (no dessert) while there were people asking for food outside.

Central Park - pffttt!

Cannot wait to get home next week and will never complain about London prices again!

Anyone else felt the same?

OP posts:
me109f · 13/01/2022 00:12

Well worth a visit I suppose. I haven't been for years and have only spent about 10 days there during 3 stop offs when in transit.
Dirty, violent, dangerous, vulgar and expensive. Prostitutes and drug sellers and beggars accosting me on the streets, some stroppy and unhelpful locals, it was quite an experience. Lots of locks on the hotel room doors. I have had people rattling the door at night trying to get in!
I was not travelling 4 or 5 stars, but had OK hotels and was not short of cash. It was the worst US city I have ever experienced, but I have always been glad I saw it.
I would never visit on holiday but I am sure if you were well funded it must have a good side to it. Not for the old or retired. I went in the summer and also the autumn. Winter must be terrible!!

Kanaloa · 12/01/2022 23:02

@Movinghouseatlast

I agree 100%. I went in April, October and April again with work

It is dirty. It is noisy. It smells. It all looks the same.

Walked over Brooklyn Bridge- it was windy and dirty.

Highline- what the ACTUAL fuck is it with that? It's just a very narrow park.

Central Park. Why bother when we have beautiful parks in London?

Shops. Nothing as beautiful as Harrods.

It was all just so horribly urban. I come from Gorton in Manchester and it reminded me of that.

Good things- The Tenement Museum, Arturio's pizza, Magnolia bakery, Washington Square area was OK.

London is just a million times better.

Urban? It’s a city. That’s what urban means. If you wanted suburban or rural then don’t visit a city!

I honestly think some people are destined to be constantly disappointed if they complain that a major city like New York is ‘too urban.’ It would be like going to Rome and saying ‘it was just a bit Italian.’

I do love London, but if you go places with this ‘nothing as beautiful as Harrods’ and ‘nothing beats beautiful London’ nonsense then you won’t enjoy it. It isn’t London. It’s not going to be the same as London.

PrincessNutella · 12/01/2022 22:54

Thank you for these wonderful stories!! Wish I could send you all a bialy with a shmear!

StartingGrid · 12/01/2022 21:44

I hate the trains in London but loved the subway in New York, it was so cheap at the time for a weeks pass, $30 I think about 6 years ago? Loved Central Park, especially the zoo, and how cheeky the squirrels were, found Times Square fascinating (who needs to go to H&M at 2am?!), made the most of a City Pass and loved every attraction except the Guggenheim (call me uncultured but it was crap!).

Grand Central station was beautiful, we enjoyed both Empire State building and Top of the Rock but did one by day and one at night to get the best overall view. Walked the Brooklyn bridge, visited South Street Sea Port and got tickets to a Broadway show there, and ate at great places like Ellen's Stardust diner, Katz's deli, and Carlos's bakery as well as grabbing the odd mammoth pizza slice!

Actually spent less than I thought I would, surprisingly! Shopped at Macys and Bloomingdales among other places but didn't go mad.

Ive only ever been to NY and San Francisco in America, and have to say it really saddens me to hear how badly both cities are struggling as I'd definitely have revisited both if I had the opportunity.

allfurcoatnoknickers · 12/01/2022 21:38

@TizerorFizz I live here (NYC) and I love museums! I go to museums wherever I can. I've been to the Tenement museum many times.

My point was sort of a reverse because I hate hiking and even if I was near a famous hiking trail wouldn't want to go hiking because I hate it IYSWIM. Being on holiday wouldn't suddenly make me be in to hiking.

Movinghouseatlast · 12/01/2022 21:35

I agree 100%. I went in April, October and April again with work

It is dirty. It is noisy. It smells. It all looks the same.

Walked over Brooklyn Bridge- it was windy and dirty.

Highline- what the ACTUAL fuck is it with that? It's just a very narrow park.

Central Park. Why bother when we have beautiful parks in London?

Shops. Nothing as beautiful as Harrods.

It was all just so horribly urban. I come from Gorton in Manchester and it reminded me of that.

Good things- The Tenement Museum, Arturio's pizza, Magnolia bakery, Washington Square area was OK.

London is just a million times better.

purplecorkheart · 12/01/2022 21:18

Loved New York when I was there. I must confess we did a huge amount of planning before we went and researched areas to stay and eat and I do think this made our holiday very sucessful.

We did spend a good bit on food but that was at high end places we wanted to try but also found excellent low cost restaurants nearby and it would have been very easy to eat quite cheaply. You just need to avoid places aimed at tourists or around Time Square in my experience.

