Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why more people don't adopt?

706 replies

adoptionthoughts · 09/01/2022 11:55

Recently I've started thinking maybe adoption is a route for me. I've always said I wouldn't do it but recently I'm having a change of heart as I think about it and logically it makes a lot of sense for a variety of reasons.

I'm struggling TTC, but this is something I'm thinking about irrespective of whether or not I eventually manage to have biological kids.

I also think giving a child a life they may not have otherwise had is a really nice thing. Also, why add to a climate change problem when there are so so many children I wanted across the world - the more I think about it the more logically adoption makes lots of sense. It means you don't get the physical problems from childbirth, it means you are providing a life for a child that may have been in foster care and many other positives.

Am I being naive? Why does hardly anyone do it? Why are we only happy with children if it's related to us by blood? I'm not trying to be funny here I'm genuinely asking to see why to see if I'm crazy to consider it.

I appreciate the children up for adoption often come from trauma often, which is concerning in terms of how that trauma may play out in later life but I'd likely want a very small baby (not saying this eradicates this but I think is reducing the risk). And also, the same can happen with biological kids you never know how they will turn out.

I'd like to hear from not just those that have adopted but also those that haven't and wouldn't as to why?

OP posts:
Linning · 09/01/2022 23:49

@EishetChayil

most babies abandoned at birth won’t suffer much trauma

Newborns suffer huge trauma being separated from their mother.

Much doesn’t mean no trauma. Not much trauma is STILL trauma. But separation at birth followed by quick placement into a loving family can be equivalent to not much trauma when you know orphanages and the foster care system is filled with kids who have all been separated from their mom/dad who in most cases they likely learned to know and love and was likely the source of their (potential years of) abuse and neglect etc... and then probably spend years in a system that also often abuse and neglect them before being adopted or (more commonly) never being adopted. The trauma simply isn’t comparable. In both cases it’s trauma but healthy babies who get adopted quickly simply have a completely different path and shot at adoption over older/less healthy kids with more traumatic stories.

My belief is that people who can only cope with a child with no visible/known trauma are probably not good candidates for adoption. All kids in the adoption process have trauma and while not everyone is equipped to deal with a child with multiple health issues and massive trauma responses. Being able to cope with trauma in general should be one of the pre-requisites of being an adopting parents and one own standards when wanting to adopt, so when I hear people say “I know an adopted child probably have trauma but I want to adopt a baby anyway so it should be okay/limited” it’s a massive red flag. It’s nice to want to adopt but all kids have trauma wether it’s a lot or not as much and I think the expectations when adopting should be to receive a kid with quite a bit of trauma and being both emotionally and physically ready to deal and navigate it so as to help the child overcome it as best as one can rather than adopting to help a child in need and then purposefully picking the child that’s assume to not have much needs (in that area).

BatFird · 09/01/2022 23:44

Because it is really fucking hard.

To meet the threshold of criteria
To get through the process
To survive matching process
To handle a traumatised child
To deal with unexpected issues as they grow.

I'm in the adoption process and I still understand when people say they couldn't or it isn't for them.

TTC and the pain that came with that has a breeze for me compared to the adoption matching process.

SmaugMum · 09/01/2022 23:41

@ineedsun, thank you and that’s incredibly big of you - and reflective of you, you see, you’ve been taking on board all that therapeutic/repairing relationships stuff we’ve all been taught in our theory sessions - and it works. Grin

Look, I’m the most passionate adopter I can possibly be but even though we’re all in the same tribe, we may be more or less evolved in our journeys, and we don’t always sing from the same hymn-sheet. The point I was trying to make is that I do notice stuff and I’m not oblivious to the silly comments but, perhaps stupidly, I like to think that most people operate from a place of misguided ignorance and simply need gentle correction and education. These days, I reserve my ire for the (very many) professionals who really SHOULD know better.

Anyway, once again, thank you, very magnanimous of you; it’s no doubt why you make a great adoptive parent! Smile

ineedsun · 09/01/2022 23:27

@SmaugMum

I can’t quote your reply to me, but I did want to apologise. My use of language was ill thought through. The point I was trying to make (badly) was that you weren’t open to hearing any perspectives other than your own, on reflection I can hear that this is likely impacted by your current situation being particularly tough.

I still believe that language should be challenged for the sake of our kids, when people use those terms (I won’t repeat them again) I, and all the adoptive families I know (adults and kids) find it demeaning and disrespectful. I also want a more balanced picture of adoption to be heard, that in spite of the stresses it’s an amazing thing and outcomes can be really positive.

But I genuinely do apologise, I let my emotions get the better of me and should have just stepped away.

RedPandaMama · 09/01/2022 23:21

Haven't read the whole thread. Previously have thought about adopting myself but seen what a family member has gone through to adopt and now think I probably won't ever do it.

