Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why more people don't adopt?

706 replies

adoptionthoughts · 09/01/2022 11:55

Recently I've started thinking maybe adoption is a route for me. I've always said I wouldn't do it but recently I'm having a change of heart as I think about it and logically it makes a lot of sense for a variety of reasons.

I'm struggling TTC, but this is something I'm thinking about irrespective of whether or not I eventually manage to have biological kids.

I also think giving a child a life they may not have otherwise had is a really nice thing. Also, why add to a climate change problem when there are so so many children I wanted across the world - the more I think about it the more logically adoption makes lots of sense. It means you don't get the physical problems from childbirth, it means you are providing a life for a child that may have been in foster care and many other positives.

Am I being naive? Why does hardly anyone do it? Why are we only happy with children if it's related to us by blood? I'm not trying to be funny here I'm genuinely asking to see why to see if I'm crazy to consider it.

I appreciate the children up for adoption often come from trauma often, which is concerning in terms of how that trauma may play out in later life but I'd likely want a very small baby (not saying this eradicates this but I think is reducing the risk). And also, the same can happen with biological kids you never know how they will turn out.

I'd like to hear from not just those that have adopted but also those that haven't and wouldn't as to why?

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 09/01/2022 12:45

@adoptionthoughts

I didn't post on the adoption board because I'm looking for opinions for people generally on why they do/don't adopt
Because it's (rightfully) a long hard process Because you rarely end up with a cute baby Because the children who really need adopting have either had a really difficult start to life or they have some form of disability Because sometimes you get a child who's had lots of trauma and there's insufficient support

And people don't think they could cope

DrSbaitso · 09/01/2022 12:45

Since you didn't intend to do it for a long time, you must know some reasons why people don't want to.

MimiDaisy11 · 09/01/2022 12:45

It does seem tough. For me it’s the fact there’s a lot out of your control. You go jump through all the hoops and then get a child assigned to you but there’s a period of time you have to spend with the child before it’s official and what if you have an attachment and then it’s decided the child isn’t to be with you anymore. Also I’ve read accounts on here about people failing to succeed with ivf and then going to adopt. They get turned down for adoption and it’s yet more failure and rejection but this time it’s not just biological luck but an official examining your life and saying you’re not fit to be a parent. Must hurt.

I did look into it a little and now lots of agencies mention sibling adoptions so it’s quite common to adopt more than one which is a challenge. Like others say healthy babies are rare. I knew someone at uni who found out they were pregnant a 5 months and planned to put their baby up for adoption but when they were born they decided against it. I imagine that’s often the case and most babies are from homes with issues.

LightDrizzle · 09/01/2022 12:45

Echoing that very, very few tiny babies are available for adoption in the U.K. The emphasis is on keeping mother and baby together with support.

Babies removed from birth will have a very elevated risk of FAS and/ or other issues related to exposure to drugs in utero. They will be placed in foster care, probably for months, before any adoption process will be considered. You won’t get a tiny baby unless there are exceptional circumstances such as the baby being close family and even then there would be hoops and a lengthy process.

We have friends who were able to adopt two very young children; they were still under two by the time they moved in. They are lovely children but the girl does have some additional needs that were not discernible when younger. Of course our friends knew this could be the case. These additional needs are manageable and don’t negate the joy she brings to the family.

Another friend was adopted herself with her two siblings. She was the youngest at under two. All three have struggled although she has struggled least as the youngest and has achieved material success. Her elder siblings have struggled in a way that must have caused their (adopted) parents so much heartache. Their parents are by all accounts lovely but their two biological children have not had the problems their three adopted children have had. The children suffered extreme neglect before they were removed from their birth mum. We know neglect can cause permanent damage unfortunately. It’s tragic.

Until the mid 1970’s unmarried mothers were still often encouraged and even coerced into giving up their children for adoption, so you did get small healthy babies available. The process was also probably a lot less vigorous. In other countries poverty and lack of welfare support for single mothers means that more babies are available for adoption.

I used to think I might adopt a child with a disability after doing work experience at a residential facility attached to a special school, however my second child has profound disabilities so I had enough on my plate.

Adopting a child or baby is almost invariably a very different prospect to deciding to conceive one yourself. I wouldn’t put any one off, but I would urge them to do a lot of research and talk to a lot of people.

