Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want dd to tell me where she is getting this money from

711 replies

Curato · 09/01/2022 09:43

Dd is in her second year at university and for Christmas she bought ds a laptop. I thought this was a lot to have spent so I looked it up and it must’ve cost her around £600. I asked her about it and she said she could afford it and loves her brother etc so I accepted it.

It was ds 16th birthday on Friday and for that she bought him a new IPhone and Apple Watch.

I spoke to her and said I noticed she had spent a lot of money on ds for Christmas and his birthday as she is a student with a part time job in retail.

She then said she has a little extra thing on the side which is going really well. When I asked what this was she refused to tell me.

I spoke to DH who said she is an adult and doesn’t have to justify herself to me anymore and I should respect her decision. I am really worried though that she has become embroiled in something though.

AIBU to speak to her again and insist she tells me what she is doing to generate this money or do I need to cut the apron strings.

OP posts:
DriftGames · 16/01/2022 07:11

100000% onlyfans.

RowanAlong · 16/01/2022 06:46

That would be really worrying OP. I’d find out what all the negative implications for her are, list them and give them to her, saying you are here to talk any time. She’s young and won’t have really considered how this will look/feel long term.

onelittlefrog · 16/01/2022 06:44

@foxgoosefinch

Leaving all my personal feminist objections aside, whatever she’s doing must take a bit of time to do, even if it’s only uploading foot pics or chatting to perves. I’d be thinking that rather than enjoying bits of cash now, she ought to put that time into her university work so that she can get a good job later.

University is for such a short time, and the vast majority of students are not doing anywhere near the work they ought to be doing in order to do really well.

No point spending time earning cash for expensive handbags, then get a 2:2 and ruin your job prospects. Even if she’s on track for a 2:1 she’s be better off putting her extra OnlyFans time into getting a First rather than doing “borderline sex work” for extra luxuries.

Well if we all had that kind of maturity and insight in our late teens/ early twenties, we would all be rich and successful.

No offense but pointing out that a teenager is doing something daft isn't exactly genius level thinking! Grin

cookiemonster2468 · 16/01/2022 06:41

She says it’s safe and doesn’t think it will have any future implications

That is one naive comment that you could address straight away. Anything she's doing on Only Fans could potentially be floating around on the internet forever, and form part of her digital footprint for life. What kind of career does she want? Presumably she does want a career as she is at uni. It is worth doing some research and having a chat about that.

cookiemonster2468 · 16/01/2022 06:38

@Curato

So I spoke to her this afternoon. I was told her that I was very worried that she had become caught up in something and that I am her mum so will always love and support her.

She wasn’t very forthcoming at first other than to say it wasn’t illegal. After a bit of a heart to heart she opened up and told me that she is using various websites to get people to send her money as part of some fantasy they have. She says it’s all online and was adamant that she has never done anything that will come to light in the future when I asked her.

I am struggling to process it in truth. I am not happy about it really other than the fact she says it’s safe and doesn’t think it will have any future implications. I just don’t like the thought of her doing anything to indulge random mens fantasies for money.

Just saw this. That must have been very upsetting to hear.

There is nothing you can really do as she is an adult and can make this decision if she wants to, but she does need to make it with her eyes open about potential dangers.

If you Google "dangers of digital sex work" or "dangers of Only Fans" you could find some resources to send her way, such as: blog.blackbullion.com/student-blog/2021/03/30/do-you-know-the-dangers-of-onlyfans/

Just make sure she has all the information about what she is doing, and then once she does, you will need to respect her decision.

cookiemonster2468 · 16/01/2022 06:34

@MsAgnesDiPesto

Although her decisions are her own at that age, she is still young and might not realise that, if she is doing some form of sex work, she could be putting herself in danger. I’d avoid making an ultimatum, and try to keep the lines of communication open so she can talk to you if she is worried or feels unsafe at any point.

