Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely HATE New York

993 replies

GreetingsFromVenus · 10/01/2022 01:01

Dreamed of going there for many years. Thought it would be amazing. Everyone seems to think it is.

Here now and I hate it. Extortionate prices, rude ignorant locals, so many aggressive beggars. mentally ill people shouting in the street. loads of homeless people. The subway stations are disgusting and feel very menacing compared to London.

I find it really depressing actually and feel that the way Hollywood has portrayed New York is all smoke and mirrors. It is nothing special at all IMO. In fact it has a LOT of social issues and it made me feel quite sick to be spending $100 just for a mid range meal for 2 (no dessert) while there were people asking for food outside.

Central Park - pffttt!

Cannot wait to get home next week and will never complain about London prices again!

Anyone else felt the same?

OP posts:
MissConductUS · 10/01/2022 15:35

I'm a New Yorker.

The city is a bit chaotic at the moment due to the pandemic. I think it was unrealistic to expect a Hollywood portrayal to accurately predict your real-world experience, particularly in January and with omicron shutting so many things down. Every place is short-staffed.

You mentioned a shopping mall at the WTC. Why did you not go to the museum instead?

Victoriaspongecake1 · 10/01/2022 15:33

Nothing! So disappointed as I thought it would have been magical but it wasn’t. It was like we were there in October! Not sure if covid had anything to do with it as they didn’t allow us in until 8th Nov.

Tried to do a Broadway show but that was cancelled due to covid.

Didn’t even see Santa which I’ve been told is basically on every street corner with his bell and bucket. It was very disappointing.

London is much more festive than New York and I never thought I’d say that

whenwillthemadnessend · 10/01/2022 15:31

I went in the early 90s and loved it but I hear a lot of the US has really gone downhill recently. Back to the old days homelessness violence no go areas again. Apparently it's the same in LA

WhereYouLeftIt · 10/01/2022 15:24

Coincidentally, The Times had a fairly long article in their magazine on Saturday about New York and how the covid pandemic has affected the city, and its people. Increased homelessness, dirt, businesses shutting down, decrease in vibrancy etc.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/why-new-yorkers-are-escaping-the-city-thsx707z7

UniBallEye · 10/01/2022 15:23

@StrychnineInTheSandwiches - exactly!
I simply don't recognise some of these descriptions of NYC but then it;s the same on lots of these threads - terrible descriptions of cities I adore - Paris / Rome / Dublin etc.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 10/01/2022 15:21

What I love about London is how easy it is to live well on very little

Really?

Risibisi · 10/01/2022 15:21

@Victoriaspongecake1

I went at the beginning of December after imagining it to be amazing.

Was happy to come home! Wasn’t what I thought at all.
My aunt was assaulted by a homeless woman who tried to rip her handbag from her, we would be bothered by homeless people constantly and they never would take no for an answer

The place smelt like weed

The cab drivers had no idea where anything was so we had to google maps everything and direct them

The hotel staff - like the cab drivers - had no idea about anything.

The shops weren’t festive, not a Xmas light or song on site.

Very disappointed and would never go back!

Where the hell were you staying?! 😂 I just can’t imagine it. I was in Manhattan in early December a few years ago and it was wonderful; sparkly, Christmassy, romantic.
StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 10/01/2022 15:20

I was once in NYC in November and it was like an explosion in a Christmas bauble factory. In a good way.

Lovemelongthai · 10/01/2022 15:19

Nope, completely overrated filthy metropolis.

MomOfTwoGirls2 · 10/01/2022 15:17

I visited for first time at the end of summer. I LOVED it.

We stayed in Brooklyn, which I adored. We took subway many times every day and went all over NY. I generally felt safe, but I did need to keep my wits about me while in subway stations, and at times while out walking around.

We did a bike tour in Central Park. Our guide was great, he pointed out loads of sights to us, especially regards what had been in the movies. He was funny and enthusiastic and it was very enjoyable.
However, if I had just walked or cycled around it on my own it would just have been a nice walk, but not the memorable experience I had.

I can’t wait to go back. Hopefully sometime this year or next. I had thought Jan 2023 as it would be quieter but based on this thread it sounds like December is better if I plan a winter visit.

