Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people are going to have to be inconvenienced to actually stop climate change?

214 replies

Confrontayshunme · 08/01/2022 22:52

A road near our home was closed to create a Low Traffic Neighbourhood during the first lockdown. Children at the local junior and high schools have benefitted hugely in road safety, the cycle and scooter racks were overflowing and the pollution was measured recently as 40% less (in an area with 3 schools).

And yet they reopened the road because enough drivers wanted to save 10 minutes in the morning. The day after it reopened, half of the bikes and scooters were gone due to safety concerns. Even my coworker who said it made her cycle to work easier and safer was hugely relieved that she doesn't have to go an extra 10 minutes out of her way when driving.

Anyway, I just despair for the planet if adults and people riding in heated, air conditioned, comfortable, waterproof music players can't possibly leave the house 10 minutes earlier to allow our community's children just one intersection's worth of safety and convenience. Plus, the level of pollution driving our children all these miles (when they could be exercising or improving their mental health) inside a car shortens their lives so there isn't any time saved overall anyway!

And before the pile on commences, I realise many people are not able to use alternate transport or active travel due to physical disability or huge distances and I wouldn't include them in this.

OP posts:
gobbledygoook · 09/01/2022 13:30

@sst1234

Sure, go on trying to reduce the less than 1% carbon emissions the that the UK produces while the two big hitters (or should I say emitters) are producing more than 30% between them and continuing to increase. It may make you feel better. Makes no difference to the planet though.
This is what I came to say! Even if you re weight the emission figures based on who is producing what for which country (e.g some of chinas / India's are for uk production) it's still no way near as much.

But yes, go ahead make everyone drive ten minutes longer (and produce more pollution).

LethargicActress · 09/01/2022 13:20

I agree with you that people will need to be inconvenienced to have any chance of us saving the planet, but I don’t think you’ve chosen a very good example.

If enough cars are having to travel for an extra 10 minutes daily, that’s a lot of extra emissions that don’t need to exist. Moving a problem away from a school and into other areas where families live and work isn’t really solving the problem.

ChrissyPlummer · 09/01/2022 13:14

@Theunamedcat

Unless and until jobs are available where you live people will still need to use transport I've always needed to travel 20 miles plus to get to work there was no public transport in that area no other way of getting there

People hate working from home and actively fight against it without seeing it could solve a lot of our problems my school is within walking distance work is not shopping is not cut the travel to work aspect out and I've reduced my car time to once a fortnight instead of daily

Same here, as I said earlier when I worked in London and lived in the Home Counties it was much easier. It’s pretty much impossible here, there’s nothing here work-wise. Anything they build now, is usually a massive out-of-town warehouse/logistics place on spare land by the motorway where there aren’t bus routes/train stations or many houses within walking distance, so you have no choice but to drive.

Same with the hospital, not really near the train station and buses/trains don’t run for those on early/late shifts. It’s also quite difficult in most areas to travel between two towns that are only a few miles apart as it usually means going into the centre of another town to change buses/trains, taking up to an hour when driving would take 15-20 minutes.

My friend lived in Maidenhead and liked shopping in High Wycombe, it’s about 12 miles; by train it would cost nearly £25 and she’d have to go into London first. Driving was about 20 minutes.

SoManyOptions · 09/01/2022 13:14

It's all such a compromise trying to do the right thing. Can see why people give up. I have reduced plastic from my home and try to avoid waste, and I walk when I can to shop etc. And I keep my personal consumption low.
But, I work as a carer in the community. Can't work for my company without a car, and the plastic that we use is unreal. Ppe, wipes, pads, etc etc. I could of course find a job that did not create so much waste, but someone needs to do it. My petrol consumption is high, but I don't see an alternative if we're to continue looking after people in their own homes.
My meagre efforts feel like I'm pissing in te wind if I'm honest.
I don't know what the answer is, but I don't think we can keep blaming individuals.
I think we'll just wipe ourselves off the planet and hopefully not too many other species with us. The planet will sort itself out one way or another.

Calendulaaaaa · 09/01/2022 13:04

Agreed OP. The number of people in this thread justifying continuing as they are doesn't make me hopeful though.

sst1234 · 09/01/2022 13:03

Sure, go on trying to reduce the less than 1% carbon emissions the that the UK produces while the two big hitters (or should I say emitters) are producing more than 30% between them and continuing to increase. It may make you feel better. Makes no difference to the planet though.

ChrissyPlummer · 09/01/2022 12:53

@DdraigGoch No, it’s nearly 30 miles each way. I’d like to live closer but the nearest areas are very nice where a two bed terrace is circa £500k, which I can’t afford. The area I live in is cheap, but there’s no work which is why I have to travel. When I lived down south, it was much easier, I didn’t drive for 5 years as the trains were pretty much all day/night and one town was connected by HS1 and had a decent, reasonably priced bus service. I did struggle with shopping through but I managed just fine. Unfortunately, it’s not doable in a lot of northern towns/cities. Even Manchester, it has decent public transport in certain areas, but others are very lacking.

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 09/01/2022 11:59

Totally agree @Notthemessiah. People stand to lose far too much money if we all did what needed to be done.

Notthemessiah · 09/01/2022 11:46

@MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry

It won’t happen. Climate change won’t be stopped
It can be stopped but it won't be - the changes required would be too great and the ones that would lose most would be the ones at the top of the chain making all of the money under our current system.

They will never do it voluntarily - their current plan is to make as much money as they can now in the hope that it will insulate them from the things that are coming (or chances are they are old enough now that they will be dead before the shit really hits the fan).

