Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no Morrisons now is not a good time to introduce a sniff test

131 replies

Fiftythreepercent · 09/01/2022 20:54

BBC News reporting today that Morrisons is removing use by dates from its milk in favour of best before and encouraging consumers to take a sniff test when deciding whether to use the milk or not.

Tremendous timing Morrisons since I’ve not been able to smell more than 20% of anything since Covid in August. Left on gas? Nope. Chopping onions? Not a whiff. Gone off milk. Not a hope in hell.

Me and half the country?

OP posts:
MissMaple82 · 10/01/2022 10:09

But some people can't read either so you can please everyone! The point is to stop people being so darn wasteful, the milk industry is utterly barbaric, the least we can do is be mindful of over consumption, not waste and treat milk with the respect it actually deserves!

greenlynx · 10/01/2022 10:07

@FluffyBooBoo
I’m absolutely fine with best before dates on other products like vegs, fruits, etc. we have very little food waste in this house as everything is used, however I disagree with putting milk in the same category as apples and carrots.

greenlynx · 10/01/2022 10:00

@CaptainMyCaptain
bad choice of word on my side, I’ve meant that I’m not cooking it just using as it is.

RustyBear · 10/01/2022 10:00

DH used to work for a food research institute, where they undertook several projects to establish best before/use by times for various foods. None of the results were consistent enough to establish anything except that the Harvard Law is true.

The Harvard Law states: "Under controlled conditions of light, temperature, humidity, and nutrition, the organism will do as it damn well pleases."

So best before/use by dates are set by producers with a wide safety margin - but even then they can't guarantee the organism will co-operate, which is why the consumer is always advised to check for themselves.

Tricked2003 · 10/01/2022 09:56

@WetLookKnitwear

Wish I could get my DH to do this. The moment the clock strikes midnight marking the beginning of best before date the whole lot goes down the sink. Sad
This makes me so angry/sad..........a family friend is like this, throws out jams, pickles all sorts of foods that are perfectly safe to eat.

I think Morrisons is great for doing this..........far too much food is wasted. I've never blindly abided by "use by" on milk, it's sniff it and see in my house!!

CaptainMyCaptain · 10/01/2022 09:55

[quote greenlynx]@LawnFever
The current system is fine because it’s the same everywhere and people are taught in certain way.
I use fruits and vegs beyond their best before date but milk is different as I put raw milk in my tea.
Sniffing is very subtle testing, not all people can rely on it.[/quote]
'raw milk'? Raw milk is unpasteurised. If you are using supermarket milk it isn't raw, it has been heat treated i.e. pasteurised.

BasketBlocks · 10/01/2022 09:50

Do people actually throw food away when it reaches the use by date without first checking whether it’s spoiled? I regularly eat stuff that’s gone beyond the date that is perfectly fine. Had some pastrami at the weekend that was two days out but looked and smelled absolutely fine.

CurtainTroubles · 10/01/2022 09:46

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

FluffyBooBoo · 10/01/2022 09:45

@greenlynx

I personally won’t buy milk from Morrison’s any more as I don’t like this approach. I think it’s too complicated for people with learning disabilities and some elderly people. There are better ways to cut the waste and the timing of their decision is really stupid considering how Covid affects sense of smell.
So do you disagree with best before dates on other products too, or just milk? Is it only confusing because it used to have a use by date?

I'm pretty sure people with learning disabilities that can understand a use by date will be able to use the best before date in exactly the same way - and those of us that get the difference can use the sniff test.

BarbaraofSeville · 10/01/2022 09:40

@greenlynx

I personally won’t buy milk from Morrison’s any more as I don’t like this approach. I think it’s too complicated for people with learning disabilities and some elderly people. There are better ways to cut the waste and the timing of their decision is really stupid considering how Covid affects sense of smell.
It's not stupid at all and will actually help some people with learning disabilities, eg autism, because if we stop telling people that the milk will poison them at 00.01 on the day after the use by date, which is what the current system is incorrectly doing, they will be a lot more willing to use what is almost certainly still fresh milk because it's not breaking 'the rules'.

The elderly probably don't even look at the date anyway because they will remember times before such things (and fridges!) even existed.

