Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why more people don't adopt?

706 replies

adoptionthoughts · 09/01/2022 11:55

Recently I've started thinking maybe adoption is a route for me. I've always said I wouldn't do it but recently I'm having a change of heart as I think about it and logically it makes a lot of sense for a variety of reasons.

I'm struggling TTC, but this is something I'm thinking about irrespective of whether or not I eventually manage to have biological kids.

I also think giving a child a life they may not have otherwise had is a really nice thing. Also, why add to a climate change problem when there are so so many children I wanted across the world - the more I think about it the more logically adoption makes lots of sense. It means you don't get the physical problems from childbirth, it means you are providing a life for a child that may have been in foster care and many other positives.

Am I being naive? Why does hardly anyone do it? Why are we only happy with children if it's related to us by blood? I'm not trying to be funny here I'm genuinely asking to see why to see if I'm crazy to consider it.

I appreciate the children up for adoption often come from trauma often, which is concerning in terms of how that trauma may play out in later life but I'd likely want a very small baby (not saying this eradicates this but I think is reducing the risk). And also, the same can happen with biological kids you never know how they will turn out.

I'd like to hear from not just those that have adopted but also those that haven't and wouldn't as to why?

OP posts:
CounsellorTroi · 09/01/2022 15:21

@Echobelly agree which is why I'd be considering overseas only. I don't think I would want the UK processes.

Even to adopt overseas you will still have to go through the UK vetting processes and you will have to pay for it yourself. It can cost several thousand pounds.

foxgoosefinch · 09/01/2022 15:17

And if you are thinking of adopting from overseas, OP, you are even less likely to find out if there are suspected issues with syndromes like FAS, or potentially heritable genetic, physical or mental health issues. The U.K. processes are there for a reason.

Simonjt · 09/01/2022 15:17

[quote adoptionthoughts]@Echobelly agree which is why I'd be considering overseas only. I don't think I would want the UK processes.

Admittedly as some posters mention yes I do need to do much more research and I've also committed to waiting another five years to do this - to give myself time to research and decide if it's still something I would like to do.

I'm not considering going to the adoption agency tomorrow! [/quote]
You don’t want to go through the UK process, so you want to adopt from abroad which means going through that countries process and the UKs process…

Bjarnum · 09/01/2022 15:16

We adopted a sibling group of 4 and have 3 natural children. The youngest adopted girl lies, steals from us and is continually in a fit of rage for something trivial with some luckless person. Nothing is ever her fault and she is unable to hold down a job for more than a few weeks and has no long term friends . She rewrites history on a regular basis and becomes bitter and spiteful when called out. Counselling has achieved nothing. The other 6 are fine - normal ups and downs. My friend has 7 natural children and all of them are unpleasant entitled jerks. Adopt or natural - always a gamble. And the idea that a small baby has escaped trauma is misleading - at least with older children you may have some idea of how things are likely to go. But on paper the youngest child looked fairly untroubled and the eldest had severe behaviour issues (he was violent and disturbed). Yet now he is in a stable relationship, is settled into a job where he is making steady progress and is relaxed and happy. So, imagine we had only adopted one - if it had been the youngest I would be warning you to prepare for future problems and decide how you will support an abusive dishonest adult who you really love but who cannot be trusted not to steal from you or spread dangerous lies. If it had been the eldest I would be saying that however bleak things may look hang in there because love and boundaries can work miracles. Not much help am I?

foxgoosefinch · 09/01/2022 15:14

Even in previous eras where babies were relinquished by single mums with no health issues, the babies have often had longstanding emotional problems. The stories of people adopted in the 50s and 60s trying to make contact with their birth mothers later in life are often extremely sad and harrowing.

By the 1980s there were already very few young babies put up for adoption without significant problems. My parents knew two families very well who both adopted small babies during that time. Both children initially seemed to settle well, but later developed serious behavioural, social and mental health issues. In one case it became clear much later on that the child had been affected by FAS, and there were serious behavioural issues ending up in prison. In the other, the child developed serious mental health problems in his teens, and is now in a mental health hospital with severe schizophrenia.

