Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why more people don't adopt?

706 replies

adoptionthoughts · 09/01/2022 11:55

Recently I've started thinking maybe adoption is a route for me. I've always said I wouldn't do it but recently I'm having a change of heart as I think about it and logically it makes a lot of sense for a variety of reasons.

I'm struggling TTC, but this is something I'm thinking about irrespective of whether or not I eventually manage to have biological kids.

I also think giving a child a life they may not have otherwise had is a really nice thing. Also, why add to a climate change problem when there are so so many children I wanted across the world - the more I think about it the more logically adoption makes lots of sense. It means you don't get the physical problems from childbirth, it means you are providing a life for a child that may have been in foster care and many other positives.

Am I being naive? Why does hardly anyone do it? Why are we only happy with children if it's related to us by blood? I'm not trying to be funny here I'm genuinely asking to see why to see if I'm crazy to consider it.

I appreciate the children up for adoption often come from trauma often, which is concerning in terms of how that trauma may play out in later life but I'd likely want a very small baby (not saying this eradicates this but I think is reducing the risk). And also, the same can happen with biological kids you never know how they will turn out.

I'd like to hear from not just those that have adopted but also those that haven't and wouldn't as to why?

OP posts:
stilltiredinthemorning · 10/01/2022 17:19

tearsandtiaras I'm pretty shocked you work in fostering and adoption and would call someone 'stupid' for asking a question. I'm glad the professionals I worked with exercised a bit more empathy and understanding otherwise I doubt we'd have our two wonderful children now.

I find it pretty bloody insulting that you are dismissing the genuine reports of adoptive parents and adoptees as 'skimming over serious consequences'. We're living those consequences every day, but we're still able to give a balanced view.

I certainly hope you don't tell any children you work with they're 'damaged' - I honestly thought we'd moved past such inappropriate language, especially in those who should know better.

Eleganz · 10/01/2022 15:51

My friends have adopted and we acted as "references" during the process. It was difficult and drawn out with lots of spanners thrown in the works along the way. I can completely understand why people are put off by it. There does seem to be, on occasions a hunt for problems rather than just highlighting genuine concerns. Random, detailed questions about decades old fully recovered from medical conditions was one example.

Perhaps it was just my friend's situation but even after getting approved it seemed really tough as they were lined up with a number of children who did not end up coming to them at the last minute for one reason or another beyond their control (some of which seemed to simply be down to disorganisation), which was very distressing for them.

Of course, it did work out for them in the end and their children are lovely (but do have issues related to the trauma they have experienced), but if they hadn't been so resilient or things had taken even longer it might not have.

I understand fully that we need to make sure that potential adoptive parents are up to the mark, but there were times that I felt that disorganisation and pointless second-guessing were dominating proceedings and causing undue stress.

tearsandtiaras · 10/01/2022 15:39

Yes I work in adoption and fostering and have for several years

Nothing in my message suggests any child is unloveable. Please don't gas light.

I questioned the OP's motives to adopt with her naïve views on trauma.

Unfortunately this skim over serious consequences and issues and what a lot of other posters have said is what we see all the time.

OP Please don't ask strangers on the internet for advice . Contact your local adoption agency or local authority

Jannt86 · 10/01/2022 14:41

*adopted mine as a baby not birth sorry x

Jannt86 · 10/01/2022 14:40

There's a lot of misinformation on here. Yes babies can and are adopted and LA's work hard to ensure that if it's obvious that a child is unlikely to be safely returned to their birth family that they're offered permanence asap. My daughter came to us at 9MO and was with a lovely foster family from a few days old. However it's very naive to assume that a child who's adopted as a baby won't have any problems. One of my biggest bugbears is people informing me that because I adopted mine at birth she won't have any issues. For a start alcohol and drug use can have a severe impact on a baby's brain. Birth mothers do not always fully disclose substance misuse and even if they do the true impact on baby may not be apparent for years. In addition to this even a newborn baby has at the very least suffered the trauma of being removed from their primal bond. I think to say all adopted children are 'damaged' is wrong and insulting but I don't think it's catastrophising at all to say that they are all traumatised. We simply don't know how this will show itself. The brain is a fascinating thing. We still don't know why some Romanian orphans, for example, emerge from their experience relatively unscathed where others are left with severe and permanent disabilities. What I think is fair to say though is that trauma WILL show itself in all adoptees whether it be in a big way or a less obvious way. It doesn't mean by any means that people shouldn't adopt but perhaps they shouldn't adopt if they aren't prepared to accept this reality...