The only place we came across beggars was on Broadway and near Time Square and they did not approach us. We noticed they tended to target the people who either were wearing clothing with New York written on it or holding maps etc. We found that by walking confidently we were left alone.

I honestly can every local we met were lovely and could not be more kind. To be honest I was quite surprised at how kind they were to tourists. Small things like when we walked into Grand Central a businessman warned us that someone had spilt coffee and the floor was slippy to people coming in the door. A couple in another restaurant advised us to split a starter and not to order sides in another restaurant as the portion sizes were huge but the staff had to make you think they would be small.

Admittedly, this was pre covid but I would return to New York in a heartbeat.

MissConductUS · 12/01/2022 21:16

One activity that I think is really fun is the stage door tour at Radio City Music Hall.

www.rockettes.com/christmas/experiences/tour/

You get to see the costume rooms, all of the lighting and mechanicals, etc. You even get to chat with a Rockette.

TizerorFizz · 12/01/2022 21:02

@allfurcoatnoknickers

But surely if several of the world’s iconic museums are in NY you might just find something interesting in one of them? I always recommend the Tenement Museum for example. You can dip into the big name museums to check out what interests you. If people don’t really like what NY has to offer, why go? It’s not difficult to research highlights and see what you think is of interest to you.

I’ve not been to Battery Park. I preferred walking across the Brooklyn Bridge. I’ve enjoyed lots of hidden gems but you have to do your research. I’m left wondering what city the OP would like?

AllThePogs · 12/01/2022 20:54

What I love on holiday is seeing something amazing or different.

allfurcoatnoknickers · 12/01/2022 20:50

@AllThePogs I mean, I go to the supermarket at home but I LOVE going to the supermarket on holiday. A foreign supermarket is like catnip to me. I always come back loaded down with interesting foody stuff.

I think @ChampagneLassie is trying to say don't try and be someone you're not? So if you normally love hiking, then why not hike on holiday (or walk the perimeter of Manhattan, or the marathon route, or whatever) as opposed to making yourself walk around museums you'd never go to at home because you don't like museums.

DoloresMadrigal · 12/01/2022 20:46

@MuddySnowflake

Ok, the Nescafé Gold comment from the OP makes me think she must be trolling us.

OP: when you go on holiday, it is your responsibility to make the most of it, plan and research interesting things to do.

This reminds me of a wise saying my mum often says: ‘when you travel, you take yourself with you’.

If you’re a boring grump at home and you’re not interested in very much, I’m afraid New York won’t be your cup of Nescafé Gold.

(This hits hard because I would LOVE to be in NYC right now and it makes me sad that someone is there not appreciating it!)

I do sincerely hope your trip improves though. Do follow some of the many helpful suggestions given by other posters.

“when you travel, you take yourself with you”

...this is amazing, thank you for sharing, it puts into words exactly how I feel about certain negative nancies I’ve had to travel with in the past.

I adore NYC too, and cannot fathom someone not enjoying it!

AllThePogs · 12/01/2022 20:20

@ChampagneLassie why would you fly across the world to do the same things you enjoy doing at home?

mathanxiety · 12/01/2022 18:51

As for Battery Park, that isn't much more than any town's local recreation ground.

Maybe you had your back to the great views?

TizerorFizz · 12/01/2022 18:42

@BurbageBrook
You chose the wrong sights then. We have always found NY has something to offer. I cannot see why the Chrysler building would be underwhelming? Or walking back to Manhattan on the Brooklyn Bridge? Or seeing the art in MoMa or the American art section of the Met? Or walking the High Line? There is the iconic trip to the Statue of Liberty and fantastic walks around SoHo with cafes on every corner. Why would you think any of them was underwhelming?

BurbageBrook · 12/01/2022 18:20

I love almost all cities I’ve been to — Paris, San Fran, Rome, Florence, Madrid, London etc — so it’s not because I’m a country bumpkin that I don’t like NY. It’s just, to me, got a hard and cold atmosphere and it’s nothing like I expected. I have never seen that level of homelessness and people with severe mental illnesses who should be receiving medical help in any other city, either. The lack of a real security net for the vulnerable is really stark in NY. And I also found most of the sights underwhelming.

ChampagneLassie · 12/01/2022 18:10

My parents felt like this - but they are country folk who hate all cities. Surprised you live on edge of London. I love NY I think its more "fun" than London - but perhaps partly because I've only been there on holidays. But it is a bit city with something for everyone so why not just do whatever you normally do at home / in London that you enjoy? i.e. don't feel you need to do specific tourist checklist.

TizerorFizz · 12/01/2022 18:05

I never get that either. Films are stories. Fairytales. Not real. If you go anywhere do your own research. Make sure you go and see what suits you in full knowledge of what it’s really like.

Roxy69 · 12/01/2022 17:33

There are better places to go. Imho a lot of the USA is very overhyped. Why do we believe it really is like in the movies?

carbuncleonapigsposterior · 12/01/2022 17:03

This is a long thread so haven't read everyone else's opinion. I've been three times, each time loved it a bit less. Completely over awed the first time, it gave me goose bumps because it was as if I'd already been there, portrayed of course in so many films it had a resonance. When I first walked out on the street it felt magical, like a forest of high rise buildings. My children were with us, they were quite young junior school age, now they are grown up I think that NY trip has always been etched in their memories, especially going up the Empire State and visiting the John Lennon memorial in Central Park. Back then I thought it was the most exciting place in the world I had ever visited. Last time we were there maybe 7 or 8 ago and it wasn't quite as I remembered it, I suppose nothing ever is. I didn't like Times Square hated the subway found parts of it over whelming, especially the heaving crowds and quite dirty, possibly my tolerance levels were different age does that, but parts of it no longer held the wow factor. My husband couldn't wait to get away from the place and swears he will never go back. I think in comparison to London, NY's parks are underwhelming, Central Park isn't a patch on many of the Royal Parks, I lived closed to Richmond and Bushy Parks for many years and they are both fantastic. As for Battery Park, that isn't much more than any town's local recreation ground.

I think for many years New York would have been considered amazing, America's place in the world being at the fore in so many respects, we naturally expect so much when we go there, but all sorts of places that wouldn't have even been considered cool places to visit, have eclipsed NY.

TizerorFizz · 12/01/2022 16:16

I think you can find fantastic NY where people are pleased to see you and are helpful. Anyone working in a museum for example. We much prefer staying in SoHo. More laid back. More of a neighbourhood vibe.

Subway is horrible and old fashioned. Real time train info isn’t universal. Of course druggies are everywhere. Just like sleeping in doorways is common in London. Maybe they should all be rounded up like in a communist state? But it’s a fact you will see people you don’t like in cities.

Therefore: take cabs, be discerning and visit nicer places. Central Park is ok for a stroll but the Met Museum nearby is better! There are plenty of lovely buildings and experiences you can do which don’t involve talking to others much.

Food has never been cheap in NY. Taxes and tips add around 30%. So if you don’t do your homework, it’s a shock! However plenty of publications give great recommendations. Again, be discerning.

cillacilla · 12/01/2022 16:07

I live in NY in Brooklyn. I haven't lived here too long but I do think it feels more unsafe than when I lived in London. There does seem to be more people on drugs here and I have witnessed a few random attacks from clearly paranoid people on the subway to innocent bystanders. I used to get the tube/bus late at night in London regularly but here I would avoid it tbh.

Nothing7 · 12/01/2022 16:01

The vibe was great, yes some locals weren’t interested in us but others were lovely.
The architecture was lovely, a mix of old and modern buildings.
And I don’t know how to explain it but I just had a lovely feeling about the place

Nothing7 · 12/01/2022 15:59

I went 2 years ago just before Xmas - but not before the rockerfeller lights switch on. It was Black Friday weekend.
I loved it and I was someone who had absolutely no interest in going. It was a surprise from hubby.
We did a food tour in the meat packing district, the rockerfeller, cycled Central Park, walked Times Square, walked the high line. We did a tour of the bridges cheap by getting the east river ferry from Wall Street right through. That was lovely and we just grabbed a few beers on the ferry and chilled. Saw liberty on the free Staten Island ferry.
We didn’t go on a shoe string but made our money last so we could enjoy beers . We didn’t really do any meals our, just because breakfast one day was crazy filling, and the day we did the food tour of Chelsea market we were equally stuffed. So just grabbed bar snacks.
Would go again absolutely

whenthedoveslie · 12/01/2022 15:26

Parisians on the other hand... apart from some exceptions, they are scary! I reckon they just smelled my fear and couldn't help themselves

That made me smile @UglyModernWindows I actually find the dripping condescension from Parisians as part of the charm of being there, particularly when speaking to them in badly constructed and accented French. They are simply unable to hide their disdain Grin

LOL at all Americans being rude. In my vast experience they are some of the friendliest folk on the planet... Even New Yorkers!!