Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely HATE New York

993 replies

GreetingsFromVenus · 10/01/2022 01:01

Dreamed of going there for many years. Thought it would be amazing. Everyone seems to think it is.

Here now and I hate it. Extortionate prices, rude ignorant locals, so many aggressive beggars. mentally ill people shouting in the street. loads of homeless people. The subway stations are disgusting and feel very menacing compared to London.

I find it really depressing actually and feel that the way Hollywood has portrayed New York is all smoke and mirrors. It is nothing special at all IMO. In fact it has a LOT of social issues and it made me feel quite sick to be spending $100 just for a mid range meal for 2 (no dessert) while there were people asking for food outside.

Central Park - pffttt!

Cannot wait to get home next week and will never complain about London prices again!

Anyone else felt the same?

OP posts:
Whoknowsweknows · 10/01/2022 07:26

Yabu.
I’ve been a couple of times, one of which was January. You’re really not seeing it in its best light.

romatheroamer · 10/01/2022 07:25

Haven't been for a long time but in that decade went several times and loved it so sorry it's fallen on hard times. But even now I'd be happier there than in the miles and miles of Trump-supporting wastelands beyond.

EileenGC · 10/01/2022 07:25

Going in July and I’ll actually have a schedule of things to do - I don’t think mindlessly walking around NY will give me the best impression the city has to offer. Museums, shows, walking tours, that’s what I like to do in big cities. Broadway will keep me entertained for half a week.

Never once had a bad experience with US immigration. They were always polite and efficient. I’ve had two uncomfortable border experiences - one in Serbia a decade ago entering by land, and one at Stansted Airport last year. I was interrogated as to what the purpose of my visit was, did I have a job back ‘home’, when was I flying back Shock… I have an EU passport. Two of them actually. And settled status. It seems that their online database didn’t remind them of that. One pays taxes for years, has a life built in the UK and is then interrogated for simply coming back home… Confused

PersonaNonGarter · 10/01/2022 07:22

YANBU.

It’s weird how crap it is. Although I loved the breakfasts.

TheGoldenWolfFleece · 10/01/2022 07:21

I haven't been to New York as i suspect i would hate it as i find London to be exactly as you describe, dirty, overpriced, don't feel safe on the tube, there's always the feeling something could kick off. There's a huge homelessness and crime problem. I bloody hate London.

Mellowyellow222 · 10/01/2022 07:18

I have been twice, both in early autumn and overall liked it.

But yes the people are incredibly rude and unhappy. It is dated, almost stuck in the 1980s. Im not sure why the locals think they are so modern - maybe because so few of them leave? I also suspect it is very different if you are super wealthy - I suppose like any city.

January would be particularly bleak.

I am so sorry you aren’t enjoying your trip.

SeeMyLanyardAndWeepBitch · 10/01/2022 07:18

I agree with you. I didn't hate it exactly, but i was definitely underwhelmed by it. We had a nice time but I wouldn't rush back. It wasn't especially attractive. I found everything quite shabby and dated compared to London. I was expecting the shopping to be amazing but it wasn't a patch on most decent shopping cities in the UK. It was quite interesting just people watching though.

ShadowGirls · 10/01/2022 07:11

I went in 2001. The subway felt v safe, I remember being told how much had been invested cleaning it up. We didn't really meet any locals or even Americans whilst there, our hotel was ran by French ppl

I don't remember it being expensive but I do remember the beggars. We thought they seemed to be drawn to our accents so kept quiet when approaching them

No plans to go back

user1497787065 · 10/01/2022 07:06

I loved NY when I visited but that was ten years or so ago and in December so everywhere looked stunning prior to Christmas. With any city break I think you need to have a concise plan of what you want to see and do and your first stop should be your hotel concierge.

I thought the service I received everywhere was excellent as staff rely on their tips. It is not acceptable not to tip. It is just the way it is there.

I thought Central Park was beautiful but we are all different.

