Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that a student loan can be enough to survive on at uni without having to get a job?

186 replies

Mickeyx0x0 · 08/01/2022 23:10

My son is in second year of uni. Due to a drop in our income due to pandemic, he has received full student loan last year and this year. If he had not got full loan, we would otherwise have made it up to the same amount with our parental contribution.

He has found the amount he has been awarded more than enough to live on, without needing to get a part time job. Perhaps it is the area his uni is in (Loughborough where costs are cheaper than some places). Maybe my son is more frugal than the average student (quite possibly; not sure about this one). I am just curious as to whether other people find that their student DC is can manage on their student loan without needing to work as well?

OP posts:
MollyBloomYes · 08/01/2022 23:56

I started university in 2008 on the full whack of student loan because I was a mature student by one year and classed as financially dependent thanks to x number of p60s (and because I'd been working in bar jobs and childcare my p60s were woeful!) As soon as my first lot of rent went out for my halls I was into my overdraft. So there was no way I would have survived without working. I was at Nottingham Uni so not a million miles from Loughborough and of course, 2008 was right when everything went crash.

I left in a lot of overdraft and credit card debt. I didn't want a credit card but had to in the end just to get food. I didn't go out that much, super clubs not being my thing. I was more of a house party and pub kind of girl.

sessell · 08/01/2022 23:54

Both my DDs get full student loans.The oldest one who graduated last year saved £5k from her loans. The other is in central London on £12k pa and has already saved £1k in her first term. They both know how to cook from basics and buy most of their clothes in charity shops (you'd never know). They have good social lives - pubs, clubs, theatre etc. But again they are sensible and 'pre-load' before nights out so they only need to buy one drink at pub/club prices. So it's more than possible to live comfortably on a full student loan.

TitoMojito · 08/01/2022 23:53

It absolutely depends on the circumstances. My student loan was enough for me but I lived at home. My friends who needed to pay for accommodation, for the most part, had jobs.

YerAWizardHarry · 08/01/2022 23:52

@elelel Scottish funding is abysmal! £6750 MAX is shocking

adviceneeded300385 · 08/01/2022 23:52

well yeah obviously if he gets the full loan! i got about 4k a year at uni and my rent was over 5k for the year

forcedfun · 08/01/2022 23:51

The full student loan sounds tolerable but most students won't get the full loan. So I think you may be right but only in cheaper parts of the country and if the student gets the full loan.

Redlocks28 · 08/01/2022 23:50

I’m sure you can understand though that kids qualifying for £9000+ will be able to cope better without getting part time work than those only getting £4200!

forcedfun · 08/01/2022 23:50

Agree with the advice to ensure they do some paid work before looking for graduate jobs. I think it makes an enormous difference.

Scottishskifun · 08/01/2022 23:49

I couldn't live on a student loan alone 15 years ago very much doubt the majority of students can these days!
All of my housemates including myself worked, any friends who didn't were given extra cash by their parents.

It's also not a bad thing at preparing young people for work life and hard work balancing - I did a 30 hr a week course plus a part time job of 20 hours.

forcedfun · 08/01/2022 23:48

@Neverforgetwhothisisfor but the holidays are longer. I saved up in my gap year and also worked during the long holidays.

Kite22 · 08/01/2022 23:46

I couldn’t have survived on just my student loan. I got the minimum amount and no additional help from my parents so needed to work.

Yes, but OP was talking about the full loan. The amount every student should end up with. Not the student loan less the parental contribution. I wouldn't expect students to be able to get by on 1/2 the amount that has been calculated to be the amount needed.

Nope. I'm in London and get the max, about £12k, plus £2.5k grants
but many students choose not to apply to London for that reason. Everyone makes choices. Everyone knows cost of Living in London is considerably more than elsewhere.

Even outside of London, I don't think you can and yet hundreds of thousands of students do manage every year.

Cambridge Uni students aren’t allowed to work during term time, so they have to find a way to manage on their student loans.

But they also have far shorter terms than everyone else so far more weeks to work in the holidays. Also hugely subsidised (catered) accommodation in many colleges so accommodation is cheaper than in so many other Universities.

Wonderfulstuff · 08/01/2022 23:42

The whole system is ridiculous and I’m glad I protested against it when I was a student even though it sadly didn’t get anywhere.

Starting off £30k in debt is not a great start for anyone.

Gmcg123 · 08/01/2022 23:42

In NI the max student loan is just over 6k so I think most would struggle living on that much in the Uk, unless they go to a very cheap city.