Pineapplemonkey · 10/01/2022 09:29

Just reading this with a cup of tea. Just went and looked at the use by date on my Tesco 2 pinter of skimmed. 24th Dec. Tastes fine, and I can taste/smell even slightly off milk at 100 yards so mine is fine. There's at least half a pint left (probably more) and I will keep on using it. I never look at the use by dates on eggs, dairy, fruit, veg. Meat and fish I look at it and then base the decision on look and smell.

greenlynx · 10/01/2022 09:27

@LawnFever
The current system is fine because it’s the same everywhere and people are taught in certain way.
I use fruits and vegs beyond their best before date but milk is different as I put raw milk in my tea.
Sniffing is very subtle testing, not all people can rely on it.

Sparklingbrook · 10/01/2022 09:21

@greenlynx

I personally won’t buy milk from Morrison’s any more as I don’t like this approach. I think it’s too complicated for people with learning disabilities and some elderly people. There are better ways to cut the waste and the timing of their decision is really stupid considering how Covid affects sense of smell.
I don’t see that having a date of Best Before is complicated. Plus the elderly will remember a time when there were no dates at all as a PP said they’ll be fine.
Electriq · 10/01/2022 09:20

Sometimes milk doesn't smell when it's gone off, many a time I've poured in a tea, then noticed the curdle, and im a sniffer before I use too.

TrophyWinner · 10/01/2022 09:15

It's still going to have a best before date if you prefer to throw perfectly good milk out on its date.

It won't harm you because it's gone a bit sour, so if you can't taste it no harm done anyway.

Cookerhood · 10/01/2022 09:12

If you aren't sure about milk and can't smell it put a small amount in a mug & microwave it. If it has gone off it will curdle. Easy.

LawnFever · 10/01/2022 09:12

@greenlynx isn’t having one date a much simpler concept?

I think often people get confused between best before/use by anyway so reducing it to a single date can surely only simplify the system.

CaptainMyCaptain · 10/01/2022 09:10

@greenlynx

I personally won’t buy milk from Morrison’s any more as I don’t like this approach. I think it’s too complicated for people with learning disabilities and some elderly people. There are better ways to cut the waste and the timing of their decision is really stupid considering how Covid affects sense of smell.
The elderly people will be fine. It will be what they've always done. It's the young people who won't know what to do.
CaptainMyCaptain · 10/01/2022 09:09

I've always used the sniff test rather than throw milk away because it's passed a certain date. No change for me.

greenlynx · 10/01/2022 09:08

I personally won’t buy milk from Morrison’s any more as I don’t like this approach. I think it’s too complicated for people with learning disabilities and some elderly people. There are better ways to cut the waste and the timing of their decision is really stupid considering how Covid affects sense of smell.

LawnFever · 10/01/2022 09:04

@BooksAndGin

I think they should do with bread, bakery, butter, juice etc but milk will be hard... I don't have a sense of smell. Sad Sure I can sit and siv it through but I'm disabled and don't have the energy for it.
You can use the best before date that will still be on the milk.
TroysMammy · 10/01/2022 08:54

Milk is always used past the use by date in my house. Skimmed lasts the longest. However I'm funny unreasonable about eggs past the use by date though.

BadPlaceJanet · 10/01/2022 08:49

I have no sense of smell and I think it's a good idea. Food waste is horrifying.

If I'm ever unsure, I get one of my kids to sniff for me, or if they're not around, I pour a little bit out and taste it. It's not hard!

I'd have more of an issue with things like chicken and seafood that really can make you ill, so I don't take chances with those.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 10/01/2022 08:39

Well the information is passed on by Morrison from the Institute of No Shit Sherlock.
Those with a sense of smell and taste carry on as you were.
Those without, use the Best Before Date.
I feel I must have missed some vital part of the story.

ECLT · 10/01/2022 08:39

As previous posters have suggested, you could treat the BB date like the UB date. The rest of us can use our own judgment and common sense, I think it's taken the pandemic to make me realise how many people rely on rules to follow and are sent into a tailspin if they are encouraged to use their own judgment and common sense based on info/guidance.
Look at the travel traffic light system, a lot of people coped when they just couldn't go, they were confused when given the traffic light guidance as they had to judge it for themselves. There was a big split between the people I know, those two could use the guidance and use their common sense, and those who couldn't were confused by it and wanted the 'hard rules' back.
The same thing is happening in this post, some are happy to use common sense with BB dates and others want to be told to use milk be a certain date.