Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who are private

163 replies

HobgoblinGold · 09/01/2022 23:02

spurred on from another thread, could people who regard themselves as private or quiet offer me some insights?

I'm trying to understand my ILs better. They don't talk about anything deep and rarely ask questions about mine, DH, kids lives - conversation is always superficial. I really struggle with this as I don't understand how family can be so uninvolved in this way?

So AIBU - of course some people are like this! (I kinda know this) but would really appreciate some insight into what its like. How do you like to connect with people? Because I can't see how, if conversation is always so surface?

Sometimes I feel like I'm an alien learning how to be human.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
youdialwetile · 12/01/2022 03:43

My DHs family are like this. Some of them drone on about stuff that no one else is interested in (fishing, golf) holding court and not an actual conversation.

Anything else is superficial. BIL was carted off to hospital one Christmas Day a couple of years ago but no one talked about it. When I asked SIL about it, she just pulled a face.

Some people are just distant. DH had little warmth with his mum and dad when they were alive. I think it's sad but for him it's normal and my family is the odd one because we laugh, cry, scream...

LookslovelyinSpringtime · 11/01/2022 23:54

My in laws were like this. They weren’t private at all themselves but they never asked questions. They really knew nothing about me and never asked about the children. Everything was jokes and ‘telling stories’ (about themselves or at someone else’s expense). They didn’t understand their children and pitted them against each other in competition. Achievement and being entertaining was all they cared about.

GrannytoaUnicorn · 11/01/2022 23:49

Are you sure they know what an MI is???

Anyway, why not confront them??? Can't possibly make the atmosphere any worse, can it?!?!

GrannytoaUnicorn · 11/01/2022 23:40

Some people are just a bit.....simple OP. For want of a more PC term

notanothertakeaway · 11/01/2022 15:36

@HaveringWavering

Fortunately, I've always kept good health, so it's never really been tested, but No, they don't ask about health. Content to listen, but don't ask

HaveringWavering · 11/01/2022 15:19

[quote notanothertakeaway]**@HaveringWavering* @limitedperiodonly*

It's just how they are. Extremely private about anything health related

Another example, my DF was in hospital himself and we only found out weeks later. He told me he'd had treatment for X condition, and wouldn't be discussing it again. And never mentioned it again[/quote]
But, again, very different choosing not to voluntarily share their own health problems. To be clear, you’re saying your own mother would not ask after your health if she was told you had had a heart attack? How does that work, did they just stop talking to you about your health as soon as you were old enough to consent to your own medical procedures?

notanothertakeaway · 11/01/2022 14:30

@HaveringWavering @limitedperiodonly

It's just how they are. Extremely private about anything health related

Another example, my DF was in hospital himself and we only found out weeks later. He told me he'd had treatment for X condition, and wouldn't be discussing it again. And never mentioned it again

limitedperiodonly · 11/01/2022 14:04

@notanothertakeaway

My parents wouldn't dream of asking any questions about health, to respect privacy eg my DH was in hospital overnight, my parents gladly babysat for the children, but they didnt ask why DH was in hospital. Probably an unusual approach, but that's just how they are

OTOH, my FIL will happily tell all and sundry about his digestive conditions. I think that's a bit odd, but we're all different

That is indeed somewhat unusual. I'm not talking about your FIL's indigestion but about your parents not asking even the most cursory questions about your husband's hospital stay like when were visiting hours and whether you expected him to survive.
WhatToDo1988 · 11/01/2022 14:02

Why are you forcing or, as you put it, "cultivating" a relationship between your DH and someone who was abusive to him? That might actually be quite damaging to him. He naturally already feels an obligation to have a relationship with these awful people and you're just reinforcing that. Leave it be. They sound awful and you are doing no good to anyone.

WhatToDo1988 · 11/01/2022 13:59

They sound cold and uninterested. It has nothing to do with being private. Private people still manage to be polite. In fact, my DP is very private and when he feels uncomfortable, he starts asking more questions so people start talking about themselves instead! It works every time!

HaveringWavering · 11/01/2022 12:06

@notanothertakeaway

My parents wouldn't dream of asking any questions about health, to respect privacy eg my DH was in hospital overnight, my parents gladly babysat for the children, but they didnt ask why DH was in hospital. Probably an unusual approach, but that's just how they are

OTOH, my FIL will happily tell all and sundry about his digestive conditions. I think that's a bit odd, but we're all different

But your DH is not their son. Do you think they would not have asked either if it had been you in hospital?
notanothertakeaway · 10/01/2022 18:30

My parents wouldn't dream of asking any questions about health, to respect privacy eg my DH was in hospital overnight, my parents gladly babysat for the children, but they didnt ask why DH was in hospital. Probably an unusual approach, but that's just how they are

OTOH, my FIL will happily tell all and sundry about his digestive conditions. I think that's a bit odd, but we're all different

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 17:45

@Twattergy

If we talk about deeper issues dad will dominate the discussion. Ge doesn't take on other peoples opinions very well and the discussion just turns unpleasant. Mum will be quite in his presence as he is emotional abusive with her. Dad does not tolerate error very well - this was one of the major difficulties for my DH when he was growing up as there was little scope for error. One if my husbands memories is his dad taking him to the park when he was about 5 but getting angry with him because he wasnt ‘walking correctly. His dad is controlling and mum has learnt to keep in her lane with this.

