Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that a student loan can be enough to survive on at uni without having to get a job?

186 replies

Mickeyx0x0 · 08/01/2022 23:10

My son is in second year of uni. Due to a drop in our income due to pandemic, he has received full student loan last year and this year. If he had not got full loan, we would otherwise have made it up to the same amount with our parental contribution.

He has found the amount he has been awarded more than enough to live on, without needing to get a part time job. Perhaps it is the area his uni is in (Loughborough where costs are cheaper than some places). Maybe my son is more frugal than the average student (quite possibly; not sure about this one). I am just curious as to whether other people find that their student DC is can manage on their student loan without needing to work as well?

OP posts:
Sandinmyknickers · 09/01/2022 10:50

@darkNlovely

Nope. I'm in London and get the max, about £12k, plus £2.5k grants

I can only afford to live because I saved up almost £20k living at home beforehand.

Even outside of London, I don't think you can

That's enough to live on in London though. Honestly, sometimes people on MN act like there aren't poor people in London. It's a frugal existence but not by any stretch if the imagination impossible for a typical student (young single person without dependents). I would still get a part time job in that situation but more for comfort...14.5k annually is definitely enough to live on in London. I would recommend finding cheaper areas to live and accommodation.
Ashard20 · 09/01/2022 10:45

It also depends massively on the subject studied. For example, a music conservatoire student in London is looking at a starting price of £189 per week, for 41 weeks, to live in halls. It's also very difficult for them to work as they are often involved in performances in the evenings or at weekends. They also need to devote a huge amount of time to practising, outside teaching hours.
If they don't receive the full loan, or parents are unable to top it up to the amount for London weighting, I can imagine that they will struggle.

Sandinmyknickers · 09/01/2022 10:40

Not recent but I graduated coming up to 10 years ago, received full loan, was in Leeds and I had enough to not require any support from parents. However unless you were a medical student and had loads of contact hours, everyone got a job because why not make some more money to fund summer and other things? Plus,you're technically an adult...therefore in my mind you need to have some form of income from work and loans are there to support you to study. But if you want anything more than the bare minimum, want to go on holiday etc, that comes out your own earnings

BurningTheClocks · 09/01/2022 10:38

DS received the full loan and the maintenance part was £4 short of his rent. Which left less than nothing to live on without a top up.

Theonewiththecandles · 09/01/2022 10:37

I got the full amount due to my mum being a lone parent and only earning around 16k a year and it was enough. I learnt to budget and calculate how much money I had each week, one year I got an Xmas temp job at Primark for some extra money but other than that it covered everything and more to be honest as my flatmate in my final year didn't get much I would buy most of the food for the both of us, particularly for breakfast/evening meal, she sorted out her own lunches. We cooked everything from scratch so it was cheaper but I usually ended up with about £60-80 a week after food shopping which was enough for me. Not London of course, but one of the big northern cities.

OrangeShark27 · 09/01/2022 10:30

With subscriptions Spotify is half the price for students

Not everyone needs every subscription, one person in the house prime, one Netflix. A takeaway is between 5 and 10. Again delivery costs shared between the whole house.

Also a lot of students work the majority of at least latter year students will have a job at least sometimes and this enables them to afford nice things, why shouldn't they?

I know a couple of students who had studio flats. Mature students with reasonably well paying Saturday jobs. They weren't paying for it out of their student loan

Mickeyx0x0 · 09/01/2022 10:27

@PattyPan

I went to Oxbridge (graduated 5 years ago) and my loan didn’t even always cover my rent so yes YABU it definitely depends on area/university and I would expect your DS’s experience to be unusual.
Did you receive full loan? If not, did your parents pay you the parental contribution?
OP posts:
RollaCola84 · 09/01/2022 10:25

@user313213521 You've never recruited an Oxford or Cambridge graduate then ? We weren't allowed to work in term time and as far as I know that hasn't changed.

Umbongoumbongo999 · 09/01/2022 10:21

My DS is first year, not London. He gets the minimum loan and we match the parental contribution to equivalent to max loan. His loan is about 2k short of his accommodation cost and we give him the balance which is 200 per month and also pay phone, xbox, spotify and his driving lessons.

He doesn't have a job (combination of lazy and not having luxury lifestyle aspirations). He rarely drinks and doesn't go clubbing, so the £200 covers travel, groceries, laundry, study supplies, and lunches out, or the odd takeaway.

I'm encouraging him to get a job as I think it would really bring him along socially, not just for the money, hut he is super introverted and struggles to spend hours in the company of others. I think something fairly solitary like shelf stacking would work for him.

Abraxan · 09/01/2022 10:21

Now, most students I know live in their own studio flats, have the latest iPhones, run a car, eat out and / or use Deliveroo several times a week, have subscriptions to Netflix, Spotify and Amazon Price etc.,and so on.

Only know one in a studio flat and she went a couple of years later than her school friends, so 20y rather than 18y. Rest are in halls (albeit en-suite rooms in flats of 4-6 with a shared kitchen, or shared houses (in years 2/3).

Latest phones - yes, many seem to. Usually nights and paid for my parents, often as Christmas or birthday gifts. Same as before they went to university.

Subscriptions - usually a family account in my experience., so they aren't paying for it.

Run a car - I know very small number with cars, but those that do it's often paid for by a parent, often bought before they went to university, or by an older student who was earning before they went.

Eat out/deliveroo - more the take away option for those I know, often paid for using birthday/Christmas gift cards. Dd and a number of friends all got Just Eat vouchers this Christmas, as well as Costa ones. A fair few tend to enjoy the odd meal out rather than spending it on a big night out drinking, mainly due to covid restrictions on that in last couple of years though.

