Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely HATE New York

993 replies

GreetingsFromVenus · 10/01/2022 01:01

Dreamed of going there for many years. Thought it would be amazing. Everyone seems to think it is.

Here now and I hate it. Extortionate prices, rude ignorant locals, so many aggressive beggars. mentally ill people shouting in the street. loads of homeless people. The subway stations are disgusting and feel very menacing compared to London.

I find it really depressing actually and feel that the way Hollywood has portrayed New York is all smoke and mirrors. It is nothing special at all IMO. In fact it has a LOT of social issues and it made me feel quite sick to be spending $100 just for a mid range meal for 2 (no dessert) while there were people asking for food outside.

Central Park - pffttt!

Cannot wait to get home next week and will never complain about London prices again!

Anyone else felt the same?

OP posts:
TorySteller · 10/01/2022 10:09

I adore New York so can’t relate. I agree with pp that mid January is probably one of the worst times to go.

I could go back again and again and do something different every time. We got married in Central Park and I found it just magical.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/01/2022 10:07

Years ago now, but I went with a sister and DM for another sister’s wedding.

It was mid December and very cold, not that that put me off, since we were expecting it.
I was decidedly underwhelmed, though, and have never felt the urge to go back.
DSis lived for many years in either Boston or Cambridge (close to Boston) both of which I preferred. Pretty orrible climate, though - very long, cold winters and very humid summers.

We’ve been at various times of year but went once in mid April to Boston to see a niece’s performance in an opera. Full spring here (SE) all the daffodils out, leaves beginning to open, etc. - there it was still bloody cold and chucked it down solid for 48 hours - a degree or two colder and it would have been a blizzard. Virtually no flowers anywhere and no green grass, it all dies off in the cold.

ChicCroissant · 10/01/2022 10:06

I didn't like NY either when I went - which was years ago - Greenwich Village was quite nice. I prefer Chicago, but like most cities it has places you'd want to keep away from at night!

OP, are you the poster who was going for your DD's birthday?

CornishGem1975 · 10/01/2022 10:05

I've been to New York in January and it was grim. I've been to New York in June and it was glorious but like others say, it's in a bit of decline at the moment - as is a lot of the US. However, in a normal situation - go off the beaten path, you don't have to go to the tourist traps (Times Square should always be avoided, dreadful place) - but there is so much more to the city.

Gonnagetgoing · 10/01/2022 10:05

@AutumnAlmanack

What a shame OP! I absolutely love NYC and can't wait to go again. We have been 5 times already and I never tire of it. We have been just before Christmas on 3 occasions and each time has been magical. I always pre-book accommodation and restaurants and have a vague plan for each day. My favourites are:-

Grand Central - beautiful architecture and has an 'exciting' air. When you've been round there, cross the road to have breakfast/lunch at Pershing Square Restaurant - it's such a lively (and reasonable) place.
Radio City and the Rockettes
A walk over Brooklyn Bridge
South Sea Port
Bryant Park is lovely - as you are there now, go and see the Winter Wonderland and maybe have a skate?
Walking up 5th Avenue right to the end, Columbus Circle and the entrance to Central Park - did you go to see the ice rink in the Park? I think it's fantastic - this huge, huge park in such a big city
Top of the Rock much nicer than the Empire State
Staten Island Ferry (free) to see the Statue of Liberty and back again

I still haven't been to Greenwich Village or some of the other famous parts, but plan that next time.

We haven't found people rude at all - remember that tips are part of the average worker's pay and they do expect to be tipped for everything they do! Last time we went, we had lunch at SaraBeth's on Columbus Circle and the man at the next table leaned over and said 'I just love your accent, are you from England?'. Classic!!

@AutumnAlmanack - agreed with all of this but it's South Street Sea Port!

Agree with Top of the Rock and your other tourist info too. Greenwich Village is great.

Agreed re tipping - it's part of everyday life and their average pay and they expect it. For a tourist not to factor this in, is not good of them.

Honeymint · 10/01/2022 10:03

Oh! One thing a friend did recommend in NY was the museums. The Natural history one and there’s a big fine art one around too.

I hope you find something fun to do while you’re there, OP

Honeymint · 10/01/2022 10:01

As a kid I always imagined the USA to be this amazing destination.