To those people who said they always wanted to go but would think twice about it based on this thread, I would say it can be wonderful. But don’t stay in Time Square (so many hotels are there), choose a nice neighbourhood close to subway with many small restaurants and bars around.

UniBallEye · 10/01/2022 15:15

@Victoriaspongecake1 - is this actually true? Not a single shop had Christmas lights or Christmas music playing???

I find that so incredibly hard to believe. We were there for Christmas (pre-Covid) and it was MAGICAL with the decorations everywhere!

Soffit · 10/01/2022 15:10

Nice things to do would include the three great museums/ planterium around the park, Moma and Intrepid

LadyEloise1 · 10/01/2022 15:09

@MrsToadflax
Ellen's Starburst Diner is somewhere I recommend. It has the singing waiters/ waitresses. Such fun. And just outside is the queue for the Movie and TV Locations bus tour.
The Boathouse in Central Park is so romantic.

I am so disappointed that New York has gone downhill @Victoriaspongecake1.
We went in late December and sat out on the open top City Tour bus. Frozen but bewitched by an amazing city.
Watching snow fall far below us on St Patrick's Cathedral - the room we were staying in was so high up - utterly magical.
Amazing memories.

Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 10/01/2022 15:07

I am hoping to go this year...Will be my 4th time but not sure l would visit in January

Soffit · 10/01/2022 15:06

My advice would be to make the absolute most of it regardless of how much you are actually hating it and assess the experience/financial damage (!) once you have landed back home.

It is bloody expensive which ever way you look at it so stretch your budget to it's limit and cram in those experiences as you'll certainly be recalling the experience for a long time regardless! I agree that I would not go in January if I could help it.

I find that those of us living in grittier parts of London adapt to New York more easily. I convince myself that I am home from home and take it from there.

RedHot22 · 10/01/2022 15:04

I flew to New York on 1st March 2020
This was later found to be date of the first confirmed Covid infection:
I flew home on the 14th. Lucky

Victoriaspongecake1 · 10/01/2022 14:57

I went at the beginning of December after imagining it to be amazing.

Was happy to come home! Wasn’t what I thought at all.
My aunt was assaulted by a homeless woman who tried to rip her handbag from her, we would be bothered by homeless people constantly and they never would take no for an answer

The place smelt like weed

The cab drivers had no idea where anything was so we had to google maps everything and direct them

The hotel staff - like the cab drivers - had no idea about anything.

The shops weren’t festive, not a Xmas light or song on site.

Very disappointed and would never go back!

Clarissa76 · 10/01/2022 14:56

I absolutely bloody love New York, cannot wait to go back. I imagine it's not at it's best in the middle of a pandemic, in January.

MrsToadflax · 10/01/2022 14:54

Unfortunately I think your first mistake was going in January. I know it's for birthdays, but you could still have gone in spring. We went in November once and we just ran from place to place and kept stopping for coffee to warm up. We enjoyed it, but not anywhere as good as when we went in spring. I really think weather makes all the difference. When it's warmer you can stroll, sit by the lake, sit outside at restaurants etc. We went to the Boathouse restaurant in Central Park and had the doors open and sat by the lake and it was romantic and beautiful. Music was playing in the park and we people watched, drank coffee, grabbed a pretzel and looked in awe at the architecture. Everywhere looks better in sunshine.

We were looking at a map and a guy asked us if we needed help. We did lots of tourist stuff, but still enjoyed it. Ellen's Starburst Diner was good fun. Went to Carnegie Hall, had drinks at The Waldorf, found great places for breakfast etc. Walked a bit off the beaten track as well. I did A LOT of research before going. Had a rough schedule for each day and an idea of places to eat. You get out of it what you put into it. Unfortunately I think your time of year and the pandemic made it a poor choice right now.

Anonymous48 · 10/01/2022 14:44

OP, I really don't understand what you were expecting. Of course it's nothing like the movies! Is anywhere? It's a huge city, in the middle of winter, in the middle of a pandemic.

