Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why more people don't adopt?

706 replies

adoptionthoughts · 09/01/2022 11:55

Recently I've started thinking maybe adoption is a route for me. I've always said I wouldn't do it but recently I'm having a change of heart as I think about it and logically it makes a lot of sense for a variety of reasons.

I'm struggling TTC, but this is something I'm thinking about irrespective of whether or not I eventually manage to have biological kids.

I also think giving a child a life they may not have otherwise had is a really nice thing. Also, why add to a climate change problem when there are so so many children I wanted across the world - the more I think about it the more logically adoption makes lots of sense. It means you don't get the physical problems from childbirth, it means you are providing a life for a child that may have been in foster care and many other positives.

Am I being naive? Why does hardly anyone do it? Why are we only happy with children if it's related to us by blood? I'm not trying to be funny here I'm genuinely asking to see why to see if I'm crazy to consider it.

I appreciate the children up for adoption often come from trauma often, which is concerning in terms of how that trauma may play out in later life but I'd likely want a very small baby (not saying this eradicates this but I think is reducing the risk). And also, the same can happen with biological kids you never know how they will turn out.

I'd like to hear from not just those that have adopted but also those that haven't and wouldn't as to why?

OP posts:
ineedsun · 09/01/2022 19:59

@SmaugMum
please, can we avoid the cancel-culture of semantics on this thread? There have been a few sharp comments in response to words used in good faith’ like ‘own’, ‘’natural’ etc

Who made me the boss of the thread when you’re saying things like this?

Those phrases are offensive and unhelpful. They perpetuate myths around adoption and just because you’re not offended by them it doesn’t mean that other people shouldn’t call them out.

You’re literally being told by people that they’re offended by the balance of the thread and you’re telling them it’s refreshing.

MooseBreath · 09/01/2022 19:53

I would like to adopt, but DH doesn't feel the same way.

I would be ok with adopting a primary-aged child, but the process of being approved puts me off massively. I don't have loads of money. I'm not at home full time. My house is rented and isn't immaculate. We likely wouldn't pass the process to adopt. That said, my DS is loved and cared for and is arguably very lucky to have DH and I as parents, and I would ensure the same for any adopted child.

SmaugMum · 09/01/2022 19:52

@ineedsun

No *@SmaugMum* you don’t get to come onto a thread and tell other people what they should and shouldn’t be offended by, and tell them not to call out unhelpful language just because you don’t deem it so.

You also don’t get to tell people who have been affected by the language used and the attitudes on this thread that this is just a realistic picture of modern adoption. The views and are experiences shared have not been balanced, they have repeatedly referred to how traumatic the process is and how damaged adopted kids are with very little balance. Can you put yourself in the shoes one one of your kids and think what it would be like for them to read how damaged they are being repeated over and over again?

Yes, the process is difficult, yes most of the kids will have experienced trauma before and during (and sometimes after) adoption, but that isn’t a life sentence.

For what it’s worth, we adapted our kids 17 years ago, the process was a bit intrusive but not significantly so in light of the fact that they’re trying to work out if we would be decent parents. Our oldest has minor anxiety around attachment and the youngest has SEND connected with his background, and I wouldn’t change a single second of it and neither would they. Our family is beautiful, we connect with the birth family regularly and all consider ourselves to be a family.

And who made you the boss of the thread?
SmaugMum · 09/01/2022 19:50

@Jellycatspyjamas

better to have the bigots out than hiding in plain sight.

That’s very true @SmaugMum, though my fear is that folk don’t see past the bigots or think they know what they’re talking about and take those views forward.

@Jellycatspyjamas, your perspective will differ from mine as you bring a professional as well as personal dimension to adoption. Although, I think if I were a professional working in adoption, I would genuinely want my families to know and understand how hard this undertaking will most likely be for the longest time. I read these threads all the time, if I take a baby, I’ll dodge a bullet and because I know I’ll be the best parent I can ever possibly be and I’ll love them to the moon and back, then everything will be perfect. Well, you and I both know that love and good intentions are simply not enough. I love my DD1 around Saturn’s fiery ring but it still doesn’t change the fact that she lost her sight due to her birth mother’s opiate use, and that she is being assessed for ASD/ADHD (genetic inheritance) and she goes missing, lies constantly, steals every last penny from every family member still speaking to her, indulges in other risky behaviours and has caused me severe stress-related ill-health. Still, I plod on as this is what I signed up for and I’d rather, for the sake of all the children waiting for homes out there, that people knew MY truth.
ineedsun · 09/01/2022 19:48

@LovePoppy

For me, I would adopt if I couldn’t have my own children, but I’d be wary as these children could have some level of issues (nature vs nurture) and I think that’s a huge amount of work to take on. I really respect those who foster, especially older children with problems, and those who adopt.

