Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pick a pub with a log burner for a family meal?

238 replies

hippohippohippo · 09/01/2022 11:43

It's my DH's birthday and I've booked a table at a pub for us and SIL and family. We have a 6 month old and they have a 5 month old. SIL says they are free but not coming, as the pub has a logburner and it's winter and might be on. It hadn't occurred to me that this was a problem and am fine taking my DS (and have regularly been to pubs with a logburner). She insists we look for somewhere that doesn't have a fire if we want them there. Is she being unreasonable or am I?

OP posts:
PersonaNonGarter · 09/01/2022 13:47

This is bonkers. YANBU

Magnited · 09/01/2022 13:42

@ivykaty44

will SIL be taking her dc in the car? ever?

pollution inside a car is much worse for a baby than an adult, and therefore you'll need to let SIL know,
www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/apr/10/vehicle-pollution-results-in-4m-child-asthma-cases-a-year

I doubt an afternoon in a pub with a log burner will be much more polluting

No, not any more.

The problem with cars these days is that journeys take so long. One gets stuck behind horses for several hours these days even if popping down to the local pub.

LessTime · 09/01/2022 13:40

Is it a one room pub?

I’ve seen plenty of threads where MILs (inevitably) are banned from holding babies because they smoke? (The mil smoke not the babies 🤔)

Flowerpower23 · 09/01/2022 13:40

Our Wetherspoons has an open fire 😆 @JesusInTheCabbageVan

FourTeaFallOut · 09/01/2022 13:40

I wouldn't go with a baby either.

FourTeaFallOut · 09/01/2022 13:39

Yeah, I wouldn't choose to go there but I have asthma which, among a host of other things, is triggered by smoke.

Nanny0gg · 09/01/2022 13:38

@hippohippohippo

Sorry - thought I had replied!

Her issue is pollution yes, she sent me the same article. But I had assumed that 2 hours in her brother's favourite pub for his birthday would be okay!

I have suggested she comes to ours first instead... will she have a similar problem with candles on his birthday cake?!

See, that's just nasty.

She might be being a bit PFB, but she's not entirely wrong

Nanny0gg · 09/01/2022 13:37

@Floralnomad

Perhaps your sister has a friend like me - I have lung disease ( life long non smoker ) and it makes me short of breath just walking past a house with a log burner alight .
Absolutely.

My DiL cannot be in a room with a log burner as it is very detrimental to her health.

And next door's fire/chimney often caused her problems too

Flutterflybutterby · 09/01/2022 13:36

She is being unreasonable and dramatic.

CheeryTreeBlossom · 09/01/2022 13:34

Log burners really are that bad, the studies are clear.
In terms of effects my DSis has generally mild asthma, despite working in central London and living in zone 2, plenty of cars around.
She went to the pub two weeks ago with one of these burning, she said the pub got noticeably smokey and since she has had a hacking cough and is needing to use her inhaler a lot more.

The particulate matter from an open fire is very bad. We have an air purifier/monitor and I can tell when a neighbour somewhere on the road fires up a log burner or barbeque from the monitor going red and beeping (hazardous exposure if long term) before I smell it.

Magnited · 09/01/2022 13:34

You forgot dairy!

Lockheart · 09/01/2022 13:30

@JabNotInArm And how do you imagine one might become "severely asthmatic"?

What makes a person susceptible to asthma is not entirely understood, and could be due to inherited susceptibility, childhood illness, allergies, a premature birth etc.

Asthma attacks can be triggered by pollutants and irritants (such as smoke from a log burner).

ancientgran · 09/01/2022 13:28

@hippohippohippo

Sorry - thought I had replied!

Her issue is pollution yes, she sent me the same article. But I had assumed that 2 hours in her brother's favourite pub for his birthday would be okay!

I have suggested she comes to ours first instead... will she have a similar problem with candles on his birthday cake?!

I guess your husband should decide which is more important to him, he might not care if his sister is there or it might be really important to him. Why not ask him what he'd prefer?
Lockheart · 09/01/2022 13:26

@JabNotInArm I'm very aware of Ella Adoo-Kissi-Debrah's case and agree there needs to be a huge reduction in the level of traffic and personal car ownership in this country. I've posted about this several times before if you don't believe me. But that doesn't change the fact that for the majority of people the use of a logburner (or car) is not going to have a material impact on their health and that the risk of a log burner in a pub is being massively overblown on this thread.

