Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who are private

163 replies

HobgoblinGold · 09/01/2022 23:02

spurred on from another thread, could people who regard themselves as private or quiet offer me some insights?

I'm trying to understand my ILs better. They don't talk about anything deep and rarely ask questions about mine, DH, kids lives - conversation is always superficial. I really struggle with this as I don't understand how family can be so uninvolved in this way?

So AIBU - of course some people are like this! (I kinda know this) but would really appreciate some insight into what its like. How do you like to connect with people? Because I can't see how, if conversation is always so surface?

Sometimes I feel like I'm an alien learning how to be human.

OP posts:
boringcreation · 10/01/2022 15:02

@saraclara

Those of us who are private or quiet can't help you. Because that's our natural state. How do you expect us to explain it, or why we are how we are? We just are.

I do talk to people, but I'm but sure what you want from someone like me? I didn't use to ask people questions either. I thought of it as intrusive. I didn't want people prying into my private life, so why would I do the same to them?

Having children changed that for me a lot. People showed interest in my babies, and I wad touched by that. So it occurred to me that if I liked people asking after my children, then they'd probably like it if I did too. So my social skills grew from there, basically.

Most people would now think I'm friendly, but mostly it's still fairly superficial chat. I still don't ask what I consider to be nosy questions, so if you know me and you want to share, you're going to need to be the one that starts those kinds of 'personal life' conversations.

Jesus Christ, I've never seen how I felt written out so well
CheltenhamLady · 10/01/2022 15:01

[quote HobgoblinGold]@limitedperiodonly

I was talking to MIL over the Christmas period and she was talking about how private her son is (DH brother). I find mum and dad will say things like this to avoid talking about the real issues. Such as the fact that DH brother is inconsiderate. I find their complete lack of insight and ability to look through rose tinted glasses annoying and frustrating.[/quote]
To be fair, as a MIL I wouldn't be comfortable discussing our other children's faults with my DIL. How she views/deals with other siblings is not your business.

Lostinafield · 10/01/2022 15:00

I'm sorry it makes you sad though.
Re your husband, they may well care but can see he's okay so don't feel the need to ask.

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 14:57

@Lostinafield

Cross posted. I agree.

OP posts:
HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 14:56

@Lostinafield

I think they maybe prefer there solitide, so I should respect this and learn not to expect something from them they cannot give.

OP posts:
Lostinafield · 10/01/2022 14:56

What I meant by accommodating them was accept that they don't ask the questions or do socialising in the way you would like them to.
If that's too much for you, then of course you are free not to see them.

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 14:53

@Lostinafield

I have tried many many things. But ultimately there comes a point, when whether they have autism or not, there comes a point when there nothing more I can or should do.

OP posts:
fdgdfgdfgdfg · 10/01/2022 14:52

You'd probably find me to be quite like your parents. I'm not private particularly but I am introverted.

The things that you mention, asking about your life, your kids life, thats not something I'm very good at asking about. I conciously make the effort to now, but it's not something I do naturally. I'm also not particularly comfortable talking about myself, work etc. I don't really understand why that would be interesting to anyone else.

I'm much happier talking about stuff. Politics, Marvel movies, sports, something you can get into a bit of a debate about.

I am better at talking about the stuff you feel is important if I'm 1 on 1 with someone, I don't know why, it just feels easier then

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 14:51

@Lo

OP posts:
Lostinafield · 10/01/2022 14:50

The ableism is because, if you believe they are autistic, why are you not trying to work out how you can accommodate their differences rather than criticising them for it on social media?

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 14:44

@Lostinafield

Not austistic people as in ALL autistic people. I (alongside my husband) have long since suspected that both parents potentially have autism - there is absolutely nothing wrong with thinking this. DH has been diagnosed with autism.

OP posts:
iwanttobeonleave · 10/01/2022 14:43

@Cleopatra2022

My own mother is like this. She’s not being private she just isn’t interested.
I was going to say, they don't sound interested to me. Perhaps they don't really care (which is awful and sad of course). Thanks
HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 14:41

@TulipsTwoLips
I am definateky guilty of expecting something that they for whatever reason cannot give.

OP posts:
Cuck00soup · 10/01/2022 14:38

What is perhaps worse is people who potentially have autism but have no insight into how there behaviours impact those around them.

Seriously?

TulipsTwoLips · 10/01/2022 14:36

You seem to need to find a label for people who aren’t giving you what you need from communication!

BooksAndGin · 10/01/2022 14:35

Me and DH are private people, I find it exhausting when people moan about every single detail and demand validation 24/7.
I'd rather keep to light subjects or subjects that are interesting About history, science exploration, etc.
It is draining listening to someone's medical problems, or failed marriage or parenting woes all the time. I cut someone out for that reason.

Lostinafield · 10/01/2022 14:35

[quote HobgoblinGold]@BoredZelda

Neither have been formally diagnosed. But all the clues are there. Mum did take a test online which did suggest she made autism.