Adopted children aren’t just there to be your back up.

Your “own” children could have just as many issues. You know that, right?

Adopted children are not second class citizens ffs

👆👆👆👆

Absolutely

ineedsun · 09/01/2022 19:46

No @SmaugMum you don’t get to come onto a thread and tell other people what they should and shouldn’t be offended by, and tell them not to call out unhelpful language just because you don’t deem it so.

You also don’t get to tell people who have been affected by the language used and the attitudes on this thread that this is just a realistic picture of modern adoption. The views and are experiences shared have not been balanced, they have repeatedly referred to how traumatic the process is and how damaged adopted kids are with very little balance. Can you put yourself in the shoes one one of your kids and think what it would be like for them to read how damaged they are being repeated over and over again?

Yes, the process is difficult, yes most of the kids will have experienced trauma before and during (and sometimes after) adoption, but that isn’t a life sentence.

For what it’s worth, we adapted our kids 17 years ago, the process was a bit intrusive but not significantly so in light of the fact that they’re trying to work out if we would be decent parents. Our oldest has minor anxiety around attachment and the youngest has SEND connected with his background, and I wouldn’t change a single second of it and neither would they. Our family is beautiful, we connect with the birth family regularly and all consider ourselves to be a family.

canyoutoleratethis · 09/01/2022 19:41

@Simonjt

Being a biological parent and an adoptive parent isn’t at all comparable.

My son came to me at 18 months old, he’s now six, he’s doing brilliantly right now, but he will likely never be ‘okay’. His parenting needs are different, he needs therapeutic parenting, even when I’m knackered, stressed and he is being a bloody nightmare and pressing every button. Even now I’m finding things he is yet to experience that have caused gaps in his development, one is a need for certain sensory experiences, specifically rocking and general proprioception, he’s currently barrel rolling on the spot at a soft play (aka hell on earth) and has been for a few minutes, he’ll if left to his own devices do that until we leave. He has issues around resources, you can’t take anything off him, he needs to always have access to food and drink, including in his room as he sometimes needs to secretly eat and drink, at school he has to be watched very carefully because he will eat out of the bins.

He has a very good attachment to me, I’m very lucky that he can be babysat by people he knows well. If he doesn’t know them well its a disaster, it took months to slowly build nursery up from an hour a day to four short days a week. For the first term of school he would be so distressed he would vomit, I missed so much work I nearly lost my job. If his both his teacher and the clas TA are off (this has happened a few times since covid) he can’t go to school.

He pushes me to test my attachment to him, he will scream, shout, tell me he hates me, spit at me, hit me and kick me. He’s doing it because he needs to know that I do love him, that I’m not leaving, that no matter what he has done he’ll still get a cuddle, a kiss or a rock.

Compared to the other children at our adoption group he is (currently) fairly easy, there aren’t any signs of FASD, ASD, ADHD or ADD at the moment.

He now has a little sister, she was born in November, when we visit her he is lovely, gives her cuddles, helps bathe her and is generally very positive. Thats because he sees her in her foster home, not his home. I’ve now set up the cot and a few things so they’ve been in our home for a while before she comes home. Those items are obviously a threat to my son, his security and his main resource me, so it will be very challenging when she moves in.

You have to consider that the birth family and foster carers become part of your family. As well as pictures of us on display we have pictures of his foster carers, his birth mum, I talk about them, he tells people about them. My son didn’t join me and become my family, I became part of his.

He is hard work, but I don’t know any different, to me my parenting experience is completely normal, yes its stressful and I get tired, but I enjoy and I love being his Dad.

I just wanted to say that you sound like a wonderful dad. It’s clearly really hard sometimes, but your DS is so lucky you have come into his life, and that you love and care for him in the way you clearly do. I wish you the very best with the arrival of his sister Flowers
CreamFirstThenJamOnTop · 09/01/2022 19:40

@Jellycatspyjamas

3b. When my kids really piss me off the thing that helps me to regain perspective is reminding myself that I created them. Not sure how I’d feel not having that.

