Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who are private

163 replies

HobgoblinGold · 09/01/2022 23:02

spurred on from another thread, could people who regard themselves as private or quiet offer me some insights?

I'm trying to understand my ILs better. They don't talk about anything deep and rarely ask questions about mine, DH, kids lives - conversation is always superficial. I really struggle with this as I don't understand how family can be so uninvolved in this way?

So AIBU - of course some people are like this! (I kinda know this) but would really appreciate some insight into what its like. How do you like to connect with people? Because I can't see how, if conversation is always so surface?

Sometimes I feel like I'm an alien learning how to be human.

OP posts:
saraclara · 10/01/2022 13:58

Privacy is important to everyone

Except it clearly isn't, because many many people have no respect at all for other people's privacy. Not to mention all the people who announce happily that they're 'an open book' and resent it when others don't tell them everything.

Again, the OP asked specifically if people who consider themselves to be private, would help with this. So those of us who are, are letting her know where our posts are coming from.

BoredZelda · 10/01/2022 13:54

I'd love a private MIL. She wants to know everything and most of it is none of her business.

She asked me if my daughter had started her periods.

You don't need to know every detail of someone's life to make a connection.

I think both parents are on the autism spectrum which impacts the way they see the world, people and the way they interact with people.

Yeah, this is pretty offensive. Have they been diagnosed?

5128gap · 10/01/2022 13:46

Theres a difference between being private about one's own life and disinterested in other people's. For many years I was 'private' in as much as no one who knew me really knew a lot beyond the superficial. Certainly they wouldn't have known of any problems in my life. This didn't mean they didn't confide in me though. My reasons for it were partly because I was stuck in a 'helper' role that started in childhood, and saw confidences as something I received, and support as something I gave, never the other way round. I was also a people pleaser, and very keen to present myself in the way I thought was most positive to others. This naturally involves keeping what you see as the less palatable aspects of yourself private, and not wanting to 'impose' on others with your personal stuff, as well as a fear of being judged. Thankfully over the last decade, this has changed. I no longer need to be the outwardly 'perfect' go to person, and have found the value in opening to people. I'm not suggesting all private people are like this, or should change. Just my experience.

PhilCornwall1 · 10/01/2022 13:35

I'm a private person and will only talk about superficial things about me/my life. Anything else is nobody's business and I want it to remain that way.

I'm the same with anyone apart from my OH.

My parents know about my medical condition, but they don't know the full story and have no need to.

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 13:21

@limitedperiodonly

I was talking to MIL over the Christmas period and she was talking about how private her son is (DH brother). I find mum and dad will say things like this to avoid talking about the real issues. Such as the fact that DH brother is inconsiderate. I find their complete lack of insight and ability to look through rose tinted glasses annoying and frustrating.

OP posts:
limitedperiodonly · 10/01/2022 13:06

Privacy is important to everyone including exhibitionists who only expose bits of their private life they want to.

It's precisely because I don't think the minutiae of my life (apart from information like bank details) would be interesting to anyone that I don't share them.

Announcing that you are a private person without realising that all of us value privacy and you are not special is a particular kind of attention-seeking.

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 13:06

@CheltenhamLady

‘However, with regard to the medical issues, I absolutely would ask, inquire and offer any help or support needed. I find that cold and unfathomable.’

Thank you for your insight. I do question my interpretation on how they are. But I do find it sad that they simply do not ask and seem uninterested on this ad so much more.

OP posts:
HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 13:03

@HikingforScenery

They do not call him. My husband jokes that the only reason we do have contact with them is because of my efforts.

OP posts:
PrivatePrivatePrivate · 10/01/2022 12:31

People who announce: "I'm a private person" are attention-seekers.

What bollocks! Maybe they are not interested in the tedious munutae of your life and wish you would keep your neb to yourself regarding their life!

