Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why more people don't adopt?

706 replies

adoptionthoughts · 09/01/2022 11:55

Recently I've started thinking maybe adoption is a route for me. I've always said I wouldn't do it but recently I'm having a change of heart as I think about it and logically it makes a lot of sense for a variety of reasons.

I'm struggling TTC, but this is something I'm thinking about irrespective of whether or not I eventually manage to have biological kids.

I also think giving a child a life they may not have otherwise had is a really nice thing. Also, why add to a climate change problem when there are so so many children I wanted across the world - the more I think about it the more logically adoption makes lots of sense. It means you don't get the physical problems from childbirth, it means you are providing a life for a child that may have been in foster care and many other positives.

Am I being naive? Why does hardly anyone do it? Why are we only happy with children if it's related to us by blood? I'm not trying to be funny here I'm genuinely asking to see why to see if I'm crazy to consider it.

I appreciate the children up for adoption often come from trauma often, which is concerning in terms of how that trauma may play out in later life but I'd likely want a very small baby (not saying this eradicates this but I think is reducing the risk). And also, the same can happen with biological kids you never know how they will turn out.

I'd like to hear from not just those that have adopted but also those that haven't and wouldn't as to why?

OP posts:
NotTheGrinchAgain · 09/01/2022 12:53

I thought about adoption. Then a friend of mine tried. Married, settled, good job, lovely husband. Months and months of invasive assessment. Turned down because she had previously had clinical depression, ironically because she was unable to conceive. A few months later she fell pregnant and is the most natural, wonderful mother. She is still sad that the adoption process was so flawed.

I also saw a documentary about a woman who adopted a baby. Foetal alcohol syndrome. She gave up work to care for the baby. A few years later, the bio mum got herself pregnant again. The adoptive parents agreed to adopt the sibling. Guess what. Foetal alcohol syndrome. Third child, she adopted again. And now, you guessed it, she has three kids still battling the disabilities of foetal alcohol syndrome.

You are being startlingly naive.

PurpleDaisies · 09/01/2022 12:53

Anyone get the distinct impression the op isn’t really listening to anyone saying anything negative?

Fedupsotired · 09/01/2022 12:52

Adopting children is hard. So much harder than anyone thinks, even babies can have trauma and this can come out later. It is not a simple option at all

Whadda · 09/01/2022 12:52

My brother and his wife foster.

While I know fostering and adopting are very different from the foster parent/parent perspective, both are centered around child in the care system and it’s grueling.

All of the newborns/very young babies my brother has fostered have been born to parents with addiction issues and the babies themselves often have medical and neurological issues as a direct result.

The children he’s had aged maybe 3 to 11 have often been recently removed from their parents and often have had very traumatic upbringings.

The older children have often been through mixes of care homes/foster homes, going back to their parents temporarily, back to foster care etc. They’re very tough to parent. So many are traumatised and act out. Many have a history of rubbing away and trying to get back to their parents, often to be rejected. It’s harrowing.

Based on my brother’s experiences, social workers aren’t working effectively, in many cases.

CaveWoman1 · 09/01/2022 12:52

Sorry - replying to @Thunderbolted there

Briarshollow · 09/01/2022 12:52

@Thunderbolted

This sounds awful, and I wouldn't say it publically, but DH and I are better looking and more intelligent than average. A biological baby is more likely to inherit those traits.

Also, I work with mental health services and know first hand how important the very early years are to good mental health. We're not in the 1950s where unmarried mothers were forced to give up babies because of the stigma. Most children up for adoption are not babies and have serious attachment issues and worse which makes parenting much much harder.

Wow. Work in mental health care, do you? Wow.
Newnormal99 · 09/01/2022 12:52

I have a family member who has fostered many babies prior to adoption and has kept in touch with many of them.

Being a baby is no guarantee there are not issues that come out further along.

Why do you think babies get given up for adoption? In many cases it's because the parents are deemed unsafe / incapable of looking after them. Those root cause issues can well be handed down to the next generation regardless of them living elsewhere.

Fivebeanchilli · 09/01/2022 12:52

We supported friends who adopted. Their child was removed at birth and had one foster family and came to them at 8 months which is fast for adoption it seems.
They do not regret their choice.
But their child has FASD and moderately severe LDs and he will probably never live independently. The extent of his birth mother's learning disability was not made apparent to them beforehand. They have found it hard to access the right level of support.
They are in several adoption groups and their story is one of the easier ones.
I wouldn't have adopted because I'm not a patient person. I'm a fixer and a doer and those would not be good traits. I'm also not naturally maternal.
I have absolute respect for those who do.

CaveWoman1 · 09/01/2022 12:51

I have an IQ lower than that of an Alsatian, & I look like The Grinch - & that’s on a good day. My sons however are veritable geniuses I tell you; with the promise of Adonis-like looks. They may well rule the world

anotherneutralname · 09/01/2022 12:51

Just to reply to the poster who asked whether the question should be why is it so difficult to adopt?

