Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To absolutely HATE New York

993 replies

GreetingsFromVenus · 10/01/2022 01:01

Dreamed of going there for many years. Thought it would be amazing. Everyone seems to think it is.

Here now and I hate it. Extortionate prices, rude ignorant locals, so many aggressive beggars. mentally ill people shouting in the street. loads of homeless people. The subway stations are disgusting and feel very menacing compared to London.

I find it really depressing actually and feel that the way Hollywood has portrayed New York is all smoke and mirrors. It is nothing special at all IMO. In fact it has a LOT of social issues and it made me feel quite sick to be spending $100 just for a mid range meal for 2 (no dessert) while there were people asking for food outside.

Central Park - pffttt!

Cannot wait to get home next week and will never complain about London prices again!

Anyone else felt the same?

OP posts:
EachandEveryone · 14/01/2022 19:46

@Kanaloa

I do think there’s a business opportunity here that I might zero in on - New York tourist resort.

It would be about the size of a large John Lewis and would of course have all the main stuff (statue of Liberty, Empire State) all together to save all that pesky walking around a city. Of course it would have no poor people hanging around spoiling the holiday spirit, and would feature waxworks of popular New York fiction like friends and sex and the city, and I would plant trees every few feet to stop it looking too urban.

It would serve only the finest Nescafé gold and everything would be paid for in pounds not those stupid dollars. And (of course) there would be no rude nasty yucky AMERICANS there!!!

The perfect New York holiday for people who don’t actually want to go to New York.

Thats the New York hotel in Vegas😃
Delatron · 14/01/2022 19:06

There were piles of rubbish piled up in the street when I spent 5 awful weeks there in 2018. I’m sure it’s got worse though.

NotANewYorker · 14/01/2022 18:28

Well I’m home now and thoroughly enjoying my cup of Nescafé Gold!

I’m intrigued by the number of people regularly getting accosted by beggars and homeless people. I’m not saying it didn’t happen, just that I didn’t have that experience at all. Maybe I don’t look like a tourist

@BasketBlocks Have you been recently? As in the last few months? It beggared [pun intended] belief actually how many times were were approached. As DD and I were two women on our own it put us right on edge and probably coloured our whole experience. I’ve never felt so unsafe anywhere else in all my life. Didn’t expect the tonnes of bags of rubbish piled up in the streets either. Obviously the fallout of all the tourist $ they lost during the Covid lockdown has been immense. I only hope they have some recovery by Spring and more importantly they get their act together on the social issues that they’ve obviously massively dropped the ball on.

Has anyone on this thread pooh poohing my experience been there since Covid?

BasiliskStare · 14/01/2022 16:10

Oh and v quickly - went to Vegas once - interesting but happy I wasn't doing it on my own dollar - What is in Vegas should stay in Vegas not dropped on Central Park. ( Other opinions are available ) Grin But I admire those who are prepared to uniform up and get helicopters

BasiliskStare · 14/01/2022 16:06

Re Harrods @elp30 and @Kanaloa - DS went with DH for a long weekend in New York - Bought a very smart jacket from Bloomingdales which was originally $400 and was $65 and he wears it to this day - I do think NYC does shopping well. A niche point. DH still as a scarf he bought from there and he keeps the heart foundation badge they gave him on it ( his mother died from heart disease. ) But look forward to the NY Harrods ( or indeed not ) Grin & would agree would keep those having done the Marble Arch Mound at a fair distance for any new dept. store.

I think it a great city as long as you do not think you are in Harry Met Sally. - there are those places but lots of different ones too.

If I am to be be honest I prefer London but equally NYC is brilliant in so many ways - architecture , restaurants , trips round the rivers , hotels , diversity of neighbourhoods - If I were to go again I would probably not trouble Times Square - but there are some very nice places - Opera -Theatre.

elp30 · 14/01/2022 14:57

@Kanaloa

Let's hope that the construction of the New New York Harrod's isn't made by the same crew who constructed the Marble Arch Mound!

allfurcoatnoknickers · 14/01/2022 00:24

@Kanaloa GrinGrinGrin you're right. I was far to ambitious.