In both cases - hugely sad as the adopted parents were highly committed and lovely people, and in each case had at least one biological child as well - it was only later clear that there were inherited medical and mental health problems that they could not have anticipated and which caused huge trauma to the families and children.

Adoption is a difficult, traumatic, bumpy process which often breaks down. Adopting a small baby is incredibly difficult, and it very naive to think that by doing so you avoid trauma, abandonment and inherited health issues.

I’m full of admiration for those who can do it, but it’s not by any means easy or straightforward, OP.

CounsellorTroi · 09/01/2022 15:14

I am convinced after hearing what it is like, that the adoption process is designed to weed out those too weak to deal with the realities of the child they will be given and frighten the living shit out of them. Of a group of ten couples, my friend and her husband were one of only two who went on to actually adopt.

Yes I agree. They will want to weed out those who are less than wholehearted about it or seeing it through rose tinted specs.

Nat6999 · 09/01/2022 15:13

My friend adopted 2 siblings in her second marriage after she couldn't have any more children herself & her new husband wanted children. Her husband then announced he didn't love her & left. She is left bringing up two children both with significant disabilities at an age when her birth children are both grown up & having children of their own. While she loves them had she known how much the disabilities & trauma from their birth parents have affected them she says she wouldn't do it if she had her time again.

Beautiful3 · 09/01/2022 15:13

My husbands cousin had to go through the adoption process. They had to have counselling and be interviewed multiple times. It took around 2.5 years! They didn't get a baby like they wanted, they were offered sisters 4&6 years old. There were issues that needed monitoring because of the mother. It wasn't plain sailing. Also when the father left prison, he began searching for them. They had to change their names.

adoptionthoughts · 09/01/2022 15:12

@Echobelly agree which is why I'd be considering overseas only. I don't think I would want the UK processes.

Admittedly as some posters mention yes I do need to do much more research and I've also committed to waiting another five years to do this - to give myself time to research and decide if it's still something I would like to do.

I'm not considering going to the adoption agency tomorrow!

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 09/01/2022 15:11

The overseas adoption industry is rife with exploitation and dodgy goings on.

You're thinking of this like adopting a pet - but it's not an animal you're talking about, but a human. There are incredibly huge differences.

It's probably fiction, although it says based on a true story, but have a read of "A long way from home" by Cathy Glass. Also read some of the stuff that Lumos is putting out there about orphanages, if you're genuinely interested in overseas adoption. These are both good starting places to see what kinds of problems you might experience in this area.

(I have not read all 300 posts. Sorry if repeating.)

Branleuse · 09/01/2022 15:08

The threshhold for removal is quite high but the system still sets people up to fail. There are a lot of families that would benefit from long term and intensive support and even things like boarding schools would have better outcomes for many children than removal from parents especially if the child is wanted but the parents are terrible at it.
The thrrshold for removal is high because in most cases it is best for everyone involved that children arent removed unless actual abuse is involved

PrincessPaws · 09/01/2022 15:07

We were considering it, and went to an adoption information session. We didn't proceed partly because I'm not convinced I would get accepted due to being overweight, and I can't face going through the ordeal of the process only for it to fail. I don't think I could cope with that after all of the other disappointments.

I understand why the process is so gruelling, because they need to make sure children are going to a safe suitable environment, but some of the expectations (such as the requirement to spend time volunteering) take a lot of time and seem a bit over the top and unnecessary

justasking111 · 09/01/2022 15:06

Friends son and partner adopted a baby.sadly he has so many health issues they are barred from adopting another despite the mother being a trained nurse. We are talking physical and mental issues.

fizzypop100 · 09/01/2022 15:06

The courses and assessments are exhausting. Most children have some special needs and /or attachment disorder. Speaking as an adoptive parent

Cattenberg · 09/01/2022 15:06

Friends of mine were approved as potential adopters after a demanding 18-month process. However, they found the matching process heart-breaking. They and another couple were short-listed as potential adopters for a particular child, but ultimately Social Services chose the other couple.

