Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely HATE New York

993 replies

GreetingsFromVenus · 10/01/2022 01:01

Dreamed of going there for many years. Thought it would be amazing. Everyone seems to think it is.

Here now and I hate it. Extortionate prices, rude ignorant locals, so many aggressive beggars. mentally ill people shouting in the street. loads of homeless people. The subway stations are disgusting and feel very menacing compared to London.

I find it really depressing actually and feel that the way Hollywood has portrayed New York is all smoke and mirrors. It is nothing special at all IMO. In fact it has a LOT of social issues and it made me feel quite sick to be spending $100 just for a mid range meal for 2 (no dessert) while there were people asking for food outside.

Central Park - pffttt!

Cannot wait to get home next week and will never complain about London prices again!

Anyone else felt the same?

OP posts:
DeathOnTheNile · 10/01/2022 03:58

New York has always been very polarising. Some people find it brash, its locals rude and its streets dirty and crowded. It is all those things, but I absolutely loved it the couple of times I've been, including once over December-January. But I love lively, busy cities and I don't need pretty in a destination either. I didn't feel it was particularly expensive either.

Sometimes you vibe with a place and sometimes you don't, and that's okay.

MayLeaveADentInYourSofa · 10/01/2022 03:51

I was there last week. My first time visiting. I loved it. But I'm a city person, and I expected all the issues you described.

Cameleongirl · 10/01/2022 03:46

@BritWifeInUSA

Just to add I’ve been to Florida (pre Covid) a few times and loved it. Great, reasonably priced food and the people were lovely.

And that’s your problem. This country is made up of 50 states that are more like separate countries than parts of the same country. Florida is a few thousand miles from New York so of course it’s going to be different. That’s like going to Berlin and being shocked you didn’t like it because Spain is lovely.

So true, @BritWifeInUSA!
2021mumma · 10/01/2022 03:37

I love New York- we went exactly 5 years ago and loved being there in early Jan!

The snow made everything so beautiful and we walked for miles around the sites which kept us very warm.

There are so many great places to eat that are affordable just keep away from the tourist traps.

www.katzsdelicatessen.com/ Best pastrami on rye EVER. It's the place that was in When Harry met Sally. When you go up and order, tip your sandwich maker a couple of dollars and they'll give you a better portion

www.levainbakery.com/ Ultimate cookies.

urbanspacenyc.com/urbanspace-vanderbilt/ Great to stop off for breakfast or lunch. You need to get a coffee from Toby's Estate (it's up the back) and is my favourite coffee in the whole word! You can also get a doughnut from Dough Doughnuts here - really good doughnuts.

robertaspizza.com/ Brilliant pizza in Brooklyn. Also, Brooklyn is well worth a trip...walking the Brooklyn Bridge at sunset is a must!

I’m guessing covid etc is negatively impacting your stay.

Download todays tix app- we got Broadway tickets really cheap.

teaandchocolate1 · 10/01/2022 03:29

@Mumwithapub

Yes went a couple of years ago, not a place I would go back to. Ripped off royally by a taxi driver as soon as we got off the plane. Beggars asking for 50 dollars for weed! Prefer California much nicer people.
I was ripped off by a taxi driver as well when I got off the plane.

Another taxi driver tried to rip me off by claiming I smoked in the car (I didn't) and he wanted me to pay a fine.

There were police sirens everywhere, 24/7

Locals were aggressive/rude

It was a truly horrific, dystopian experience and I was glad to come back to the UK.

LemonSwan · 10/01/2022 03:29

YANBU,

I found that they tended to pride themselves on being cold and rude; and yet if by some miracle you did end up conversing with someone half decent then they would just go on about how much like Londoners they were.

As a Londoner of decades I can count on one hand the moments of down right rudeness. I would have got run out of fingers on the first day in NYC.

I did like the Highline and the pocket parks though. Some very nice public realm design.

DillDanding · 10/01/2022 03:25

Haven’t been since 2019, but we used to go once or twice a year to break up our trip to Florida (we have a place there).

We really love it. But I’ve been in January, it was too flipping cold.

But when it’s not arctic, it’s one of our favourite places in the world. We always stay in the west village.

