Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people should talk about what they earn?

81 replies

HoneyBlahBlah · 09/01/2022 12:13

Recently myself and my colleagues were talking about the hope of wage increases from our company due to inflation. We all agreed that we need to ask for more money, as our wages haven't increased to match inflation.

None of us knew what the others were earning, so I figured I'd just tell them my annual salary. One of the girls who has worked there longer than me (and is therefore more experienced - she helped train me and other colleague) was shocked, as she's on £1k less than me and other colleague. I told her that she needs to discuss this with our Manager, as there's no reason she should earn less.

AIBU to think people need to stop hiding their earnings from others? Surely you're just doing the millionaire business owners a favour by doing so, as nobody knows how much they're worth?

OP posts:
HoneyBlahBlah · 09/01/2022 15:25

@Aprilx

It’s the big bosses way of making sure nobody knows their worth, and therefore keeps everyone on as little as possible

It isn’t. It is to respect privacy and to prevent dealing with endless queries over why suchabody earns £100 more than suchabody. Seems to be a failure to appreciate that even if two people are doing two similar roles, no two individuals are identical or will be working identically.

If it were to keep everyone on as little as possible, how would knowing that everyone else be on as little as possible help? Your rationale makes no sense.

Ok so, for example, my colleague who earns less than me was promoted in June. I was then promoted in November along with another colleague to the same position, but we were offered £1k more than previous colleague.

We have both been with the company a shorter time than the colleague who was promoted in June. However, they're not going to tell her that we were offered more and offer her a top up in pay because it would cost them money, so why would they? Therefore, it's their way of keeping her on as little money as possible. There is simply no reason she should be on less, as she is more knowledge in the role, and has worked there longer.

Make sense now? 😊

OP posts:
PegasusReturns · 09/01/2022 15:20

I've been in my current job for four months and have been told very, very clearly to never discuss my salary with my colleagues

Abs that should ring loud alarm bells

ShadowGirls · 09/01/2022 15:12

I've been in my current job for four months and have been told very, very clearly to never discuss my salary with my colleagues

WorraLiberty · 09/01/2022 15:01

Oh dear @Hoppinggreen

You know it's perfectly easy to read from reputable sources, right?

I think you're just annoyed that you didn't bother checking first and engaging your brain.

That's quite evident if you have to pretend someone is 'upset' rather than simply pointing out that you're wrong.

Aprilx · 09/01/2022 14:59

It’s the big bosses way of making sure nobody knows their worth, and therefore keeps everyone on as little as possible

It isn’t. It is to respect privacy and to prevent dealing with endless queries over why suchabody earns £100 more than suchabody. Seems to be a failure to appreciate that even if two people are doing two similar roles, no two individuals are identical or will be working identically.

If it were to keep everyone on as little as possible, how would knowing that everyone else be on as little as possible help? Your rationale makes no sense.

Hoppinggreen · 09/01/2022 14:58

[quote WorraLiberty]@Hoppinggreen it would've taken you less time to Google, than to type that pile...[/quote]
Because everything on the internet is true
I’m advising caution, no idea why that would be so upsetting for you

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 09/01/2022 14:55

I’m sure when Labour were in power they were pushing towards all salaries being disclosed.

As they should be imo.

Aprilx · 09/01/2022 14:53

@Frenchfancy

I also think it is important from a feminist point of view. How are we supposed to know if we are being paid less than men if we never talk about it.
The gender pay reporting is there to reveal any organisation wide problems.
HoneyBlahBlah · 09/01/2022 14:47

@TedMullins

Yes I completely agree. If I applied for a job and found out it was a clause of employment that it was forbidden to discuss salary I would withdraw my application or turn down the offer of employment and tell them exactly why (I have done this before so I’m not just talking myself up!)

Where I work there are publicly available salary bands and my colleague actually did get a raise to bring her further up the band in line with me and others doing the same role. This is how it should be. As others have said, salary secrecy only perpetuates the gender and racial pay gap. I would happily tell my salary to anyone who asked.

I'm honestly so shocked at how many people are saying it's forbidden! It's the big bosses way of making sure nobody knows their worth, and therefore keeps everyone on as little as possible.
OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 09/01/2022 14:46

"If people are that interested in what new people are being paid, they'll Google and find the job advertisements and use that as a bargaining tool."

Adverts often only give a range and that would only be for the starting salary.