Magda72 · 10/01/2022 07:05

Sorry you're having a bad experience @GreetingsFromVenus but I agree with other posters in that January is generally an awful time to visit NY. Central Park in spring or fall is just wonderous. I last visited NY in November 2017 (having only ever visited between March & September) & I found it hard going due to the freezing cold & grey days (which I hate).
I'm from Ireland & even Dublin has really suffered with a rise in homelessness & violence during the pandemic & for the first time in my life I would feel more wary of walking around Dublin at night. I think cities have been very badly hit by the pandemic & here in Ireland prices are also rising - businesses trying to compensate for 2 years of losses. I also think that most people are really on a short fuse at the moment & are also not feeling very upbeat.
I've always loved NY & think it's so vibrant, but I also think it's been so glamorised in movies & tv that it's bound to be a disappointment for some.
It has an amazing history that is often glossed over & if you've time left I too would recommend The Tenement Museum (it really is excellent), Big Onion Walking Tours (all tours given by history grads who really know their stuff), The (new) Whitney Museum (the views alone are worth the visit), The Highline (walk off lunch from the Chelsea Markets) & defo get to Brooklyn & walk the waterfront if you can.
All that being said I do think if you're a Florida person you may just not be an NY person. I found Miami very interesting but I wouldn't go back - couldn't find the soul of the city at all Smile.

MuddySnowflake · 10/01/2022 07:04

YABVVVVU! New York is amazing! Loads of incredible things to do - if you stick to the Empire State Building and the Statue of Liberty of course you’ll have a crap time.

Here are some suggestions for alternatives:

  • book a tour of the Tenement Museum and learn about some of NYC’s social history in the 20th century;
  • go to a donation-only Yoga to the People class (in Manhattan or Brooklyn);
  • go on a free walking tour (or four!): freetoursbyfoot.com/new-york-tours/
  • go and buy dessert from Sugar Sweet Sunshine bakery in the Lower East Side;
  • find the best bagel! My favourite are from Russ and Daughters or Kossar’s (compare and contrast!);
- download the Central Park app and go on a long, self-guided walk (or join an organised tour arranged by the park);
  • go for dinner/brunch/breakfast in a classic NYC diner (I recommend Skylight Diner). It will definitely be cheaper than $100! There are loads of cheap places to eat in NYC.

Have you got a long, warm down coat with you? If so - skip the subway and walk everywhere. If not, give yourself a trip to Macy’s and buy one, and then walk everywhere!

It’s my favourite place in the world. Have fun!

Luredbyapomegranate · 10/01/2022 07:02

I love it - one of the world's great cities.

However, it's been hit brutally hard by the pandemic, and January isn't a great time of year, because I think the magic comes from street life and you experience that better in Spring and Autumn.

Focus on the great museums and art galleries is what I'd do, and get out and experience some neighbourhoods as best you can - get off the island a bit.

Firesidefox · 10/01/2022 06:58

@ElftonWednesday

You sound like a Florida person, OP, not a NY person. Florida doesn't have much appeal to me apart from the flora and fauna.
This is such a classically mean and snooty MN post it made me laugh out loud!

I'd love to meet you @ElftonWednesday and hear all about your fantastic levels of sophistication and erudition in person.

ButterfliesAndDaffodils · 10/01/2022 06:57

@MrsTerryPratchett, LA is a weird one. LAX is definitely the most hideous airport ever. As for the city itself, I stayed once in a fairly well known, nice hotel. It was shit. I remember going to the pool, and no fucker actually got in it. It was just all people sitting around posing by the pool, on their laptops, utterly joyless. On that trip, we also had a fun experience when DH asked in a bar if they had a particular beer (that clearly wasn't cool enough), and the bartender scowled and said, rather aggressively, 'why the fuck would you ask if we have that shit?' Yes there is definitely some arsiness, and public transport is awful.

However, it also has Canter's on Fairfax, Tusquellas in the Farmers Market, and Amoeba Records.