Neves7 · 10/01/2022 03:24

Also in the US tips are definitely expected in sit down restaurants and it is considered extremely rude to not tip. Bad service just gets a smaller tip (unless you basically saw them drop your food on the floor and put it back on the plate). Like it or not it is expected and most people just factor it into the cost of dining out. I don’t agree with this and think restaurant employers should pay more (and thus charge more directly) instead - it is the way things are. Culturally not tipping in the US is like queue jumping in the UK ;).

Neves7 · 10/01/2022 03:16

I actually like NYC and before I first visited I never in a million years expected to. To me the city is a distillation of humanity (or at least western culture). The good, the bad and the ugly. It’s grey and dismal in the winter and smells like hot garbage (literally) in the summer but you can find anything you are looking for there and even after the past couple of years it still has an intense sense of life and vibrancy.

Pallisers · 10/01/2022 03:15

@Ericaequites

As a New Englander since 1620, I see New York as a form of Hell, with less interesting people. The cabbies are rude and terrifying, the shops and restaurants dear, and the people are rude. People expect 20-25% tips. I shop for material in the Fashion District with many unmarked prices, and know my country mouse accent means I get worse prices. Boston has less theatre, and is less posh. It’s much more civilized and clean, with fewer beggers. The museums are great, and history far more interesting. London is better still. If only New York would leave the nation and become the free socialist dystopia it longs to be.
Also not a big fan of NYC but I have no idea what you mean about tips. most people I know in Boston give 20-25% tips, especially since the pandemic.

Laughing too at Boston being less posh. Not sure there is any posh as such in the US - I'd use a different word - but if there is, it certainly can be found in Boston.

APJ1 · 10/01/2022 03:08

TV and movies always make it look so wondeful and glamorous, I always used to want to go there. More recently though, I've realised that I would probably hate it, with all the crowds and noise!

Oblomov22 · 10/01/2022 03:03

Glad I read this thread. Was thinking about NY for next year. Might reconsider.

givethatbabyaname · 10/01/2022 02:58

And enough with the “third world” thing, please. Have some respect (to developing countries, that is).

foxgoosefinch · 10/01/2022 02:56

@britinnyc

I lived in NYC for a long time and loved it but even I found it super depressing in January and I’m sure it is even more so right now because of covid. All big cities are seeing rising crime right now and it is a complicated situation. For what it’s worth I live in LA bow and it is nothing like the poster above described. It’s a series of little cities linked together and some are what is described but most aren’t, even those that are a where the rich people love. More of a sense of community where I live now than I ever found in NYC or London. And the weather is obviously a big factor!
Yeah definitely - I spent a few days in downtown LA once for work, and that was a revelation - fantastic restaurants and bars, art, hills (!) and skyscrapers! Like a totally different city - it was like a miniature bit of Chicago had crash-landed in LA. Nothing like the rest of LA at all!
givethatbabyaname · 10/01/2022 02:54

You sound like a suburban Londoner who uses American sitcoms as your travel guide.

Your anger and disgust and disappointment is about your missed expectations. I mean, come ON. New York, in January? During Covid? Did you do any research at all? Read a newspaper maybe?

🙄

whatsupsunshine · 10/01/2022 02:54

@dreamingbohemian

You're doing it all wrong.

Signed,
A Rude Ignorant Local

Yup! This! Written as an expect Londoner from my Brooklyn apartment while my 'ignorant local' kids sleep upstairs. Sounds like Florida would be perfect for you (in joke) 😂
Sydendad · 10/01/2022 02:51

Fully agree with you. I was thoroughly disappointed and thought it looked like it stopped dead in the 90s. Everything looked old and worn and dirty to me and indeed lots of rude people. And the train and metro system just looks like it was built in the 50s and never taken care off or upgraded. Some areas even looked like a third world country to me.
The hotels as well looked like they were once great about 50 years ago.
People are horrible as well with being welcomed everywhere with an overly annoying customer friendliness that clearly isn't meant.

britinnyc · 10/01/2022 02:51

I lived in NYC for a long time and loved it but even I found it super depressing in January and I’m sure it is even more so right now because of covid. All big cities are seeing rising crime right now and it is a complicated situation. For what it’s worth I live in LA bow and it is nothing like the poster above described. It’s a series of little cities linked together and some are what is described but most aren’t, even those that are a where the rich people love. More of a sense of community where I live now than I ever found in NYC or London. And the weather is obviously a big factor!

eurochick · 10/01/2022 02:49

I went for the first time nearly twenty years ago to visit friends and felt the same. I love big cities and expected to adore the place but I hated it. It's so noisy and brash, and the people are so rude. I just didn't warm to it at all, even with a local guide. I've been back a few times for work and it hasn't improved. DC on the other hand is great. I love going there.