And the thing that helps me is knowing I chose them, they weren’t random children left with me - I actively chose these two children with all the joy and challenge that goes with it.

Which is brilliant and I’m glad you think and feel that.

But my fear would be “what if I don’t feel that? What if I wish I hadn’t chosen them?” Which would be such an awful way to feel for them and for me.

I’d hope I wouldn’t be like that but I just don’t know.

Jellycatspyjamas · 09/01/2022 19:32

3b. When my kids really piss me off the thing that helps me to regain perspective is reminding myself that I created them. Not sure how I’d feel not having that.

And the thing that helps me is knowing I chose them, they weren’t random children left with me - I actively chose these two children with all the joy and challenge that goes with it.

BlueberryJam123 · 09/01/2022 19:30

You’re being naive about the very real challenges that adoptive parents face because of the awful start their children have often had in life.

This. Even if it's a baby, it would have suffered trauma. Being removed from a biological mother is a trauma in itself.

Jellycatspyjamas · 09/01/2022 19:29

better to have the bigots out than hiding in plain sight.

That’s very true @SmaugMum, though my fear is that folk don’t see past the bigots or think they know what they’re talking about and take those views forward.

Changechangychange · 09/01/2022 19:18

[quote Jellycatspyjamas]@SmaugMum this thread is riddled with misinformation, assumptions and judgement - truthful maybe about some of the challenges but my goodness you wouldn’t have a clear, balanced understanding of contemporary adoption from reading this thread.[/quote]
I think that’s due to the framing of the OP though - the question was “those who haven’t and wouldn’t adopt - why?”

So obviously you are getting worst-case anecdotes about what has put people off, rather than a balanced picture.

CreamFirstThenJamOnTop · 09/01/2022 19:17

I haven’t considered it for several reasons, all are pretty selfish reasons really:

  1. Don’t want to go through the intrusive assessment.
  2. Would struggle to parent a traumatised child.
  3. I worry that I wouldn’t feel the same connection as I do to my biological children and that would be unfair on the child and too hard for me.
3b. When my kids really piss me off the thing that helps me to regain perspective is reminding myself that I created them. Not sure how I’d feel not having that.
Cocomarine · 09/01/2022 19:16

@adoptionthoughts

I should also point out I would likely be considering overseas adoption - for a variety of reasons.
Have a think about what those reasons are. Can I be forward and suggest that one of your reasons is that you’d rather avoid UK social services insisting on annual letter box contact with a birth parent? Perhaps another of your reasons is that you don’t like the idea of your child turning 18 (or frankly younger, social media makes detective work easy especially if the parents are happy to be found) and connecting with their birth parents. Far less risk of that if they came from a Chinese or Romanian orphanage, huh? If either of those reasons are part of your own thinking… then you have another reason to understand why many people don’t adopt.
SmaugMum · 09/01/2022 19:16

[quote Jellycatspyjamas]@SmaugMum this thread is riddled with misinformation, assumptions and judgement - truthful maybe about some of the challenges but my goodness you wouldn’t have a clear, balanced understanding of contemporary adoption from reading this thread.[/quote]
And equally there have been robust challenges and truth exchanges from those of us living the real deal. The things posted here are only what our neighbours/colleagues/friends/family are thinking and believing. I’d far rather the misinformation, assumptions and judgment were out in the open. There is a lot of ignorance about adoption, especially as Family Court proceedings are shrouded in secrecy; I, for one, am glad that people on here are curious enough to ask questions or to post the experiences of their third cousin three times removed; better to have the bigots out than hiding in plain sight.

CurbsideProphet · 09/01/2022 19:10

If our IVF doesn't work we won't be adopting. After years of miscarriages and gruelling treatment we could not physically go through years of being assessed by Social Services and the possibility of more heartbreak. I can't imagine we're alone with that feeling.

SmaugMum · 09/01/2022 19:09

@LovePoppy, I actually didn’t say it was honest and helpful, no offence intended. Please re-read my posts and quote me accurately. I’m sorry this has been hurtful for you - I would never intentionally hurt anyone with my postings as that is not my nature and I do always try to be mindful of another person’s perspective. I think the reality (or mine, anyway) is that adoption always comes from a sense/place of loss - for the child, the birth parent/s and the adoptive parent/) - and that brings with it its own difficulties and sensitivities. I simply wanted to post that I have been heartened by the stories of those perhaps several times removed from adoption who ‘get’ the lifelong difficulties faced by all involved, especially the children, who had no say in how their futures would be mapped. We all, adopters/adopters/birth parents bring our own important dimension to these tales which are usually borne from tragedy.

