Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no Morrisons now is not a good time to introduce a sniff test

131 replies

Fiftythreepercent · 09/01/2022 20:54

BBC News reporting today that Morrisons is removing use by dates from its milk in favour of best before and encouraging consumers to take a sniff test when deciding whether to use the milk or not.

Tremendous timing Morrisons since I’ve not been able to smell more than 20% of anything since Covid in August. Left on gas? Nope. Chopping onions? Not a whiff. Gone off milk. Not a hope in hell.

Me and half the country?

OP posts:
PickAChew · 10/01/2022 00:42

It's not like it's never the case that you get something home, open it soon, and it's off, though. I've found Tesco and Morrisons to be bad for this.

LittleBearPad · 10/01/2022 00:24

@PickAChew

I think the motivation is less about encouraging us, as consumers, to be less wasteful and more about them increasing their profits.

Whst come back would we have if we got a couple of litres of milk from there, opened it before the best before and it turned out to smell like old floor mop?

Unless you’ve failed to store it properly however this isn’t going to happen
JustWonderingIfYou · 09/01/2022 23:52

Milk always lasts ages after the date in our house- i suppose it differs depending on your fridge temperature and how often its opened.

Just use the best before- i don't really understand your issue. Its still going to have a date on it. Hopefully it will stop a bit of food waste.

Sparklingbrook · 09/01/2022 23:51

@PickAChew

I think the motivation is less about encouraging us, as consumers, to be less wasteful and more about them increasing their profits.

Whst come back would we have if we got a couple of litres of milk from there, opened it before the best before and it turned out to smell like old floor mop?

You could return it for a refund like you can now.
PickAChew · 09/01/2022 23:49

I think the motivation is less about encouraging us, as consumers, to be less wasteful and more about them increasing their profits.

Whst come back would we have if we got a couple of litres of milk from there, opened it before the best before and it turned out to smell like old floor mop?

AllLopsided · 09/01/2022 23:44

At first I thought you were going to have to sniff it in the shop to see whether it was ok to buy Blush

I buy a week's worth of milk at a time in litre bottles and it rarely goes out of date. Some of the milk I bought on Thursday (6th) was dated 21st and some 23rd. It will be gone by the 14th! So I rarely have out of date milk, but if i did I would give it the sniff test (at home). Was very cross that the mince I bought on click and collect was use by the next day though.

Covidclaire · 09/01/2022 23:44

@FortniteBoysMum

I told dp I will now have to go to Tesco on my way home from work which is a bit out of my way rather than Morrisons along route. Will buy my milk and things elsewhere as a result of this. Personally think it's stupid because if your on the last day or day after with milk you generally smell it anyway to check if its OK.
I don’t understand your point. By your own admission you already do what Morrison’s is recommending.

This whole thing has just reconfirmed what many of us already knew. The Brits love a good moan.

TrenchArse · 09/01/2022 23:41

@FortniteBoysMum why do you think this means you can no longer drink the milk? Nothing has changed.

sst1234 · 09/01/2022 23:35

@TigerDroveAgain

I’m torn on this:
  • in my experience milk usually is off by the time you get to the use by date
  • but use by dates in general are so super cautious that they just lead to loads of waste
  • DH lost his sense of smell a few years ago so can’t smell test anything (including a car fire, didn’t realise until the flames were coming through the floor ) Shock
Never known any fresh milk form any retailer to go bad at least 3 days after the use by date. You are storing it wrong.
sst1234 · 09/01/2022 23:34

Do people really poor good milk down the drain just because it past use before date. That’s stupid. Morrisons are just advocating for common sense.

FortniteBoysMum · 09/01/2022 23:12

I told dp I will now have to go to Tesco on my way home from work which is a bit out of my way rather than Morrisons along route. Will buy my milk and things elsewhere as a result of this. Personally think it's stupid because if your on the last day or day after with milk you generally smell it anyway to check if its OK.

Sparklingbrook · 09/01/2022 23:04

I think it’s a good idea. They aren’t removing a date altogether. So if you can’t smell or taste anything at all then you can go by the best before. Or get someone else to have a sniff?

RedHelenB · 09/01/2022 23:04

Yabu. The same date will be on it for the best before as was on it for the use by.