Notthemessiah · 09/01/2022 11:41

@Ionlydomassiveones

“OP, we are doomed I’m afraid, as this shows. Too many people wilfully blind or utterly selfish and will never give up any of their comforts. I hope to god my kids don’t have children themselves.”

What utter bollocks. Most of us, unfortunately, are low paid corporate drone slaves who live in urban areas set up to feed the same system. We can’t all start being self-sufficient kibbutz dwellers overnight and grown our own food, produce our own energy and recycle our own waste. We are all trapped in a fairly efficient and self-serving capitalist system. You hope you don’t have grandchildren because people understandably didn’t want to add 10 mins onto their commute? Bonkers.

What utter bollocks. So we can't change our way of life completely overnight (which of course is true), so why bother even trying is your argument?

And yet somehow you don't think that kind of attitude is going to cause massive problems down the line?

And of course this one specific example isn't why I don't want to have grandchildren and you well know that (unless you are an actual idiot). It's sympotomatic of the attitude that is going to ruin us all eventually unless something drastic happens.

pengu · 09/01/2022 07:23

@GettingStuffed

Or buy a new phone when their current one works perfectly well.
And recycle their old ones or sell to someone who wants a second hand model.
Smorgasborb · 09/01/2022 04:29

Yes and we will have to find some ways to discourage children, encourage childlessness and allow legal and safe Euthanasia to mitigate the fact there's less kids to wipe old peoples arses.
It doesn't matter what any of us do. If the population continues as it is or to grow the planet is doomed and is doomed within the children being born now's lifetime.. How we can encourage people to produce children at this stage is beyond me (actually I do know... consumers are fantastic for tax income and GDP and wealth creation so governments adore people creating lots of little consumers and fuck the planet)

DockOTheBay · 09/01/2022 03:26

Yes people are very used to convenience. Other examples which spring to mind are being able to get any item the next day ( or even the same day) and single use disposable items. People can't wait 10 minutes for something if they could have it NOW.

Seemslikeagoodidea · 09/01/2022 03:11

Sorry, that should say YABU to think closing some roads to cars will solve much.

nordica · 09/01/2022 03:11

I think the response to covid restrictions shows a lot of people just don't care one bit and will not change their behaviour in any significant way. It's even harder with something as huge as climate change because we see it less day to day.

Seemslikeagoodidea · 09/01/2022 03:09

YANBU to be concerned about climate change, but YANBU to think closing some roads to cars will solve much. Also, scooters are causing massive problems in urban areas, because many of them are riden on the pavements, which causes issues for pedestrians. On many roads there is no room for cycle lanes, let alone scooter lanes and disability scooters - it's getting quite perilous just walking these days.

I think our transport system needs a massive rethink and car ownership probably needs to reduce by at least a third to get things back to a point where things will improve. Also, every country needs to grow as much of its own food as possible, and we need to have more wind farms and solar farms, to become less reliant on imported gas. We have got to use the earth's reources more wisely, to reduce climate change as far as possible, although I don't think we can stop it completely. Things are going to get a lot worse before people really start to change their behaviour, and there will be many parts of the world where humans lose their homes due to rising sea levels, but eventually I think humans will find ways to adapt to the new world. It's a pity we have to learn the hard way, but that's the way humans are.

sweetbellyhigh · 09/01/2022 03:05

Totally agree. That's why laws need to be changed. So many people seem to be ignorant to the fact there is an alternative to neoliberalism.

Pixxie7 · 09/01/2022 02:52

Totally agree climate change is coming but on channel 4 yesterday even the government are backing off.

OwMyToe · 09/01/2022 02:33

If people were having to drive longer distances because of the road closure, isn't that worse for the environment as a whole, not better? Maybe fewer people were driving their children to school, but how many were driving an extra ten minutes each way due to the detour?

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 09/01/2022 02:13

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

In my experience people are much more likely to tell others to inconvenience themselves tp prevent climate change than inconveniencing themselves.
Yep
Theunamedcat · 09/01/2022 02:12

And no I can't fucking cycle I have to get children from one side of town to the other to childcare then travel to work from there apart from the fact that the children can't actually ride bikes im dyspraxic my knees are bad my heart is bad the list is endless basically it would kill me

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 09/01/2022 02:12

It won’t happen. Climate change won’t be stopped

Theunamedcat · 09/01/2022 02:08

Unless and until jobs are available where you live people will still need to use transport I've always needed to travel 20 miles plus to get to work there was no public transport in that area no other way of getting there

People hate working from home and actively fight against it without seeing it could solve a lot of our problems my school is within walking distance work is not shopping is not cut the travel to work aspect out and I've reduced my car time to once a fortnight instead of daily

onedayoranother · 09/01/2022 01:58

We were debating this back in the 70s when I was young (then it was more the energy crisis). I remember saying to my class: 'so how many if you are happy to stop using your hairdryers'? Didn't go down well. And this was way before mobile phones or computers which require mining for rare minerals. People are more aware now, but there are also billions more people on the planet using that energy.

SantaClawsServiette · 09/01/2022 01:45

I can't answer because I think the inconvenience will go well beyond the kind of thing you describe.

It will be much more like few people having cars at all, most people staying very close to home through their life, having one sweter and two outfits and probably no electronic gadgets. Something much closer to the expectations in terms of travel and property ownership that people had pre-1950.

Our lives are set up to be busy busy. Changing the shape of that isn't just about leaving 10 minutes early, it's about getting to be a half hour earlier. in the evening and getting home from activities earlier for their kids and supper on the table earlier and so on. People don't feel able to control this kind of thing so they try and ignore things that make them feel like they should.