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/01/2022 02:49

You're welcome @JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil

I mean some people love it so there's that. I still always think everyone should visit everywhere because you never know!

SquirrelG · 10/01/2022 02:49

Not been but it looks grotty, dirty and a couple of decades behind. I imagine it has lots of rats and people are rude. Not a place I want to visit.

FFS - yet another person judging a place they've never even been to (or it may well be the same person on different threads!). A couple of decades behind - behind what exactly???

knitnerd90 · 10/01/2022 02:47

@notangelinajolie

YANBU. We have had some good city breaks in London over the years and booked NY staying at the Plaza Hotel for a special birthday with family thinking it would be fabulous like London but with bells on. It was not. Terrible terrible very scarey place .
Just to point out - despite the recent increase in crime, NYC is one of the safest big cities in the US. I am regularly in Baltimore for work related reasons: that is a dangerous city.
Ericaequites · 10/01/2022 02:42

As a New Englander since 1620, I see New York as a form of Hell, with less interesting people. The cabbies are rude and terrifying, the shops and restaurants dear, and the people are rude. People expect 20-25% tips. I shop for material in the Fashion District with many unmarked prices, and know my country mouse accent means I get worse prices. Boston has less theatre, and is less posh. It’s much more civilized and clean, with fewer beggers. The museums are great, and history far more interesting. London is better still. If only New York would leave the nation and become the free socialist dystopia it longs to be.

foxgoosefinch · 10/01/2022 02:41

That’s a shame - I loved NYC but I can absolutely see why someone wouldn’t. January in NYC is freezing and with a biting cold you don’t get in the U.K.. If that’s not outweighed by some great cultural experiences, it puts a dampener on everything because walking the city isn’t fun when you’re constantly looking for somewhere to get out of the cold. Brits don’t ever tend to need the giant puffa duvet coats New Yorkers wear at this time of year so can be unprepared.

Used to go a lot, but the last time I went was pre-kid, so at least ten years ago when it was the Obama era. The highlights of NYC have always been the museums, ballet, restaurants. If they aren’t really functioning because of the pandemic, I can see it would be a difficult experience. Even good restaurants don’t have the same kind of swish upscale super clean vibe that nice places in say, Boston or California, do - it’s a lot grittier as a place. That used to be part of the charm, but I’m sad to hear the city’s gone downhill recently.

A lot of it depends on local government and the economy and that’s bad right now in the US. If you want a more upscale vibe you could try Boston, even the nice center city parts of Philadelphia (Philadelphia has its own grittiness outside of center city!), DC, Chicago. I think the idea of NYC being terribly plush and expensive is a kind of illusion created by film - even the expensive nice bits of the city are not always super plush the way that bits of London are.

I always find it interesting how the US is a funny mixture of very modern and quite antiquated/old fashioned. If you are used to Europe, there are aspects of the US which are surprisingly unmodern and unsophisticated, even a bit tatty, from the advertising to the shops (there aren’t the same kind of shiny middlebrow chain stores we are used to here, from Boots to Sainsbury’s). And though NYC has great food and restaurants, there’s also plenty of bad ones in the mix too. (Quite a lot of American food is puzzlingly unsophisticated to Europeans - especially the wine, cheese etc, even in NYC, so try other cuisines - there’s great Asian and African food of all varieties in New York). If you aren’t experiencing the great bits of the city to cancel out the bad bits, I imagine you’d feel pretty glum about it.

If open, try the Frick, the Guggenheim, the Morgan library (used to do great cocktails on a Friday in the atrium), MOMA, the Met, forget the shopping, seek out some nice niche bars and restaurants to enjoy. Museum restaurants and cafes are often really nice, reliable, and great for people watching.

mumofone2019 · 10/01/2022 02:41

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn at the poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Swipe left for the next trending thread