Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are kids really different when they're your own?

83 replies

youtown · 09/01/2022 21:19

Just that really.

I'd like to hear from people who don't enjoy kids except their own.

I have decided to have kids but really generally don't find them interesting at all and quite like to escape from others to be honest unless they're quiet and well behaved.

So I'm wandering if others have felt like this had their own and been fine with them because they're 'your own'?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EishetChayil · 10/01/2022 11:49

I am not a kiddie sort of person. Friends' children grate on my nerves and I have a visceral reaction to some of them.

My DD? Why, she's an utter fragrant angel.

Porridgeislife · 10/01/2022 11:36

I don’t enjoy other people’s small children at all. So much so that I’m pregnant currently and will still engineer moving tables restaurants/cafes to avoid being near one.

However I’m really looking forward to having my own, so much so that we spent a house deposit size figure on IVF. I really can’t wait to meet him/her and feel very maternal towards them.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 10/01/2022 11:32

Yes it's different.

When someone elses kid rolls over, its like well of course they've learned to roll over, they're a baby, that's what they do.

When your own kid has rolled over it's absolutely amazing that this little tiny creature who couldn't lift their head a few months ago has spent every day trying and trying and learning and getting stronger and finally managed to completely surprise themselves and do it. It's just fascinating seeing the process of them learning how to do it.

And that's just one tiny element, everything else is much the same

JustAnotherUserinParadise · 10/01/2022 11:13

yes it really is different
I'd only held a couple of babies briefly before having my own. Other babies are kind of gross and wierdly squishy and have a funny smell to them... mine however is lovely and snuggly and smells like milk and love!
Now she's nearly toddling and other babies/toddlers the same age are just simply not as good haha (not that I'd tell them that)! Somehow your own is beautiful and clever and the gross stuff like wiping mixed porridge/snot out of their eyes because they rubbed it in there is only a bit icky, not fully disgusting!

LadyCleathStuart · 10/01/2022 11:07

I wasn't very keen to have children as I found them a bit boring, especially babies, I remember being so not interested in my brothers kids when they were babies, would avoid them actually, although I did enjoy the odd game with them as toddlers but for as short a time as possible.

I now have two DC and while they can be a bit boring at times in all honesty (I mean do I enjoy playing Minecraft or Barbies ?- no I don't at all) I do find watching them grow and experience new things fascinating. Especially now both are in school - how quickly they learn and the amazing discussions you can have with them.

Also I love them, the bond between a parent and child is (for most parents anyway) something that cannot be put into words. I would kill for them, I would die for them. I would suffer pain a million times over to stop them feeling it once. This is something that you cannot understand until you have your own.

Luckystar1 · 10/01/2022 11:03

Weirdly, I’m the other way. I never minded other people’s children before I had them. I’d always cuddle the babies, rush to see them, play with other children etc.

Now I have my own, I can’t stand other people’s children. I feel like I have enough to do minding my own, I have no heed in doing it or anything even vaguely like it, now!

SarahAndQuack · 10/01/2022 10:59

[quote youtown]@SarahAndQuack you've summed up exactly my thoughts!!

To be honest though as I mature I am getting much kore comfortable I'm not faking that I want to play with the kids etc and just say no!! I didn't have the confidence to do that when I was younger. [/quote]
Grin Glad to be of use!

It's funny, isn't it - people do tend to assume all young women love babies and it'll be such a treat for you to get to cuddle theirs/play with their toddlers. I remember secretly wondering if I was weird. Now, of course, because I have my own I am perfectly well aware any meeting of parents of babies/toddlers is full of women saying how bloody boring it is playing with them, and I realise it's entirely normal.

(They are lovely, btw, and I'm not judging anyone who genuinely enjoys endless games of pretend, it's just I'd rather pull my own hair out, personally.)

youtown · 10/01/2022 10:56

@SarahAndQuack you've summed up exactly my thoughts!!

To be honest though as I mature I am getting much kore comfortable I'm not faking that I want to play with the kids etc and just say no!! I didn't have the confidence to do that when I was younger.

OP posts:
SarahAndQuack · 10/01/2022 10:52

I wouldn't say I didn't like children before I had my own - I was delighted when my brother and his wife had the first baby in that generation. But I didn't feel like I knew how to talk to children or play with them, so I wouldn't say I enjoyed being with other people's kids especially. It's normal. Unless you've grown up with younger cousins or something like that, these days lots of people's only experience of children before they have kids is feeling a bit awkward when someone expects you to admire theirs.

It's much easier to like children after you have your own because instead of thinking 'WTF, this four year old is trying to make me pretend to be a plane and its fool parents seem to think I love it' you just say 'No, Milly, Auntie Sarah doesn't want to play planes. I'm getting a coffee with mummy now'. Grin

XmasElf10 · 10/01/2022 10:51

Totally!! I like other peoples kids more now than I did before having my own. However I still have very little time for other people kids. Mine is great though, funny, interesting, well behaved (definitely rose tinted specs!)

Nowayoutonlydown · 10/01/2022 10:49

Used to love babies- maybe I still do!
Love the bones of my kid, but dear lord everyone else's I find to be incredibly annoying.

youtown · 10/01/2022 10:45

Lol this thread is helpful. I honestly feel that society puts extra pressure on parenting by making you feel that unless you already love kids it'll be a bad move.