The process took them nearly 3 years, huge amounts of time had to be taken off work, lots of social involvement and being made to feel 'not good enough', lots of meetings and courses. Then after 2.5 years and being almost there, the little boys bio mother decided she actually wanted him, so they had to go to court.

Now 2 years on he's really made their family whole and I don't think they'd change a thing, but it was an absolutely brutal process and had a huge effect on their family.

SmaugMum · 09/01/2022 23:19

@NormaSwilly, that’s lovely that your aunt and uncle have had such a positive influence on the grandchildren’s lives; it’s brilliant when the generational cycle of neglect and abuse can be broken. I hope those children can have happy and fulfilled lives, whatever they may be.

It’s so interesting the contrast you draw between both sets of fostered young people - and the outcomes they had. Hats off to brilliant foster carers everywhere.

Branleuse · 09/01/2022 23:16

@EishetChayil

I would like to know how society has degenerated so severely that there are so many babies and infants being abused and traumatised by their parents.
You think child abuse is a new thing?
EishetChayil · 09/01/2022 23:15

most babies abandoned at birth won’t suffer much trauma

Newborns suffer huge trauma being separated from their mother.

Rubyyyy · 09/01/2022 23:13

I would love to adopt but worry I would be turnt down due to CAMHS involvement when I was younger and some ongoing health problems. We have a lot of love to give a child but it’s probably not enough as we don’t own our home ect.

NormaSwilly · 09/01/2022 23:12

My lovely aunt and uncle fostered many, and subsequently adopted 4 children. They specialised in teens and their kids were adopted as teens. Two came from backgrounds of abuse and neglect. My uncle once said he thought maybe they had failed those kids as they lived rather chaotic lives. I pointed out the stability and love they had, what their lives might have been like without my aunt and uncle adopting, and how wonderfully the grandchildren were doing having had Nanny and Pawpaw in their lives as a constant from birth.
The other two are happy and stable. They were a sibling pair whose parents died in a car crash when they were 13 and 15. Their parents had been "ordinary" people who just sadly died. Despite this massive trauma, the good parenting they had always had meant that they have none of the drug and alcohol issues of the two who were neglected and abused in early childhood.
My aunt and uncle have a huge family of children, grandchildren and great grandchildren and the younger two generations escaped the cycle of trauma and abuse because, directly, of them being involved in supporting their adopted children's parenting from day 1.

SmaugMum · 09/01/2022 23:10

[quote CHEM20]@SmaugMum I’m sorry you seem to be having such a hard time of it lately and that it’s causing you so much stress and angst.

I hope you get the help and support you and your daughter need.[/quote]
No, I’m totally not having a hard time of things lately. I wonder what gave you that impression? I continue to deal well with my DD’s challenging behaviours, it’s why we’re a successful adoption so many years on. However, as the parent of a child with a severe disability, I will continue to challenge the very many casual ableist comments and behaviours on this site.

Linning · 09/01/2022 23:02

I think it would be a bit unfortunate to think of all the good arguments you put forward in terms of adoption to then go on to want to adopt a baby. Not that baby shouldn’t be adopted but more so that babies are almost always adopted. So most babies abandoned at birth won’t suffer much trauma (assuming their mom wasn’t addicted to drugs or alcohol and that they are born healthy).
Kids who need adopting are the older ones, the multiple siblings, the disabled kids. Those are the ones who need the extra love (again babies do too but many many people are eager to love on a baby, much less so an older child or a teenager).

I want to adopt. I would want to adopt older kids though (siblings if possible). I love little kids and it would be nice to have my bio one potentially but in terms of adoption I would want to ask for an older child because they deserve so much better than to grow up feeling too old to be loved. I think if you adopt you need to be willing to adopt almost any kid irrelevant of age, sex and origins. I do set a difference with disabilities and health issues as I do think it’s something that requires a specific type of family both in terms of emotional, mental and physical abilities as well as financial capacity but for anything else I think people who focus a lot on the “only babies and ideally only from X country/ies.” a bit suspicious.

Ultimately either you are willing to love on a kid that’s not yours and ready for the challenges that come with it and to love him/her/them through it, including trauma, search for identity and potential bio parents or relatives, potential rejection of you as a parental figure etc… or you are not equipped for it. In this case adopting a baby won’t change much, and probably should overall be avoided and IVF or other conception method preferred.

SmaugMum · 09/01/2022 22:59

This. 👇

NotMeNoNo

Tooshytoshine
I have two adopted children who I love unconditionally and am entirely devoted to.

But fucking hell it's hard work.
Same here, you put it very succinctly 🙂

Can we please ignore the previous 22 pages of bullshit?

Although, I’ll no doubt be accused of trying to speak for every other adopter and then be @-ed with totally pass-agg faux-concern messages from posters who think they’re very clever (but in fact are total last word merchants/control-freaks who can’t bear to be challenged in their thinking.)