SallyWD · 10/01/2022 14:39

Me and DH almost split up because he wasn't sure he wanted children. I was seriously considering going it alone as a single mother and adopting a child. I have such a strong maternal instinct that I couldn't imagine life without children. I have to admit I found the prospect pretty scary. You say you can adopt a baby who hasn't been abused so doesn't have issues but actually so much damage is often done in the womb. The children up for adoption in the UK are often the children of drug/alcohol addict parents and some (maybe many)are being harmed from the moment they're conceived. I also feel that you may adopt a child who appears perfectly healthy, mentally and physically but problems arise after many years. This happened to a family member of mine. I won't go in to details but let's just say the lives of the adoptive parents are extremely stressful and miserable now. The child they adopted (seemingly perfectly "normal") is now in her 40s but they still can't live a normal life because of her. I hope I don't sound heartless. Of course these damaged kids need homes more than anyone. Thank God for the people who are willing to love them and home them. I also know exactly the same issues can arise with your own biological children. I don't feel I have the mental fortitude to raise a child with severe problems. I wish I did! My DH and I now have 2 children so I'm no longer considering adoption but it's still definitely something I would have looked in to had we split, despite my worries.

DeepaBeesKit · 10/01/2022 14:38

The bond a child has with its biological mother cannot be underestimated and to lose that - even if the biological mother is abusive - is a life long open wound for a lot of adoptees, no matter how engaged and loving the adoptive parents are

And that bond is formed very early on, well before a child can remember or communicate. People on here talk about adopting babies of 8 or 15m etc as if that means they are too young to have such bonds.... no! Those bonds are there in tiny, tiny babies. It's why prem babies (like mine) are often calmest when held skin to skin against their mother - on a basic level her heartbeat is something they recognise. It's an innate thing.

ConstanceL · 10/01/2022 14:34

Our closest friends adopted two siblings one as a small baby, the other way two. Our friends are wonderful parents, always reading up and going on course to make sure they have the skills to parents their children well, but nevertheless both girls have an attachment disorder which is hard for the whole family.

The bond a child has with its biological mother cannot be underestimated and to lose that - even if the biological mother is abusive - is a life long open wound for a lot of adoptees, no matter how engaged and loving the adoptive parents are.

OP search #adopteevoices on Twitter if you really want to educate yourself.

DeepaBeesKit · 10/01/2022 14:33

I think a lot of people on this thread have got flack for honesty.

I dont think it's bad to admit that part of what you love about your bio kids is your shared genetics, knowing they have grown physically from you. I know I would struggle more to bond with a child not biologically related to me - I love seeing little things about my DS and DD (both bio) that are so like DH and I or our family members, I feel a sense of understanding of certain personality traits we share etc.i suppose it's just....familiarity. For me personally it helps that my bond with DS and DD has been easy from day 1, they are totally secure with me. I know that's not true of everyone but it's just how it works for me.

Nothing but respect for adopters but I don't think I would be suited.

IncorrigibleTitmouse · 10/01/2022 14:30

@AnonymousAdopter Really appreciate your context as an adopter. I was just sharing the experience I recently went through with friends in response to the question of why more people don't adopt. They did adopt small babies, perhaps that's why they were FTA. I completely agree that all background screening is necessary, I was just sharing what that entailed for my friends.

crosstalk · 10/01/2022 14:29

@Thunderbolte - since you and your husband are both so intelligent and beautiful you must know about "going to the mean" means.

Ted27 · 10/01/2022 14:27

@stilltiredinthemorning

perfect summary - and unfortunately the way all these threads go

I wish people would post these on the Adoption board, they would still get a range of experiences from adopters.

MeredithGreyishblue · 10/01/2022 14:11

@Whatafustercluck

I wouldn't have a clue who in our dc's schools are adopted. Unless stated by the parents, nobody would know.

But in relation to additional needs, adopted or not, you definitely have a point. I am always having these kinds of conversations with 11yo ds around inclusivity and understanding. One of his best friends is autistic and he's got into arguments with other kids defending him from them. He always includes him in his plans, but always understands on the days his friend just wants to play alone. He keeps an eye out for him and notices when he's struggling.