I worked and commuted into NYC for several years, and I now live in Florida. They are totally different places! One of the main reasons I moved to Florida was the weather, especially at this time of year. I would never in a million years choose to go on holiday to a city in the middle of winter. To be honest, city breaks at any time of year aren't my thing, but you chose one so I don't know what you thought you'd find.

I love where I live now, and I really don't miss the harsh winters, but I do miss New York sometimes, especially when the weather there is nice.

I'm sure you are finding things expensive because the pound is doing so poorly against the dollar. (Something you could have researched ahead of time.) But there is certainly good cheap food available (as well as some incredible expensive restaurants). Take yourself to China Town.

And what is your issue with Central Park? "pffttt" doesn't really tell me much. It's an enormous public park right in the middle of the city. I think it's wonderful. But it is just a park, not some magical place.

LaChanticleer · 10/01/2022 14:40

It's hard to describe but it was just non-stop experience - the noise, the dirt, the energy; a deserted Broadway on a Sunday afternoon after a snowstorm, infiltrating private views and drinking the champagne, rooftop parties, bars behind secret doors, lazy afternoons in Central Park, the cinema in summer to escape the heat, super fancy restaurant one day, a tiny strip-lit place in Chinatown for dumplings or pork buns the next; snow in Little Italy at Christmas, classical music at the BAM, jazz in Tribeca, some grungy band on the Lower East Side. Hanging out at Space Untitled on a Saturday afternoon; the Plaza for tea, the Waldorf for cocktails; dinner in the west village, shopping at Barneys, Urban Outfitters, Pearl River; Shabu Shabu on St Marks; movie stars and opera singers for neighbours. There was always so much to do, see, taste, feel. I had a BLAST.

This is making me homesick for NYC. I have friends there and I've seriously cosidered moving there, but I'd miss rural England (where I spend a lot of time) too much. BUt you capture what is so wonderful about NYC.

And speaking of rats ... as I was walking to the gym this morning, in my regional county town (it has a reputation for being vair naice) there was a big rat snuffling around the wall by the park.

We are all of us only around 2m away from a cockroach or a rat - so no-one should clutch their pearls about NYC subway rats. THey're everywhere.

LaBrujaPiruja · 10/01/2022 14:39

Perhaps the OP had very high expectations? TV shows and movies? It is a big city, with the same problems all (or most) big cities have.

LaBrujaPiruja · 10/01/2022 14:38

I lived in NY, Manhattan, for 3.5 years in the late 90s - early noughties. I would not repeat the experience; it was good but I prefer Europe and London. However, it is a great place to visit and explore. 1 or 2 weeks, plenty of things to do and no time for boredom. Nowadays I like to go for a long weekend, up to a week. Shopping and just strolling and remembering good times.

RoyalFamilyFan · 10/01/2022 14:36

One of my American relatives committed a very violent crime due to untreated mental illness. He was apparently psychotic and no longer knew what was real.
And this is where I don't understand the US at all. Because if you don't make such medical treatment free and easy to access, it can affect everyone. Yes I know mentally ill people are more likely to be victims than perpetrators. But even "only" having someone wandering the streets obviously out of it, is not going to create a nice public space for all the rich people.
I also know from a relative I care for who has serious mental illness that getting someone to accept treatment can be hard enough anyway. No way are they personally going to fight for treatment through all the inadequate medicare protocol.

hivemindneeded · 10/01/2022 14:29

@vixeyann

YANBU. It was always no 1 on my list to visit and we got to go this time 8 years ago when we went for 5 days. I can honestly say I was so disappointed. Don't get me wrong, there were some good parts - the Empire State at night and it snowed whilst we were in Central park but the bad outweighed the good. I found it a very hostile place - from the rudeness in shops and restaurants ( refused to tip in the end) and just the general vibe. I grew in London using the tube but nothing would persuade me to use the subway again. There were clear issues with mental illness on the streets and a cab driver mentioned how all programmes that had helped had lost funding pushing people back onto the streets and the subway. I can only imagine that this has got worse in the years since.
A friend said similar to me. She lived there for a decade, then moved to London. had to go back to sort out some family business last year and couldn't believe the number of really dangerous mentally ill people on the streets.