Nailsbythesea · 09/01/2022 12:44

I have had friends -decent people who have gone down the adoption route -two couple both really wanted children and couldn't have their own found the endless interviews too gruelling. One -her husband his personal interview was on the anniversary of his dad's death -he asked for it to be moved -and it was declined. They then wanted to go over and over his dad's death in the interview and why it was still effecting him 10 years later -they advised multiple sessions of counselling -he did them and then they said he clearly wasn't able to move on completely from his dad's death -he told his wife he was out and she felt the same.

Another at couple at the time she said in interview that she had issues in her past with her weight and had done counselling, seen a nutritionist, been on a diet programme -now in a healthy range -and runs x5 times a week and maintains -they said they were concerned she was 'too interested in her weight' yet -they bought it up. Again she stopped.

Never mind being on anti depressants or being divorced or having issues in your family -etc

I did know one couple that adopted 3 -aged 7,9 and 11. The 11 year old went of the rails quickly, smoking, drinking etc as soon as the adoption went through -they was NO support, NO social help at all -it was 'they are your children you deal with it' eventually the 11 year old was having sex at school and accused them of abuse -she went back into care- they struggled to adapt to the two children with one in care -both the younger two children are doing well -but their lives are in tatters from the 5 years of hell the eldest put them through........

Many reasons why people don't adopt.

Some friends of mine -young grandparents themselves. Took custody of two boys that were his nieces -after she went to prison for drug offences. They said they will never adopt the boys -as they won't get support they get about £30,000 a year for the boys to look after them which pays for holidays and luxuries -but it's not means tested and they are reasonably well off. But they have funding for them. They are doing a good job -but they do have carers in place -the boys have high SEN needs etc

Arethechildreninbedyet · 09/01/2022 12:44

Jesus Christ OP, please do an excessive amount of research before you adopt. You sound extremely naive.

This isn’t going to be you walk into a hospital, pick up a babe in arms and walk out and live happily ever after with your perfect little baby who will spend their life being indebted to your decision to take them in.

You will be very unlikely to get a little baby and if you do that baby will have had an extremely traumatic start in life, it is statistically very rare that children are willingly given for adoption at birth. If they are it will be due to a court order due to existing issues with the birth parents. This could be a history of neglect and abuse with previous children, substance/alcohol abuse, domestic abuse etc, mental health issues. That will all affect that child and it’s development. A great, great number of children also end up back in the foster care system as something like half of adoptions do not work out.

The reason more people don’t adopt is because it is a very complicated procedure and many do not have the emotional wherewithal to become parents to adoptive children.

An adoptive child is more likely to experience addiction and alcoholism, more likely to leave education before the age of 18, more likely to have a criminal record, mental health issues, developmental delays, attachment issues etc. This is not because of poor parenting from adoptive parents but due to the early childhood trauma they have experienced.

To say you would be prepared there might be trauma and you appreciate this may affect them says you really have very little insight into the care system/adoption process. Adoption is traumatic, removal from the birth family is traumatic, the care system and separation from siblings/grandparents/parents etc is traumatic, entering a stranger’s home and being expected to instantly love them/like them is traumatic. Everything surrounding adoption is interwoven with trauma and that is what puts many parents off adopting.

Consider fostering for a few years before beginning an adoption journey or at least speak with multiple adoptive parents of different ages because this will not be a simple pick a baby up and crack on.

Adoption is a wonderful process when it is successful and I have nothing but respect for people who make the decision to adopt a child it is a dedication that affects all aspects of life in more complicated ways than a biological child would and personally that is not something I could commit to already having children in the house.

Your approach to this hasn’t settled well with me, it’s coming across quite pious.

‘Why don’t more people adopt?’ Why don’t you want an eleven year old who experienced infant drug withdrawal, extreme developmental delays and is undergoing therapy and anger management whilst trying to maintain a relationship with four siblings from whom they have been separated? That is a more accurate depiction of children sitting in foster care needing to be adopted.