PrivatePrivatePrivate · 10/01/2022 12:29

I am exceptionally private, I have never discussed any problems I might have with anyone, parents, OH, children, maybe with a professional if necessary. It's just how I am, my children, 40s, sometimes find out odd things and are quite shocked and I am interested in them and their lives and those of their children. Reading this site I get amazed at how intermingled people's lives are with others' lives aqnd how much they seem to know about the lives of others.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/01/2022 12:26

@limitedperiodonly

Spies are private. People who announce: "I'm a private person" are attention-seekers. How fascinating do they imagine their lives to be?

The rest of us manage to maintain normal social contact while avoiding divulging every cough and spit and banking details.

Mmmm! And if a private person chooses to 'announce' themselves in order respond to a question on an anonymous forum because they think it might help the OP? That being what said forum is for?
saraclara · 10/01/2022 12:24

@limitedperiodonly

Spies are private. People who announce: "I'm a private person" are attention-seekers. How fascinating do they imagine their lives to be?

The rest of us manage to maintain normal social contact while avoiding divulging every cough and spit and banking details.

I don't announce "I'm a private person" in real life. I've mentioned it here because OP specifically asked private people to comment on her OP.

I have said in the past that privacy is important to me. But I think that's perfectly reasonable when you are sharing something you wish to be confidential. After my experience of totally unfounded and untrue gossip about me being passed around my workplace, I think I have reason to feel that way.

limitedperiodonly · 10/01/2022 12:16

Spies are private. People who announce: "I'm a private person" are attention-seekers. How fascinating do they imagine their lives to be?

The rest of us manage to maintain normal social contact while avoiding divulging every cough and spit and banking details.

CheltenhamLady · 10/01/2022 12:02

As a new MIL, it is difficult to find the right level of involvement with a DIL. I adore mine, but I know she has issues with her mother being over-involved and demanding. I have seen this first-hand and it is hard to deal with. I strive to avoid that at all costs.

I hope I don't err too much on the other side and seem disinterested or uninvolved, but I am aware it is a fine line.

However, with regard to the medical issues, I absolutely would ask, inquire and offer any help or support needed. I find that cold and unfathomable.

I think (hope) that I have a good relationship with all my adult children, but it can be hard to get the balance right especially with their adult partners who come into the family as unknown quantities with their own views on how family life should be.

HikingforScenery · 10/01/2022 11:31

Do they not talk with their son without you? Are you absolutely sure they’ve not asked about his well-being without you being there?
Maybe they’re not comfortable having deeper conversations with you around and have them with him in private? Do they ever ring him, etc?

You say your husband accepts them for who they are. Maybe you should too? You can still have a nice time together without deep conversations. There’s a lot to be said for unspoken communication.

C152 · 10/01/2022 11:19

I think you need to accept them as they are - if this is how they've always been, they're unlikely to change. You've said you don't understand them, and that really comes across in your comments. Knowing something and understanding / accepting it are different things. To me it seems, you know, logically, they are different from you, but feel affronted by that. I'm more like your DH's parents than you - their approach is normal where I come from - but, living in the UK for some time, I have sometimes felt the need to say to close friends that I am happy for them to speak to me about whatever their problem is, but I won't ask them about it again. I feel that if someone wanted to talk about something personal / do something, they would. It feels nosy to go poking about it in their personal business if they haven't raised the issue themselves.

saraclara · 10/01/2022 11:17

I share very little. Mostly because I was once the subject of entirely false gossip, and also because sometimes what is weighing on my mind reflects on others and I don't think they deserve to have their own privacy invaded by my talking about them to my friends.

Also problems often resolve themselves. I want to forget about them, but the friend or acquaintance still remembers them and might continue to judge me or someone else involved, long after it's all been sorted. I've found it really disconcerting to have a friend bring something up like that, years after what I thought was a fairly casual conversation about an issue that turned out to be something and nothing.

Sorry - drifted a bit from the subject. But on several occasions a close friend has found out about a worry I've had (after the fact) and been FURIOUS with me for not sharing it at the time. Not for my sake, but because they've felt that it reflects on them as a friend. Which to me demonstrates that I was right not to do so, because they clearly wanted to centre themselves.