Louiselady500 · 09/01/2022 23:03

Anything that helps less waste is fine by me!

Jijithecat · 09/01/2022 22:58

Oh and if you have too much milk it freezes really well.

Jijithecat · 09/01/2022 22:57

It's a great idea. There's still a best before date as a guideline. The removal of the use by date and replacement with best before will now mean that Morrisons will be able to donate any excess milk to charities who collect food e.g. Community Fridges, food banks that have facilities for fresh food etc. Previously they would have been legally required to dispose of it. Now there should be less waste and more people should benefit.

For anyone with milk going off before it's date, check your fridge temperature. It should be below 5 degrees.

Covidclaire · 09/01/2022 22:56

@Heruka

I’ve noticed that milk I buy from the corner shop will turn before it’s date or definitely by it, whereas supermarket milk has probably been stored more strictly and carefully.
This I agree with.
Covidclaire · 09/01/2022 22:54

@GraciousPiglet

I get milk in glass bottles from the milkman. No dates on my milk. It's been fine and actually I never even sniffed it.

I get it three times a week and it maybe lasts 4/5 days max. It's fine.

Also they are still going to have a date on, it will just say best before rather than use by.

Really? I get milk delivered and there is date on every bottle. It’s stamped on the foil lid. Sometimes difficult to see but it’s definitely there.

And I find the opposite in the summer, especially with skimmed milk. It goes off much quicker due to the time it’s left out in the heat. Have to sniff every bottle and ended up throwing a couple away. But for me it’s worth it as I’d much rather throw a couple of pints away over the summer than have to buy milk in plastic containers.

JugglingJanuary · 09/01/2022 22:54

@BrightYellowDaffodil

There’s still going to be a best before date, I don’t see the issue whatsoever.

Exactly, Morrisons are - admirably - trying to address the issue of horrendous food waste and of people throwing out food that’s perfectly fine.

Use it up to the Best Before if it bothers you, but for the rest of us we’ll be able to use our common sense (not least been use milk is usually absolutely fine beyond the use by/best before date as long as it’s been stored properly).

If Morrisons actually!wanted to DO something, they'd stop their ENORMOUS waste of food in store & instead of putting ENORMOUS amounts of food in the rubbish, they'd actually do what they claim to do and give it to people who need it.

It's not health & safety, they're unethical and would prefer to 'waste' it so people buy a newer product in store. Their staff aren't even allowed to take it home/eat it, it must be binned.

Changing to 'best before' is virtue signalling at best.

Notjustanymum · 09/01/2022 22:48

I use the “drop” test: if you make a cup of tea with boiling water and put milk into it, if it’s on the turn, the milk sinks (and if it’s off you get curdled milk) it only wastes one teabag and you don’t have to sniff it!

daisymade · 09/01/2022 22:46

Because the general public waste thousands of tonnes of produce every year from their obsession with fucking sell by dates.

We're dairy farmers - if it's off enough to give you the shits, believe me, you will know about it.

Heruka · 09/01/2022 22:39

I’ve noticed that milk I buy from the corner shop will turn before it’s date or definitely by it, whereas supermarket milk has probably been stored more strictly and carefully.

jcyclops · 09/01/2022 22:38

I've not yet had Covid (touch wood) and my sense of smell is fine, so I will volunteer to open the bottles of milk on the Morrisons shelf and tell all the other shoppers whether they are OK or not.

GraciousPiglet · 09/01/2022 22:38

I get milk in glass bottles from the milkman. No dates on my milk. It's been fine and actually I never even sniffed it.

I get it three times a week and it maybe lasts 4/5 days max. It's fine.

Also they are still going to have a date on, it will just say best before rather than use by.

Sparticle · 09/01/2022 22:34

@oviraptor21

Must be something wrong with your fridge (or the supermarket fridge) if milk is turning before the use by date. Mill from the major supermarkets usually lasts a week or so past the use by I've found.
We’re the same here. Our DC (13 and 8) know that often the milk and yogurts we have are out of date but perfectly fine (I appreciate that begs the question of why I don’t buy any until we’ve used up the old lot so we are back in credit, date-wise but that’s another thread!) 🙃