As an adult, 3 of my friends have been and all hated it. (Two went to New York, one to Chicago)
One friend was bitten by a tick, caught lunes disease and had to fly home early because it was cheaper than medical help over there. Yikes.
A few bits still look appealing; New England and the Great Lakes. And I’d still love to go to Canada.

If you’re after an amazing city-break, Tokyo, Kyoto and Osaka are lovely, clean, safe and there’s loads to do.

Frazzled2207 · 10/01/2022 09:59

Sorry to hear OP.
Haven’t been to NY for quite a few years but I would highly recommend
A boat trip eg the one to Ellis island. Really interesting museum there
Museum of modern art -Moma
A show! You used to be able to get cheap(Ish) tickets on the day at TKTS on Broadway
It is much nicer in spring or early autumn though. Been one in august and was hellishly hot

Gonnagetgoing · 10/01/2022 09:59

@puffyisgood

It has its charms. FREEZING in winter.
It is freezing in winter - the photos of the above people high snow stacked up after shovelling on sidewalks aren't fake! Air conditioning helped a bit though. And ice skating a lot.
baggies · 10/01/2022 09:59

We've been twice, in April and October last time a couple of years ago. We loved it hence going again and not managing to see everything the first time.
We were never hassled by anyone on the streets. We were impressed by the level of How clean the streets were on the whole.
We have a huge park where we live but Central park is quite different to ours. Walked and rode round it. Maybe we are quite starstruck but we loved seeing places that we'd seen in films and tv series. We also walked everywhere as someone else did and found it the best way to see stuff. Had an itinerary too and booked lots of things up.
Maybe Covid had changed things as New York was badly effected. Don't get me wrong, we saw beggars and poverty but that's the same in all large cities. Only people who stopped us were those selling passes for the tour buses.
In April we experienced heat and snow!

Gonnagetgoing · 10/01/2022 09:57

@Badbaddog

The Met is hands down the best museum I’ve ever been to and I loved the Staten Island ferry. Otherwise yes I bloody hated New York, much prefer London, San Francisco and Hong Kong. The subway, even pre-pandemic, is appalling and the people seem self-important and crude. It’s the only place I’ve visited where I was trying to get an early flight home 😂
@Badbaddog - the subway has always been known for being appalling!

My friend who's from Forest Hills (the posh part) used to take the subway everyday and hated it! She still hates the subway now and avoids where possible.

I like the fact that subways are 24/7 and you get express trains too.

I'm torn on the Met because I love it - but not sure it's the best museum I've ever been to. Staten Island Ferry is great though.

Gonnagetgoing · 10/01/2022 09:54

I've been to New York many times since I was 16, first time was as a PP has said with a local (friend).

Unless you know the areas/neighbourhoods/good walking areas then you will feel a bit ripped off. Around Times Square has always been a bit grotty and WTC was of course bombed and rebuilt on so don't know what you expected there!

They've experienced a huge pandemic, welfare is very different to in UK and you will get the fair share of beggars etc that you would in eg London.

I certainly wouldn't have been to New York at this time of year (though have been in past) as a tourist - just wouldn't appeal though at Christmas much nicer.

Mybestyear · 10/01/2022 09:53

Been three times- last time was 6 years ago. First two times, I was so excited to be there. Third time, I was a bit meh. Nothing in particular, just felt it was more of the same from the previous two times. To be fair, all three times we went with different people (third time was with DC) so we did the touristy stuff all three times and had seen it all before, so to speak. Last time took the train to Washington and found it to be much worse than NYC. Preferred it as a city in the sense of the aesthetic but found the people to be ruder and many more beggars/homeless. The guy "directing" us to taxis at the station was clearly off his head on something, was rude and obstructive then started screaming at us as we "only" tipped him $5. Note - we are happy to tip in NYC especially in bars as the staff don't really get paid as such - they get "paid" in health insurance so they live off their tips. But we do expect decent service for it.

I wouldn't go back to NYC by choice but would love to go to Boston, Utah and Colorado.

elelel · 10/01/2022 09:52

I'm sorry you are there and I'm sorry you have had some odd replies here. Someone called you entitled? For not enjoying NY. I can't even get my head around that. I suspect they just pulled the word from their lucky dip of common mumsnet terms!!

I'm really glad you posted because I have learned so much through both your posts and the replies. I genuinely have idolised NY for years, and yes, I got that from watching movies/shows because I'm autistic and how it is presented to me visually is how I form an opinion. I have now learned that's not the case so job well done people!!