OP posts:
Twattergy · 10/01/2022 17:26

Some good suggestions here. If they are introverts (like me) then they won't like surface chit chat and actually prefer deep and meaningfuls, or talking about things of deeper interest (politics, travel, life experiences). Have you tried heading in that direction?
That being said it only takes a modicum of social skill and manner to ask basic questions after peoples health etc. If they don't do that then they are pretty rude IMHO.

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 16:48

@Rrrob

Although my husband and I haven't experienced a loss like this, there have been other instances of lives up and downs and they simply don't talk about it. But then I know that they never have. Neither are close to their sons and my DH feels they are only closer to us because of the years of cultivating what I could with them. They both lack insight, especially dad, how damaging they have been to my DH, and I think to his brother too. I know I have discussed it with his brother before and he got very upset about it. Writing this all down and I have no idea why I'm even trying to force anything other than polite with them.

OP posts:
Getyourjinglebellsinarow · 10/01/2022 16:47

I don't like people knowing or being involved in my life. The few times I've asked my relatives for help I've always regretted giving them any information, which inevitably gets passed around to everyone. I just feel like it's invasive and I respect other people's privacy, if you want me to know something then you'll tell me. I won't ask.

Rrrob · 10/01/2022 16:28

@HobgoblinGold thank you, but honestly wasn’t trying to derail the thread! Just highlighting how you are not alone….there are many of these ILs around!

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 16:26

@Rrrob

I am so sorry about your loss 🌺

OP posts:
limitedperiodonly · 10/01/2022 16:19

@Rrrob

My MIL is like this. All superficial conversation. Never asks how we are, how DC are, how work is going. Even after dd1 died and we were both off work she didn’t ask any of these things. As a result we have a couple of painful interactions a year. DH hates it and finds it frustrating. I am fine with the conversation about her/ her friends we don’t know blah blah because I’ve accepted she’s not interested in our lives.
I'm sorry. It may be that she's not interested in your lives - you know her best. But some people think such questions are prying and avoid the subject.
Rrrob · 10/01/2022 15:42

My MIL is like this. All superficial conversation. Never asks how we are, how DC are, how work is going. Even after dd1 died and we were both off work she didn’t ask any of these things. As a result we have a couple of painful interactions a year. DH hates it and finds it frustrating. I am fine with the conversation about her/ her friends we don’t know blah blah because I’ve accepted she’s not interested in our lives.

HobgoblinGold · 10/01/2022 15:22

@boringcreation

All from and live in the UK

OP posts:
SisterConcepta · 10/01/2022 15:18

I think that there are people who are just not interested in people.. any people even if they are family. There are those who can prattle on for hours about something trivial in their lives and it never occurs to them to ask about another person how things are. At the end of the day, it is completely up to us how much time we spend with such people. If someone is really unpleasant that would be a 0 from me regardless of who they are...
If you feel you 'have to' spend time with such people because they are related, then I find the best solution is to just accept how they are, look for the positives and don't give it too much brain space.

boringcreation · 10/01/2022 15:17

[quote HobgoblinGold]@Dottybackorcid

I have tried this approach many times. Dad will end up dominating the conversation and mum is usually quiet.[/quote]
So they do talk to you? I don't understand what you want from them? Are you a different nationality or from a different culture to them?

saraclara · 10/01/2022 15:15

I would definitely ask about the MI and the vomiting but I would never even think to ask how someone's job was going. Like I don't know how I would answer that if I was asked other than saying 'good thanks'. What would you say to that? I think, I just presume people wouldn't be interested in the specifics of my job or the minute details of my day to day life so I don't ask others about theirs? Is that mad?

It's like we're twins @boringcreation!

One of my family members always asks another one how work's going, whenever they meet. I see him wince every time, and he answers her with about four words. Because he's really unhappy in his job (which she knows). Yet next time she sees him she'll ask him again.

She's generally so much more able than me, socially, but it's like she's so busy asking things that she doesn't actually notice the response. Whereas I'm quiet so I have space to pick up the vibes.

boringcreation · 10/01/2022 15:05

[quote HobgoblinGold]@Sinnerman

My husband (their son) had an MI just before Christmas. No questions about this. Daughter projectile vomiting all over Christmas - nothing. Never anything about mine or my husbands job/training. Nothing about sons schooling. I find it really sad, disheartening and cannot fathom how they can love there son, me? There grandkids without asking about this type of stuff.[/quote]
I would definitely ask about the MI and the vomiting but I would never even think to ask how someone's job was going. Like I don't know how I would answer that if I was asked other than saying 'good thanks'. What would you say to that? I think, I just presume people wouldn't be interested in the specifics of my job or the minute details of my day to day life so I don't ask others about theirs? Is that mad?