Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I unreasonable about house comments from in laws ?

132 replies

namechanger2222 · 09/01/2022 20:38

We've recently moved into a brand new home. We bought it when it was not completely finished yet, as is often the case. We however had no say in any of it.

There are a few bits and bobs we wouldn't have chosen, but we don't hate any of it. None of it is offensive and it's all quite neutral, so you can put your own stamp on it.

My in laws are pretty critical / negative people I would say. They always think we pay too much for stuff / are too frivolous with our money etc. Unfortunately we needed to buy at a time when prices were high, it's just how it was.

Anyway, every time they come around, they always need to say stuff like : ' well for a house of this price, I would expect they should have done X or Y'.

Sometimes it's sparked my DH asking advice on a particular subject from his dad. Other times it's his mum asking what we plan to do with XYZ feature and then me saying that we need to change the colour of something or that I want to change some handles. Not major stuff, but it's always met with ' well didn't you notice that when you came to see the house ?' Or ' I certainly think a house that costs this much, should have that feature or this features. Did you not ask the builders if they would paint the stairs a different colour etc ? '

It's getting very very irritating now. Like every tiny thing that's mentioned, somehow makes me feel like they're saying we overpaid for our shitty house, in their opinion. I've told my husband to literally say nothing more about any of it to them. But he says sometimes he has questions for his dad, which I do understand. It's all new to us, so some stuff we just don't know.

I think the crux of it is that by asking advice, he's opening the door to criticism. However, our house really is lovely and well built. We have had no major issues. It's little things that are to be expected.

I'm sure most will say I am being unreasonable. But I just don't like how they go about it. I think they can tell, as a couple of times I've shut them down a bit like : ' ok the stair colour is a minor issue MIL. It doesn't matter whether I saw the stairs before buying this house, I would have bought it anyway. It doesn't ruin the house for me'.

Why do people always chew off your hand when you give them your little finger ? This is my in laws in a nutshell. You show any tiny vulnerability or chink in your armour and they think they can just go on and on and on forever and take it to the next level.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Topseyt · 13/01/2022 10:26

My mother once sat in my sister's kitchen/conservatory and asked her (in a rather critical tone):

"Do you actually like the wallpaper in this room?"

To which my sister firmly replied:

"Of course I do or I wouldn't have put it up! Do you think I would have bought wallpaper I didn't like?"

That was end of discussion and my mother tried to backtrack by saying "Oh, err well..... I think I maybe like it too ....." Trying to dig herself out of the hole, getting deeper in etc.

I had a good laugh about it with my sister when I saw her over Christmas. Grin

Either pay them no attention or have a good riposte ready. Certainly don't invite their opinions on anything or discuss your plans with them

2pinkginsplease · 13/01/2022 03:42

I would just turn it back round on their house.

She criticises your house then you reply, yeah I don’t like that in your home too.
If she doesn’t like the wall colour then reply yeah I don’t like the colour you have on your wall.

If she doesn’t like the doors then reply, yeah I don’t like the doors you have either,

Turn it back and criticise her house, I’m sure she will soon stop!

MadMadMadamMim · 13/01/2022 02:51

This would be like a bullseye for them. That's exactly what they want me to say, so they can tell me how sensitive I am and that they are afraid of upsetting me and that they feel uncomfortable around me. grin

That's ok. You counter back, bluntly, with I think you mean that you are both pretty thick skinned, rather than that I am sensitive. It isn't acceptable to constantly snipe and make critical and unasked for comments about someone else's home. You aren't noticeably afraid of upsetting me, are you? If you feel uncomfortable, as I do when you come round, perhaps we should limit the visits.

phishy · 13/01/2022 02:36

@Ireallycantthinkofagoodone

I had a slightly different experience with my own DM. She would perhaps buy a new lamp/set of curtains/item of furniture etc., and ask me if I liked it. My usual reply would be along the lines of ‘it looks lovely in here Mum’. ‘But do you like it?’ she would persist. ‘It goes perfectly with the room’ I would then say. ‘But do you like it?’ she would repeat. Me - ‘No’. DM - ‘You never like anything I choose!’ I seriously tried to be diplomatic, but we all have different tastes. I never ask anyone’s opinion on anything I buy as I am just pleasing myself. I also never pass judgment on other people’s purchases. It’s rude and unnecessary. Fortunately, I have never received negative comments from others either.
If you were willing tell the first white lie, then why not just say you like it?

Seems a bit mean to your mum.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/01/2022 00:08

I seriously tried to be diplomatic, but we all have different tastes. I never ask anyone’s opinion on anything I buy as I am just pleasing myself. I also never pass judgment on other people’s purchases. It’s rude and unnecessary.

It baffles me why some people feel the constant need for validation of their own personal choices and get deeply offended when your own likes/dislikes are different. Neither choice is wrong/bad/worse - just individual preference.

My DGM would enthusiastically recommend things that she'd bought for herself and loved and she used to find it genuinely inconceivable that her own preferences in clothes and accessories (in her 70s) just might not be the exact same ones as those of family members in their teens!