Kite22 · 08/01/2022 23:40

Yes. Separately, all 3 of my dc have commented at different times (all at different Universities) that the people who get the full loan are quids in.

As already noted, of course it will depend where you go to University. It will then depend on the accommodation you apply for (and if you get your chosen accommodation). It will depend on the student's budgeting skills; mainly on their willingness / desire to stay within budget; on their expectations of life - if generally, they have grown up living within a budget.
However, yes, a full loan is easily enough for the overwhelming majority of students to live on even though this thread will attract a lot of the 'exceptions' to prove the rule.

JustLyra · 08/01/2022 23:37

It totally depends where you are and the accommodation costs.

Where DS is the full loan would cover the accommodation and leave a just manageable amount.

Where my two DD’s go it wouldn’t be enough, even though they’re not in London. They go to Uni in the same city and share a big-ish one bed flat and that allows them to work part time instead of trying to juggle full hours and full courses. That’s been a life saver when so many jobs traditionally done by students in/near their city (bars, restaurants, touristy things) have been virtually non existent since they went to uni because of covid.

Comefromaway · 08/01/2022 23:32

@titchy

The full loan should be enough - all unis have cheaper accommodation options (these have less demand than the expensive halls!) with the possible exception of Durham which can allocate to very expensive halls.
Yes Durham is the other one that can be a problem as well as Bristol.
Neverforgetwhothisisfor · 08/01/2022 23:32

Cambridge Uni students aren’t allowed to work during term time, so they have to find a way to manage on their student loans.

ElephantOfRisk · 08/01/2022 23:31

Also Scotland. My DC get £4750 per year regardless of whether they live at home or away. It's enough (and probably more than enough) for DS1 who lives at home, especially since he's had virtually no face to face for nearly two years so no travel costs. We feed and house him so he has no real costs. For DS2 who lives away, his loan would hardly cover his housing costs so he needs subsidised so he can feed himself and travel and have a life.

MsAgnesDiPesto · 08/01/2022 23:29

@user313213521

Regardless of what he can afford to do, I would strongly advise your DS to take on some sort of paid work alongside his studies.

I've done graduate recruitment, and I always find myself feeling deeply unimpressed by people with a string of qualifications and no actual work experience. To be blunt, I would prefer they'd learned basic workplace expectations, like turning up on time - and how to graft - before I'm line managing them.

Agree strongly with this. Recent experience with graduate apprentices shows me that ideas of how to behave in a work environment, what the basic expectations are with regard to timekeeping, initiative and common sense are NOT innate and need to be learned.

I’d much rather take someone who has worked, even in retail or hospitality alongside their degree studies, so I know I don’t have to ‘finish’ them myself.

Mickeyx0x0 · 08/01/2022 23:29

My son's self catering hall costs £4278 for this academic year (about £109 per week). His full student loan is £9706, so he seems to be fine to live on the amount he is getting.

OP posts:
SickAndTiredAgain · 08/01/2022 23:29

I couldn’t have survived on just my student loan. I got the minimum amount and no additional help from my parents so needed to work.
Almost everyone I know had help from their parents so presumably would have needed to work like I did if they hadn’t had that help.

titchy · 08/01/2022 23:27

The full loan should be enough - all unis have cheaper accommodation options (these have less demand than the expensive halls!) with the possible exception of Durham which can allocate to very expensive halls.

elelel · 08/01/2022 23:26

@user313213521

Regardless of what he can afford to do, I would strongly advise your DS to take on some sort of paid work alongside his studies.

I've done graduate recruitment, and I always find myself feeling deeply unimpressed by people with a string of qualifications and no actual work experience. To be blunt, I would prefer they'd learned basic workplace expectations, like turning up on time - and how to graft - before I'm line managing them.

I think this is individual. There is no way DS could manage a job on top of his university workload, actually he probably could but he wouldn't do so well at his course which is the most important factor right now.

Snozzlemaid · 08/01/2022 23:25

My dd doesn't get the full loan and has enough without the need for working or for us having to give her any money.
She saved quite a bit last year as she was at home for so long and got a refund on her halls rent. So that's helped this year as living costs are more now she's not in halls.

AvocadoPlant · 08/01/2022 23:25

Nope, the loan DD gets doesn’t even cover the cost of her self catered student halls.

The system would be much fairer if all students could apply for what they needed up to the maximum, rather than parents having to pick up the slack
DD would need to earn around £500 pcm to bring her up to the max loan that your son gets.