Judging by the thread that's clearly not the case.

OP posts:
Poppins2016 · 10/01/2022 02:09

My own kid, however, is my favourite person in the whole world.

That's exactly how I feel. It's a very pure, innate, truly unconditional kind of love. I was surprised by how much my love for my children would grow as they grow... I seem to feel more love as their personalities develop. It's a beautiful thing.

Amusingly (and surprisingly), I find I dislike other people's children more now that I have my own... I'm not quite sure why that is!

immersivereader · 10/01/2022 01:43

I've never met any kids as fascinating as my own

RoyKentsChestHair · 10/01/2022 01:31

Yup! I have 3 and they’re brilliant, I love the bones of them but I was never one of those gushy mums.

I have literally zero interest in most other kids.

Very occasionally I’ll meet one who is exceptionally cute but it’s often not the ones everyone else seems to love Grin

I was never particularly close to my XDPs children even after 9 years together and I don’t see much of my nieces and nephews. They’re nice kids but I wouldn’t say I love them or have a particularly close relationship with them.

I also worked as a childminder because it fitted well around my young family. I was always kind and fair with the CM kids, but more like a teacher than a second mum, unlike some other CMs I knew.

Funnily enough I can be affectionate to all cats, not just my own. But other peoples kids are more like dogs to me - fine from a distance, but don’t get up in my face, jump up and breathe on me and we’ll be fine Grin

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 10/01/2022 00:56

I think most people are like this.

I was never very interested in kids or babies until I had my own, and I don’t especially like any of the kids mine are friends with. I tolerate them. But what I’d indulge in my own kids (rabbiting on about Fortnite or Min craft for example) I find irritating from others.

MabelsApron · 10/01/2022 00:30

My mum would say no, it’s no different, but she was a diabolical parent (we don’t speak) and openly admitted that she shouldn’t have had kids and wouldn’t have done had she not been expected to.

I dunno. I have a hard time believing that biology is that strong, as clearly it failed me.

I’m infertile and childless though so can’t speak with authority!

GrandRapids · 10/01/2022 00:17

I used to physically recoil at babies and small children. No interest whatsoever. In fact, they made me feel rather queasy.

My own however, oh my, he is the most amazing human on the planet.

I've got more time for other peoples children now as long as they're not dicks.

Momentsmatter · 10/01/2022 00:03

Before I had kids I wasn't at all interested in other peoples.

I always wanted to have a family though so did. I ended up with 4 and they are everything. Stranger than that though, I now quite enjoy being around kids. My job is now child related and I do some volunteering with kids too. My friends think I'm the most kid friendly person ever.

Chely · 09/01/2022 23:59

Other peoples kids I don't mind if well behaved or babies.
Our own children drive me insane but I absolutely adore them and have so much more patience with them than anybody/anything.

AgathaAllAlong · 09/01/2022 23:49

How do you feel about the babies of people you love? I'm not a big baby person, but I do really like the babies and children I know, like those in my family and those of my friends. My own children though are entirely different, I can't explain to you how much I love them. They're the only people I feel completely comfortable with. I just love being with them so much, and love the watching them go through all the stages and learning about the world. Also, it is wonderful to have that connection with a child. I was prepared, more or less, for loving my first child more than anything else in the world - but I hadn't even thought about the fact that he would completely love me too. It's that bond and shared experience as you go through life together that make your children special to you, and other children just other people.

massiveblob · 09/01/2022 23:48

I coach kids. (Sports) I love them all. I love them because they aren't mine and I don't have to look after to them as such. They are all different personalities. Some are quiet.some are sensitive. Some are are both of a pita but I kinda like seeing them grow up & see how they change.
Age 7 upwards tho. Not babies

Frenchfurze · 09/01/2022 23:27

To be honest, claiming to adore children in general strikes me as making as little sense as saying you love all adults, but I know that’s not really what you’re asking. I think that a key difference between ‘other children’ and your children is that parenting, as watched by a non-parent, often looks like pure drudgery, because only the external stuff is visible — the nappies, dealing with homework, tantrums, laundry, potty-training, The interesting stuff in parenting isn’t visible, and is even hard to describe because it’s so individual to you as an individual parent and your child as an individual child, and your circumstances. My experience as a FT working mother of one primary-aged NT child in an inner city in a new country, with a hands-on DH co-parenting, is going to be very different to that of a rural-based single parent of three teenagers, or a SAHP of newly-adopted siblings with some additional needs. I often don’t recognise the experiences of parenting on here because they don’t mirror my own — things like the assumption of grandparents providing care (we had DS in another country to all family so assumed all childcare needed paying for) and the difficulties and benefits of that.

Aria2015 · 09/01/2022 23:26

If I'm entirely honest, I love and adore my own but literally everyone else kids (and I include my own nieces and nephews in this), I just fake liking. Sounds terrible I know, but it's true. I just have zero interest in children other than my own but I'm sensitive to others feelings so always make the right noises and make the appropriate fuss.

I look back and just think me having children was a gamble that paid off because I didn't really like kids and wasn't broody. I do adore them though and I am a ‘natural’ mother - my mothering is just exclusively limited to them!

Doodar · 09/01/2022 23:24

loved my nieces and nephews pre kids, lost touch with friends who had kids and kept bringing them to lunch when we met. so tedious.i never bring my kids to a friend meet up unless they specifically ask.