DickMabutt73962 · 10/01/2022 06:56

OP I signed in relief as I was driving through the streets of London from the airport see a week in NYC. I did like Central Park though. We need to stop idolising America.

Aaa456789 · 10/01/2022 06:55

I just got home from here yesterday, I went two years ago and it was amazing. This time I still loved it but the New York feeling wasn’t there it’s not the same since covid! We spent 3k in 3 days as a family of 4 prices r horrendus! Enjoy yourself wile you are there you’ve paid enough to get there.

DysmalRadius · 10/01/2022 06:55

I agree OP- we went a few years ago and found it pretty grim and we did most of the stuff the NY lovers suggest and still didn't enjoy it! And everything is closed on Mondays! Ended up in New Orleans and didn't want to leave, though, so decided that everyone has a place in the US and New York wasn't ours!!

YourenutsmiLord · 10/01/2022 06:55

I think in NY you need to be visiting museums and seeing shows. I agree Central park - I have nicer scenery outside my window. I've seen some amazing parks in London.
I hated the noise, square grid roads means cars are stopping and starting and peeping the whole time. Awful.
But Jan is a bad month for anywhere in the Northern Hemisphere.

Staryflight445 · 10/01/2022 06:50

I’d rather go to Tokyo than New York. It just doesn’t interest me one bit.

FrankGrillosWrist · 10/01/2022 06:50

There’s places that I’d’ve like to go in USA, but just the very thought of flying United or American again fills me with horror. Then there’s the screams that you get going through immigration telling you to get in line, & don’t they just love to give you a good patting down! As for the entitlement to a tip when they did nothing but squawk far too loudly in a nasal tone at you. Awesome it ain’t!

DefyingSanity · 10/01/2022 06:47

I went 6 years ago. Like you I had high expectations based on how much they praise NYC. I heard their customer service was amazing - it wasn't, especially in shops.

The blocks all look the same, pizza place, starbucks, American flag and then a diner, which repeats itself on every block. No character or individuality and just predominantly their own American brands.

The subway system like you said I just thought was really old-fashioned. Tickets instead of contactless and massive turnstiles instead of the little barriers. No staff in the subway to help you so we couldn't get out, they told us on the phone they would have to send someone over and it would take 10+ mins.

I saw racial tension just whilst waiting in line for a theatre show. People shouting at each other over their skin colour. Was really bizarre.

Saw a cab driver start an argument with an Italian family he had just dropped off at their hotel demanding they gave him a tip. So disgusting.

However, saying all this, I did miss NYC a few years later. It wasn't all bad- the tourist stuff was fun I just thought it didn't have a thing on London!

CurtainTroubles · 10/01/2022 06:47

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Rainbowbrite2022 · 10/01/2022 06:44

I can’t speak for it now but I’ve been three times and loved it. I last went in 2019
Just before the pandemic and it was great. Love exploring the districts and different places it has to offer. Never really felt unsafe as it’s always busy and people around. Never found people rude, just city people. Never demanded for tips although probably because we always tipped when eating and drinking. Central Park is great in summer too. I’ve been at this time of year and the experience is totally different to summer.

Sad to hear it’s lost its mojo but a pandemic will do that I guess.

UserBot989 · 10/01/2022 06:44

I emigrated from Dublin to London and in the 90s and took to London like a duck to water, loved it, it was exciting, I found everything, the tube was easy to navigate. Then I and 3 friends went to NY and we could NOT figure out what side of the platform we needed to stand in NY. We couldn't seem to figure any thing out at all and London was so logical. LOGICAL but exciting. NY seemed to me to be vast and sprawling but underwhelming. I also knew I just wasn't finding the good bits. One night my friends and I ended up in a TGFs and we were disappointed in ourselves but couldn't seem to find any restaurants that looked welcoming. We had wandered in to a restaurant and the waitress screamed ''whaddya want?'' at us and we didn't feel it was a welcoming kind of whaddya want. Saw all the tourist sites though.

Therealrealitystar · 10/01/2022 06:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.