Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why more people don't adopt?

706 replies

adoptionthoughts · 09/01/2022 11:55

Recently I've started thinking maybe adoption is a route for me. I've always said I wouldn't do it but recently I'm having a change of heart as I think about it and logically it makes a lot of sense for a variety of reasons.

I'm struggling TTC, but this is something I'm thinking about irrespective of whether or not I eventually manage to have biological kids.

I also think giving a child a life they may not have otherwise had is a really nice thing. Also, why add to a climate change problem when there are so so many children I wanted across the world - the more I think about it the more logically adoption makes lots of sense. It means you don't get the physical problems from childbirth, it means you are providing a life for a child that may have been in foster care and many other positives.

Am I being naive? Why does hardly anyone do it? Why are we only happy with children if it's related to us by blood? I'm not trying to be funny here I'm genuinely asking to see why to see if I'm crazy to consider it.

I appreciate the children up for adoption often come from trauma often, which is concerning in terms of how that trauma may play out in later life but I'd likely want a very small baby (not saying this eradicates this but I think is reducing the risk). And also, the same can happen with biological kids you never know how they will turn out.

I'd like to hear from not just those that have adopted but also those that haven't and wouldn't as to why?

OP posts:
Fromtheground · 11/01/2022 14:10

We wanted to adopt and after TTC unsuccessfully for several years started the process. Everything was going well until they asked who would be staying at home with the child/children. When we explained we both planned to work we were told categorically that if we both worked we would never get a child placed with us. I know people who have adopted who both worked but in every case their finances meant they could afford for one to give up work if necessary. That wouldn't have been an option for us and I imagine it isn't for a lot of people. I'm sure this isn't the case everywhere, but we were told this by 2 different LAs. It is really not easy to adopt

ivfbabymomma1 · 11/01/2022 13:19

@sweetbellyhigh it's funny because I didn't feel any of this really or think about it until I had my own son and then I realised I have never had this bond with anyone before absolutely no one. It's something I feel I have never experienced like a really deep connection which I guess is normal for most people

scully29 · 11/01/2022 12:47

yes, my dd is perfect too!

2old2beamum · 11/01/2022 12:43

Subulter we have adopted 8 and only one was removed for his own safety. The others were relinquished at birth due to medical conditions. The loveliest people I have ever met, we have been so lucky.

sunshineandskyscrapers · 11/01/2022 12:31

@keke95LND
Also there's no such thing as a 'perfect baby/Chiild' when it comes to adoption

You haven't met my son obviously. Seriously though is there such a thing as a perfect child anyway? My son (adopted) is perfect in my eyes at least.

Subulter · 11/01/2022 12:30

@Jellycatspyjamas

Because adoption is essentially about giving a the poor abandoned kid a loving home.

@Subulter the vast majority of children placed for adoption aren’t abandoned - they’ve been purposely removed from parent who for many varied reasons can’t care for them. They are usually loved and wanted, but parents don’t have the capacity to care for them.

Ohm I get this I was responding to a poster who seemed to have a saviour fantasy. I'm not an adopter, but have several now-adult godchildren whose adoptions I remember I've no doubt they were loved in most cases, but by parents whose addictions or MH issues made it impossible for them to give them safe or stable lives.
Keke94LND · 11/01/2022 12:22

My dads cousin and her husband are very well off and lovely, they couldn't have kids and adopted 2, a boy and a girl, they were both very small babies when they were adopted, the daughter is mid teens now and she has a lot a lot a lot of issues which stems from things that happened when she was a very small baby that she won't even remember now, but it still effects her, just something to be mindful of, just because it's a very small baby doesn't mean it hasn't suffered long lasting traumas. Also there's no such thing as a 'perfect baby/Chiild' when it comes to adoption

AllThePogs · 11/01/2022 11:58

It obviously depends on the individual situation. I know a woman with a severe eating disorder who had her kids removed. She was basically starving her kids. She does see them once a month. Because although they were at real risk if living with her, they do benefit from seeing her regularly. She is their mum and loves them and they love her.

Simonjt · 11/01/2022 11:56

closed adoptions are all about the adoptive parents.

They’re really not, we attempted some contact with birth mum, the trauma that caused my son was awful, it got to the point where he would just be in freeze around her, he didn’t move, speak, eat or drink, once sessions ended he would be physically sick, he would scream, hit and kick. It would take him a good three weeks to sleep through the night again, it would take days for him to eat properly. We would then have one good week until it was contact yet again. It was really the only time we used the car, he then started being sick the moment he was in the car and he would scream for the entire journey, it wasn’t a quick journey, it was multiple hours.

Ted27 · 11/01/2022 11:53

@sweetbellyhigh

Do you think that if Arthur or Star had survived the actions of their parents, it would have been beneficial to them to have had ongoing contact with their abusers ?

Notmenotme · 11/01/2022 11:50

If @sweetbellyhigh is writing a feature length article I hope you don’t include tripe like that.

How offensive and ridiculous!!

Do you not understand why children are adopted? The threshold is incredibly high!!

Have you read the news recently? If the level of abuse is so high you would like children to maintain contact with the very people who have abused them???

But thanks so much for the judgement and potentially spreading the judgement to others with your feature length article!

sunshineandskyscrapers · 11/01/2022 11:45

@jannt86
That's absolute bollocks about open vs closed adoptions.
Thank you. That's what I was hinting at.

@sweetbellyhigh you're not even using the terminology correctly, and if I understand correctly you have no first hand experience of adoption?

Jellycatspyjamas · 11/01/2022 11:40

Closed adoptions are for the benefit of the adoptive parent, and play into the fantasy of acquiring a child with "a clean slate".

Given my kids were 4 and 6 when placed, there’s no clean slate fantasy happening here , just the knowledge that my kids would be actively harmed by direct contact with their birth mum.