CHEM20 · 09/01/2022 22:49

@SmaugMum I’m sorry you seem to be having such a hard time of it lately and that it’s causing you so much stress and angst.

I hope you get the help and support you and your daughter need.

Jellycatspyjamas · 09/01/2022 22:49

*It is a horrendous process. Lots of vetting and classes. You need a good income and lifestyle. If you are very lucky you might get a child under 3.

The older children are the ones that need it most.*

They must have made a mistake with me then. Decidedly average income and lifestyle and while we actively wanted older children the other 6 sets of parents in our group all had children under 2 placed with them.

The process was long because of things in my personal life which were both unforeseen and out of my control but I had a good relationship with my social worker who went above and beyond to support us through the process. It was literally the least stressful thing in my life at the time.

NotMeNoNo · 09/01/2022 22:44

@Tooshytoshine

I have two adopted children who I love unconditionally and am entirely devoted to.

But fucking hell it's hard work.

Same here, you put it very succinctly 🙂
Rupertgrintismyguiltypleasure · 09/01/2022 22:41

I’ve always said I would adopt if I had the funds or space, when I was younger (maybe 10/11) one of my close friends had to be put in care, I always vowed that if I had the money and the space I would adopt. I don’t mind the age. Unfortunately my life didn’t quite pan out how I’ve wanted it, I love my kids to bit and would not change a thing.I think all kids have a right to be loved, to be kids. It makes me sad that there are kids out there that have experienced things people shouldn’t in a lifetime let alone as kids.

stilltiredinthemorning · 09/01/2022 22:33

user1471538283 It is a horrendous process. Lots of vetting and classes. You need a good income and lifestyle. If you are very lucky you might get a child under 3. The older children are the ones that need it most

And we seemed to have looped back to the beginning.... Ho hum.

user1471538283 you seem to be presenting these things as facts. I appreciate they might be your personal experience, but that does not make things universal truths.

I have 2 adopted children. The assessment process was quite pleasant, they were both 6 months old when placed with us (2.5 years apart), we are very average (literally) in terms of our earnings and our lifestyle. Of all the adoptive parents we met during the assessment process (probably about 15) they all adopted children under 12 months.

NovRainbow5 · 09/01/2022 22:23

My mum is a foster carer and has been for 30 years. She adopted 2 children she fostered herself they were 4 and 6. Both with attachment issues, autism and post traumatic stress disorder. It was the best decision she’s ever made although challenging at times.
She mostly has babies placed with her and more often than not they’re adopted. Usually they are less than a week old when placed with her and don’t get adopted until 16month plus.
Social services need to assess the birth parents and any family members that come forward first. This takes a long time. They then need to put it to court and go through the adoption process which can take Even longer. As soon as perspective parents hear that they won’t get a new born baby then it puts them off.

Ifitistobesaid · 09/01/2022 22:21

We have been looking into it due to infertility and recurrent miscarriages but anecdotes like the ones on this thread scare me off. It sounds very hard and sad and I’ve already been through something very hard and sad. I don’t know if I’m up to it.

Jellycatspyjamas · 09/01/2022 22:17

What we actually said was we were considering moving into a bigger house, closer to family in a few years time. No where in the near future. So it all fell through which we found really hard at the time.

That would potentially be very difficult in that an adopted child may not tolerate a house move even a few years post placement. My little boy is really very well adjusted in adoption terms but even now I wouldn’t consider relocating because the impact on him would be awful especially if he needed to change schools and friendships etc. That’s not to say we wouldn’t move if circumstances demanded it, but there would need to be a very compelling reason to do so, one that was worth the risk to his well-being.

Better to have all major moves done before bringing a child into the equation.

user1471538283 · 09/01/2022 22:11

It is a horrendous process. Lots of vetting and classes. You need a good income and lifestyle. If you are very lucky you might get a child under 3.

The older children are the ones that need it most.

JeffThePilot · 09/01/2022 22:11

[quote NorthSouthcatlady]@OldLadyInPolyester oh yes, the madness and control freakery of telling people with fertility issues they have to use contraception Confused Do people actually adhere or just nod and smile, then secretly decline to do that[/quote]
There are reasons they are told to use contraception. Imagine adopting a child who may have attachment difficulties and trauma, then as the placement order is made you find out you’re pregnant. Imagine the potential impact on the adopted child of that scenario.

Social workers don’t put these rules in place for shits and giggles.

daisymade · 09/01/2022 22:09

There is something about growing and carrying your own child. I'd have absolutely considered adoption if I couldn't have carried my own. But even with the miscarriages and perhaps because of the miscarriages, it was a very important part of becoming a parent for me, and one I still look back on quite often.

cravingmilkshake · 09/01/2022 22:06

Our friend couldn't have babies and single... whole process took 4 years ... on the uk it's insane ! The whole process from interviews to actually getting the baby !