MRSAHILL · 09/01/2022 12:44

Forgot to mention but we weren't well off. We lived in a 2 bed semi in the North West. Only had a couple of grand savings, average earners etc Dh was only 2 years into remission from cancer (chemo resulted in infertility) and I've always been a bit overweight. Also, it was 2nd marriage for me but that didn't cause any problems. We were honest with Social Workers about what type of child, with what types of needs, background etc we felt we could cope with, sounds harsh but honesty on both sides is crucial to a successful adoption. Our son did have some special needs but they were ones we felt confident at being able to deal with. A neighbour who adopted at the same time suffered a heartbreaking adoption breakdown, due to having a child placed with them who they were totally out of their depth to deal with. I knew there were people out there better equipped than us to adopt children with certain special needs and we were honest from the start about what we felt we were able to cope with and our Social Worker listened to us.

raspberrymuffin · 09/01/2022 12:44

@wheresmymojo is that a blanket rule about bipolar? I had assumed DH's bipolar would be something we'd need to discuss if we went down that route but didn't realise it would be an automatic no.

Nickwinkle · 09/01/2022 12:44

Been struggling TC for 6 years now. Many people have suggested adoption to me and it's a huge no.

There's nothing wrong with adoption. People who are able to take in other people's children and treat them as their own and provide a life for them that they never would've had are absolute saints but it's not for everyone. You've got to take other things in to consideration;

  1. Some people aren't maternal. Pregnancy gives the chance to get that maternal bond. I for one do not go 'goo goo' at babies so adopting would make me feel weird around said kid. Not a given, but not a chance I'm willing to take.
  2. The reason for wanting a child in the first place. I'd like a child that was half me and half my partner, something we created together and that's going to leave our legacy in this world. I don't want a baby just as something to dress up and take to play dates.
  3. I want the joy of seeing a positive test, watching my baby grow and feel it kicking inside me. Why should I be denied this to bring up someone elses child and 'be happy with that.'?

To each their own - nothing wrong with adopting OP and if that's the choice you and your partner want then go for it and f*ck what everyone else thinks :)

GoGoGretaDoll · 09/01/2022 12:44

Overseas adoption is even more difficult than UK adoption - as it absolutely should be. It's colonial AF, risks contributing directly to exploitation and gives me the ick on every level.

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 09/01/2022 12:43

I think people are being a bit harsh to Thunderbolted. When we were thinking of having a family I was imagining a mini DH and me. I love DH (mostly, not so much when he doesn't properly turn off taps and leaves them dripping) and I though it would be cute to see some of his features on a baby and have the child grow up and have some of our quirks and personalities. And my adoptive son has recently become a father and it IS bloody cute to see him in her face and expressions, the way that she's an extreme extrovert like him and the temper when she's hungry and the food isn't coming fast enough.

I couldn't love my DC anymore than I do, even if they had been born to us. But it's perfectly alright if people already know that they only want little versions of themselves and their partner. They are not bad people because they like themselves and their partner and want tiny, cute versions of the same.

PhoenixIsFlying · 09/01/2022 12:42

I have one biological child and one step daughter and had always wanted to adopt. I love my step daughter as if she was my own. I can't adopt as I only live in a two bed, low income and single. I am not blood connected to my step daughter but I love her so much x

wejammin · 09/01/2022 12:41

I've worked in the care system and I've worked with adoptive parents when adoption has broken down. I appreciate I only see the negative cases - no-one needs a lawyer when things are going well!

My main thoughts are that there is a huge lack of support and resources at all parts of the process, from initial child protection intervention all the way through to post adoption services and it is an absolute travesty that lets down the most vulnerable children, birth parents and adoptive parents. It makes me so angry and I would never personally adopt because if problems do arise the lack of help is often deafening. I have DC with SEN already and feel abandoned by health and education even on the most basic issues.

wheresmymojo · 09/01/2022 12:40

@Nocutenamesleft

My friend is a child psychiatrist. She specialises in children under the age of 2 who have had severe trauma

Something like 93% of children she sees are adopted

I asked her once if they can ever recover. She said no. They could lead a normal life with therapy for their lives.

It’s so so sad.

See, this doesn't phase me in the slightest.

And we have a large family home with lots of space and the money to fund any therapy or care needed.

But still...I'm fat and have (a completely stable with medication) MH issue. So I can't.

They take far too much of a broad brush approach.

SantaHat · 09/01/2022 12:40

Overseas adoption comes with a whole extra set of risks and issues (including exploitation).

sites.uab.edu/humanrights/2018/03/13/orphan-fever-the-dark-side-of-international-adoption/

Sockwomble · 09/01/2022 12:39

"I also think giving a child a life they may not have otherwise had is a really nice thing"

If you adopt it should be because you want a child. I don't think wanting to give a child a better life should be the main motivation.

ineedsun · 09/01/2022 12:39

I have only read the first post.