My friends described their experience of adoption as “horrific” and said they couldn’t put themselves through it again. They decided to try IVF instead, and were successful.

SmaugMum · 09/01/2022 15:05

@GiantCheeseMonster

I work in Children’s Social Care - I’m not a social worker but I work with them and I oversee the education of children in care and adopted children, so I work very closely with them. A massive part of my job is trying to educate schools about the effects of trauma and poor attachment on this cohort of very vulnerable children. No child who is adopted has not experienced trauma. The nature of it and the impact might differ, but the principle is the same. Women in the UK do not give up babies at birth as an alternative to abortion as does happen in the US. The only children who are adopted are those who have to bs removed from birth parents, and who have no relatives available or suitable to become special guardians. They have spent time in the care system, and probably been fostered. The impact of the initial trauma plus changes in carers is huge and has life-long implications. And the threshold for permanent removal of children is very high. Most of them become looked after and go into either long-term foster care or are ultimately returned to birth parents if improvements are made. For a judge to agree to permanent removal, a child has either experienced severe abuse, neglect, or has been born to a mother with a history of drug or alcohol abuse or significant mental health difficulties which mean she cannot safely care for a baby. So as well as the impact of attachment difficulties and trauma, many of these children also have foetal alcohol spectrum disorder or are born addicted to drugs. They are far more likely to have SEN than their peers.

I admire adoptive parents with all my heart. But it is not an alternative to having your own child. It is a very different undertaking and experience of parenthood. The adoptive parents I support in my job have to fight for so much. For their child’s needs to be recognised at school, for additional support, for an EHCP. They are awe-inspiring people.

OP, I would do some reading about attachment and trauma. Louise Bomber’s books are a good place to start.

Hi @GiantCheeseMonster, single adoptive parent of two here, your first paragraph is THE best simple explanation of the reality of contemporary adoption I have ever read. I’m going to copy it and cut and paste it every time (and working in Virtual School, as I believe you do, you will appreciate that these occasions are very many) I have to deal with a teacher or other professional who believes that adoption is the happy-ever-after ending for a trauma and care-experienced child.
gumball37 · 09/01/2022 15:05

I have a biological child with significant mental illness. It was hell in earth for 3 years until we finally got the help he needed. But it's never going to go away. It's also something that wouldn't be clear when adopting. I don't think to expect sunshine and roses

Drinkyourweaklemondrink · 09/01/2022 15:05

We have never gone down the adoption route for our second due to the fact that we still rent our home. And we supported friends through the adoption process and it was gruelling, intrusive and financially draining

godmum56 · 09/01/2022 15:04

I know three couples who have adopted and something that hasn't been mentioned here is dealing with the biological parents. In two cases, the mother still had access and in one case the mother was allowed to visit the child in the adopters home. In both cases the adoptive parents had a lot of problems with the mothers, abusive phonecalls, begging for money and so on. In one case there was also an abusive father in the background. The adoptive parents go to great lengths to not allow the father to know where the child is as he had turned up at the foster parents and made threats previously. The third parents are in the US and I don't know them IRL. They adopted from abroad and the brother and sister they adopted came with horrific attachment issues. She would come on social media (very private group) for support and to let off steam. The last i heard was that things were finally coming good for the children but she stopped posting as she felt it was unfair as the children got older. The last adoption failed sadly. No one's fault but the match didn't work and the child developed stress related illnesses.

IncessantNameChanger · 09/01/2022 15:04

I have no real experience so who am I to say. But as a biological mum to disabled/ sen children who have been born into a loving and stable home and dealing with children disability socail care and the SEN education system, theres no way I would get enough support.

The reality vs imagined help is very different. You could take on a toddler who has had massive trauma either from fostering and bonding or abuse by biological parents. You would presume there would be lots of help and support waiting for you. I think from.mmy experience with adoptive parents of SEN children, you would be very much on your own

BeMoreGoldfish · 09/01/2022 15:02

I agree with those posters saying the threshold for removal from parents is too high. Catastrophic damage is already done. But then there aren’t enough homes for these children to go to so it’s a vicious circle.