PattyPan · 09/01/2022 10:15

I went to Oxbridge (graduated 5 years ago) and my loan didn’t even always cover my rent so yes YABU it definitely depends on area/university and I would expect your DS’s experience to be unusual.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 09/01/2022 10:14

Dd can’t work for various reasons though she does work in the summer holidays

Ds2 will be looking for a job this year although he will probably just work during the summer as well

Asdf12345 · 09/01/2022 10:14

It’s a long time since I was at uni, but back then there was no way it would have been workable without significant parental support or bursaries.

The rules were clear that if we failed an exam and had been working in term time there would be no second chances, but bursaries were not necessarily available unless very low family income.

This ended up with an odd situation where of the two flat mates with most disposable income one was from a long line of investment bankers, and the other was from nothing. Those of us from middle of the road backgrounds were the most stretched.

halulat · 09/01/2022 10:14

Definitely depends on location. DS went to Newcastle where his rent was under £500 a month. DD is at Oxford and while hall fees are actually cheaper than Newcastle was( as they are subsidised), when she has to move into a house next year, rent will be almost £700 per month.
She is also not allowed/ able to work on term time but did save a lot for her 6th form job fortunately.
We have topped up to full loan amount for both.we were lucky that they haven't been at u I at the same time though.
I was in my last year when student loans were introduced and am sure one of the arguments for them was that they were not based on parental income. The grant system which was based on parental income did take into account siblings studying which IMO the loans system should still do.

OrangeShark27 · 09/01/2022 10:14

It very much depends where you are based. I went to uni in Wales and my accomodation was half that of some of my friends, drinks were about a quarter sometimes even less. Buses were less, parking was less. Everything was cheaper and so its doable

When I was in first year it was very much a competition of frugality, how much money you can save, how little you can live off. But that gets boring very quickly, it's nice to have a bit more money to eat better, maybe run a car, go on holidays, buy drinks when you are out instead of having to make sure you've drunk enough before entry. Have the odd meal out. It doesn't take many hours a week as a student to improve your lifestyle quite a lot. I think I worked about 10-15 hours a week and that easily tops you up. The people who were still mass cooking plain pasta and bean tins in final uear, and refusing to do anything to save money were a bit irritating when they could have a got a bloody job.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 09/01/2022 10:13

@Mickeyx0x0

My son's self catering hall costs £4278 for this academic year (about £109 per week). His full student loan is £9706, so he seems to be fine to live on the amount he is getting.
In the position your child is in my children would manage absolutely fine…its more weekly money than they are getting now

Dh pays their rent which is about 6k per child and they get £250 a month on top

Lazypuppy · 09/01/2022 10:12

OP as someone else has said, they really should get a job regardless. Whrn thry come to apply for jobs after 3 years of no work, most employers won't be that impressed and would prpbably chose someone who had real world wotk experience. Unless he is doing a full time degree like teaching, he will have very few hours of lectures a week and ppenty of time to work

WestendVBroadway · 09/01/2022 10:10

I agree with you OP, but only if the student receives the full loan. My DD is at what is considered a 'London' uni, and due to my DH having recently retired she receives the full loan this year. This gives her £236 per week. Her 2nd year accommodation in shared house is approximately £120 a week with bills. This leaves her with over £100 per week for food and other expenses. This is more than enough. In her first year when she received less we topped it up slightly. However most students do not receive the full loan and they have no choice but to work to supplement their income.

RampantIvy · 09/01/2022 10:09

One of mine saved thousands during this time.

Doing what? Was this before covid?

Mickeyx0x0 · 09/01/2022 10:04

Thank you all for your posts BTW. All of the insights given much appreciated. The reason I posted this thread was to work out whether my DS is atypical in being able to manage fine on his student maintenance loan. As my DD is about to start Uni this year, I was wondering if she will also be able to manage her finances. DD is a more extravagant spender than DS so I am curious if she is likely to need to get a job.

OP posts:
hedgehogger1 · 09/01/2022 10:04

Lots of info here www.moneysavingexpert.com/students/student-loans-tuition-fees-changes/

Redlocks28 · 09/01/2022 09:59

Now, most students I know live in their own studio flats, have the latest iPhones, run a car, eat out and / or use Deliveroo several times a week, have subscriptions to Netflix, Spotify and Amazon Price etc.,and so on.

I don’t know a single student who lives a life like that!

All live in halls or shared houses, none run a car (most can’t drive due to covid disruption to tests), none use deliveroo regularly and the ones watching Netflix are using their parents’ login!

LethargicActress · 09/01/2022 09:55

My dc get full loan because I’m a low income single parent. Both living in halls or dedicated student accommodation, in expensive cities, and neither have to work out of necessity. Nor do I have to provide financial support beyond the normal things that most parents would provide like bedding, kitchen equipment etc.

Mickeyx0x0 · 09/01/2022 09:54

@Paq

Also, if he's in halls and not a flat in second year (less usual for students) presumably his rent includes utilities/wifi?
He is in a uni flat, so rent does cover gas, electricity, and WiFi. He is self catering so buys food. Seems to order a lot of takeaways which he appears to be able to afford.
OP posts:
Lou98 · 09/01/2022 09:54

[quote YerAWizardHarry]@elelel Scottish funding is abysmal! £6750 MAX is shocking[/quote]

While I do agree it's not a lot, they also cover the cost of uni fees so we don't need to pay anything (unless you go on to do PG etc)

I didn't qualify for bursaries when I was at uni a few years ago so I got the full loan amount of £4750 for the year. Split over 10 months I got £475 a month, I was in the cheapest halls at my Uni and was still £450 a month for accommodation. I had to work as £25 a month covered nothing.

I got a job in a local nightclub so I could work at night, I made such good friends doing it and had such a great time that I was glad I did it. The money was rubbish and I was constantly skint but I somehow made do