Jellycatspyjamas · 11/01/2022 11:38

Mine is of investigating this issue for a feature article.

Excellent, you’ll know much more then that adoptive parents or someone with 25+ years experience in child protection. Open adoption can be incredibly harmful for children and in some cases very dangerous. Each case on a case by case basis.

Jellycatspyjamas · 11/01/2022 11:36

Because adoption is essentially about giving a the poor abandoned kid a loving home.

@Subulter the vast majority of children placed for adoption aren’t abandoned - they’ve been purposely removed from parent who for many varied reasons can’t care for them. They are usually loved and wanted, but parents don’t have the capacity to care for them.

Jannt86 · 11/01/2022 11:34

That's absolute bollocks about open vs closed adoptions. I would gladly allow my AD to have contact with her BPs IF I felt it was in her interest. However they had contact with her whilst she was in her foster care and either didn't turn up to said contact or turned up and were more interest in talking to each other. They've also had letters every year since we adopted her and not bothered writing back to a single one. I'm absolutely for open contact with the right parents but only if it's safe and beneficial. I hold no resentment towards my daughter's BP's but sorry 18 years of flakiness and apathy are not going to benefit my daughter and are simply not worth the security risk. They've had more than enough chance to show her that they care

sweetbellyhigh · 11/01/2022 11:34

[quote sunshineandskyscrapers]@sweetbellyhigh

Open adoptions are all about the child, closed adoptions are all about the adoptive parents.

Would you like to explain what you mean by this as it doesn't reflect my experience at all.[/quote]
What is your experience?

Mine is of investigating this issue for a feature article.

The resounding message was that open adoptions are the way forward.

Closed adoptions are for the benefit of the adoptive parent, and play into the fantasy of acquiring a child with "a clean slate".

But of course all of us have our own stories when we arrive into this world, and open adoptions acknowledge the importance of respecting this.

sunshineandskyscrapers · 11/01/2022 11:22

@sweetbellyhigh

Open adoptions are all about the child, closed adoptions are all about the adoptive parents.

Would you like to explain what you mean by this as it doesn't reflect my experience at all.

Hankunamatata · 11/01/2022 11:05

My dear late friend was a foster carer. She always took teens as she was classified disabled and couldn't get up in the morning due to her condition. She made such a difference to so many lives as her teens often stayed until they were 18+ when they then got their own places or went to uni.

She fostered primary age child with long term intention to adopt, she had her chronic condition under control in mornings and a taxi took the child to school. Unfortunately by the time she was end primary she was still smearing her bedroom walls, wouldn't talk to any adult about her past after years of therapy and was still having authorised contact with the drug addicted mother - therapist though this was why she wouldn't open up about past abuse, ss know she was sexual abused by at least two of her mothers partners. The child ended up going back into the system. I do wonder if they had cut all contact the child may have recovered more

sweetbellyhigh · 11/01/2022 11:00

*story

sweetbellyhigh · 11/01/2022 10:59

There was a sorry today about a very young mother who died soon after giving birth. The photographs of her holding her BEAUTIFUL little boy are just heartbreaking. That baby is undoubtedly adored and cherished by his mother's family, and his loss will be offset by his connection with grandparents, but it will also colour his every moment , a child who only got a few weeks with his mother.

sweetbellyhigh · 11/01/2022 10:57

@ivfbabymomma1

Of course you do and it actually makes me feel quite angry when people assume that babies "don't remember" or "are nut affected".

You only have to see a newborn with their mother to see the extraordinary bond. For that to be severed can only be traumatic. Just because the baby cannot articulate their distress or grief does not mean they are not feeling it. Of course they do.

At least with open adoptions the child knows where they come from, good or bad. Open adoptions are all about the child, closed adoptions are all about the adoptive parents.

Jannt86 · 11/01/2022 10:35

It always makes me laugh that people who've never adopted nor have any intention to adopt are the first to lecture people on how they shouldn't be so selfish and selective. It's not materialistic to choose the child who you think you could offer the best life to. Would I love a severely disabled child or a child with severe emotional difficulties any less, absolutely not! Do I commit to prioritising my child if such problems weren't obvious initially but then arise? absolutely. Would I quit my job to support this child? You bet! But would I CHOOSE to turn my back on a career I've spent years studying towards and care for a child with complex needs that I have virtually no experience with? Quite possibly in place of people who DO have vast experience in these areas. NO! This would lack pragmatism and actually quite a selfish thing to do as I likely couldn't give this child the support they need as effectively as some other adopters despite my hero complex. It's prudent not materialistic or selfish to be honest with yourself about which children you can give the best life to. Believe me most people with half a heart want to take every child in care home with them when they see their profiles but they know it's simply not possible

MRSAHILL · 11/01/2022 10:24

You have to be realistic when adopting about what situations/backgrounds you can and cannot cope with, to avoid the adoption potentially breaking down. There is nothing materialistic about it, it's just being realistic. There is no room for altruism in adoption, that's one of the first things our social worker told us. To people who were adopted as babies but still grew up feeling detached from their adoptive families, that is a very sad situation, but what is the answer? Would those people have preferred to be brought up in a children's home instead of being adopted?

AnonymousAdopter · 11/01/2022 07:21

It is only sensible for adopters to think what they can or cannot cope with. It isn't the same as a birth child because here you are making an active choice to bring a child with specific known issues into the family.

Adopters have different skills and backgrounds, some might feel they couldn't cope with e.g. a child born as result of rape (eg if they were raped themselves previously) where as others might feel that wouldn't be an issue for them. You have to be able to talk to your child about their life story.

It does no one any good to place a child with a family who can't cope.

Swipe left for the next trending thread