Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely HATE New York

993 replies

GreetingsFromVenus · 10/01/2022 01:01

Dreamed of going there for many years. Thought it would be amazing. Everyone seems to think it is.

Here now and I hate it. Extortionate prices, rude ignorant locals, so many aggressive beggars. mentally ill people shouting in the street. loads of homeless people. The subway stations are disgusting and feel very menacing compared to London.

I find it really depressing actually and feel that the way Hollywood has portrayed New York is all smoke and mirrors. It is nothing special at all IMO. In fact it has a LOT of social issues and it made me feel quite sick to be spending $100 just for a mid range meal for 2 (no dessert) while there were people asking for food outside.

Central Park - pffttt!

Cannot wait to get home next week and will never complain about London prices again!

Anyone else felt the same?

OP posts:
speakout · 10/01/2022 06:43

There isnt much that I didlike enough to use the word hate, but big sities are not my thing at all.
I have been to many big cities in my life and find them all overwhelming, and he same mix of hedonistic wealth and extreme poverty, glitz and people sleeping under cardboard. Usually amaing things t0 find- museums, the arts, food, shopping, but all cities are logjammed wth trafffic, noisy, poor air quality.
I like rural living, my nearest city is quite close, but small and very beautiful, good for a few hours, but good to come home to my home in the woods.

Whatayear81 · 10/01/2022 06:42

London, in my opinion, is the most wonderful, fascinating, incredible city in the world.
New York is piss poor in comparison

The former is an hour on the train from me
The latter is an utter pain in the arse to get to
No brainer

PompomDahlia · 10/01/2022 06:41

I think you have to give it time. First time I went I was underwhelmed - after all the movies and SATC I just didn’t get it. I was goi g to a lot of the touristy places. Then I went back and met some friends who live there and went to more local places and got a different perspective and it does grow on your and I loved the energy. But yes, the subway is in awful condition and confusing to navigate. There are huge labour shortages currently so service is very slow and there’s more quieting. Prices have really gone up too, but NYC should have some good cheap local places to eat - I liked the pizza by the slice places.
The US also really seems to have horrific problems with homelessness which are especially bad currently. I was just in the west coast and it was horrible seeing tent cities and people who look so so mentally and physically unwell just wandering around or having a crisis and shouting in distress/wandering into traffic/not wearing proper clothes or shoes - people who looked like they needed taking into hospital or sectioning. It feels like another level to the UK

Policyschmolicy · 10/01/2022 06:39

I loved New York when we went but it was 10+ years ago and August. We were just passing through so only had a couple of days there and one of the best things we did was just walk from the bottom of Manhattan upwards, taking in the atmosphere of the city. There is so much incredible architecture.

I’d love to take the kids back but the pandemic makes everyone a bit weird, even at home. And NY was so badly hit by covid, they need time to recover.

The visibility of mental health issues is not specific to NY, I found San Francisco and LA a lot worse. It’s symptomatic of course that America has a non-existent health and social care system for people not in decent jobs. Underneath all the glitz it’s a country of two halves; the ‘have nots’ basically live in a 3rd world country.

Travelledtheworld · 10/01/2022 06:39

Lived upstate for many years and always enjoyed visiting the city. But NYC was really awful In the 1990s before Rudi Juliani cleaned it up. Best visited in spring and autumn to avoid the stress of very cold winters and hot, humid summers.
I had planned to go back and live like a local in Brooklyn in June 2020 and then came Covid....
It will be interesting to go back.

Chanel05 · 10/01/2022 06:37

Sorry OpP, not with you there. I have been to New York a few times and I adore it.

Belledan1 · 10/01/2022 06:34

Not sure if this has been mentioned but Ellis Island is a good trip. Have you been to times square? It was along time ago that I went though.

Tabbypawpaw · 10/01/2022 06:33

I lived in New York 20 years ago and I did love being there but remembered being shocked at how run down it was, the neglect of the basic infrastructure. It was a real eye opener to me. I’d grown up in a developing country so was used to that kind of stuff but had no idea American cities were so run down. Basic stuff like the pavement, potholes in the road, litter everywhere.

Kbyodjs · 10/01/2022 06:31

I think you’re going to the wrong places if you’re paying that much for an average meal. When I went it was expensive but no more so than London and we did a lot of research into restaurants and booked ahead so everywhere we ate was lovely.
I’m not sure why you don’t like the sights; I loved them and would love to go again.
I wonder if it’s the post Christmas still in pandemic atmosphere

BarkminsterBlue · 10/01/2022 06:31

OP, in your position I would cut your losses and get a train to either Boston (5 hrs) or Philadelphia (1h30). See if you can transfer your flights home. It will still be freezing and neither city is perfect but both are much more compact than NY and have lots of history.

sandgrown · 10/01/2022 06:31

I went to New York in January 2007 and loved it . Like any city it had some grim
bits but I loved the buzz. It was like walking round a film set . Some people were a bit abrupt and though we speak the same language I struggled to understand them but on the whole people were so helpful. We had a free tour of the WTC site with two people who had been in the buildings when they were hit. It was so moving to hear their stories . I would love to return as so much more to see. My one regret is that we were looking at a map a d having a row one day about which way to go and a man came to ask if he could help us . I declined but I think I was quite rude and will have given him a bad impression of English people !