Kanaloa · 14/01/2022 00:18

[quote allfurcoatnoknickers]@Kanaloa So what you're saying is we go to Vegas, nick the New York New York Casino, bring it back, zhuzh it up a bit and plonk it in the middle of boring Central Park?

I'm on it. I've got a ski mask and some delta points. We Uber at Dawn. I'll bring bagels, you bring the Gold Blend. [/quote]
Bagels? BAGELS? Please keep your nasty American food in America.

The New York tourist resort will serve cucumber sandwiches and Nescafé gold. This is the states, we’re not all going to be sipping bodega coffee from the gutters that the rats run down for $75 a sip.

But yes that’s the basic idea. Except it won’t be in Central Park, it will be in Hyde park. I mean why go all the way to scrubby dirty New York when you can be in beautiful wonderful absolutely perfect London? I call New-New York tourist resort for the discerning British traveler. Possibly I’ll have a Harrods there as well, it’s still under construction.

nettie434 · 14/01/2022 00:13

Even before Covid it was really, really hard to evict people in NYC. One of my neighbours in my old building didn't pay rent for A YEAR and the landlord still couldn't evict them. We have really good tenant protections.

Thanks for that info allfurcoatnoknickers. Noted!

elp30 I remember the reports about Hurricane Katrina and the number of individuals who took in people who had been made homeless. It was hugely impressive.

princessnutella What a fantastic way of writing about what it feels like to visit somewhere in reality, not just via photos/films/books/paintings etc. That's not knocking indirect experiences. I find seeing the real thing actually makes the indirect experience more exciting as you compare it with your preconceptions.

allfurcoatnoknickers · 14/01/2022 00:13

@Kanaloa So what you're saying is we go to Vegas, nick the New York New York Casino, bring it back, zhuzh it up a bit and plonk it in the middle of boring Central Park?

I'm on it. I've got a ski mask and some delta points. We Uber at Dawn. I'll bring bagels, you bring the Gold Blend.

Pallisers · 13/01/2022 23:33

@DillDanding

Pmsl at windy on Brooklyn bridge comment.
yes. Although the complaint that New York City was just so horribly urban is also pmsl territory.
BasketBlocks · 13/01/2022 23:33

I’m intrigued by the number of people regularly getting accosted by beggars and homeless people. I’m not saying it didn’t happen, just that I didn’t have that experience at all. Maybe I don’t look like a tourist Grin

DillDanding · 13/01/2022 23:27

Pmsl at windy on Brooklyn bridge comment.

Kanaloa · 13/01/2022 23:11

Seriously though, it does come across a bit like some people are expecting somewhere to be beautiful and friendly because they’re on holiday. I get at a resort people fall over themselves to facilitate you having a good time, but that’s their job! A resort is a place you literally go for a holiday and they depend on you coming back.

New York is a city where people live, work, struggle etc. It’s not nearly packaged to be palatable to a holidaymaker and that’s part of why you would go there. Expecting people to be super friendly and sweet and everything to be spruced up and clean because you’re on holiday is just daft. I mean how many Londoners are happy to stop and have a lovely chat about Buckingham palace when they’re sitting on the tube on the way to work on a Thursday morning?

Realistically if you live in London you don’t care that it’s some American person’s holiday - you’re just getting through the day!

Kanaloa · 13/01/2022 23:08

I do think there’s a business opportunity here that I might zero in on - New York tourist resort.

It would be about the size of a large John Lewis and would of course have all the main stuff (statue of Liberty, Empire State) all together to save all that pesky walking around a city. Of course it would have no poor people hanging around spoiling the holiday spirit, and would feature waxworks of popular New York fiction like friends and sex and the city, and I would plant trees every few feet to stop it looking too urban.

It would serve only the finest Nescafé gold and everything would be paid for in pounds not those stupid dollars. And (of course) there would be no rude nasty yucky AMERICANS there!!!

The perfect New York holiday for people who don’t actually want to go to New York.