5yo dd is neuro diverse. I am already seeing her being put into the 'naughty' box and we, as parents, put into the 'bad parenting' box. It's so sad. She has so much to offer, she's utterly brilliant.

A really good point. I know of two adopted children in my DS's school because of shared experience of the school's woeful sen provision.

There may well be lots of other adopted children there that I wouldn't know about because, well, why would I? Its my skewed view because I have only had contact with parents of the children who have additional needs and not the ones who don't.

That's given me food for thought. Thank you. Sometimes MN is balanced and helpful after all.

stilltiredinthemorning · 10/01/2022 12:59

Moonopoly I couldn't agree more. @tearsandtiaras have you actually read any of this thread at all?? If not I'll summarise:

Step 1:OP asks why more people don't adopt
Step 2: A bunch of people jump on to say (as if it's fact) that the assessment process is basically inhumane, there are never any babies available for adoption, adopted children are 'damaged' or 'broken'. The OP is, at best, naive.
Step 3. A bunch of actual adopters, adoptees and relevant professionals jump on to say that much of the information that has been presented as fact, is actually innaccurate, over-blown and in some cases deeply offensive
Step 4. A bunch of people jump on to say (as if it's fact) that the assessment process is basically inhumane, there are never any babies available for adoption, adopted children are 'damaged' or 'broken'. and the OP is, at best, naive.

Arrrrrrrrggggggghhhhhhhhh!!!!

Moonopoly · 10/01/2022 12:37

For all those saying ‘babies aren’t available for adoption’ in my experience this simply isn’t true. Whilst there may be more older children looking to be matched there are also (sadly) many babies removed at birth/very early on.

@tearsandtiaras your tone is pretty judgemental and implies that children who have experienced those things are somehow broken and not worthy of loving parents. I have an adopted child who has experienced some of the things you mentioned. It doesn’t make him awful to parent infact in someways he is easier than my birth child.
How you are speaking to OP really isn’t okay. Do you have direct experience of adoption?

Whatafustercluck · 10/01/2022 12:24

Sorry that last point was in response to @AnonymousAdopter. Quote failure.

My earlier response at 12.12 was to @scully29

Whatafustercluck · 10/01/2022 12:21

I wouldn't have a clue who in our dc's schools are adopted. Unless stated by the parents, nobody would know.

But in relation to additional needs, adopted or not, you definitely have a point. I am always having these kinds of conversations with 11yo ds around inclusivity and understanding. One of his best friends is autistic and he's got into arguments with other kids defending him from them. He always includes him in his plans, but always understands on the days his friend just wants to play alone. He keeps an eye out for him and notices when he's struggling.

5yo dd is neuro diverse. I am already seeing her being put into the 'naughty' box and we, as parents, put into the 'bad parenting' box. It's so sad. She has so much to offer, she's utterly brilliant.

tearsandtiaras · 10/01/2022 12:19

What do you mean a small baby eradicates some of the trauma risk of an older child?

If the baby is removed at birth in which case its highly likely to have been conceived / grown to a drug addict mother ( which has long term consequences to a babies development) - check out fetal alcohol syndrome.

Otherwise the baby will have been removed throughout the formative first months of its life- having potentially suffered lack of food, sleep , warmth, cuddles, and potentially been subject to violence perpetrated upon them both physically and or sexually.

You are naive and stupid to think that just because a baby is a baby there is not long term trauma and reduction in development and meeting milestones.

Babies that are given up for adoption by parents that make that decision themselves are more often than not adopted via special guardianship by a kinship carer associated with the family.

Yes there are exceptions.

Do some proper research- not television programmes- ring adoption agencies or your local authority.

Whatafustercluck · 10/01/2022 12:12

I think part of the problem is that the quality of the adoption process is such a postcode lottery. Dsis had nothing but good things to say about the social care team. The process itself was as expected, the professionals involved were excellent. But her support from the LA disappeared as soon as she adopted her sons. Communication with the local authority was terrible, she faced continual chasing, she was left to her own devices fighting their corner medically, educationally and for the support they all, as a family, needed. I don't think this experience is uncommon.