Why is it offensive to suggest someone may have autism? It is a know disorder which impacts how people interact with others and can be hugely distressing to those who have parents who are autistic. What is perhaps worse is people who potentially have autism but have no insight into how there behaviours impact those around them.[/quote]
I am autistic. I find it offensive that your focus is on how autistic people affect others around them, in your eyes negatively.
How ablist can you be?
Your poor parents-in-law. If you think they are autistic, maybe consider how difficult it must be for them to fit in with a world which Oscar majority neurological, rather than focusing on your "needs".

limitedperiodonly · 10/01/2022 14:34

[quote HobgoblinGold]@limitedperiodonly

I was talking to MIL over the Christmas period and she was talking about how private her son is (DH brother). I find mum and dad will say things like this to avoid talking about the real issues. Such as the fact that DH brother is inconsiderate. I find their complete lack of insight and ability to look through rose tinted glasses annoying and frustrating.[/quote]
Hi Hobgoblin. My parents grew up in a time and place where to be poor or of dubious moral character was enough reason for authorities, usually church-based, to step in and forcibly take children away from families for what was considered to be for their own good and put them in orphanages or with right-minded members of society sometimes on the other side of the world. Shocking, isn't it?

As you can imagine this created a deal of misery not to say abuse. It persisted in some parts of Britain and Ireland until the 1970s. Therefore my parents were wary about revealing family details to authority figures from Church, schools, health, local authority etc. That extended to us even though that was unlikely to happen. I still remember my mother saying to me every day before I went to school "None of my business." This was in the 1970s.

If you are interested there have been plenty of books and documentaries started by a wonderful woman called Margaret Humphries who I met after she founded The Child Migrants' Trust It wasn't the only example of state-sponsored child snatching here but the most organised and highly respected. It makes people taking photos of random children in the park pale into insignificance.

Those were special circumstances like coming from a country with State sponsored surveillance. Happily most of us do not have a background like that. I don't mind that people such as @PrivatePrivatePrivate sneer that my life is boring and of no interest. It's nice - not the fact that my life is boring but that the authorities are not interested in it.

I doubt your in-laws have the same motivation for secrecy as my parents. I think you are right in guessing that they don't want to talk about inconvenient things like the fact that your BIL is inconsiderate.

It's annoying. I find people who talk about their privacy to be irritating in the same way as people who say they don't like confrontation. Hardly anyone enjoys confrontation but sometimes it has to endured otherwise situations fester and everyone suffers.

It's normal to have things we'd prefer to keep to ourselves. That's not the same as dodging the issue which appears to be happening here.

I can't offer any answer. They can't be forced to confront things. But please don't go along with people who insist that they are "private" people as if they are somehow more special than you. My life is an open book until I decide to close it. That is how it should be with everyone.

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 14:34

@Dottybackorcid

I think what ive learnt from this thread is that I have never expected them to become involved in a ‘me-me-me culture’. I am just saddened they don't even ask after the health of there own son. This is an example of how they are so emotionally distant.

@Dottybackorcid do you know who I am btw?

OP posts:
HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 14:27

@Dottybackorcid

I have tried this approach many times. Dad will end up dominating the conversation and mum is usually quiet.

OP posts:
HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 14:25

@BoredZelda

You are absolutely right - autism is on the spectrum with various presentations. Of course I can't diagnose but I can have an educated guess. This and lots of other factors help me to understand why they are the way they are.

OP posts:
Dottybackorcid · 10/01/2022 14:14

Both myself and my DP are private people, to be honest it's draining around family members who insist every one should be interested in them constantly. The never ending Facebook posts of there kids every single day, the god awful memes about how good parents they are and how love is all you need, It never stops. When you meet them all they want to talk about is family gossip and moan how people are not interested in them or their kids.

We have a perfectly happy life and work toward our own goals,but we don't feel the need to seek approval for every little thing, or post none stop on social media just so we can validate our life's.

Private people often enjoy more discussions about things you have learned or new topics shared not for validation of your feelings but for interesting conversation. When you speak to someone and all they can discuss is them self's or their children or constantly seeking validation for your feelings is draining. Try discussing some thing special intresting you have read or seen or done out side seeking validation and I suggest they may open up more.

It's not up to there's to make you feel good, and if you want to label them boring because they do not subscribed to the me me culture look closer to home it's very draining to private people. Wink

BoredZelda · 10/01/2022 14:11

Why is it offensive to suggest someone may have autism? It is a know disorder which impacts how people interact with others and can be hugely distressing to those who have parents who are autistic.

Because not everyone with autism is like that, and not everyone who acts like that has autism. You don't get to diagnose people.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 10/01/2022 14:10

I'm not sure they are private. I think it sounds like they dont care very much or dont have social skills. Sorry to be blunt. I answered your other thread but now I've seen your examples I think it's that rather than them wanting privacy.

So I'm private. I dont tell people what's troubling me, I dont really tell many people my views about a lot of things, I probably don't share how I really feel. It makes me uncomfortable.

However if someone was ill or there was something going on with their kids that was big, I'd always try and remember to ask about it (eg how is your child settling into reception, how is your dad after his recent op, how is your sister after she got made redundant, how is work as you said you were busy last time etc etc).

To me, if someone has told me something, it's ok to follow up on it (unless its private and you're following up on it in front of others) and if it's a significant event in their lives it would be rude not to. That's nothing to do with me wanting privacy, as me asking any of those questions does not threaten my privacy in any way.

It sounds like they just don't care enough to ask, I don't mean that in a horrible way just that some people are so self involved it's just that other peoples lives dont register with them. Or they massively lack social skills and just talk about what they want and assume you will talk about what you want rather than needing asked. I'd guess they relate to people by choosing to socialise with people who are happy to listen or put up with it, or on a very superficial level eg hobbies where it's fine just to talk about the weather, or people who are similar and all just talk at each other rather than listen and question.

Ultimately I'm not sure that understanding them is going to help you. What you seem to really want is for them to take an interest in you and your family, and there is nothing that you can do to make this happen.

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 14:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread