Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pick a pub with a log burner for a family meal?

238 replies

hippohippohippo · 09/01/2022 11:43

It's my DH's birthday and I've booked a table at a pub for us and SIL and family. We have a 6 month old and they have a 5 month old. SIL says they are free but not coming, as the pub has a logburner and it's winter and might be on. It hadn't occurred to me that this was a problem and am fine taking my DS (and have regularly been to pubs with a logburner). She insists we look for somewhere that doesn't have a fire if we want them there. Is she being unreasonable or am I?

OP posts:
etulosba · 09/01/2022 18:29

I wonder if we are storing up lung problems for future by the current trend for wood burners

No more than there was in the past. Some of us were brought up in houses heated solely by open fires. Even in children’s bedrooms.

oviraptor21 · 09/01/2022 18:27

I wonder if we are storing up lung problems for future by the current trend for wood burners

Surely any issues related to using fires as hearing would be reducing as houses tend to be heated by central heating these days.
I spent all my childhood in a house heated by one coal fired stove as I'm sure did many of my generation and earlier.

etulosba · 09/01/2022 18:26

A possible solution?

To pick a pub with a log burner for a family meal?
MasterGland · 09/01/2022 18:23

@Dguu6u but they didn't control other variables, merely had the participants note them in a journal.
I know how to design an experiment, whilst not an academic, I have a science degree. It is also not a logical assumption to assume that the particles enter the room when the door is opened, as stoves are designed so that there is a significant draw up the flue. That is why, with proper refuelling technique, you open the door slightly, to allow pressure to equalise.

Anyway, I think I will leave this now, as MN has made its mind up about this one.

Ozanj · 09/01/2022 18:21

Exposure to wood burning pollution before 1 is linked to cardiac and autoimmune problems later in life. But this is long term exposure - a single evening at a pub won’t cause any problems.

TequilaBlaze · 09/01/2022 18:17

@1forAll74

Just go without them, the woman sounds annoying and nitpicking, for a relitively short visit to a pub,
This.
1forAll74 · 09/01/2022 18:06

Just go without them, the woman sounds annoying and nitpicking, for a relitively short visit to a pub,

Laney39 · 09/01/2022 18:03

@Woodlandwater do you have a link to your air purifier?

Brainwave89 · 09/01/2022 17:53

Everyone is entitled to their own choice. However, in my rural area a lot of clean wood is burned, and proportionately our experience of asthma and other issues is a lot lower than in urban areas. Pollution and particulate exposure will be made up of many factors. To ignore a pub with a log burner is a huge over reaction. To those who suggest we do not know the future implications, log burners have a history of over 180 years in rural England. Trust me, we are not falling like flies.

Thadhiya · 09/01/2022 17:51

I bet she doesn't care so much about cancerous fumes driving her precious babies around in a car, does she?

Dguu6u · 09/01/2022 17:48

[quote MasterGland]@Dguu6u. I have read the report, thank you. I noticed some of the limitations of the methodology used (including those that the authors themselves note) and thought it would be interesting to see if the results could be reproduced. Testing for reproducibility is a critical part of the scientific process, as I am sure you are aware, as I take it you are an academic yourself.
The authors themselves noted that they wanted to carry out their research under real life conditions in the home. I carried out the same measurements in my house, that the 20 people in Sheffield did for this report. I'm not saying that it is conclusive, but that it is interesting that I could not reproduce the results. It warrants further investigation, in particular with the particulate attribution analysis that the report authors also recommended. I look forward to the publication of further research.[/quote]
Yes but testing findings is usually done under controlled circumstances, not by a random person who doesn’t know what they’re doing. Burning wood produces fine particles. Log burners produce fine particles. You open the door you are burning wood in, you spread those fine particles inside. It’s all a logical assumption, and just because you couldn’t measure it doesn’t mean it wasn’t there. Leave it to the experts I’d say.

gogohm · 09/01/2022 17:47

Just as well nobody had children in the olden days Grin

Never heard anything so ridiculous, 2-3 hours in a pub with dozens of tables meaning it's unlikely you are even near the fire, is not going to heard anyone. Plenty of houses are still heated by wood

MondayYogurt · 09/01/2022 17:38

Her baby sounds like a wimp! It should toughen up and learn the life isn't all clean air and roses. Maybe buy it some Benson and Hedges for first birthday.

MasterGland · 09/01/2022 17:30

@Dguu6u. I have read the report, thank you. I noticed some of the limitations of the methodology used (including those that the authors themselves note) and thought it would be interesting to see if the results could be reproduced. Testing for reproducibility is a critical part of the scientific process, as I am sure you are aware, as I take it you are an academic yourself.
The authors themselves noted that they wanted to carry out their research under real life conditions in the home. I carried out the same measurements in my house, that the 20 people in Sheffield did for this report. I'm not saying that it is conclusive, but that it is interesting that I could not reproduce the results. It warrants further investigation, in particular with the particulate attribution analysis that the report authors also recommended. I look forward to the publication of further research.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 09/01/2022 16:50

@Giggorata

Paraffin candles are made from petroleum by products and do emit pollutants and carcinogens. I don't suppose birthday cake candles will do much harm, for the milliseconds people are exposed to them.
You need to educate yourself. Peer reviewed studies have shown that paraffin wax and vegetable waxes have exactly the same emissions. The only wax that has slightly less emissions is beeswax. The problems come when candles are fragranced. The emissions go up slightly but some people can be sensitive to certain chemicals in the fragrance. If you look at the CLP label on a scented candle, it will show you any allergens, hazards and warnings associated with that fragrance.
Flipflopblowout · 09/01/2022 16:29

Interesting that your sister is leaving all of the work up to you and can't even offer an alternative pub.

Dguu6u · 09/01/2022 16:26

@MasterGland

The research constantly referred to in the guardian article is flawed. There was no attempt whatsoever to control any of the variables, that might also impact upon particulate measurement indoors. I have tried and failed several times to reproduce the results of the report, once I had controlled for other factors. I have placed a particulate monitor next to the log burner, and have often failed to notice any increase from base levels whatsoever during refuelling. I use proper refuelling technique, and only seasoned wood. I live in the countryside. You have to really squint at my chimney to see if the burner is lit or not, it burns hot so there is very little smoke.

During the course of my "experiments" with particulate measurement, I found the burning of incense and candles to produce the highest levels of particulates, with levels that stayed elevated for longer. Up next was a hairdryer, which was surprising, and frying food.
I do wish someone would publish a study with proper control variables.

Brilliant, didn’t realise you’re an academic and your “experiments” were peer reviewed and published in an academic journal www.mdpi.com/2073-4433/11/12/1326
Velvian · 09/01/2022 16:04

My DS2 had constant bronchiolitis 1 winter, so it would've been sensible to avoid wood burners/fires, had I been aware.

FourTeaFallOut · 09/01/2022 16:03

You know the guardian didn't do the research, right?

Soontobe60 · 09/01/2022 15:57

@WiganDiva

Wow. I thought she was bonkers until I read that Guardian article. Totally unaware of this!
Don’t forget though, some Guardian articles would have us believe that people can change sex, females should accept males in single sex spaces and Laurel Hubbard had no advantage as a male bodied transwoman even though they took the place of an actual female in the Olympics.
Youngstreet · 09/01/2022 15:56

@PriamFarrl

If log burners were banned here I think 40% of citizens would be cold.

Bollocks. Everyone I know who has a log burner has it because it’s nice. And that includes my family where I grew up which has a dodgy electrical supply and no gas.

I don’t deny that there is a need for log burners etc in rural areas but it is most certainly not 40% of the population.

Did you see I live in rural France? Logs are much cheaper than oil or electricity. Electricity is really expensive in France. I don’t have any friends or neighbours in France who buy log burners to look at. God, I’d love a simple, price equivalent alternative that didn’t need cleaning, emptying and lighting everyday from November until March! My dh would love not to cut logs one day every fortnight to keep us going. You’re the one talking bollocks.
RamblingFar · 09/01/2022 15:48

I'm asthmatic. My neighbours' ones set my asthma off when I'm inside my own house. The smell and particles travel a long way.

HardbackWriter · 09/01/2022 15:46

@StoneofDestiny

Nuts. There are lots of pollutant substances in the environment. You'd be hard pressed to get through life avoiding them all - fires, log burners, air conditioning, scented candles, vehicles, pesticides etc
Again, I'd love to see the reactions if someone took this attitude to cigarette smoke on MN - 'there are loads of risks in life so of course it's fine for you to smoke into the pram, MIL' - said no MNer ever... But wood fires are pretty and tasteful so it's fine.
PriamFarrl · 09/01/2022 15:45

If log burners were banned here I think 40% of citizens would be cold.

Bollocks. Everyone I know who has a log burner has it because it’s nice. And that includes my family where I grew up which has a dodgy electrical supply and no gas.

I don’t deny that there is a need for log burners etc in rural areas but it is most certainly not 40% of the population.

BigRedDuck · 09/01/2022 15:41

Well they can't ban log burners until they can guarantee that all of us in deepest darkest rural areas are always going to have power/gas supply/oil fired heating/delete as necessary.
Literally every single one of my neighbours has a log burner or an open fire because when the power goes out (no gas supply here) that's all we have for heat/cooking. And as previous posters said, wood needs to be properly seasoned. If you're in a pub and the fire is smoky then there's an issue with the wood.

SIL is only unreasonable for asking you to change your plans. Just go without them and do something else another time