Because they are finding the right families for traumatised children, and the consequences of getting that wrong are more trauma for the adopted child (and of course for the other family members).

I would love to say it's also because they are putting the right support package in place for each child, but ...

I'm sure there will be people who waited longer, and people who waited less, but of a group of potential adopters I know (6 families) all had children placed with them within 12 months of beginning their approval assessment process (which locally is a series of interviews and meetings, and a programme of training). To me, that's not much longer than a pregnancy, and as you go through the process it becomes clear why the specific questions are asked.

I'm so sorry to read about the person who said they went to a panel competing with two other families to be matched to a child! That's appalling. It's not how it's done locally, thankfully.

nitsandwormsdodger · 09/01/2022 12:50

I fostered hardest thing I ever did
One partner must be at home if primary age
Months of interviews, vetting, interviewed my family and line manager at work medical , you need a spare room before process starts
I would start by volunteering for etc
My friend who adopted had to do work experience in a nursery and become a brownie volunteer

Also children put up for adoption abroad are not unwanted but poor so you will have to live with that

ByTheSea · 09/01/2022 12:50

Whilst I think think adoption can be a wonderful thing and love my adopted nephew no less than my other nephews, I wouldn't blame anybody for not feeling able to take this on. I raised my stepson who had severe developmental trauma (disorganised attachment) from neglect he suffered as a tiny baby. I won't go into details but all my other children (and DH and me) now struggle with mental health as a result of the non-stop trauma and abuse he brought to the household for years. He really should have been an only child. 😥

Mellowyellow222 · 09/01/2022 12:50

Ideally people should adopt to help the children. Because they believe they have the skills and hope life to give a child a great life - to work though the issues that child might have.

Unfortunately many view it as the next step of they can’t conceive themselves. They think of adoption as a way to fill three desire for a baby’s bit as a way to help that child.

I don’t think this will ever change.

I often hear people comment ‘why didn’t they just adopt’ and this makes me so cross. Adoption isn’t for everyone. It takes a special person to deal with the emotional and downtime physical issues that come with an adopted child. It’s not an easy option, and it should absolutely be centred around the needs of the child not the needs of the parent.

C152 · 09/01/2022 12:50

Yes, you do seem to be quite naive. For a start, many people want a baby because they feel they're less likely to be 'damaged' than an older child. So not only will you likely wait years - if not forever - for a baby, just because it's young does not mean it has not been damaged. It may be going through drug or alcohol withdrawal; it may have significant disabilities etc. Also, children in the system for any length of time are going to come with issues - both from whatever has led them to be placed there, and from simply living in that environment. It is an extremely hard slog to raise a child with such issues. It is not impossible and obviously it's not all doom and gloom, but you have to be prepared for the reality of the situation, and your post appears to look at it through rose tinted glasses.

Ponoka7 · 09/01/2022 12:49

Are you happy to have a disabled child? Most babies have come from addicts and it can take a few years before their disabilities because of that comes out.
As said, you've answered your own question by wanting a baby, otherwise you'd just want a child.

"I also think giving a child a life they may not have otherwise had is a really nice thing."
A nice environment doesn't remove attachment issues, or other MH/emotional issues. You are convincing yourself that overseas adoption doesn't have massive ethical issues just like the old adoption system in the UK did when we took babies from single mothers, the impoverished WC and gave them to parents who had more money.

"They could lead a normal life with therapy"

Unfortunately many don't which is why it takes a few generations until there isn't SS intervention. Money and therapy can't solve their issues. The fake a normal life.

Motherland101 · 09/01/2022 12:49

I also think giving a child a life they may not have otherwise had is a really nice thing. Also, why add to a climate change problem when there are so so many children I wanted across the world

Whilst I absolutely agree with your other points on adoption, for it being a selfless and beautiful act to help deprived children who are in need, and people who adopt are amazing people, adopting will in no way ever replace the natural drive that some people have to have biological children of their own. So for that, you are being naive. I would never opt for adoption instead of having children of my own. Climate change or not. I salute the ones who can but I think for most people it just doesn't work like that.

Movinghouseatlast · 09/01/2022 12:48

I didn't adopt because I was too old to adopt a baby. I didn't want to adopt a child.

I think you are right about all the ethical reasons to adopt though. In the end I didn't even do IVF and the ethical perspective was a driver in that.

I also felt that I wouldn't love a non biological child as much if I adopted say a 6 year old. I might have been wrong of course. I didn't have a huge maternal instinct anyway and I just didn't feel I would bond with an older child.

Really I suppose the only urge I had was to have my own and as that couldn't happen then I wasn't the best person to adopt a child.

KoreyBay18 · 09/01/2022 12:48

Because it is fucking hard, OP.

I adopted my son before his first birthday. Perfect happy healthy little baby, same FC since removed at birth, "low risk".