I don’t know what the answer is - a shame parents who conceive naturally don’t get the same level of intense screening as those who adopt Sad.

housemaus · 09/01/2022 15:01

OP, that you so blithely threw in the part about overseas adoption and have ignored all the comments about trauma and attachment show you haven't really thought this through.

It's not the 50s/60s any more - a good handful of my mum's friends (and my mum) were adopted as babies, and their birth mothers were all very young, unmarried women. It was a socially acceptable way to 'deal' with unwanted pregnancy. Now, the stigma around being unmarried and young while pregnant isn't as strong, and young women generally have better access to/information about abortion - so if they find themselves pregnant they can either terminate, or keep their baby without the fear of being judged (or, not as much, anyway). So there are far, far fewer babies available for adoption - and as PPs have said, most of the children being adopted now are older and have considerable trauma to contend with. Not that these children shouldn't be adopted - they absolutely deserve loving parents and I take my hat off to those who adopt - but if you can't see how parenting a child who has significant trauma and the sheer gulf left in a child's life when they are removed from their birth family (no matter how awful they may seem to an outsider) could be enormously challenging and not as simple as 'giving them a good life', you're deluded.

Add to that the issue of removing a child from their heritage and birth country and raising them in a way that allows them to properly connect with that heritage (this piece on the trauma of transracial adoption shares a lot of sentiments I've seen echoed elsewhere)...

I'm not saying don't, I'm saying do some proper research first and be prepared for your entire life to change and not 'just' in the way it would if you have a biological child.

Branleuse · 09/01/2022 15:01

*This seems like a strange post. Intelligence and good looks aren't the most important things in life and they don't define someone's worth.

What about people who are neither good looking or intelligent? Do they usually decide not to have children as a result?*

Is it really that strange?
I dont know how other people make their decisions, but people do decide not to have biological children for all sorts of genetic reasons, and people often want an attractive partner for their children.
Peoe searching for sperm donors and (simple) surrogates often have requirements about intelligence and appearances of the donor or surrogate.
People with intellectual differences and disabilities are encoraged to have " counselling" before having a family.

Its not always a case of " a kid is a kid and theyre all much the same" Nature playd a huge role, not just nurture.

As for me, my kids might all be mental but at least theyre not ugly. That can smooth lifes path in life quite a lot (rightly or wrongly).

I dont think i would struggle to love someone elses child though
If it was a simpler process with better support then id have considered it.

Im just saying that its not that unusual to want your kids to have your genes. In fact its most peoples main reason for procreating

GromblesofGrimbledon · 09/01/2022 15:01

I thought the same as you OP until my friend adopted. After seeing her and her husband go through the adoption process I knew for sure I couldn't do it.

It is a brutal and invasive process. The stress from the years of jumping through hoops and turning the most intimate details of your lives over to social services is unbelievable. The ups and downs, the disappointment, the waiting, it's a huge undertaking. The children are all understandably from traumatic backgrounds and most often have severe difficulties. Adoption is not what is was many years ago when my great aunt adopted a newborn from a young mother who gave her child up. I am convinced after hearing what it is like, that the adoption process is designed to weed out those too weak to deal with the realities of the child they will be given and frighten the living shit out of them. Of a group of ten couples, my friend and her husband were one of only two who went on to actually adopt.

You are being naive OP. I was naive too. I'd rather go through the pain of labour a million times over again than the adoption process. Hats off to anyone with the strength to do it. Most people nowadays haven't the faintest clue what adoption actually means.

Nc123 · 09/01/2022 15:01

DS1 is adopted, but previously he was my stepson and his birth mum opted out - so it’s a different situation completely. We didn’t have to go through the screening and matching process as if we were seeking to be matched with a child.

DS1 is very laidback and doesn’t have abandonment issues, but I was expecting that he would.