JabNotInArm · 09/01/2022 13:25

@Lockheart

Log burners do emit harmful particulates and do present a risk to health.

But you are not going to suddenly develop stage 3 lung cancer from sitting in pubs with one for the occasional lunch.

You might develop lung cancer if you regularly use one throughout your life, just as you might develop lung cancer if you smoke and you might develop bowel cancer from eating too much processed red meat and you might develop cancer if you live next to a road or spend a lot of your life driving.

Unless you are severely asthmatic (for example), the risk is not so high that it presents an immediate danger to your health, just like hundreds of things we do. And we all have to go at some point; over Christmas my dad passed away from something completely unrelated despite having open fires in his house from childhood.

And how do you imagine one might become "severely asthmatic"?
JabNotInArm · 09/01/2022 13:22

@Lockheart

Log burners do emit harmful particulates and do present a risk to health.

But you are not going to suddenly develop stage 3 lung cancer from sitting in pubs with one for the occasional lunch.

You might develop lung cancer if you regularly use one throughout your life, just as you might develop lung cancer if you smoke and you might develop bowel cancer from eating too much processed red meat and you might develop cancer if you live next to a road or spend a lot of your life driving.

Unless you are severely asthmatic (for example), the risk is not so high that it presents an immediate danger to your health, just like hundreds of things we do. And we all have to go at some point; over Christmas my dad passed away from something completely unrelated despite having open fires in his house from childhood.

Tell that to the parents of Ella Kissi
hippohippohippo · 09/01/2022 13:21

Sorry - thought I had replied!

Her issue is pollution yes, she sent me the same article. But I had assumed that 2 hours in her brother's favourite pub for his birthday would be okay!

I have suggested she comes to ours first instead... will she have a similar problem with candles on his birthday cake?!

OP posts:
KiloWhat · 09/01/2022 13:18

It's her family, her rules. Neither are being unreasonable and you can't force her to eat somewhere she doesn't want to.

MrsKDB · 09/01/2022 13:17

They are incredibly harmful to young lungs. Would you be happy to have your baby at a table where someone was chain smoking for three hours?

PriamFarrl · 09/01/2022 13:15

Unpopular opinion:

Bring back smoking in pubs and all of then install a log burner and then pubs can go back to being adult only spaces.

Lockheart · 09/01/2022 13:15

Log burners do emit harmful particulates and do present a risk to health.

But you are not going to suddenly develop stage 3 lung cancer from sitting in pubs with one for the occasional lunch.

You might develop lung cancer if you regularly use one throughout your life, just as you might develop lung cancer if you smoke and you might develop bowel cancer from eating too much processed red meat and you might develop cancer if you live next to a road or spend a lot of your life driving.

Unless you are severely asthmatic (for example), the risk is not so high that it presents an immediate danger to your health, just like hundreds of things we do. And we all have to go at some point; over Christmas my dad passed away from something completely unrelated despite having open fires in his house from childhood.

BendicksBittermints4Breakfast · 09/01/2022 13:13

@Wiredforsound

Is there a problem with getting somewhere else reasonably close? Or ask her to suggest somewhere suitable?
Why should they allow someone's over-active mind dictate where they want to eat? If the SIL doesn't want to come, they don't come but they don't get to dictate to the hosts.
StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 09/01/2022 13:12

Tell her 'That's a shame. Hopefully see you soon then'.

PriamFarrl · 09/01/2022 13:12

@Jennalong

How does she think she even exists ? Her ancestors would have heated theirhouses with open fires , and the fact that she had been born is proof they lived to produce children , who would have lived the same and so on .
When I grew up many households only had open fires as a source of heat. That was the 70s not caveman times.
BendicksBittermints4Breakfast · 09/01/2022 13:11

@WiganDiva

Wow. I thought she was bonkers until I read that Guardian article. Totally unaware of this!
You do realise that the Guardian is as reliable as the Daily Mail, it too has an agenda but one can assume that its agenda is more acceptable to some!