Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who are private

163 replies

HobgoblinGold · 09/01/2022 23:02

spurred on from another thread, could people who regard themselves as private or quiet offer me some insights?

I'm trying to understand my ILs better. They don't talk about anything deep and rarely ask questions about mine, DH, kids lives - conversation is always superficial. I really struggle with this as I don't understand how family can be so uninvolved in this way?

So AIBU - of course some people are like this! (I kinda know this) but would really appreciate some insight into what its like. How do you like to connect with people? Because I can't see how, if conversation is always so surface?

Sometimes I feel like I'm an alien learning how to be human.

OP posts:
Ruibies · 10/01/2022 10:10

Maybe they don't really like chatting? My PILs LOVE chatting and I find it exhausting, draining and unenjoyable after a few hours. I don't want to be talking all the time, I don't have anything to say, I'd much rather be on my own or reading a book. We could be talking about something I'm extremely enthusiastic about, and it's still just too much for me. Too much conversation, too much interaction. By the end of a weekend with them I am completely withdrawn and don't want to say a word for days. Maybe they feel similarly?

ElectraBlue · 10/01/2022 10:07

I think you have two different things here:

  • I am a very private individual, quiet and a bit of an introvert so it takes me time to trust people and to open up to them. I tend not to share too many personal details too quickly.
  • But there is a massive difference between the type of personality I described above and someone who never bothers to ask you about your life/how you are feeling/any issues you and yours might be going through or who is only able to ever have superficial conversations. This is the sign of someone who simply does not have much interest in getting to know you better and deep down does not care about you. Or they are someone who are simply so shallow and lacking in empathy that they will never be able to connect with you beyond the superficial.

I think a private person would eventually open up to you a bit as much as they are able to but they will still show you warmth and be interested in your life. I really think you are not dealing with people who are simply private here...They sound cold and disinterested for whatever reason.

I would stop trying to get any more reaction from them, and instead focus on those who can return your love and enjoy your company. Just be polite with them but don't waste more time trying to get them to engage. It is their loss.

Frenchfurze · 10/01/2022 09:50

My ILs are like this, and I think it’s just that their lives are so different to ours and always were, even at the age we are now — they live within half a mile of where they were born, left school at 13, had three children together by the time they were both 21, went in to have a huge family, always struggled financially, worked repetitive manual jobs so their main mental investment was in the wider family (MIL) one of 13, FIL one of 7). DH and I have lived abroad most of our adult lives, have one child by choice and have professional jobs were very involved in mentally and while we’re both fond of and close to our siblings, we’re not entangled in various cycles of gossip and bickering on a daily basis as PILs are.

They just don’t get our lives at all — neither do my own parents, but there’s slightly more grasp. (Pils, for instance, don’t know what do for a living, and I’ve been in their lives since the late 90s and have always been in the same field.) So they literally don’t know what questions to ask, and as they both worry so much about anything they interpret as ‘adverse’, DH doesn’t tell them a lot, as they just torment themselves with ‘What if’s.

user1471538283 · 10/01/2022 09:42

I'm private however, I engage with people and I'm interested in their lives.

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 09:40

@Ohyesiam

I think this too. And yet I find FIL has such a sure sense of himself that I find it mind boggling that her simply cannot relate to his own children. He was talking the other day about the science of where to sit in a crowded room to interact people. It was bizarre.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 10/01/2022 09:40

OP,

I would really work on not being so invested in people that give so little and actively minimise the time you spend with them.

There is nothing to be gained spending time with them and hoping for a different outcome.

Your FIL isn't nice?
Spend the minimum amount of time and stop listening to HIM talking about himself.

Invest in relationships that bring you joy.

Your husband is in therapy because of his father?
Stop spending time with them.
Absolutely minimise it.
Flowers

offtothebeach · 10/01/2022 09:40

In my experience people think their lives are far more interesting than they actually are. I give people my time and do listen but find it quite boring and repetitive so I tend not to ask questions. I do however still get to hear all about the house extensions, child's gymnastic medal, GP visit etc. What joy. Your in laws may be having a different sort of relationship with close friends they enjoy chatting with. I do appreciate this may hurt to acknowledge though because they are family.

Sheabutterisdelish · 10/01/2022 09:39

OP I would feel the same , so frustrating

Hottbutterscotch · 10/01/2022 09:39

@starray

I find people who don't ask questions - especially when you make an effort to ask about their lives, just rude. And small talk is just boring.
What do you consider small talk? I have a friend who prides herself on being interested in other people but actually she’s known for being nosey.
Sheabutterisdelish · 10/01/2022 09:38

I've got a friend like this, she's private to an absolutely ridiculous level, so much so you can't help her at all even when she's struggling massively. I've given up now, got fed up with the constant rebuffs and snubs

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 09:38

@HaveringWavering

I'm glad you've picked up on the complete outward neglect of important topics, like the fact there son had a heart attack and they simply don't ask how he's doing.