You could have a conversation about the future, and being careful about your digital footprint, and so on, without accusing her of anything or demanding information she doesn’t want to give.

You are right to be concerned but this will need careful handling and a willingness to step back, if you are to maintain a strong relationship into her adulthood.

This is very good advice.

She doesn't want to tell you because it is sex work of some kind, either
online or IRL. Most likely Only Fans but it could be some sort of escort work and there is a chance she could be putting herself in danger.

She is young. Yes she's an adult, but she may still be naive.

I would attempt a non-judgmental chat, where you make it very clear that her choices are her own, and you will respect whatever she decides to do, but tell her you are there to talk if she ever needs to.

It will probably sound a bit preachy if you start talking about the dangers of it, but it's important anyway to reiterate that people do get into trouble doing this sort of thing, and that her brother doesn't need her to buy him a £600 laptop.

I would also offer to pay for some counselling for her if you're in a position to do so, just as an ongoing thing (not because there's anything wwrong with her), just so she has someone to talk to.

jamandmarmaladethesecondcoming · 16/01/2022 05:33

How are you feeling about it all now, OP?

mathanxiety · 16/01/2022 02:56

Plumbuddle, no, I don't think she could, any more than the money launderer's local Tesco could, or a taxi driver who takes him to the airport, or the dog walker who walks his dogs, etc.

Baxterbear · 15/01/2022 20:17

[quote MorkandMandy]@Baxterbear Mum subs her income so it really does.[/quote]
I didn't mean my response to come across so abrupt! I was coming from the point of view that if dd does reveal how she's making her money it may not be an answer that mum was expecting and could in theory be quite upsetting. It could be she's much better off not knowing?

Plumbuddle · 15/01/2022 19:15

Might be a point to make to her. Also she may be used by money launderers. If they are investigated and their bank accounts seized, she could be investigated as a recipient.

Plumbuddle · 15/01/2022 19:14

This is how this sort of work leads to blackmail...

CarlatheJackal · 15/01/2022 18:58

Would a future life partner find that appealing

Yeah, I teach my daughter not to give a fuck what any real man thinks, let alone imaginary ones she hasn't met.

MorkandMandy · 15/01/2022 18:53

@Baxterbear Mum subs her income so it really does.

MorkandMandy · 15/01/2022 18:52

Would she think twice OP if she realised she needs to immortalise all of these incomings by filing a self-assessment return? I’m assuming she’s well above threshold given those gifts.

Baxterbear · 15/01/2022 18:51

Could be something like Only Fans? Whatever it is your dd is doing to earn herself a bit of coin has got absolutely NOTHING to do with you! She's an adult after all!

Mirw · 15/01/2022 17:56

Making money online, declaring it to the taxman? If not, then it could come back and bite her especially if she has a student loan. Money earned needs to be declared before she spends it...

MorkandMandy · 15/01/2022 17:11

I know this isn’t the point but with such (suggested) high income, do make sure she understands how self-employment and taxes work. You don’t want this to leave a lasting impact of any sort. (I’m not actually sure if people who do that stuff register, but I’m assuming it’s legal?)

hivemindneeded · 13/01/2022 23:32

She is utterly naive if she thinks it has no chance of coming back to haunt her. Would a future life partner find that appealing? What about a future employer? Our lives are not private any more. If it started on line, there's a record of it and if that falls into the wrong hands she could end up publicly humiliated or really regretful.

PurpleMauve · 13/01/2022 21:19

@Gemzerella

I’m guessing you missed OP’s update two days ago or I do not have a clue about cryptocurrency:

‘…..She wasn’t very forthcoming at first other than to say it wasn’t illegal. After a bit of a heart to heart she opened up and told me that she is using various websites to get people to send her money as part of some fantasy they have. She says it’s all online and was adamant that she has never done anything that will come to light in the future when I asked her.

I am struggling to process it in truth. I am not happy about it really other than the fact she says it’s safe and doesn’t think it will have any future implications. I just don’t like the thought of her doing anything to indulge random mens fantasies for money.’

Gemzerella · 13/01/2022 18:39

Just to give you a more positive potential outcome...

She could be into cryptocurrency, there is A LOT of money in it right now, it's very easy with the right guidance to make a shed load of money.

Always worth considering non illegal activities 😍

I know a guy at unit that's turned £3000 of student loan into £3,000,000 (no exaggeration here, I know this for a fact) so it could be something like that?

Imagine if she were the next crypto entrepreneur! 😁

StationaryMagpie · 13/01/2022 15:36

oh.. FinDom.. i've not dabbled but i know someone that wants me to do it.. but in honesty, i'm not comfortable with it... but if you're happy to basically degrade someone and tell them to pay you to make up for what a shit person they are, its fine.

Plumbuddle · 13/01/2022 09:43

[quote anotherbrewplease]**@StellaDarkley* and @foxgoosefinch* - yep - you're both right but unfortunately the OP does not have magical controls over her daughter. She can advise and be there for her, but at the end of the day, the daughter is going to do what she wants to do, and it probably isn't sensible. (!)

Not sure how your comments are helpful to the OP when it is basically stating the very obvious Confused[/quote]
I think these ideas are supportive and helpful to op because they may give her ideas to float in her discussions with her daughter that could be a way into supporting her daughter out of this. For example the economic logic about wasting time now and being lower qualified later might motivate a young woman who was money minded, more than lecturing her about the male abuse or danger angle. Everyone has their triggers. It's worth brainstorming about. What op can't do is just leave it be and wash her hands if it but she has to be so subtle.

Plumbuddle · 13/01/2022 09:37

@AllThePogs

Women on onlyfans are encouraged to lie about their earnings because it is a MLM scheme. If you sign people up, you get a percentage of their earnings. So the more people they sign up, the more money they get. So don't believe what you hear. Most do not make much money at all unless doing extreme stuff.
Thanks for confirming it is a pyramid scheme as I imagined. I said that earlier down the thread and someone insisted I was wrong. Prostitution of women seems to be thriving as a form of exploitation in this day and age because women are willing and recruit each other. We are at a real crossroads in social history it seems to me. On the one hand me too and everyone's invited type campaigns recognising how oppressive this stuff is to young girls and on the other the allegedly free and liberal young voices saying it's about freedom from taboo and financial liberty for women. I come back to Virginia Guiffre here. If someone had tapped her on the shoulder aged 17 and started lecturing her about what she was doing taking wads of cash because it was easy money and recruiting her friends (see the text she sent to "Carolyn" boasting about getting to sleep with a prince) she would have really rejected the advice. But experience makes one wiser. She's calling it rape now. But she would never have done then. I hope she wins so that young girls can see how it plays out in real life. But op you have to thread so carefully to keep your daughters trust because only experience teaches a girl at this age and it takes time to see the realities.
anotherbrewplease · 13/01/2022 05:23

@StellaDarkley and @foxgoosefinch - yep - you're both right but unfortunately the OP does not have magical controls over her daughter. She can advise and be there for her, but at the end of the day, the daughter is going to do what she wants to do, and it probably isn't sensible. (!)

Not sure how your comments are helpful to the OP when it is basically stating the very obvious Confused

foxgoosefinch · 13/01/2022 02:24

Leaving all my personal feminist objections aside, whatever she’s doing must take a bit of time to do, even if it’s only uploading foot pics or chatting to perves. I’d be thinking that rather than enjoying bits of cash now, she ought to put that time into her university work so that she can get a good job later.

University is for such a short time, and the vast majority of students are not doing anywhere near the work they ought to be doing in order to do really well.

No point spending time earning cash for expensive handbags, then get a 2:2 and ruin your job prospects. Even if she’s on track for a 2:1 she’s be better off putting her extra OnlyFans time into getting a First rather than doing “borderline sex work” for extra luxuries.