AuldAlliance · 10/01/2022 06:28

@Ericaequites

As a New Englander since 1620, I see New York as a form of Hell, with less interesting people. The cabbies are rude and terrifying, the shops and restaurants dear, and the people are rude. People expect 20-25% tips. I shop for material in the Fashion District with many unmarked prices, and know my country mouse accent means I get worse prices. Boston has less theatre, and is less posh. It’s much more civilized and clean, with fewer beggers. The museums are great, and history far more interesting. London is better still. If only New York would leave the nation and become the free socialist dystopia it longs to be.
You must have seen quite a lot in your lifetime.
Darbs76 · 10/01/2022 06:26

I loved NYC but I agree with all your points. It’s a very dirty city too with rubbish outside all the shops etc. London is my favourite city and NYC didn’t change that, but I did enjoy it and going for the 3rd time this year

Tomlettegregg · 10/01/2022 06:25

I went in September 2019 and didn't have this experience so wonder if it's covid related? More homelessness due to unemployment / addiction issues sparked by the same issue?

That said, I did find it felt markedly less safe then London or Sydney and I wouldn't get the subway alone after dark.

NigellaLawdaughter · 10/01/2022 06:24

You probably would've loved it 20 years ago.
There's no way I'd go there now!

While you're there, take a trip upstate NY, or even Connecticut.
It's beautiful.

Beaconoflight · 10/01/2022 06:22

New York is amazing but agree with pp, January and current situation not ideal. Don’t know if anyone advised you yet but book a visit to Bobbies ! Best pancakes in New York

VenusClapTrap · 10/01/2022 05:54

I’ve been to NYC many times over the years and always liked it. I haven’t been since covid hit though, and I’ve heard it’s been hit hard, which makes me sad.

I don’t think you can really judge a city from a couple of mediocre meals, tourist traps like the Statue of Liberty and a park in January. You could have a crap experience like that anywhere. I’ve had bad meals in London, loathe Leicester Square and would find Hyde Park in January a bit uninspiring too. But I wouldn’t assume that meant the whole city was a write off. It’s a bit short sighted of you.

JustJam4Tea · 10/01/2022 05:44

I’ve not been for 10 years, so fully accept that it might have changed, that the pandemic will have altered things…but I loved it then. Went a few times.

Was in San Francisco 3 years ago and was shocked at the homelessness. TBF shocked at it in Manchester a couple of weeks ago.

whenthedoveslie · 10/01/2022 05:34

The city has definitely lost its spirit. But it’ll come back. New York always does.

I am sure of this. It sounds a grim place to be right now and New Yorker friends of mine literally fled when the pandemic hit.

I studied there in the late 90's. It will remain one of my favourite cities in the world because of that experience. I would hate to visit now and have that memory shattered.

PurpleFlower1983 · 10/01/2022 05:30

What made you choose to go now OP? Didn’t you realise it was such a bad time? LA is having similar awful issues.

WutheringHeights66 · 10/01/2022 05:27

I’ve been three times and loved it each time.

BUT it’s always been in the summer. I think the same about every city break I’ve been to, that the place is only great in the summer or Christmas and that includes most of Europe and North America.

EvenleyWitch · 10/01/2022 05:23

@Nancydrawn

New York is a spectacular city.

New York in January in the middle of a pandemic surge is...less great.

It also entirely depends where you go. Did you go anywhere off the beaten path? Walk around the lovely neighbourhoods? Go to Brooklyn or on the river at all? Did you go to the world class museums? Libraries? Theatre is mostly closed right now, as is the ballet and the opera. Concert scene is dead at the moment. But the Knicks, the Rangers, and the Nets are playing, if you want sport.

The subway is indeed atrocious right now. The pandemic has put additional pressures on social care that make it difficult. And New York is messy, mid-covid. It hit hard and it hasn't let up.

But Central Park meh? It's gorgeous at this particular moment, all gilded with snow. And people aren't rude, if you talk with them. They're just not frosty polite on the front and rude behind your back.

One of my very favourite places in the world.

No, they're just rude to your face Grin
EvenleyWitch · 10/01/2022 05:19

@Envoitrevisage

I adore NYC. Manhattan and the rest of it, and I love Jersey too.

I could spend days alone in NYC. It always makes me crave my younger, child free and successful and single days.

I don't have to go to New York to crave that Wink
EvenleyWitch · 10/01/2022 05:17

@RoseRedRoseBlue

I love love love NY!
Can you tell us some of the things that you loved about NY for comparison?
PurpleFlower1983 · 10/01/2022 05:17

Your experiences sound truly horrible! As for tourist stuff I also found the Statue of Liberty a bit meh except the crown, the 9/11 museum I saw years ago when it was small and temporary. So harrowing and moving but I would never go back. A Circle Line cruise around Manhatten is an interesting way to see the city and walking the high line is cool although may not be safe now. Theatre is a big thing for me so that was always a big focus and I always stayed very central to mainly walk everywhere.

If you were expecting Florida (Orlando) though, that’s like nowhere else in US. It’s fun of course but completely manufactured around the theme parks and not a good representation of everywhere else.

Swipe left for the next trending thread