IWillFartOnYourCake · 13/01/2022 23:02

Complaining that it was too windy on Brooklyn Bridge is very Mariah Carey style behaviour!

mathanxiety · 13/01/2022 22:59

Walked over Brooklyn Bridge- it was windy and dirty.

A bridge over a mile long spanning open water was windy?

Say it ain't so.

Blackberrycream · 13/01/2022 22:47

New York might seem relentlessly urban compared to cities like London that don’t have the same density. I don’t really worry about a city being too urban. It’s kind of the point.
I find it odd that so many don’t see the beauty of the New York . The canyons that stretch for miles, Central Park is an awe inspiring sight from above with the scale of the surrounding buildings. Also, to say there is no interesting architecture is just real ignorance.

PrincessNutella · 13/01/2022 22:03

Sigh, not all Nescafe can be GOLDEN Nescafe.

SquirrelG · 13/01/2022 19:14

See you on the next America-bashing thread! I'm sure there will be one along soon.

Yep, it won't be long, there seems to be one a week at the moment. Must be about time for an Australia/NZ/Canada/anywhere that isn't the UK one soon - we haven't had one of those for a while.

SquirrelG · 13/01/2022 19:10

When she used to pick me up from the airport we'd drive back north through the city suburbs to join the main highway north. I don't know the name of those neighbourhoods but I remember the first time driving through and thinking 'what a dump'.

My friend said much the same thing when she arrived in London and was on the way to her SIL's place. In fact, although this happened several years ago, earlier this week I was telling her about this thread and she mentioned it again. However, she loved London and, unlike you obviously, was able to see that you can't judge a whole city on what part of it is like!

ComtesseDeSpair · 13/01/2022 18:56

I think London is wonderful - and I’ve also lived here over 15 years with a 4-year break in a big house in a lovely town in Scotland in the middle. I missed this city with all its little pockets so much I had to come back!

Malkukupad · 13/01/2022 17:56

@ComtesseDeSpair

But where did you think poor people live? Or did you previously think there were no poor people in NY? About a third of housing in London is social housing estates, not all of them particularly salubrious, but I wouldn’t expect the average well-informed tourist to declare London a total dump on the back of having seen them.
TBH London is a bit of a dump! I've lived there for 15 years.
allfurcoatnoknickers · 13/01/2022 17:46

See you soon all! I'll be hanging out in my Manhattan triplex waiting for the next time someone from Slough feels the need to tell me I don't have any holidays or healthcare Grin

Anonymous48 · 13/01/2022 17:46

@Movinghouseatlast

I agree 100%. I went in April, October and April again with work

It is dirty. It is noisy. It smells. It all looks the same.

Walked over Brooklyn Bridge- it was windy and dirty.

Highline- what the ACTUAL fuck is it with that? It's just a very narrow park.

Central Park. Why bother when we have beautiful parks in London?

Shops. Nothing as beautiful as Harrods.

It was all just so horribly urban. I come from Gorton in Manchester and it reminded me of that.

Good things- The Tenement Museum, Arturio's pizza, Magnolia bakery, Washington Square area was OK.

London is just a million times better.

There are so many ignorant posts on this thread, but this one in particular struck me.

It's dirty, it's noisy and it smells. It's a huge city of 8.5 million people. What do you expect?

It all looks the same. That isn't remotely true. Even in Manhattan there are big differences between the different neighborhoods like midtown, Greenwich Village, Tribeca, Upper East Side, etc.

It was windy walking over the Brooklyn Bridge. No way? You walked over a bridge over a river and it was windy? Who would have thunk it?

Why bother going to Central Park when there are beautiful parks in London? News flash. Central Park wasn't created as a tourist attraction and it wasn't put there for your enjoyment. Those 8.5 million New Yorkers can't just pop over to London when they want to go to a park, can they?

Nothing as beautiful as Harrods. Who cares if the shops aren't as beautiful as Harrods? (Whether that's even true or not I don't know. Did anyone in New York claim there were shops more beautiful than Harrods?)

So horribly urban. Grin See my first point.