AnonymousAdopter · 10/01/2022 12:06

Branleuse I know.
Some (not most or all, but a significant minority) parents on MN are all for kindness and inclusion. Until it comes to inviting anyone other than 15 'close friends' to a party, or a play date, or even a game at break, or working with in the classroom. Then it turns into 'my child should be allowed to interact with whoever they want' or 'my child will be ostracized if they invite Z'.

Branleuse · 10/01/2022 12:02

@AnonymousAdopter

While you are helping adopted children, try a bit of compassion when they end up in your child's class at school too. They don't have to be best buddies, but a bit of inclusion wouldn't go amiss. Mine were well behaved and 'a pleasure to teach' but because they presented a bit younger and 'quirky' were often left out or suffered a drip drip of negative comments.
thats unfortunately any kid with additional needs. Made to feel that theyre just not great people
Frenchfurze · 10/01/2022 11:51

@AnonymousAdopter

While you are helping adopted children, try a bit of compassion when they end up in your child's class at school too. They don't have to be best buddies, but a bit of inclusion wouldn't go amiss. Mine were well behaved and 'a pleasure to teach' but because they presented a bit younger and 'quirky' were often left out or suffered a drip drip of negative comments.
I think that's fair. I know when he was younger, I had to have a couple of talks with my five/six year old DS about a child in his class who he experienced as disruptive and rather frightening, but who was also an adopted child with significant additional needs.
AnonymousAdopter · 10/01/2022 11:47

While you are helping adopted children, try a bit of compassion when they end up in your child's class at school too. They don't have to be best buddies, but a bit of inclusion wouldn't go amiss. Mine were well behaved and 'a pleasure to teach' but because they presented a bit younger and 'quirky' were often left out or suffered a drip drip of negative comments.

YetAnotherProcrastinator · 10/01/2022 11:35

[quote Jellycatspyjamas]@YetAnotherProcrastinator I hear you, after we adopted I realised how many Disney movies feature kids who have been adopted or are care experienced too - sitting with my newly placed children. In some ways it’s given space to talk about different families and what makes a family but it was hard for them to see their lives portrayed as less than ideal. We’ve not got to the “adopted serial killer” stage yet but I’m very aware of it.

My two were older in adoption terms and are the most fantastic, happy, smart kids - I push back hard against the idea that they are “damaged” by their experiences. Yes they are impacted by their past, but aren’t we all? They are resilient and have coped with so much with more grace than many adults I know. They both see adoption as something positive in their lives and are good kids.[/quote]
I like the use of "impacted" rather than "damaged". That is how I would describe its effect on me - just as I've been impacted by many other things non-care or adoption related too.

And some of that impact is actually really positive!

Separate point - I'm thinking about real-life conversations I've been witness to now, but I do dislike my supposed plight as a child being used to make people suffering fertility issues feel bad. I doubt that anyone suffering the awful thing that is unwanted infertility has actually not heard of adoption, and it is not their responsibility to solve the problem 9f children in care. They're not doing anything wrong by choosing not go down that route.

The best thing anyone can do to help children in care and and potential adoptees is not to guilt people into adoption, but campaign for better funding and support for foster carers, adoptive families, care leavers, kinship carers, and those in residential homes and with struggling birth families - and all who work with them.

YetAnotherProcrastinator · 10/01/2022 11:15

@stilltiredinthemorning

YetAnotherProcrastinator Hell yes to the TV stuff! I really like crime drama (TV and books) but honestly it's so ridiculous how many times the murderer/rapist etc. turns out to be care experienced! I try not to get upset about it now and figure the writers just really need to get a better imagination (me and my husband play 'adoption crime bingo' when watching TV dramas series and if I've been watching something he hasn't he'll say, don't tell me.... the adopted kid did it?

It makes me sad that this is the depiction my children will grow up seeing. Just once I'd love to see a programme/read a book where there's some children who are looked after or adopted and it turns out to be a bit of irrelevant character background, like they enjoy eating pizza or their first car was a red mini. It always has to be a 'thing'

We do and say the same when we watch TV! Once you see it you can't unsee it. It's very lazy writing imo and adoption or care experience is used in place of an actual explained and explored motivation. It's funny because people would rightly be cross if TV show after TV show portrayed LGBT people, Jewish people, black people, Irish people etc as messed up murderers. But with adoptees it's OK for them to be almost universally negatively portrayed?!