HoneyBlahBlah · 09/01/2022 14:45

@padsi1975

My colleague (does exactly same job as me and definitely not better than me) told me her salary and turned out she was making 13k p.a. more than me. I was so disheartened. I raised it with management and it was corrected at the next salary review. So I think transparency can work. They'd have NEVER corrected the disparity if I hadn't found out about it.
Exactly! Of course they're not going to offer you more if they don't have to, they'll just line their own pockets with it 🙄

This is why we need to be more open. Thank God the idea of secrecy around wages is dying out

OP posts:
HoneyBlahBlah · 09/01/2022 14:42

@OhGiveUp

It's nothing to do with anyone else what my salary is.
Then, with all due respect, you are part of the problem I'm afraid.
OP posts:
HoneyBlahBlah · 09/01/2022 14:33

@Eternallyfrazzled

We don’t talk about it enough I recently discovered I was on quite a loss less than other employees whose workloads and skill level was a lot lower than mine! I was been underpaid by approx 3-5k I asked for a pay rise got 5p more an hour so I resigned starting new job soon!
Well done!!!!! Good for you! See what I mean about power? You took it back because you knew what you were worth 😘
OP posts:
TedMullins · 09/01/2022 14:16

Yes I completely agree. If I applied for a job and found out it was a clause of employment that it was forbidden to discuss salary I would withdraw my application or turn down the offer of employment and tell them exactly why (I have done this before so I’m not just talking myself up!)

Where I work there are publicly available salary bands and my colleague actually did get a raise to bring her further up the band in line with me and others doing the same role. This is how it should be. As others have said, salary secrecy only perpetuates the gender and racial pay gap. I would happily tell my salary to anyone who asked.

padsi1975 · 09/01/2022 14:11

My colleague (does exactly same job as me and definitely not better than me) told me her salary and turned out she was making 13k p.a. more than me. I was so disheartened. I raised it with management and it was corrected at the next salary review. So I think transparency can work. They'd have NEVER corrected the disparity if I hadn't found out about it.

WorraLiberty · 09/01/2022 14:07

@Hoppinggreen it would've taken you less time to Google, than to type that pile...

EngTech · 09/01/2022 14:05

Experience has shown me that you have to leave a company, work for a related company in a similar field for about 2 years and then come back on more money and a senior position.

Bonkers but the joys of working in a the corporate world 😳

PegasusReturns · 09/01/2022 14:00

Are you a HR expert or lawyer?

I’m a lawyer and have posted exactly the same up thread.

Now of course your next comment might be well no one knows that you are a lawyer and yes that would be correct.

Hopefully however flagging the issue will encourage those who have had discussions unlawfully suppressed to do their own research rather than unequivocally accept the counter argument that has been widely expressed on this thread that your employer is allowed to prevent you disclosing your salary.

Hoppinggreen · 09/01/2022 13:55

@WorraLiberty

And YANBU OP

Employers can't legally stop their employees from discussing their pay.

Are you a HR expert or lawyer? I’m not and I would never give such unequivocal advice. It’s dangerous for people to listen to advice like this from people unless they can be certain that they are suitably qualified Maybe this is right and maybe it’s not but people need to be very cautious when doing things that could have serious consequences based on anonymous people on a forum
OhGiveUp · 09/01/2022 13:54

It's nothing to do with anyone else what my salary is.

Nowayoutonlydown · 09/01/2022 13:51

In principle I'd agree however I've seen these conversations make everything fall to shit.
I oversee subcontractors often,
One had been unhappy with his wages, I've always sort of said, I'm sorry I'm unsure what the going rate is for your trade sort of thing and they get on with work.

Then the team got to talking, turned out one worker was paid significantly more. Within a week one of them was sacked and the other quit his job.
Created a pretty bad ripple effect.
If people are that interested in what new people are being paid, they'll Google and find the job advertisements and use that as a bargaining tool.

lightisnotwhite · 09/01/2022 13:49

I agree.
It would also filter down to children and students so they could have realistic expectations for the future.
I think it would stop the over paid Idling along and make the under paid not put themselves unnecessarily.

emuloc · 09/01/2022 13:44

@Gwenhwyfar

"Comparing salaries is never helpful."

Of course it's sometimes helpful. Very important to check for things like gender inequalities.

Yes, and racial inequalities too.
Ponoka7 · 09/01/2022 13:42

My DD has just joined a Union for NHS, but private contract, for non nursing staff after finding out that they are all on different wages. The wages aren't connected to performance etc. They deliberately do contracts that don't include time and a half over weekends and bank holidays. There has been a worry that the leveling might be down and not up.

Gwenhwyfar · 09/01/2022 13:37

@Spinner12345

Disagree with people saying companies won’t raise your salary if you find out someone is being paid more. Based on experience, if you’re in an industry where there’s lots of jobs and there’s a reasonable prospect you’ll leave the company they’ll raise it
And sometimes just to keep the peace as well.