Jellycatspyjamas · 09/01/2022 19:06

@SmaugMum this thread is riddled with misinformation, assumptions and judgement - truthful maybe about some of the challenges but my goodness you wouldn’t have a clear, balanced understanding of contemporary adoption from reading this thread.

LovePoppy · 09/01/2022 18:56

@SmaugMum

I’m glad this this has been honest and helpful to you.

As an adopted child it’s been more than slightly horrifying

Xenia · 09/01/2022 18:54

I could have my own children so did not consider it. If that had not been possible I would not have ruled it out. My parents were considering adoption as it was taking a while to conceive me but then I came along and then my siblings. It is certainly a bit simpler to have your own children if you can as there are no birth parents out there and you tend to know a bit more about the family history etc.

Mommabear20 · 09/01/2022 18:54

@adoptionthoughts I'd highly recommend watching 'the crazy pieces' videos on Facebook. They're an American family with 3 biological children and about 13 adopted kids! I've always had adoption on my heart and after 2 biological kids it's still very much there! I love their videos as it really shows the positives of adoption that people never talk about.

SmaugMum · 09/01/2022 18:50

@LovePoppy

For me, I would adopt if I couldn’t have my own children, but I’d be wary as these children could have some level of issues (nature vs nurture) and I think that’s a huge amount of work to take on. I really respect those who foster, especially older children with problems, and those who adopt.

Adopted children aren’t just there to be your back up.

Your “own” children could have just as many issues. You know that, right?

Adopted children are not second class citizens ffs

To be fair, and I write as an adopter twice over and 14 years in, the vast majority of adopters adopt because, for one reason or another, they can’t have birth children (and, please, can we avoid the cancel-culture of semantics on this thread? There have been a few sharp comments in response to words used in good faith’ like ‘own’, ‘’natural’ etc. In my opinion, and I’m happy to be beaten down, as this is Mumsnet after all, this has been one of the most refreshing and truthful threads about the realities of contemporary adoption I have ever read in my 14 years of being an adoptive parent. It’s heartening that people are willing to read and be educated about what life CAN be like for adoptive families out here in 2022.
x2boys · 09/01/2022 18:48

Having birth children doesn't always mean parenthood will be problem free either ,my youngest son has severe autism and learning disabilities,he has very complex needs,there is no guarantee however you become a parent that it will be an easy ride .

LovePoppy · 09/01/2022 18:42

For me, I would adopt if I couldn’t have my own children, but I’d be wary as these children could have some level of issues (nature vs nurture) and I think that’s a huge amount of work to take on. I really respect those who foster, especially older children with problems, and those who adopt.

Adopted children aren’t just there to be your back up.

Your “own” children could have just as many issues. You know that, right?

Adopted children are not second class citizens ffs

madisonbridges · 09/01/2022 18:40

My friend was single when she adopted. Her child was forcibly removed and there were multiple challenges in court by her family to have custody. By the time it was all sorted, she was 18mths. But she was living in foster care and has had no issues and is a very easy child.
My friend had to go through hoops. A social worker would be assigned to visit and for a report to be done. That person would either ho off sick or be moved to snother section and the report would never get written. So then my friend would be back to square 1. She was forever on the phone trying to her reports done so she could move on to the next stage. One report she filled out herself, all her personal details, dates, times etc, and sent it to the SW to just fill out the comment at the bottom.
Eventually she had the child living with her, but even then they put her through the mill. Reports not written etc. She was told all the time the child wasn't hers and they could take the child off her. She asked if she could take them on a weeks holiday to Spain. Two social workers said, no. The child wasn't hers, she had no right to take them anywhere, she might abscond. Bearing in mind that she owned her own home, she had permanent employment here, her family and support network were all here.
Anyway, the head social worker came a couple of weeks later and watched them together etc. My friend again broached taking the child away. The SW said, of course, she's yours and you must do everything with her that any family would. It was a few weeks before the actual papers came through but she said the difference on the way she was treated and spoken to made all the difference.
She said that she was so close to dropping out of the process so many times because of the way she felt almost vilified.

Swipe left for the next trending thread