For some unpleasant people, it goes the other way too - where instead of wanting you to validate their choices, they will keep putting down your choices and telling you how they really don't like them, in the expectation that you will be upset or offended. If it relates to wildly different beliefs on a serious moral issue, they may have a slightly valid point; but not when it's just a preference for blue curtains or green ones!

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/01/2022 09:07

‘Can you please stop nitpicking about the house? It’s getting very wearing.’

Immunetypegoblin · 11/01/2022 08:44

@Ireallycantthinkofagoodone

I had a slightly different experience with my own DM. She would perhaps buy a new lamp/set of curtains/item of furniture etc., and ask me if I liked it. My usual reply would be along the lines of ‘it looks lovely in here Mum’. ‘But do you like it?’ she would persist. ‘It goes perfectly with the room’ I would then say. ‘But do you like it?’ she would repeat. Me - ‘No’. DM - ‘You never like anything I choose!’ I seriously tried to be diplomatic, but we all have different tastes. I never ask anyone’s opinion on anything I buy as I am just pleasing myself. I also never pass judgment on other people’s purchases. It’s rude and unnecessary. Fortunately, I have never received negative comments from others either.
My mother was a bugger for this! Never happy to just accept the obvious tactful answer which was being offered, she always had to push you into admitting the truth and then got the hump. It was exhausting. She's dead now but that is behavior I do not miss....
JanuaryBluehoo · 10/01/2022 19:29

We built up this buffet... Great post.

It's really important to remember this, it's not a sign of happy people at all.

Ireallycantthinkofagoodone · 10/01/2022 14:17

I had a slightly different experience with my own DM. She would perhaps buy a new lamp/set of curtains/item of furniture etc., and ask me if I liked it.
My usual reply would be along the lines of ‘it looks lovely in here Mum’.
‘But do you like it?’ she would persist.
‘It goes perfectly with the room’ I would then say.
‘But do you like it?’ she would repeat.
Me - ‘No’.
DM - ‘You never like anything I choose!’
I seriously tried to be diplomatic, but we all have different tastes. I never ask anyone’s opinion on anything I buy as I am just pleasing myself. I also never pass judgment on other people’s purchases. It’s rude and unnecessary.
Fortunately, I have never received negative comments from others either.

MsTSwift · 10/01/2022 11:23

My in laws are hilariously negative. My mother asked fil about Dh who is basically the perfect son - first in family to get to university (Cambridge) all done on his own great career lovely friends etc. All fil could do was sigh and say “well I suppose he never gave us any trouble” 😁

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/01/2022 10:20

Some people do genuinely thrive on being joy sponges and only wanting to find a negative in everything. If they won exactly £10m on the lottery and were congratulated by well-wishers, they'd feel the urge to stress that the effective win wasn't actually that much, as you needed to allow for the £2 cost of the ticket!

I don't see that it can really come from a happy or contented place. I always stop to think that, with the kind of negative people who cast a grey shadow over your life when you spend half an hour with them, they live under that shadow for every second of their own life and can't leave. Of course, they can always re-evaluate and change their character, but a lot just never seem to have it in them to be able to 'escape'.

Like an annoying, angry wasp at a picnic that refuses to leave you alone, it might seem that they're the ones in control and doing what they want to; but I for one would never for a second contemplate wishing to exchange lives with the wasp!

CornedBeef451 · 10/01/2022 10:19

I just have to let the comments slide off!

When we showed MlL around our new house she didn't comment on the weird layout, which would have been understandable, or how big the rooms were, just how tall the trees were in the garden and how hard they'd be to manage. She was right but it was such an odd thing to pick up on.

DM was hilariously worse though, we took her to look round our last house and she just said it was lovely and that it seemed a bit too nice for one of us!

I think it was less about us as a couple and more about where she comes from but it was still very odd. It made me laugh but that's because she's mine and I know what she's like.

DF and ex BIL used to start lots of helpful advice with "what you want to do..." and I'd have to reply is, what I want to do is pay someone to do that for me, IF we decide that we want it doing. Eventually they both stopped saying it.

Good luck with the in laws!

namechanger2222 · 10/01/2022 10:10

@godmum56

I do wonder if they are bored? have they got much else going on in their life? sometimes people do like to extract every morsel of interest out of a subject and their way of doing it is to nitpick. Doesn't make it any more acceptable though....

And to those who say its an old people thing, its not. As Roy Hudd used to say, if you were a miserable bugger when you are young, you will be a miserable bugger when you are old. I spent much of my working like working for old people in the NHS. Almost always the people whiose families disliked them had always been unpleasant and the people whose families liked them had always been nice. The exceptions were due to personality changes caused by stroke, dementia and so on.

Oh yeah sister in law and brother in law are the same as them and they're young. It's a family attitude thing !
OP posts:
godmum56 · 10/01/2022 09:58

I do wonder if they are bored? have they got much else going on in their life? sometimes people do like to extract every morsel of interest out of a subject and their way of doing it is to nitpick. Doesn't make it any more acceptable though....

And to those who say its an old people thing, its not. As Roy Hudd used to say, if you were a miserable bugger when you are young, you will be a miserable bugger when you are old. I spent much of my working like working for old people in the NHS. Almost always the people whiose families disliked them had always been unpleasant and the people whose families liked them had always been nice. The exceptions were due to personality changes caused by stroke, dementia and so on.

namechanger2222 · 10/01/2022 09:24

Thanks everyone for sharing your experiences. And sorry that this seems so common when it comes to houses!

Nothing the developers did in our house was ever going to be good enough for my in laws, is what I'm realising.. they made up their mind before we even bought it, that the builders were going to do a rubbish job and they'd only use cheap materials.

So no matter what the house was going to be like, they were always going to be critical of it.

OP posts:
Ozgirl75 · 10/01/2022 09:17

My FIL can be a fun sucker like this. My DH (the non golden child) moved jobs for a big promotion and his dad said no congratulations, just said “I wonder why you keep moving every five minutes, your brother has been at his work for 5 years”, despite the fact that DH was earning more than his dad ever did by the time he was in his late 20s.
He can be fine, just really thoughtless - my SIL finds it infuriating. They have this thing against all new fangled stuff. He took against phonic learning to read and kept buying all the grandkids the Janet and john books and said how DH and his brother learnt with them and that was good enough for everyone.
Still, luckily we live in Australia and them in the U.K. so I don’t have to deal.

LakieLady · 10/01/2022 08:00

My DF, who was often unintentionally rude, once said to his hyper-critical brother, "When I want your opinion, I'll ask for it. Until then, I'll than you to keep it to yourself."

This became a standing joke within the family and was the stock response to even the tiniest criticism.

Fairyliz · 10/01/2022 07:39

@PurpleRainlnTheSky

Not ALL 'older' people of course, but SOME. And it's far less likely to be younger people making the scathing and critical comments.
@PurpleRainlnTheSky I’m sorry you’ve had some nasty comments from older people it’s not nice is it. But you do realise that these ‘old’ people were young once, did they suddenly change at say 50? Surely the answer is some people are horrible irrespective of age.
Brigante9 · 10/01/2022 07:09

You have a Dh problem. Why does he ask his dad all the time, knowing it leads to criticism? Can’t he Google it? I mean, he should be able t9 ask his dad stuff, but if it leads to criticism, maybe he could ask him away from your mil?

Cam2020 · 10/01/2022 06:57

DP also constantly compared to sibling. That's seems to be a theme.

Cam2020 · 10/01/2022 06:55

Had this with FIL. He'd come round and shit all over everything we owned (not literally) everything we did, everything we hadn't done, everything we planned to do. Possessions, ideas, DP's job - all found wanting, always 'terrible'. Mostly because he's a narc and controlling and he hadn't been consulting. He'd also 'fix' things that didn't need fixing, completely unbidden and often break things in the process.

I used to have to leave the room. I'm actually NC now with either of DP's parents due to other appalling behaviour.

Sunnysideup999 · 10/01/2022 06:49

‘Yes there are a few minor things we’ll change in time. Anyway, thank you for your comments’.

SummerLovin2022 · 10/01/2022 06:38

My mil is the same. When we bought our house the only thing she commented on was the big stone wall in the back garden and how lovely it was. Over the years she has told us what type of extension to build, what colours to paint with, floors, carpets.. Everything. Of course her two other sons homes are fabulous, according to her. Confused

FangsForTheMemory · 10/01/2022 06:04

@Brainstorm21

I bought a house and when my mum and brother came round the first time they walked round the entire place and pointed out the faults with every room. I sent them packing and they haven't been invited back since.
Same but it was a friend. She acted as though my small house in a fab location was a grotty bedsit. I won't be inviting her to stay again.
travellinglighter · 10/01/2022 05:53

Warn your husband and use extreme sarcasm,.

“You don’t like that? Well it’s lucky you didn’t buy it then.”
“You feel uncomfortable round me? Maybe you should visit less?”
“I’m overly sensitive? I’m not the one bitching about being uncomfortable when I defend myself.”
“I’m sorry that defending myself from your rude comments makes you uncomfortable, I’ll stop defending myself when you stop attacking me.”
“You do know there is such a thing as constructive criticism? That’s not constructive criticism, it’s just criticism?

When you go to theirs point out things you don’t like and if they get offended, say “Oh I’m so sorry, you don’t in my house I thought it was what you did in your family.”

If you really want to go nuclear. Next time they come round, open the door, smile brightly say

“Hi mil, fil, come in unless you’re here to criticise our lovely home, if that’s the case you can fuck off back to that hovel with all that DIY you’ve botched.”

The reality is, you could just put this back on your DH. Ask him if he likes them slagging off the house and if he doesn’t then tell him to put a stop to it or you will in the manner I have suggested.