Boood · 10/01/2022 11:00

To offer you a different perspective: my mother would make the same complaint about me, in fact I know she does to other relatives. She finds me cold, distant and uninterested, I don’t share anything with her, and conversations are hard work. From my perspective I am like this with her because she’s utterly toxic. Anything I tell her will be shared as widely as possible, even if I ask her not to she will pass it on and dissect it with others. Any problem I have will be instantly topped by one of hers that it similar but worse, and she will then return to my issue endlessly and use it as evidence of how hopelessly inadequate I am. Basic information- plans, things I’ve done, things I like or don’t like- goes in one ear and out the other because she’s not listening, she’s just waiting for her next opportunity to speak. And then because she hasn’t listened I end up answering the same question on the next three times I speak to her, so it starts to feel like a lot of effort for nothing. I don’t want to cut her off altogether, but I have to be extremely guarded with her because otherwise she’s quite capable of driving me absolutely to the brink. It’s self-preservation.

I’m obviously not accusing you of being as difficult as my mother, I’m sure you aren’t, but you did ask!

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 10:55

@JugglingJanuary

Do you organise meeting up with them? Or DH?

I used to Alot more - but have started to reduce this. Mum invites us round for Sunday tea most Sundays - I have thought about just sending DH and the kids then I can get on with work as deep down I don't like there co any buy on the same level yearn for a parental figure.

ow does DH feel about their interaction with him/you/DC?

DH has long resigned to who they are and is definitely more accepting of them, whereas I keep stupidly thinking theyll be different

OP posts:
HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/01/2022 10:54

That would be me. I don't share much at all, because it is my private business and H and I deal with it.

I won't ask you questions about your private life because I know that if you want me to know you will tell me. I won't pry it out of you. I will ask a simple, polite question "How are you doing now?" and leave the depth and breadth of your answer down to you.

If you aslk me the same question you will probably get a 'surface answer' unless you have been involved in something previously. I wouldn't want to bore you with anything nor would I want to over share anything.

But if something big comes up then I will talk to you, support you, help you find information, formal support. And I will never speak about it to anyone else, ever.

If I trust you to do the same then I would trust you if anything ever hapened in my life that meant I needed support.

I have had many poeple assume I am ytuck up, anti social, unfreindly etc. But I don't care as they probably would be the very same people that would think nothing of gossiping about 'friends'

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 10:51

@JugglingJanuary

Autism, not adhd

OP posts:
Cuck00soup · 10/01/2022 10:51

I'm fairly quiet & private. Partly I think because it is my natural inclination and partly because I had a complicated childhood meaning I'm cautious about too many questions.

I can't really imagine being like this with my DC though.

thereisonlyoneofme · 10/01/2022 10:38

Im a private person. Another person has fallen out with me big time because "I dont talk to her" . This is someone who always has to have the last word, asks quite personal questions about people who are acquaintances as best, and can top you in everything you say or do ! I just keep mum, and because she doesnt know anything about me, she hates it I was always taught by my parents not to ask personal question s and stick to it.

Ozanj · 10/01/2022 10:38

My mum is like this. Incredibly narcissistic and is only interested in the minor things and never interested in the big things unless they involve her favourite golden kids.

JugglingJanuary · 10/01/2022 10:31

@HobgoblinGold

What makes you think they have ADHD?

I don't think anything good will come of asking why they don't ask questions/show more interest etc I really don't.

Do you organise meeting up with them? Or DH?

How does DH feel about their interaction with him/you/DC?

I think the best thing to do, would be to accept they're never going to be the parents/in-laws/grandparents you want them to, for whatever reason. It's sad, but it's what you've been dealt.

Are there any other family members (DH Aunts/Uncles) who you could develop more if a relationship with? If not, look outside of the family.

You can't make people be who you want them to be & it's sad when they're not, but all you can do is accept that's who they are and develop other relationships!

Hope you DH makes a good recovery & they can find the cause & they can help him minimise the risk of future events!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread