Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if any of the mums on here are the non-resident parent and if so what that's like as a mother?

31 replies

Draineddraineddrained · 08/01/2022 22:54

When my parents split up it was my mum who left to live with her affair partner, and my sister and I lived with my dad. We saw our mum reasonably regularly when we were small, less and less often as we got older. She always said it was because my dad (who at that time was alcoholic and abusive to her) had said that if she went after custody he would make sure she never saw either of us again, would use her mental health history to discredit her etc. I've never spoken to my dad about it. Its entirely plausible that this is true given the kind of person he is, however my mum is also an unreliable witness and due to her not pursuing contact with us as teens as it waned, and waiting until we were adults before really getting involved with us again and various other factors, not least she didn't take us with her when she left, I'd be surprised if she had actually wanted any custody of us or would have ever seriously tried for it.

Recently watched The Lost Daughter and a lot of it resonated uncomfortably. My mum was never maternal, always treated us like confidantes and friends far more than children even when we were very little.

So I'm wondering - what's it like to be the mum who leaves? To see your kids rarely, or not at all, by choice? I literally can't imagine ever willingly leaving my daughters. And that brings up a lot of feelings about my now deceased mum (who as an adult i had a very close, quite dysfunctional relationship with) and how she felt about me/us. Especially in the light of more and more frequent threads on here where mum's state categorically that they are not depressed or anxious, they just think motherhood was a mistake and they don't enjoy their children. Any insights or views would be much welcomed.

I'm well aware men do this all the time and no-one bats an eye, so don't really want the thread to turn into a dissection of that inequality. It's more that, given that social context and the pressure on mums to stay and assume the responsibility, what is it like to swim against that tide and what motivates it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AreSomeGoldfishJustDicks · 12/01/2022 10:28

@Nomoreusernames1244

It’s complicated isn’t it. The pressure on mums to remain rp is huge, and the societal shame if they aren’t is immense.

I know when my brothers dd wanted to move in with him for a’levels- the college on his doorstep was outstanding, ran the course she wanted, her school had no 6th form etc, her mum said no. The mentality was very much “i won’t let him take my kids off me”. Child ended up having to get up at 6 and take two buses to go to the 6th form nearest her mum.

No background, involved dad, (mum had had the affair), genuinely child's choice.

As a mum I would feel the same. Absolutely heartbroken, if my child decided to live with their other parent. Somehow it feels much more impactful for a mum. I have an acquaintance whose child did move in with dad for a’levels- she’s rented the childs room out, and seems to have completely disconnected. Grief? Moving on? Who knows.

If it’s genuinely done in the interests of the child though, why do we still feel it’s wrong? Do we think men can’t parent? Or can’t parent as well? In a way has society created these dads who disconnect after a split- they’ll never be RP, never have that relationship, and is splitting between two homes good for the child?

Thinking about it- why doesn’t boarding school have the same stigma, to the same extent? Mum and dad will only see the child holidays and weekends, same as a nrp.

Very interesting point actually. It was my therapist that said to me, why shouldn't her father be the resident parent if that's what makes her happy?

He's a brilliant Dad to her, although spoils her a lot more than I'm comfortable with but she's thriving in school and is very happy and content.

I really think that it's only the mother that suffers alot of the time and sometimes we really need to put the happiness of the child above our own expectations. As heartbreaking as that is.

Nomoreusernames1244 · 12/01/2022 08:05

It’s complicated isn’t it. The pressure on mums to remain rp is huge, and the societal shame if they aren’t is immense.

I know when my brothers dd wanted to move in with him for a’levels- the college on his doorstep was outstanding, ran the course she wanted, her school had no 6th form etc, her mum said no. The mentality was very much “i won’t let him take my kids off me”. Child ended up having to get up at 6 and take two buses to go to the 6th form nearest her mum.

No background, involved dad, (mum had had the affair), genuinely child's choice.

As a mum I would feel the same. Absolutely heartbroken, if my child decided to live with their other parent. Somehow it feels much more impactful for a mum. I have an acquaintance whose child did move in with dad for a’levels- she’s rented the childs room out, and seems to have completely disconnected. Grief? Moving on? Who knows.

If it’s genuinely done in the interests of the child though, why do we still feel it’s wrong? Do we think men can’t parent? Or can’t parent as well? In a way has society created these dads who disconnect after a split- they’ll never be RP, never have that relationship, and is splitting between two homes good for the child?

Thinking about it- why doesn’t boarding school have the same stigma, to the same extent? Mum and dad will only see the child holidays and weekends, same as a nrp.

Ivchangedmynameforthis · 12/01/2022 07:20

@HunterHearstHelmsley thank you. There has never been any court proceedings here as DC is old enough to have his opinion be enough. I absolutely 100% wish it could have gone to court as I am a professional well educated woman, good job, lovely home and other DC are happy, academically gifted and thriving. Any court anywhere in the world would see straight through them and see that I am in fact a very loving mother. My only crime and wrong doing was making sure he was punished by school for something he did which I found absolutely disgusting. I should point out he has been assessed by CAMHS numerous times and has a history of violence and being particularly nasty.

Oneforthemoneytwo · 11/01/2022 22:41

@Natty13 you wrote my story word for word. Children should be able to be with their mums. I can’t ever forgive my mother for not trying to get us back living with her. My father is incredible, one in a million but my relationship with my mum is irreparably damaged, I dislike her intensely and I have no proper maternal relationship

HunterHearstHelmsley · 11/01/2022 22:33

@Ivchangedmynameforthis

I'm NRP to my eldest child. My heart is broken. Iv not seen him in over 2 years (his choice not mine). I'm not abusive, an alcoholic or anything mentioned above. Just a normal, loving mother whos child has been poisoned by a Disney Dad. Iv had CBT, many many counselling sessions etc to get to a point where I can actually talk about it. The constant guilt, the sadness and feeling of loss is all consuming. The worst part for me is my other DC growing up without their sibling. 💐 for all who know exactly how I feel.
I really feel you. My heart breaks for my friend and I'm utterly sickened by the amount of so called professionals that can't see through it. Flowers
HunterHearstHelmsley · 11/01/2022 22:31

My best friend is NRP. Not through choice. If you asked the children they would say it was her decision because their Dad has successfully brainwashed them.

She isn't the same person she was. She won't go out really, other than for really special occasions. She says she shouldn't be having fun as she hasn't got her children.

I hate that man with all my soul. Those poor children are missing out on a wonderful mother and support network I just hope that one day they finally see their father for what he is.

I was privy to all the court proceedings so I know I have the full story.

IncorrigibleTitmouse · 11/01/2022 22:30

It's the worst thing that's ever happened to me. In my case it was incited by PND and PTSD. But like @RubyWho I just can't talk too much about it.

WeaverofWords · 11/01/2022 22:25

I would say that our 50:50 arrangement is more like 90:10 😬

AreSomeGoldfishJustDicks · 11/01/2022 22:25

I was raised by my Dad and now I've ended up being the NRP with my eldest daughter, it's like history repeating itself.

Except I have a great relationship with DD's dad.
She just prefers to be with him because she's an only child there and can do whatever she wants and I have two more younger children and rules at my house.
I see her every Sunday. Her choice. She has a busy schedule during the week!

I hate it, the guilt eats me up every second of every day. Everyone tells me, as long as she is happy that's all that matters. And she is very happy. It's only me that's hurting.

The worst is I spent the first 5 years of her life working all the hours under the sun to keep a roof over our heads when I split with her Dad. He never paid a penny towards her but within that time their relationship grew because I was never there.
I feel very bitter about that.

Hunderland · 11/01/2022 22:25

A friend of a friend left her DH and two young daughters to move to the US with a man.

My friend was horrified she chose to do that. But life is not usually as simple as choice A or B, I find.

WeaverofWords · 11/01/2022 22:24

My exh and I share 50:50 care except that he chose a trendy house near our city & he is also very lenient & less disciplined than I am. I live in a remote village. As a consequence my dcs choose to live more at his than at mine.

I won’t lie, it did hurt at first, but now I make a lot of effort to see my eldest in particular, by suggesting lunch dates, dinners here, offering lifts. I just have to work that little bit harder. They were/are also at boarding schools which meant even less time together! The time in the car has been invaluable. I find myself offering lifts a lot, to stay engaged, and also using social media to check in (non invasively!) where appropriate, or suggesting things to do together. One of them recognises now that my house is tidier and more ordered than my ex’s, and that the bedrooms here are larger with more space for get-together with friends, and seems to be starting to prefer it. Time will tell…

Ivchangedmynameforthis · 11/01/2022 22:14

I'm NRP to my eldest child. My heart is broken. Iv not seen him in over 2 years (his choice not mine). I'm not abusive, an alcoholic or anything mentioned above. Just a normal, loving mother whos child has been poisoned by a Disney Dad. Iv had CBT, many many counselling sessions etc to get to a point where I can actually talk about it. The constant guilt, the sadness and feeling of loss is all consuming. The worst part for me is my other DC growing up without their sibling. 💐 for all who know exactly how I feel.

Draineddraineddrained · 11/01/2022 22:10

@Natty13

The way you describe your aunt really resonates with my memories of my mother. She too treated us like her friends, over confided (told us in detail about her suicide attempts when we were 8 and 10) and over relied on us for emotional support. She was also incredibly sensitive to anything she perceived as rejection or criticism or betrayal. She was very emotionally fragile. And when she was alive I had a lot of sympathy with her, felt very responsible for her and we were very enmeshed. Now she's dead, and I am struggling to be a good parent to my girls and have healthy relationships with them I realise what a handicap it is to have no idea what that really looks like.

OP posts:
dogaibu · 11/01/2022 22:06

I am.

My ds10's father is a controlling narcissist who pushed me to a suicide attempt in 2013.

He then used said attempt to paint me as an unfit mother and generally mentally unwell woman who was not fit to have then 3yo DS.

He refused to leave our flat, and intimidated and terrified me until I had to leave for my own safety.

He got residency of DS and I git visitation.

I now have DS around 35% of the time. I'm in the middle of another court battle right now, trying to increase it to 50%.

What is it like?... soul destroying is what it's like. The constant feeling that I failed as a mother, that I failed to be there for ds, and do the one thing a mother is meant to do. All the nights he went to bed without a kiss from his mum. All the raised eyebrows and look of surprise when someone finds out I don't have custody of my own child. All the times I grit my teeth when someone tells me I'm lucky, because I can still go out when I please, and lie in when I don't have ds. I would give this up in a heartbeat, to have my boy with me.

If you can avoid being the NRP, then do. Do. It has psychologically damaged me for life.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 11/01/2022 10:09

Not the same as any of the harrowing tales above.

My dd is 13 and has decided she wants “week on, week off” 50:50 with me and her dad because she finds going back and forward more than once a week (on a weekend day) too complicated logistically. She doesn’t even get on that brilliantly with her dad, and I’m not sure this is 100% good for her but she was getting very upset by the moving back and forward when she did EOW and Wednesdays.

I miss her a lot when she’s there and I don’t feel things are quite “whole” here without her. I still have younger one 10 of 14 nights.

Natty13 · 11/01/2022 09:56

Some of these stories are just so sad and my heart goes out to you.

My aunt was the NRP. She and her husband divorced when their oldest was about 11 and both of their 2 children chose to stay with their dad. Even now, decades later she has fairly regular breakdowns about it and struggles a lot with poor mental health.

As much as I have a lot of compassion for her, I can absolutely see why her kids chose to stay with dad. She's a very emotionally immature person, she treated her kids like friends from an early age and for example leaned on them for emotional support in an inappropriate way. Even now they are adults she almost expects them to parent her in a way. It's very sad because she doesn't see it, I think she thought she would have children and they would love her as unconditionally as she loved them and that she'd get that love 100% of the time. On the other hand, their dad is a very mature person, he represented stability, boundaries and real parenting.

In a contrast to the Disney dads we hear about, he was the one who made them do their homework, go to bed on time, ferried them around their hobbies, brush their teeth every night. All she seemed to want from parenting was to have weekly crying fits because she felt fat/ugly/unloved and expect her young children to reassure her then the next day when she was in a better place (I.e. sober) everyone would get treats/fun outings/no bedtimes.

She kicked off the last Christmas we had together and I said to my mum yes, it's very draining being around her but imagine how difficult it is to be her. She has absolutely zero insight into how she affects other people. I think a lot of the mums who are NRP because of drinking or emotional abuse (NOT the ones who have shared stories here about parental alienation or fleeing control and DV) just have a similar outlook on parenthood - it's the children's job to make you feel loved and when there's any kind of the normal parenting difficulties they don't want to know because they feel rejected.

AgathaMystery · 11/01/2022 09:10

Lots of love to all on this thread. My mum was the NRP - she left to live with a man she was having an extra marital affair with when my youngest brother was about 8.

I look at my little DC & marvel that she ever met another person she loved more than she loved living with her own DC. To this day it baffles me. I won’t how she felt about it. She must have wanted to do it so that’s that.

I’m so sorry to everyone struggling. I’m in my 40’s now and me and my mother have a very very good relationship.

Draineddraineddrained · 11/01/2022 08:48

@Toloveandtowork

But what if the "huge problems" were the husband's alcoholism and psychological abuse? Doesn't seem so brave to leave two young children when you go then.

Thanks to those who have replied. It seems in many cases the choice is out of your hands due to ex or kids making their choice. Which I suppose may be how my mum felt, that she was t strong enough to go against my dad for custody. But fundamentally I just don't understand how she could have left us in a situation she herself found intolerable. It's a hard thing to get your head around.

OP posts:
Toloveandtowork · 09/01/2022 19:01

If there were no huge problems, apart from feeling desperately, inconsolably unhappy as a mother, it must take an enormous amount of courage to walk away and be a non resident mother.
The guilt and shame projected from society would be difficult to bear I imagine.

BlackeyedSusan · 09/01/2022 18:30

RubyWho Flowers for you too.

BlackeyedSusan · 09/01/2022 18:28

If dad sees kids once a fortnight he is amazing... If mum does not have main residency she is considered some sort of abomination... Society is far from equal and very unfair in its judgment of women. This is not fair.

Flowers niceshrubbery

RubyWho · 09/01/2022 18:28

I’m a mother and the NRP. The guilt and shame I feel is all consuming.

That’s all I have the energy to say about it.

StormBaby · 09/01/2022 18:09

One of my children decided to live with Dad at age 15. There was no fighting, no drama, me and the ex are extremely amicable. I don’t think I’d ever even raised my voice at said child to be honest as they were so easy to raise! It’s been horrid as I only see them a few times a year as they’d rather see their mates than me. I honestly think they like being spoilt by daddy. Not much I can do. My door is always open. 🤷🏻‍♀️

RandomMess · 09/01/2022 17:53

When things were very very bad with then H I planned to split. He was primary parent, we couldn't afford 2 houses. I would have had to live in a shared house.

He had an epiphany and decided he would work on our marriage.

How did I feel? Awful but staying where I was had driven me to suicidal thoughts and I was under psychiatric care.

I still sometimes struggle with my anger over how he treated me and the damage it caused between me and my DC.

AgnesXNitt · 09/01/2022 17:34

I can give a perspective as a resident SM. My DSCs Mum went on a decade long downward spiral (drugs, alcohol, DV) following her split from my DH and he was nearly instantly the RP. However, she then met a lovely partner and had more children and really turned her life around. I know she has regrets about missing out years with the kids but has really tried to make amends and they have welcomed her back with open arms (which their Dad and I are delighted about). I've spoken to her on many occasions about it and she acknowledges that she doesn't have the same relationship with them that she has with her younger children but that despite that she and they love each other very much. My DSC are very well adjusted, wonderful adults now who are just grateful that their Mum is in a much better place now and who love their little siblings unconditionally.