I just want to scream at them sometime - like why don't you ask? This is important right? Your son had an MI ad you just don't ask? I just don't get it.

OP posts:
HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 09:33

@Lotusmonster
🌺

OP posts:
Ohyesiam · 10/01/2022 09:23

It sounds like they don’t know how to relate rather than they are private.

thepeopleversuswork · 10/01/2022 09:09

I think people have different capacity for emotional investments. There's only so much to go around as it were.

This is a really important consideration, I think.

People have very different amounts of bandwidth to absorb other people's emotional stuff. Some have vast capacity for it -- often to the point of being a bit prurient and over-involved. Others just can't deal with it and have to limit it.

It sounds like you are quite an open person who wears their heart on their sleeve a lot and some people find this slightly tiring. I have to say I find this a bit of a struggle sometimes with people unless I know them really well.

I do think the lack of interest about their son's heart attack is very weird -- but it may be that they've talked about it with him offline.

But I can't help wondering if you make them feel slightly backed into a corner by prompting them to respond emotionally when they're not ready to do so?

picklemewalnuts · 10/01/2022 08:38

@HobgoblinGold your FiL doesn't sound very nice, and your MiL isn't kicking against the traces at all.

The lack of grandparents on your side is pushing you to accept/hope for too much from his side.

Far better to recognise they aren't great grandparent material and move on. There are better people to build relationships with. Family doesn't need to be blood.

DrManhattan · 10/01/2022 08:24

They are just not that into you

HaveringWavering · 10/01/2022 08:22

I’m really intrigued at all the posters who say you are similarly “private”, many for reasons related to your childhood. But this is a situation where people are not concerned enough to ask about the health of their own son, who had a heart attack very recently. Would you behave like this towards your own children when they are adults?

ittakes2 · 10/01/2022 08:11

You married their son not them. I think you may find it more useful to understand why you need something from them rather than trying to understand them. Your husband presumably grew up with them and is used to their ways unless you are trying to tell him something different. It would be helpful to you if you lower your expectations of them.

Diggersaursarethebest · 10/01/2022 08:09

Do you all like board games or cards? Or do the kids like that kind of game? Does everyone enjoy bbqs or playing cricket or skittles in the garden? They not going to happily start having the kind of conversations you think are a necessary part visiting family but that doesn’t mean you can’t improve the visits while respecting the fact they prefer to avoid ´deep’ topics.

ferneytorro · 10/01/2022 07:54

You are going to drive yourself mad trying to work out why they are like this. Much better (and not easy as it’s something I do) is to work on your reaction to it. Stop seeing them as much, spend time with people who are interested in you and your family. If you want a good role model / figure for your children, it doesn’t have to be grandparents. Stop trying to engage them. As others have said they just do not care, but that’s their loss not yours.

oopsyoudiditagain · 10/01/2022 07:33

What would be ”deep” talk?

Also why woudld you want anything from them?
Why ”should” they be giving you anything?
I don’t understand.

I would advice you to stop expecting anything from anyone.
It’s strange you go into someone’s or invite someon in your space and sit there thinking they own you something.
Just be.

LaChanticleer · 10/01/2022 06:54

I guess what I'm struggling with is what I need and what they can (and should) give.

What about what you can give?

Your language here suggests something quite demanding.

I tend to find that when I forget about me and what I need, and get interested in others and get into step with them, I have the most interesting and satisfying interactions with others.

And as I’ve become older, I’ve realised that I need to give myself what I need. That expecting from others just doesn’t work. I get more from giving to others.

FestiveFlavours · 10/01/2022 02:59

My in-laws, who are otherwise lovely, blab personal information about us - including private medical issues - around their social circle, even when we’ve specifically told them not to. So we really restrict what we tell them now.

OP - maybe they’ve over shared in the past and been criticised for it, or maybe someone has over shared their private information, so they are more cautious about asking anything.

Lotusmonster · 10/01/2022 02:34

I’m private. I have major stuff going on in my life that only a few can relate to and it evokes huge social stigma. So rather than face that backlash, I prefer to be private. It’s not of choice, more survival. 😞

chaosmaker · 10/01/2022 02:26

OP I understand you don't like the relationship you have with them but at the same time you can't force a relationship that isn't there. As other poster's have said it's probably less mentally taxing to go low contact and make a better family out of friends instead :)

Swipe left for the next trending thread