I hope you can take some positives from this thread OP to help make the rest of your trip more enjoyable

BigSandyBalls2015 · 10/01/2022 09:49

I went about 30 years ago and it was terrifying … then the new mayor came in and transformed it. I went back 4 years ago and it felt much safer, we (DH, myself and two teens) explored the city on foot, cycled round Central Park, had some lovely meals and did the other ‘tourist’ stuff and some less touristy.

Had a great week but we all agreed it isn’t a patch on London. Seems like going back in time … and as for JFK airport Shock

soupey1 · 10/01/2022 09:45

We have been a few times and love it but I understand from someone that lives there that it has changed immensely since Covid and that it is not a good place to go at the moment. Prices have risen disproportionately and there is a massive drug and homelessness problem which is even affecting previously safe tourist areas.

XingMing · 10/01/2022 09:42

I lived there in the 1980s, and loved it even though the city was clawing it's way back from bankruptcy at the time. I read that it has reverted back to those days in the last couple of years. But it has become desperately expensive (accommodation always was). Not sure that large Californian cities are better though. SF is currently on a very low dip.

Badbaddog · 10/01/2022 09:42

The Met is hands down the best museum I’ve ever been to and I loved the Staten Island ferry. Otherwise yes I bloody hated New York, much prefer London, San Francisco and Hong Kong. The subway, even pre-pandemic, is appalling and the people seem self-important and crude. It’s the only place I’ve visited where I was trying to get an early flight home 😂

Hairbrush123 · 10/01/2022 09:41

Sorry to hear OP. I didn’t like New York to start off with either but I went back and now love it. I have been five times and going again next month

HikingforScenery · 10/01/2022 09:40

@GreetingsFromVenus

Just to add I’ve been to Florida (pre Covid) a few times and loved it. Great, reasonably priced food and the people were lovely.

There is a totally different vibe here.

Been a spate of stabbings on the subway too. When we got off at the Natural History Museum this morning, there was LOTS of blood all over the floor. Not cordoned off just right there as you walk across it. Completely shook adult DD up.

We came in Jan for DD’s and my birthdays. Well prepared and wrapped up but unprepared to be harassed literally on our way into the hotel by beggars. Have had it at least 3/4 times a day since. One this morning started violently hitting a shuttered shop front with a walking stick when we refused to give him money. Made us jump 10 feet in the air. It literally feels like a 3rd world country.

I’ve visited a number of “3rd world” countries and no one has aggressively begged me for money.

Yabu for using the phrase 3rd world. It is widely known as a derogatory phrase tbh.

BeMoreGoldfish · 10/01/2022 09:40

I absolutely LOVE NYC - didn't find New Yorkers rude at all! As a previous pp said, it's definitely a city for people who love cities.

Florida? Nah.

KitKat1985 · 10/01/2022 09:40

I went to New York 10 years ago. I did enjoy it but don't think I would have felt safe to be honest if I wasn't with DH (he's a big bloke). It's the only city I've been to which I can say I wouldn't feel comfortable walking alone in.

Even then DH got his credit card cloned out there and we didn't realise until we got back.

I would say it's an interesting city but yeah crime and violence are commonplace which ruins it.

Norugratsatall · 10/01/2022 09:40

YANBU. Went 13 years ago, in August! Quite enjoyable I suppose but somewhat underwhelming and very expensive. Much much prefer London, it has more character and history. I wouldn't bother to go back I don't think. Boston however is amazing!

DottyHarmer · 10/01/2022 09:39

I lived in NY a long time ago. I went back three years ago with the dcs. I was very disappointed. It was so, so touristy. When I lived there the Staten Island ferry was empty; now it was absolutely heaving. Same with museums which I had enjoyed in the past and now had mile-long queues. I was disgusted by the behaviour of young tourists abusing other visitors as they tried to get Instagram shots without other people in the background. Because of the dreaded internet, “secret” out of the way places were now under siege from seething masses.

The subway has always been a bit dodgy and the homeless are more visible, but from every report I’ve heard lately it all seems much worse. I sadly think the US is in decline. When the number of “undesirables” reaches a certain number it is death to a city as their presence overwhelms the ordinary residents.

CounsellorTroi · 10/01/2022 09:39

I loved it when I went but it was nearly 25 years ago.