I totally agree with you, on a very practical level and it’s exactly why we adopted. However the process is intrusive and you are placed under more scrutiny than biological parents which is right because you have to be a particular type of person to parent adopted kids.

The child comes first, even if it hurts, you have to find a balanced way of talking about their background and biological family which is going to keep them safe but not build on the trauma that they have already experienced. There is no place for ego in adoption.
I know that people would say all that about birth parenting but it’s more so with adoption and some people can’t do that. If it’s important to them to have the biological connection, the genetic link, the continuation of the gene pool then adoption isn’t for them.

Also, our boys were both babies, but we adopted a sibling group from an uncertain background. It is possible to adopt babies but even then it won’t come without challenges.

DysmalRadius · 09/01/2022 12:38

I appreciate the children up for adoption often come from trauma often, which is concerning in terms of how that trauma may play out in later life but I'd likely want a very small baby (not saying this eradicates this but I think is reducing the risk). And also, the same can happen with biological kids you never know how they will turn out.

I think it's particularly naive to think that trauma only exhibits itself in later life' - I knew several kids who are adopted and they have needed a lot of love, care and support from the outset, with plenty of full-on and intense parenting needs as soon as they are placed.

The parents also tell me that support for them is negligible to the point of being non-existent at times, although I don't know if this varies from area to area, or depending on the child's age. While the process for being assessed and approved for adoption is gruelling and intrusive, the 'after-care' is limited and doesn't extend much past the first couple of weeks.

ginislife · 09/01/2022 12:38

You could always foster to adopt ? I fostered and offered to take an SGO for my boy but SS didn't get their act together. A friend fostered a sibling group at 2,4&6 and adopted them at 13,15,16.

Fallagain · 09/01/2022 12:38

@adoptionthoughts

I should also point out I would likely be considering overseas adoption - for a variety of reasons.
Why do you think oversea adoption is a good idea? Removing a children from their culture and language will make things incredibly difficult for them.
Rrrob · 09/01/2022 12:37

We wanted to adopt after our only child died a few years ago. I wasn’t prepared to ttc again in case I had another sick baby.

We looked into adoption a lot and were keen to adopt siblings, but there were lots of hoops to jump through so we decided against it.

P0pc0rn · 09/01/2022 12:37

@alltitchy

I'm not saying that children who are adopted are not likely to have experienced trauma which will need additional support to work through. But to say that 99% of us are "very damaged" is pretty insulting.

Bonnealle · 09/01/2022 12:36

I looked at this and we went to a few starter sessions. They told us in no uncertain terms that babies would be likely to be born with addictions, or it would be temporary care whilst waiting on a decision by the courts. Once approved you often get little warning, so that may be an issue depending on what job you have. There is a rigorous approval process, quite rightly, but they said there was no upper age limit. They made it very clear that you need to expect the child to have problems, it’s not the movies where a young mum gives up her healthy baby to an older couple. The testing tries to ensure you are capable to withstand these problems and how to deal with them. We felt that as we both work, we may not be able to give round the clock care that a child with additional needs may require, and whilst nursery is great (I personally think a must as it helps socialisation), this may not be suitable for some adoptees.

flapjackfairy · 09/01/2022 12:36

Having adopted myself I am amazed people adopt at all having survived the approval process and jumped the myriad number of hurdles placed before us.
In my opinion the system needs a radical overhaul.from top.to bottom to prioritise the children who should be at the centre of the process. I am also a foster carer and again the system is woefully inadequate at prioritizing the children and imo gives too many chances to birth families and takes too long to release children for adoption and get them settled in permenant homes.
The adoption system also offers little real support post adoption and many families are left dealing with children who are challenging due to trauma in their early lives.
I am seriously passionate about fostering and adoption myself and I find it disheartening to see the whole system under such pressure that it struggles to cope

BarefootHippieChick · 09/01/2022 12:36

If you are considering overseas adoption then you need to be prepared to learn everything about their language, culture, heritage etc. I know (white) friends who have adopted Korean children, they have always been very open regarding their culture and heritage. Now they are growing up those children are curious and want to visit the country of their birth and discover, in a sense, where they actually come from.