He is 5 and the issues we are facing, particularly the lack of access to proper post-adoption support, is horrific. And his entire childhood will likely be dominated by this.

Adoption isn't an easy choice.

CaveWoman1 · 09/01/2022 12:48

@Thunderbolted

This sounds awful, and I wouldn't say it publically, but DH and I are better looking and more intelligent than average. A biological baby is more likely to inherit those traits.

😆😆😆😆😆

BungleandGeorge · 09/01/2022 12:47

You’ve started to consider it because you are having problems TTC. I think that’s your answer why more people don’t do it, they never get to that stage.
There are very few babies for adoption and those that are taken that early often have older siblings already adopted so will preferentially join them. Are you so keen to adopt an older child from a troubled background? I have a lot of respect for people who do this

GingerAndTheBiscuits · 09/01/2022 12:47

I always thought growing up that I might consider it. But having worked in children’s services for years I wouldn’t now for various reasons:

With a neurotypical biological child you can just about make it with “good enough” parenting. An adopted child is likely to require ongoing therapeutic parenting, a whole level above what I know I am capable of.

Reading about too many adoption breakdowns especially once children hit their teens.

The intrusive assessment process. DH was a referee for a friend’s application. He had reservations about the friend’s wife, based on his experience of seeing her parent their birth child and things his friend had told him about her approach to the child and parenting in general. He was honest with the assessor but it was quite difficult just being a referee let alone being the ones assessed. I wouldn’t be comfortable opening myself or DH up to that level of scrutiny.

I’ve observed and sat on adoption panels in one of the most deprived places in the country. After a while I couldn’t shake the feeling in some cases we were taking children away from poor people and giving them to richer people, and if birth parents had had the same opportunities and financial means as the prospective adopters the children may never have needed to be removed. That is not to say every adopter who came to panel wasn’t committed, dedicated and likely went on to make excellent parents to those children.

Lots of countries do not allow adoption of children from state care, which I hadn’t realised. Once I did it made me wonder a bit more about the ethics of it. I’ve not worked out where I land on that yet.

coraka · 09/01/2022 12:47

It is a lovely thing to do to OP, so if you feel called to it, then don't let other people's feelings about it put you off.

adoptionthoughts · 09/01/2022 12:47

@DrSbaitso no actually because everyone is different - and doesn't think the same as me.

OP posts:
Loobyloula · 09/01/2022 12:46

Blimey the misconceptions about adoption and the adoption process on this thread 🤣🤣 why do people post about something as sensitive as this that they haven't personally been involved in... Anyway..

OP to adopt you need a spare room (each child in the house needs their own bedroom), you do not need to be well off but you do need to be financially a float and be able to provide financially for a child, you need to be relatively fit and healthy (having a disability is not a definite no depending on circumstances etc!!), you need to have an open mind and be willing to learn about the kids and their needs now and potential needs in the future, you need to be able to take time off post placement for adoption leave...in a nutshell those are the things you "need". There will be other things that come up as you're assessed and you would be grilled a lot about adoption as a first choice when you don't have any reason to believe you can't have bio kids.. That wouldn't be enough for you to not be approved but SWs would need to be sure of your motivation etc.

It sounds like you're already aware of trauma, attachment and therapeutic parenting which is a good starting point.

The process isn't that bad. It's intrusive yes but it has to be so these kids are getting the best for their circumstances. I don't think it is unreasonably intrusive.

The process involves a medical, work and personal references, finance checks, home safety checks, pet checks and weekly interviews with your SW where they will want to know about you and your lifestyle/home life etc.

You will have an approval panel to become an approved adopter and a matching panel where you are matched with your child. Your child will move in and after 10 weeks or so you can apply to the court to make the adoption official once you are ready. You do not go to panel being pitched against other adopters for a particular child, no sure where someone got that idea from.

There are babies available for adoption both in the traditional route of adoption and in the Foster to adopt scheme. It is not selfish to want to adopt a younger child and arguably better for the kids anyway.
In terms of contact with birth parents most APs have indirect letterbox once per year with BP. But unless there is a court order stating otherwise that is up to you as the parent to decide if its in your child's best interests to keep going or not. Most kids it would be in their best interests of course, it can be a very positive thing to do for you child.

Adoption UK and the adoption boards on here are great.

Adopting our DC (who are our own just as much as our bio DC!) is the best thing we've ever done (alongside our bio kids). It is not always easy but I would do it again and again if I had the space/money/patience.

BiscuitLover3678 · 09/01/2022 12:46

I would be up for adoption but had the biological urge to try pregnancy. It’s also much, much easier to do it through biological pregnancy. Now I’ve had a biological kid, I’m not sure I could adopt. Having kids is so, so hard. Like really hard. I’m not sure I would mentally cope with adoption.

I know some men have said they’re worried they won’t feel the same love for another person’s child, which is sad.

If I’d not had children biologically I would definitely have considered it but I’m not sure about for further children as am worried about the effect on my son.

Swipe left for the next trending thread